With our system set up as it is, yes, the major national institutions are too big too fail. Letting them fail in September would have destroyed the credit market, and the credit market is what keeps the economy moving, both the commercial paper market, and long term corporate and small business debt. Letting the banks fail would have resulted in a Depression, capital D, and one that would have had a decade or longer recovery time.
But it doesn't have to be that way, and we certainly should not have facilitated the mess of mergers that occurred in the wake of presumptive failures. That exacerbates the problem, making these megabanks larger, and making the consequence of their failure more serious. Shielding them from failure makes matters worse.
So they must be allowed to fail. We must first examine why their failure would be so damaging, and how to let them fail in a way that lessens the impact on us.
Read More