OK

TopCommentsRedux

Government is not a solution to our problem; government is the problem.

--Ronald Reagan, First Inaugural Address

The mindset articulated in Reagan's famous quote is what must be changed politically in America. This statement is perhaps the most subversive, insidious, unpatriotic, and, indeed, treasonous idea ever to be unleashed upon the citizens of the United States. Far too many of us have bought into it for far too long. This is the foundational lie that must be changed.

Join me below the double gnocchi to talk about what must be changed and why. I apologize for the length of the diary. You can skip it and go to the good stuff if you want to. But first, a word from our sponsor.

Top Comments recognizes the previous day's Top Mojo and Top Photos and strives to promote each day's outstanding comments through nominations made by Kossacks like you. Please send us the comments you'd like to nominate (but not your own) either by email to topcomments@gmail.com or by our KosMail message board before 9:30pm ET. Just click on the Spinning Top™ to make a submission.

Make sure that you include the direct link to the comment (the URL), which is available by clicking on that comment's date/time. Please let us know your Daily Kos user name if you use email so we can credit you properly. If you send a writeup with the link, we can include that as well. The diarist reserves the right to edit all content.

If the 20th Century taught us anything, it is that American government, when properly applied, is good. So Reagan's claim suffers immediately because it is a lie. It is, perhaps, the biggest lie since the one that says white-men-of-Western-European-culture-are-superior-to-everyone-else-by-birth-and-by-the-grace-of-God-and-are-therefore-entitled-to-whatever-they-want. The two lies are related in a perverse symbiotic way. They enable each other. But Reagan's lie is not just a big lie; it is an all-pervasive lie.

Reagan's statement is a direct slap in the face to the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, and the Declaration of Independence and is obviously unpatriotic. The Preamble to the Constitution says:

We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
This statement says that we rely upon government to help us do collectively what we cannot do individually. Therefore, to say that "government is the problem" is to say the Framers failed in their effort, that the tool of the Constitution is ineffective. Reagan is saying that "We the People" are incompetent. That we cannot govern ourselves. That liberal democracy (small-l, small-d) doesn't work. In other words, it goes against everything the Framers believed. And every Republican since has repeated Reagan's lie with gusto. They can wear all the flag lapel pins they want, but if they believe Reagan, they're unpatriotic.

This lie is insidious because it takes away the only real tool the people have to keep the oligarchs in check. If government can't stop them from robbing us, then what can? Without laws and enforcement (government), we can't protect ourselves from the Lords of the Manor. Because America bought this lie, the 1% has been stealing from us as fast as they can for the last 30+ years.

How did this happen? My theory is that many white people in America turned against government because of civil rights. It was one thing to support civil rights when it was fat rednecks loosing fire hoses and dogs on peaceful, dignified demonstrators on TV. It was another thing to actually have people of color from the ghetto in your child's classroom. As government began to push for civil rights through court orders, many working class whites became resentful as the realities of integration set in. And it wasn't just the South. Some of the worst riots over busing were in true blue Massachusetts. And the Republican party didn't mind exploiting that resentment in order to gain/maintain power (cf. Nixon's "law and order," Reagan's "welfare queen," and Bush the Elder's Willie Horton, et al., ad nauseum).

Added to the economic woes created by Nixon and continuing through Ford and Carter, people began to despise government and forget the 40 years of shared prosperity that government properly applied had given them, the period Krugman calls the "Great Compression."

I teach Steinbeck's classic The Grapes of Wrath, and if that book has one clear message, it is that the people need government to protect themselves from the "Great Owners." The people heeded that call in 1940 and the middle class exploded. Wealth inequality decreased. The boats of the 99% rose with the flood of prosperity.

But that ceased in 1980. Look at this chart showing productivity and wages:

Again, what happened? We took away progressive taxation under the very flawed notion that "Greed is good," we deregulated the media and many industries under the pernicious guise that "government functions poorly," and we began to systematically dismantle labor unions under the false claim that "unions coddle the lazy and incompetent."

Why? Because "gov'mint" was bad according to Saint Ronnie. A popular joke told at the time went like this:

Q. Know what the three biggest lies in the world are?

A. "The check is in the mail," "I'll still love you in the morning," and "I'm from the government and I'm here to help you."

This meme produced an "every man for himself" mentality that destroyed whatever remaining "we're all in this together" sentiment still lingered from the unifying experience--and propaganda--of World War II. People forgot what TVA and Social Security and the G.I Bill and interstate highways had done for them. They forgot that everyone sacrificed to win the war. They forgot that, despite our differences, we are all Americans and we have an obligation to "promote the general welfare."

In 1979, Jimmy Carter saw the lie ("a mistaken idea of freedom") coming and talked about it in his famous "Malaise" Speech (actually entitled "Crisis of Confidence"). He said:

We are at a turning point in our history. There are two paths to choose. One is a path I've warned about tonight, the path that leads to fragmentation and self-interest. Down that road lies a mistaken idea of freedom, the right to grasp for ourselves some advantage over others. That path would be one of constant conflict between narrow interests ending in chaos and immobility. It is a certain route to failure.

All the traditions of our past, all the lessons of our heritage, all the promises of our future point to another path, the path of common purpose and the restoration of American values. That path leads to true freedom for our Nation and ourselves. We can take the first steps down that path as we begin to solve our energy problem.

