Skip to main content

View Diary: MRFF Lawsuit Alleges Mandatory Christianity in US Military (304 comments)

Comment Preferences

  •  Also - I actually almost never do "edited"... (2+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    arodb, godislove

    Writing. I'm going to start soon, but for $

    dKos doesn't pay. If this forum gave me frontpage space, I'd edit my writing, sure.

    But, I know what it is to edit - indeed, the last 'edited' piece I did wound up as an LA Times op-ed.

    (after more edits ! - I drafted it, did a number of edits, then it passed onto a former NYT writer who did more edits...)

    •  Congrats for LA Times OpEd... (2+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      Troutfishing, godislove

      the closest I got was one published in the San Diego Union Tribune.  And the subject wasn't saving the political system, but getting more tennis courts in the community.

      I used to get several N.Y. Times Letters published, about 14 over a decade or so.  Brevity was important, so like a Haiku I worked on making the direct point concisely. Usually they work with the writer to pare it down getting approval of any edits.

      In one letter about police brutality the editor simply chopped off the last paragraph, destroying what made the letter worthwhile.  When I complained he said I should have been happy since mine was selected out of hundreds submitted.

      It takes a lot of work to write a substantive diary, and even more work to edit it down to the ideal form. You seem to hit the recommend list frequently, which provides some satisfaction, but it doesn't pay the rent.

      So, I understand your reaction to "constructive criticism."  Drop me the link to the OpEd if you feel like it.

      Regards

      Al

      •  Here it is, but I can't call it "mine" anymore... (2+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:
        arodb, godislove

        I just did the initial drafts which I edited a number of times... Chris Rodda threw in some nice points too.

        Then Reza had at and it the piece, with Mikey throwing in points too, and in the end it was no longer recognizable as mine... it was a group effort. Somebody else, in a PR firm working for MRFF, coined the gem of a phrase "The Rapture Is Not A Viable Exit Strategy". That's the making of the sausage.

        Anyway, here's the final product which - I'd say - was indeed better than my version although there were some flourishes I liked which got edited out. Probably for good reason. It's not considered genteel to mention that the use of the word "crusade" in the context of Middle Eastern politics is generally not a good idea for, among other reasons, the fact that the Crusaders were known for, among other charming behaviors, occasional savage bouts of cannibalism (when food was lacking) that in one case involved skewering and barbecuing children and cooking adults in big stew pots. Ah, the Crusades !

        http://www.latimes.com/...

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site