Daily Kos

View Story | 34 comments

  •  All of the above (3+ / 0-)

    Sorry, I was gone for the day, hope you see this response.

    I think all of those play in.  The industrial agriculture companies started giving major funding to the land-grant universities a while back.  So the major agricultural universities don't dare put out research critiquing the conventional system.  I've talked with people whose research showed that NONE of the chemicals they were testing were very beneficial, but they were told that they could not publish that research.  And since the Extension Service is funded by the same people and relying on the published studies, the only solutions they recommend are the conventional chemical ones.  

    And then there's everyone with a product to sell.  Holistic sustainable agriculture requires fewer inputs, and the inputs decrease over time -- which means less and less money.  Conventional agriculture requires ever-increasing inputs, in contrast.

    And our type of agriculture is difficult mental work!  Farmers have been told they're stupid, and just follow the nice, simple instructions on the bag of fertilizer.  It's difficult to get out of that rut.  

    There's also the farming culture.  It's very conservative -- not necessarily politically (although that, too), but in terms of not liking change.  If you're the "weirdo" doing "that organic stuff", you'll get grief at the local feed store, equipment store, etc.

    And then there's the government.  USDA and many of our state agriculture departments are terrible examples of industry capture of the agencies.  The senior officials are all from industry, or hoping to go to industry, and so they make the rules to suit the big money interests.  

    •  Sorry, my husband wa slogged in (3+ / 0-)

      Not to create any confusion ... FarmerAlan is my husband's Kossack name

      Help protect independent farmers! Go to www.farmandranchfreedom.org

      by judith2007 on Sun Jan 06, 2008 at 05:19:20 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Sounds Like (2+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      OrangeClouds115, anotherdemocrat

      quite the uphill struggle, then.

      I guess I suspected as much.  I definitely hadn't even considered the research funding to the land-grant schools, which would seem pretty difficult to overcome, simply because Big Ag already has the capital in hand that they can spread around to get research that will generally support the conclusion they'd want publicized.

      Thanks for all your responses here.  It sure sounds as though you've got your work cut out for you!

      Can you smell the Constitution burning?

      by The Maven on Sun Jan 06, 2008 at 08:54:00 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

View Story | 34 comments