Skip to main content

I was listening to Seymour Hersh on DemocracyNow.org this morning via podcast on my morning run. What I heard made me stop running. Find a place to sit. And weep.

I have not wept for some time over the war in Iraq. I get angry, but much less angry than I did even 6 months ago. In the back of my mind this really bothers me. How can I, and the rest of the nation, have stopped getting angry as the war rages on? What is wrong with me - with us?

I suppose you can only be angry about things over which your influence is not so much for only so long. And to my credit (I hope) I have been doing a better job redirecting that anger towards longer term work for political change. Nonetheless, the war is such a terrible thing that it is downright evil to take it for granted. And I point that finger straight back to myself.

Hersh seems to know all too well that war is on. And when he talks about the war he seems to know that he knows a bit too much. In the speech I heard this morning (given by Hersh yesterday in Illinois) he didn't sound as panicked and worried as he sometimes is. But he still had truly terrible things to recount.

He started by talking about war 35 years ago. He described how a mother of soldier in Vietnam told him that she had "sent them a good boy, and they sent me back a murderer" to describe her son. Flash forward to now, and another mother tells Hersh the same thing. Only much more graphically.

The mother of a soldier who gave Hersh the first publicly released photos of torture in American prisons had told Hersh how her daughter was totally changed upon return. Depressed, isolated, unhappy. Hersh described his meeting with the mother, who showed him the photos of violent horror that took place in Iraq at the hands of soldiers under the command of George Bush.

This I had heard before. So I took in the details once again. But I could keep running, hearing about the background of the torture story wasn't too overwhelming to stop and weep or anything like that. I could think about what was being told to me. I could recount my initial horror upon first hearing the news.

Hersh finished up his account of the story of how he had gotten the photos. Then he added a little detail. He had become friends with the mother. So later she called him to tell him about how her daughter was doing. The soldier had been going in to get little black tattoos. She'd been doing this on a regular basis. A black square here, another one there. Eventually, her entire visible body (and presumably not visible as well) was covered in tattoo. Hersh put this way, she had given herself a "new skin."

Imagine your sister, mother, daughter or friend coming back from torture camps. Depressed, isolated. And she then slowly covers herself with a monocolor tatoo. Imagine that.

And she says, you know, one thing I didn't tell you that you have to know about the young woman, when she came back, every weekend, she would go and get herself tattooed, and eventually, she said, she was filling her body with large, black tattoos, and eventually, they filled up every portion of her skin, was tattooed, at least all the portions you could see, and there was no reason to make assumptions about the other portions. She was tattooed completely. It was as if, the mother said, she wanted to change her skin.

And so, they sent me a boy, and I sent him back a murderer, changing her skin. This war is going to reverberate in ways that we can’t even begin to see.

grassrootsgrowth.org

Originally posted to grassrootsgrowth on Wed May 11, 2005 at 11:00 AM PDT.

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  speechless (4.00)
    n/t

    "When fascism comes to America, it will come wrapped in an American flag" Senator Huey Long

    by Baseballgirl on Wed May 11, 2005 at 10:56:18 AM PDT

    •  it is so hard to picture (4.00)
      such pain.  such deep pain felt by all involved.

      I am lost when it comes to my country.  We are lost.

      •  incredible (4.00)
        I think a lot of people try to purge themselves of trauma with self-inflicted pain.
      •  I heard Hersh also (4.00)
        I actually found the part where he said that the Americans are killing Iraqi civilians on a regular basis with bombings, and that all of Iraq is one "free fire zone".  For those of you who recall from the campaign, this was what Kerry was referring to in 1971, that they set up free fire zones where you could shoot anything that moves, no questions asked.

        If this is true, this is outrageous!  But hearing it from Hersh isn't enough.  I wish there were more reporters who were willing to investigate and find out what is going on in Iraq.  We always hear about when insurgents attack and we hear about when the Americans go on an offensive attack and kill 100 "terrorists".  But, apart from the Italian incident, we never hear about Americans killing innocent Iraqi civilians.  Does this mean it's not happening, or that reporters haven't got the information, or are we simply being lied to?  I'm interested in the truth, and I'm getting a funny feeling we're not getting it . . .

