Skip to main content

View Diary: One Hundred Names You Won't Hear This Memorial Day (194 comments)

Comment Preferences

  •  you sound just like.. (none)
    My brother,reading your words I hear his voice, I do miss him,(His death is not related)and in a weird sort of way, thank you for bringing him back to me so vividly.

    That being said, I gotta tell you, what I find disgusting is the fact that you would have American soldiers refrain from protecting themselves because a child might be, or actually was amongst their attackers. More disgusting is the fact that you seem not to care that Iraqi MEN, and WOMEN, put those children in harms way, by hiding amongst them, while attacking U.S. Soldiers.

    To insinuate that I or any one else would hold a child accountable for any of this is ludicrous on its face, and so simplistic as to make one wonder how it is you were ever able to learn to type, much less form complete sentences. Perhaps it was your rush to comment that prevented you from commenting intelligently, and forced you into the standard "sarcastic" using space but providing no substance response type that seems to grow promiscously wild on this thing called  the web.

    I think you missed the greater point, so let me try again, I'll even type slower if it might help. Not one of the incidents displayed at the beginning of this thread was the result of maurauding American troops, out of control with bloodlust and hatred for anything Arab, all were finalities of actions against insurgents, and any others who had been shooting at or otherwise attacking American troops.
    To only be revolted at the symptoms, and have no regard for the cause is a bit juvenile, don't you think?

    Whether or not we should be in Iraq, (which I do not believe we should...) is not the point here, whether or not American soldiers have the right to defend themselves from the very people the entire world agrees do not have Iraqs best interest at heart is.

    I wonder why, in all fairness, in sympathy for all the wrongfully dead out there, why were no pictures of American dead being dragged through the streets posted? Why were no pictures of American, and or Iraqi dead due to suicide bombers, or roadside bombs posted? Surely they are just as disgusting, just as heart wrenching, and just as much a reason to stop this war as any of the pictures that were posted.....

    Of course I realize that posting those images wouldn't allow the author to feel self righteous disgust for a government they can no longer control, because they are not yet ready to give up their SUV's, HDTV, and professional wrestling on Friday nites.....

    VOTE, SPEAK OUT LOUD LONG AND STRONG, AFTER ALL IT IS OUR COUNTRY.

    by techadvisor2thedead on Thu May 26, 2005 at 10:57:58 PM PDT

    [ Parent ]

    •  Very very nice. (none)
      You have a problem with my sarcasm. As was evident from your first post, and now backed up by your second one, it's clear that I could not have expected a rational conversation with you. You just want to vent, and flame anyone who gets in the way. So when I see such frothing ignorant hate, yeah, I'm going to ridicule it. It makes the point much more succinctly by highlighting the absurdity of your argument. Works much better than what I'll try to do here, which I'm sure will be pointless. But here you go anyway.

      Where in my post did I say American soldiers shouldn't defend themselves in battle? I didn't. So you can mark that part out. They're going to fight because they have to. But it doesn't make dead innocents a somehow acceptable thing. Expected yes, acceptable, no. Human tragedy, yes. And when you say I don't care that Iraqi men and women put these kids in harm's way, you again sidestep the issue. First of all the kids are dead. That's all that matters. What would keep you from acknowledging the horror of it? It doesn't take away from the horror of our own dead.  

      Secondly, these kids (or adults) live in towns. They walk down the street like people do anywhere, and suddenly a bomb drops, an IED goes off, or a gun battle erupts. And they get wasted. Armed Iraqi fighters are the object and do also die, but so do random bystanders. You make it sound like adults walk kids around on leashes and say, "go stand next to that bomb, kid." Even the army will admit that "collateral damage" is unintended and regrettable. Not you, though. They're dead and you just won't acknowledge the tragedy of it.

      In fact you say "I will care not one moment for those whom appear in these photo's". Why? Why can't you care? Do you only have so much care to go around? Do only Americans count? The post wasn't about saying "let's not care about our own dead because the war is wrong". It was about remembering the tens of thousands of others, just as dead, that the media doesn't report about.

