Daily Kos

View Story | 10 comments

  •  Images, meanings, and exclusion (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    amsterdam

    Despite what some may view as my dismissive tone, I am in no way dismissive of this nor its implications. This is not just some other display of the lunatic right.

    This is perhaps THE visual that should go alongside modern American uses, such as George W. Bush's notions of "liberty", as for many Americans liberty without christ- and christendom has become an oxymoron- no such thing.

    For those of us un-godly in the midst of all this (or those deemed some 'wrong version' of godly) this is nothing less than a word grab, it's by thier own words, a redefintion.

    Then there's the ugly matter not just of rewording, but of re-envisioning who the statue is about.

    Upon the Statue of Liberty a plaque was later added in 1903, it was inscribed with two lines from a poem, "The New Colossus", by
    the nineteenth-century American poet Emma Lazarus:

    "Give me your tired, your poor,
    Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
    The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
    Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me.
    I lift my lamp beside the golden door."

    Whereas inscribed upon this so called "Statue of Liberation" you get treated to this;

    "Give me your POOR, BROKENHEARTED Your CAPTURED, BLIND, AND BRUISED Your huddled MULTITUDES
    yearning to be free;
    The wretched LOST SOULS from shore to shore, Send these,
    the SICK, OPPRESSED, HOMELESS
    The tempest LOST to Christ.
    I lift the cross as a symbol
    that CHRIST IS THE DOOR.

    (Luke 4:18, John 8:32b, Romans 7:24, Acts 10:38, 2 Corinthians 4:3, John 10:9)"

    One really has to ask whether "from shore to shore" in the latter applies to peoples throughout the world, or has been reduced to those within the boundries of America, from our eastern shore to our western shore? The ambiguity in that really points to yet another deep posible shift in the very essence of the Statue's intended audience.

    Americans are a people to whom immigration, and the legacy of immigration IS our story- almost all our story. To "desecrate" such a symbol of our shared common heritage in a crass attempt to lay unique claim to it by any one subsuculture is to me at least, abhorrent, despicable.

    Yes, the cross- raised flyswatter like, is indeed a 'stop' sign, a 'our tribe only, no others need apply' sign, a raised finger, not merely to the world and other Americans but also to rejecting Frederic-Auguste Bartholdi's vision and the shared French- American history the real Statue of Liberty is steeped in.

    So yes, the picture and particularly the 'new symbolism' on the christian statue (see http://www.worldovercomers.org/... in particular) are viceral level punches to the gut. They betray everything the Statue of Liberty is. The  pedastool is not sumbolic of 'the tomb of christ', it was created through the efforts and contributions of ordinary Americans.

    Those who love our country might want to spend a few minutes here, this July 4th:
    http://www.americanparknetwork.com/...

    So their 'christian liberation only' statue, far from just an eyesore, it's a physical expression of hatred of our shared genuine history.

    barf.org : a resource for all who work to monitor and counter the Biblical America movement.

    by stormcoming on Tue Jul 04, 2006 at 01:45:16 AM PDT

    [ Parent ]

    •  Thanks for your comment (1+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      stormcoming

      Another thing that disturbes me is that the cross is held like a weapon. The statue is like a crusader inviting Americans to pick up their weapons and crosses to conquer and subdue what is outside these borders.

      I already posted this in another diary, but in my mind's eye the image of this statue keeps on superimposing itself on the image of lady liberty as she stands in New York harbor.

      How do you think this image resonates with the majority of Americans?

      I think this image is so powerful that it could be catalyst to awaken America.
      On the other hand if Americans would feel comfortable with this image, it would indicate to me that at some level the American psyche has changed so dramatically, that in essence the American spirit as we thought we knew it ceased to exist.

      •  just my impression (0+ / 0-)

        Well, the below could be just my impression, but that said, my impression comes from a particular place.

        I've been studying the Biblical American movement here in the US for the past decade with my partner, and was working as an 'activist' of sorts for a good long time before that- working along many different fronts- Queer politics, feminist politics, reproductive autonomy work, environmental work, etc etc. My partner and I have spent a sizeable chunk of the last ten years traveling America by car (well truck, mainly) both along highways and well off the major thoroughfares. We've spent some of that time going into Biblical American events, conferences, street events, bookstores etc etc etc.

        My other major bias going into all this is that I am an artist with a particular interest in installation pieces and what have come to be known here in America as 'roadside peeks'.

        That said, my opinion? The image is upsetting to some of those of us outside, other 'outsiders' will dismiss it, either as another 'nutso display by religious freaks along the highway' (we've got plenty of 'em), or in a few cases, as some kind of actual artistic statement- not a very good one, but perhaps an artist's vision. It will not however, been seen for what it fully is. Even in the other writings I'm seeing on it, there is little to no analyis of tribalism, redefinition, posessive-ism, etc.

        As for those on the inside, I think it will resonate pretty strongly with at least the FRAME they occupy- not neccessarily in the actual execution (they may not like the statue, personally, but they will agree with the symbolism and meanings behind it).

        So no, ultimately, despite this being a wake-up call, and a definite point in the process that's taking place here in this country, I deeply doubt people here will comprehend it.

        As for majority or minority, I'm not sure that's the right question. I think the real question is how does it resonate with those with power and influence, and who would on some level have the power to change our current trajectory- and again, unfortunately, as Biblical Americans views are perhaps disproportionately found in centers of power and influence (as those very places have been specifically targeted BY Biblical Americans over the past few decades).

        For those out of power with little to no influence, well, we diary (among other things)- and it gets very little attention.

        Your last paragraph is key- and dead on. I wish the image could act as a catalyst- if only to alert people to where we now stand (you'll note that this is my first and only diary with a picture attatched.)

        But, yes, I too, am convinced, primarily via my travels that whether people agree or disagree with the image, they are comfortable with the statue. We as a country have changed dramtically.

        And key components of what America has been recognized for, or aspects of what have been pointed to by others as "American Spirit" are now being willingly cast aside without so much as a second thought. "American Spirit" is now little more than a crumpled pack of cigarettes lying amidst the litter by the side of the road. (Where's Snake Plissken when you need him? Sorry, a little "Escape from L.A." reference there.)

        Liberty- and Lady Liberty's lamp are being actively replaced by "liberation" which we are told is only found within one narrow religious construct. Liberty itself is eroding daily.

        As for those of us for whom this statue is a marked point in a process of (what my partner and I have been calling) changing out the hardware to run new software, well, even if we do see it, we don't seem to be able to make much of a dent.

        barf.org : a resource for all who work to monitor and counter the Biblical America movement.

        by stormcoming on Wed Jul 05, 2006 at 12:31:43 AM PDT

        [ Parent ]

View Story | 10 comments