Skip to main content

View Diary: Thoughts on the Gun Debate (75 comments)

Comment Preferences

  •  "So are you espoucing banning all guns? " (0+ / 0-)

    Absolutely. Why not?

    If suicide is truly something you want to lower, then focus on fixing the suicidal.
    Yeah, the problem is that your beloved guns convert the suicidal into the dead before we can fix them in ways that other methods (knives, meds, rope, etc) don't. Do you just not understand this simple fact? It is the finding of every significant study on suicide as a public health problem.

    I will repeat: guns are a big part of why we don't get the chance to "fix the suicidal". Sheesh.

    •  "Why not?" (1+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      andalusi

      The Constitution. Individual liberties. Freedoms of innocent people.

      "beloved guns"
      Beloved liberty, actually.

      "Not understand this simple fact"
      Again. 33 countries with gun control has higher suicide rates than the US.
      Guns aren't the boogyman that you think they are. Stop cringing in fear & stop trying to take liberties away from innocent Americans for your irrational phobia.
      Your fears don't trump other's liberties.

      Those who would sacrifice liberty for security deserve neither.

      by FrankRose on Fri Mar 08, 2013 at 10:03:06 PM PST

      [ Parent ]

      •  Why not? (0+ / 0-)

        "The Constitution"
        The document was written to be amended and changed as needed. Obviously the bar is high, but it's pretty clear we've reached that point.

        "individual liberties"
        Meaningless RW pablum. How about my liberty to not have chunks of metal fired at high speed into valuable organs? Plenty of objects and actions are restricted when the benefit of having them is outweighed by their danger to society, many of them are even weapons. Prescription drugs. Fissile material. On and on. This is a non-argument.

        "Freedoms of innocent people"
        There is nothing innocent about all this killing the gun owners are doing/enabling.

        33 countries with gun control has higher suicide rates than the US.
        That's nice. Again, the research shows that when there are fewer guns, the completed suicide rate goes down. All you are emphasizing is that those countries would do well to not have more guns. That doesn't really help your argument.
        Stop cringing in fear & stop trying to take liberties away from innocent Americans for your irrational phobia.
        There is nothing "irrational" from my side here, citing academic research and pointing out the danger to our society from your fetish.

        Simply put, if you want to live in society your "liberties" cannot be unlimited. You have proven you cannot have guns, so they will go away.

        It would be nice if, instead of coming back with silly meaningless things like "you can't take guns because freedom" you actually cited some kind of risk/benefit analysis that favored widespread gun ownership, or tried in some other way to have a rational argument. I know that is a losing proposition for your side, but it would be much more convincing than the "individual liberty" whine.

        •  "Pretty clear we have reached that point"? (1+ / 0-)
          Recommended by:
          Patrick Costighan

          The AWB can't even come to a vote, but you think you have the support to change an amendment in the Bill of Rights?!?
          Good luck with that.

          "Individual liberties"
          You find liberties to be RW?!? I think homosexuals, women whom support abortion, everyone whom believes warrantless wiretaps to be unacceptable would disagree.

          "How about my liberty to not have chunks of metal fired at high speed into valuable organs?"
          Thus the crimes of murder, attempted murder, assault, etc.

          " Again, the research shows that when there are fewer guns, the completed suicide rate goes down. "
          The real world & 33 nations disagree.
           But have it your way...if you think that owning a gun would lead to an unintentional suicide, then don't own a gun, & allow others to make the same choice.
          Neat how freedom works, innit?

          "silly meaningless things like "you can't take guns because freedom""
          I don't find individual freedom written in the Bill of Rights, to be either 'silly' nor 'meaningless'.
          It is telling that you do.

          Those who would sacrifice liberty for security deserve neither.

          by FrankRose on Sat Mar 09, 2013 at 02:47:03 PM PST

          [ Parent ]

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site