Daily Kos

View Story | 82 comments

  •  It's admittedly uncentered (none / 0)

    Nowhere did I claim to have a unified point: notice the generalness of my title.

    Thank you for your feedback, and you're right: I'm not sure about what either.  Suffice it to say that I think a lot of the energy being spent over this issue (and other similar ones) is counterproductive...

    •  Wha? (none / 1)

      You argue that Summers was right to raise the question - to provoke debate. Now you're saying spending energy over this issue is counterproductive.

      Your thesis may not have been perfect but it is a topic that needs hashing in thinking-out-loud discussion.

      I think the diary nazis lose sight of the big picture at dkos.

      •  Not exactly linked (none / 0)

        Though I do agree that the "diary nazis" are bothersome at times.  Still, while I did say both of those things, I said them in different contexts, and that is important.  I am interested in provoking debate, and believe Summers comment was good for doing so.  At the same time, I do think a lot of the energy being spent (and dare I say, much of the energy being directed against me at the moment) is counterproductive.  One can have a discussion with a good ideal that doesn't necessarily work out so well in reality.

        Anyway, thank you.  I do agree that this topic needs hashing out, but I don't think it's going to happen here to be honest.  I'd be willing to bet that another diary on the topic would go much like this one did: a lot of misrepresentation, a lot of unnecessary energy, and a lot of me having to defend myself from false accusations.  That said, I'm glad I did it, as I did learn a few things from the few people who were kind enough to comment in a way that actually responded to my questions and assertions.  But I think that, for now, I'm going to give the topic a rest.  DailyKos is a fine community for many things, but true open dialogue on topics of political correctness and other things that rub people the wrong way is not really one of them.

        I must admit, I'm toying with posting this at that other political Scoop-powered site (right-leaning, much less popular than Kos, but an interesting site nonetheless) to see how it goes there.

        •  Will check it out over there (none / 0)

          I'd like to see the reaction.

          I'll have to re-read all the comments in this diary. Like I said, this is a touchy topic, but the discussion needs to take place out in the open.

          How long had Summers been silently positing his theory about intrinsic ability differences before he aired them publicly? A while I suppose. While I'm disappointed he assumes these differences are innate, I'm glad he did so publicly, rather than claiming a view of equal ability then retracting it "that was just for show, the pc police" in a smoke-filled room.

View Story | 82 comments