        P.S. -- if it's the case that Hersh is exaggerating, and in fact, there are few Iraqi civilian deaths at the hands of Americans, I would like to know that, too!  I just want the truth with no agenda.

        •  Agreed (none)
          Free fire zone =killing Eye Talians
        •  It is true & it is outrageous (none)
          It would be good if Americans would stop hiding from the obvious.  

          Not only is Iraq a free-fire zone.  But when Negreponte was there he organized our very own death squaders.  They are starting to show up in incidents that are blamed on the insurgents but have no strategic (from an Iraqi point of view) value:  Black ops.  

          This is what 21st century America is.  

          If we wish to mitigate our fate at all, we need to stop this.  

          •  Can you say any more about this? (none)
            if possible -
            •  No details--I wish there were (none)
              But look at the general picture, especially the Sunni/Shi'ite civil war talk.  The US is trying to provoke discord.  If you look at the incidents--bombings, &c--in detail, some of them look like black ops.

              For a specific example, look at my diary here, and follow the links back.  

            •  PS it was Negreponte's specialty (none)
              When he served in Central America.  
            •  Hersh wrote (none)
              a piece for The new Yorker, about 6 months ago, on the "Salvadorization" of Iraq - how we had the same general who organized the hunter/killer squads in El Salvador in the 1980s, now setting up the same thing in Iraq today.

              It's worth reading.  The real agenda involves making the populace more afraid of us then they are of the resistance, by flattening cities with massive bombings, and knocking off random civilians with the death squads.  Hersh said, in his speech in Urbana yesterday, that we are currently destroying Ramadhi, just as we did Fallujah, only this time there are no embedded reporters looking on, so there will be no witnesses.  After we have accomplished that destruction, we will move on to the next city of 200-300k people and do it all over again.

              Freedom is on the march, alright, crushing the bones of the Iraqis we have murdered.

              "You may experience episodes of explosive amnesia."

              by redcloud54 on Thu May 12, 2005 at 02:56:30 AM PDT

              [ Parent ]

        •   Body Counts (none)
          http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/7818807/site/newsweek/

          "The U.S. considers all of Iraq a combat zone," says the report, which was wrapped up at the end of April, three months after the elections that were supposed to have turned the tide in this conflict. "From July 2004 to late March 2005," says the document, "there were 15,527 attacks against Coalition Forces throughout Iraq." Then comes one of several paragraphs marked S//NF (secret, not for distribution to foreign nationals): "From 1 November 2004 to 12 March 2005 there were 3306 attacks in the Baghdad area. Of these, 2400 were directed against Coalition Forces." In a span of four and a half months, which included the election turning point, that's not only a hell of a lot of hits in the capital city, it's just pure hell.
          The report in question was prepared at the direction of the Multi-National Corps commander in Iraq, Lt. Gen. John R. Vines, to answer questions about a now-infamous incident on the night of March 4. Italian journalist Giuliana Sgrena had just been released by the hostage-takers who'd held her for a month, and she was on her way to Baghdad airport with Nicola Calipari, a major general in the Italian intelligence service who had negotiated her freedom. At a U.S. roadblock on an access ramp leading to the airport highway, U.S. troops opened fire, wounding Sgrena and killing Calipari.

          "Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter." ~Martin Luther King, Jr

          by SarahLee on Wed May 11, 2005 at 10:56:14 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

      •  Actually a picture would make an eloquent point (none)
            I think a picture of her would be a very powerful thing.  That someone, especially a woman (our culture, for whatever reason, is less accepting of  women engaging in non-cosmetic surgery-based body mod)  would do something this extreme to her body to serve as mute witness to horror she can't bear to articulate, is stunning.

        That photo might be THE Picture of this war.  Just as the photo of the Little girl covered in flaming napalm woke up a previous generation to the horror a war being fought in their name, this girl's self inflicted transformation would similarly awaken  our all too complacent fellow citizens.

        Knowledge is power Power Corrupts Study Hard Be Evil

        by Magorn on Wed May 11, 2005 at 01:21:31 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  This is a total guess (4.00)
          but I would think the last thing she would want to do is be photographed and become the face of the Iraq War.