Emphasis added

With the hindsight of 2013, it is clear we took the wrong path. We need to change direction. We need to replace the lie told by Reagan with the truth spoken by FDR:
The only sure bulwark of continuing liberty is a government strong enough to protect the interests of the people, and a people strong enough and well enough informed to maintain its sovereign control over the government.

--Franklin D. Roosevelt, Fireside Chat 12: On the Recession (April 14, 1938)

That is a huge task that FDR has laid before us. The Republican argument is always that "government is out of control" and in some cases it is (see NSA), but to abandon the tool of government because it has been wielded imperfectly at times is to throw the baby out with the bath water. It seems to be the people actually raised by nannies and who employ them who are quickest too decry the "Nanny State."

We the People need to maintain "sovereign control," not the privileged few. The question is whether we are "strong enough and well enough informed." That is why I think the three most important reforms we should push for are first, to make America more democratic (small-d) by eliminating the filibuster and the Electoral College; second, by decentralizing media and reestablishing fairness; and finally by controlling election spending and procedures. In this manner we can gain the strength and knowledge needed to maintain control.

But, reform aside, we need to push back hard against the slander that Republicans have perpetrated against our Constitution. It will take time to change that meme and it will take action. Thankfully, people are beginning to fight back. Daily Kos is an important part of that and events like NN13 are key to making things change. So, many thanks to kos for providing this site and for inventing Netroots Nation.

We all see the injustice. We all see the lie. We have to start praising government where government is due. We all know government is imperfect, but we have to remind our neighbors that there is a reason why the Founders handed us the tool of government. Capitalism is also imperfect, often much more than government. Many more businesses fail than government programs. So we need to refute the lie, and once we do, we need to wield the tool of government wisely, judiciously, and practically.

Image Credits:
Reagan courtesy theweek.com
Constitution courtesy opednews.com
Integration courtesy www.upa.pdx.edu
Productivity graph courtesy Daily Kos
FDR courtesy Howard Payne University
We're the government courtesy waliberals.org

TOP COMMENTS
June 22, 2013

Thanks to tonight's Top Comments contributors! Let us hear from YOU
when you find that comment that is tops!

From JayRaye:

I second the motion by The Gryffin in zenbassoon's recommended diary Ohio School Bans African American Hairstyles.
From TerryDarc:
delphine explains the Snowden case from a non-hostile, non-incendiary viewpoint better than any I have seen in today's Abbreviated Pundit Round-up by Greg Dworkin.
From Puddytat:
This gallows humor by gooderservice in SouthernLiberalinMD's rebuttal dairy What I Want to Know: 10 Reasons Why We Shouldn't Be Focusing on Glenn F%#king Greenwald shouldn't be missed.
From Steveningen:
In my diary Religious right vows to pitch epic fit as Supreme Court rulings loom, Catte Nappe gives us one of those simple moments of clarity that has to get sent on to Top Comments.
From Chrislove:
This comment by candid psychiatrist in poopdogcomedy's diary about Anthony Weiner's health care reform proposal for New York City may or may not have made me pee a little.
From your humble diarist:
mahakali overdrive flagged this "brilliant" comment about security and phones by bluebird of happiness in joelgp's controversial recommended diary 10 Reasons Why Greenwald is Foolish.

This "excellent" and pithy comment by DBoon was flagged by Dirtandiron in VW will not expand in Chattanooga unless labor is represented - updated, a recommended effort by Sandy on Signal.

TOP MOJO
June 21, 2013


(excluding Tip Jars and first comments)

Got mik!


  1) The blitzkreig of nasty that is coming at us from by funluvn1 — 178
  2) It seems her weak apology didn't butter up anyone. by jwinIL14 — 127
  3) An evil man trying to undo   by TomP — 111
  4) Good Gawd! by Gooserock — 109
  5) Insulin futures plummet. by Crashing Vor — 107
  6) This is such a slap in the face by kimoconnor — 105
  7) And what a delicious citizens win - by LilithGardener — 100
  8) Stellar job brother. by One Pissed Off Liberal — 92
  9) This DOJ is just pathetic.... by SixSixSix — 90
10) Well, bless her heart. by raboof — 84
11) Poison food by Reetz — 84
12) Dear Professor Mr. Preznit, by Mogolori — 82
13) People filibuster! by livebyChocolate — 79
14) He was practically giddy by hnichols — 78
15) For-profit schools, run by stupid people. n/t by JeffW — 76
16) She probably didn't feel that way toward by The Dude 415 — 75
17) And how many banksters and war criminals by HCKAD — 72
18) 30 year old friend by indubitably — 71
19) Spanking by joy221 — 71
20) Hmmm by Dallasdoc — 70
21) They were waiting to see how much by blueoregon — 70
22) This story seems to have no by Lisa Lockwood — 66
23) Look on the bright side. by Ice Blue — 66
24) Rec! Rec! Rec! by coquiero — 64
25) Well, by Dragon5616 — 63
26) freaking idiots by jplanner — 62
27) Yes, save the fetuses by hnichols — 60
28) I give it about a month before she's hired by Jeff Y — 58
29) "However we Americans voted for the Bush... by Meteor Blades — 58
30) I am at NN13, but was following last night's by nomandates — 56

TOP PHOTOS
June 21, 2013

Enjoy jotter's wonderful PictureQuilt™ below. Just click on the picture and it will magically take you to the comment that features that photo. Have fun, Kossacks!

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.