We hear a lot about how small schools are changing urban education. For example, the Chancellor of NYC schools recently claimed victory by announcing small school graduation rates were higher than those in large schools, and held up Evander Childs, a Bronx high school broken down into 5 small schools, as an exemplar. Celebrating Evander, an ad proclaims: "The building is the same, but the school is very different." In this post, I show that the building is the same, but the students definitely aren't. This is not to say that small schools don't have benefits for the students they serve - they certainly may - but that we can't compare apples and oranges and declare school reform victory.
Read More