Skip to main content

View Diary: Anti-Prop 8 backlash changes minds (419 comments)

Comment Preferences

  •  no, you're talking about a political movement (0+ / 0-)

    and a church - entirely different things.  Plenty of mormons out there who don't agree with the church's every stance.  

    And actually, you are the one splitting hairs or whatever the opposite of that is -- the KKK wasn't a religion, mormonism is.  You can't lump them together as the same thing.

    •  You still pay a yearly tithe to the organization (0+ / 0-)

      that intentionally stripped hundreds of thousands of people of their basic civil rights. You're all guilty.

      •  And you pay taxes (0+ / 0-)

        You're guilty too, bud.

        Much more guilty than the mormons - the voters did have their say at the end of the day, not to say that I agreed with them.  You are scapegoating the mormons for a much bigger problem and then attempting to blame them as a class.  

        •  Analogous how? (0+ / 0-)

          How are my tax dollars supporting the de jure subjugation of an oppressed minority? Because that's what your donation to the LDS church does.

          the voters did have their say at the end of the day, not to say that I agreed with them.

          Well? Do you agree with them?

          You are scapegoating the mormons for a much bigger problem and then attempting to blame them as a class.

          77% of the funding and an even greater proportion of phone bankers and canvassers. This is not scapegoating; it is reality. The LDS church didn't have to make itself into a political machine of bigotry, but it did, and now it will suffer the consequences.

        •  there is no legal force requiring you to give to (0+ / 0-)

          a church that you k now disciriminates. there is the force of the state requiring we pay taxes. your logic is lacking here. but i think the illogics is what youhve left to justify your own behaivor.

    •  this is why I don't want to argue with you (1+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:

      the minute the mormons as an organization became both the monetary financiers and foot soldiers for Yes on 8, they lost any right to claim they were being attacked for religion. you can not both act as a political group and a religious one because you can not use that faith as a shield to argue you are above the political. once you are involved in the politics- you are fair game.

      the Mormons became a political organization. this is why they are now under investigation by the state of California (as of this morning) for their role in Prop 8. This is why NY Times did a reporting about them representing something like 80 percent of the GOTV for Yes on 8. The Church organized this. they sent out a letter specifically telling its members to do so. But for the manipulation of using the fact they also a religion- this would bring up questions about their non profit status.

      There is no substantive difference other than the veneer of more religiousity (in your mind) for the Mormon Church with regard to Prop 8 and something the KKK would have done down South.

      Read up on the history of the KKK movement. Most of the hate groups out there are heavily based on religious doctrine.  You can google some of their sites online. look at their quoting of scripture.

      One of my little test by the way of people's prejudices is where they can not see how much they are a like another group they don't want to be associated with.

      The KKK's central difference is that they advocated violence as well as political control over blacks. They do not differ in the use of religion to justify their position. Your claim that because the Mormons are an "official" religion changes nothing. It's a form over substance argument under the circumstances.

      The fact you need to pretend that there is some big difference from the fact that both organizations are using religion to define their position on a political movement is where you show your own inability to frame this as it is.

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site