      And does it matter whether the people in the pictures died due to accidental reasons? Does that make it OK? They're dead! Horribly killed. You write it off like some kind of ho-hum detail. Imagine if it was your own mother or children or brother. Seriously. Close your eyes and picture your mother's stiffened corpse in your arms in the middle of the street, next to the bloody lump of meat that used to be your baby. Conjure up the feelings you'd have. Stop reading and do it. Did you do it? Would't be so ho-hum then, would it. It would shatter your life, and you'd never have any satisfaction or justice over it. Imagine people on the other side of the world seeing your picture and saying, "yeah well, that kind of thing happens, you know. They shouldn't have been living there." That's what you're doing.

      You "will not care one moment" about the shattering, the tens of thousands of shatterings, when it's someone else and somewhere else, and our soldiers are being killed in the same arena. The thing is, you don't have to care one iota less about our own dead. Just acknowledge that every human deserves to live and feels the same ultimate suffering when their loved ones are killed.

      As for why no pictures of mutilated US corpses were shown, it looks to me like the post was saying, "As we go into the holiday where we mourn our own dead, don't forget these people". We do mourn our own dead. We sit over here sick, knowing our own young people are getting blown to bits, which is bad enough by itself, but worse when it's all in service of the heartless Machiavellian designs of our demented leaders.

      And in fact, people have posted pictures here of mutilated American dead. Know why it doesn't happen more? Because the military censors and blocks the journalists over there. And because papers here won't run them because people then say, "How disrespectful. This is horrible." And when those pictures are posted here at Kos, the same thing happens. People just like you say, "this is an outrage. how can you disrespect their memories and their sacrifice and their families like this?"  

      Actually let me take that back, I don't know if you personally would react that way.  From your overheated rage and inability to accept the real horror, that's just my guess. I happen to think that the only reason we let this kind of thing continue is because people are able to change the channel and deny the grisly reality of mass carnage. I say that if every one of us had to stand next to human beings (American and Iraqi) being ground into bloody, charred sausage every day, this war would be over in a week.

      So you think the author of that post won't accept the full reality of the war (American dead) because they don't want to give up their SUVs, etc?  Well like I said, they aren't denying it.  But more importanly, what about you? You won't accept the full reality either.

      So rev up your hatred and ridicule and really let me have it now. Because it will be productive.

      Please join me in a revolution, won't you?

      by Your Brother on Fri May 27, 2005 at 07:22:18 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  All Revved up with no one to hate... (none)
        Your sarcasm was ill placed, and a poor attempt to ridicule a very valid point. The fact that a four year old, or any child for that matter was killed because of this war, is of course tragic, and if the images that have been presented here sought(sp?)only to express that, then perhaps my response would have been different. However these images are nothing new, the compilation is not that of a sad and concerned individual, heart breakingly compiled to show the world the pain and suffering of innocents in the region. This particular compilation has existed on many sites, and in many discussion threads as a means to villify and damn American troops. This author is nothing less than a cut and pasting poser, who fully deserves not only all my frothing anger and hatred, but perhaps that of yourself and others like you who actually see that the tragedy is all encompassing, and not one sided...

        If you go back to my original post, you will see that I opposed this war from the beginning, still do, and always will. That any one man woman and children have had to die because of this conflict, is tragic, and perhaps you are correct, no one more or less tragic than another.  I am an American, however, and damn proud to be one by the way, therefore American deaths hit me harder, mean more to me, if for no other reason than I believe and feel that they are of my own, and someday soon may actually be from and of my own.

        I agree with you as you say "that if every one of us had to stand next to human beings (American and Iraqi) being ground into bloody, charred sausage every day, this war would be over in a week." I also think that every gruesome picture and film from a battle should be shown on CNN,FOX,NBC,CBS, et al, daily, unedited, and without commentary other than pointing specific facts. Then my friend, then we will see a much different attitude towards war.

        Sorry, dude, no hate here, only anger, frustration, and much sadness. This weekend, as always, we will remember our dead, our fallen heroes, our living, soon perhaps to be dead, doing things and living in conditions most of us could not imagine, will not imagine,and hope to never do. Because of you, a moment will also be given to those on the other side of the world, and the tragedy and burdens they too bear.

        PEACE

        VOTE, SPEAK OUT LOUD LONG AND STRONG, AFTER ALL IT IS OUR COUNTRY.

        by techadvisor2thedead on Fri May 27, 2005 at 03:13:05 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site