          It sounds like she is trying to escape from the world in a most surreal way. Using solid black is powerful and  disturbing (not in any racial way) because it precludes change. We have all seen people covered in tattoos. Whether we like it or it creeps us out , we can at least recognize the committment to artistic expression. This forbids artistry, forbids expression, and unltimately forbids redemption.

          Somewhere around 2001, Mr. Spock grew a beard.

          by Olds88 on Wed May 11, 2005 at 02:54:18 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

          •  I know that when it is dark and (none)
            no one can see me, I am invisable to the neked eye.  Right?  I think she [the girl] wants to just be invisable to everyone including herself but with such horrendish pain that she feels on a 24/7 basis.   I think this is the case here.  What is so sad is, that she probably will refuse help of the psych. help she should be getting.  This is the problem with women inthe battle zone.  If you want, go and ask a VN nuse [in-country] and ask about the pain she saw.  Now that Memorial Day is approching we need to really see the pain of thsi kind of sacrifice.  We need to just take this administratin and let them know what fools they have been 1 million times over.  I know, fo I still ahve nights that sleep it never to come.  It is horrendous to let those sights be forever engraved in your mind and never get rid of them.  They haunt one for the rest of ones life.  Sadly, this girl will be sufferring this pain for the rest of her life.
        •  Sure it would (none)
           But, to further exploit what is obviously a deeply troubled person, probably too much for her to bear.
           All I can say is fuck, oh fuck.
  •  Me too... (none)
    ...thoughts racing, heart beating, words fail...

    Little Black Tattoos

    To write in plain vigorous language one has to think fearlessly, and if one thinks fearlessly one cannot be politically orthodox. George Orwell, 1946

    by deepintheheartoftx on Wed May 11, 2005 at 11:05:16 AM PDT

  •  Hersh can skip the Pulitzer (4.00)
    and go straight for the Nobel.
  •  Damn (none)
    and too many other words

    Anything by Loudon Wainwright III

    by Earl on Wed May 11, 2005 at 11:10:15 AM PDT

    •  damn those who made this happen n/t (4.00)
      •  I had just come from Metafilter (4.00)
        Saw this link The recoil is so powerful. Lilly was set to publish in 2001, but after the planes hit the publisher backed out (says the post), so he was published in France. Again, the recoil is so powerful, this is about--my uncles? Your grandparents? Heroes?

        I have to remind myself that to hate this stuff is not to hate them, not to hate my country, is not to hate Iraqis, North Koreans, on and on. It is to hate war and what it does to regular people. A hate that is, unfathomably, not real enough to our current leaders. They can actually laugh at it.

        Anything by Loudon Wainwright III

        by Earl on Wed May 11, 2005 at 12:18:54 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  Sorry, missed a tag (none)
          First line in first paragraph should read:

          Saw this link following a paragraph from Robert Lilly (unlinked) regarding rapes by American soldiers in Europe between 1942 and 1945.

          Anything by Loudon Wainwright III

          by Earl on Wed May 11, 2005 at 12:21:04 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

  •  in my name (none)
    Because I identify myself deep down as an American, I feel responsible for this.  I hate myself.
    •  Self-hate... (4.00)
      ...is not the answer. Yes, we are all responsible. But responsibility is not fulfilled through self-flagellation, but by taking what action we can to stop the ongoing wrong, and then to do what can be done to make amends, though the harms done can never be, in fact, undone.
      •  yes (none)
        anger is a call to action
        •  Yes (4.00)
          Self hate only turns on us.  We have a joke in my house when our teenager does something goofy.  We say that her frontal lobes haven't come in yet, and that is a fact of science.  Military Intelligence took a bunch of kids whose lobes weren't in yet and a few sadistic elders and they created nightmares for all of us. I didn't do it though and I would have never done it.  They did it and they have lied and lied and continue to lie and I'm angry.  I will do all I can to see that justice is done when the time comes and we are able.  We need to be able though.  We need a majority in the House or the Senate.  I don't think that I will be able to rest though completely until some sort of justice is done for all they have done.
      •  I am not wearing sack cloth and ashes (4.00)
        and I am working for peace.  That reminds me ==  I went to a peace rally this weekend, and heard something very soothing.

        A methodist minister told us about a "breath prayer" (as in one you say under your breath)to say when the news of war and its victims get too overwhelming (like now).  The prayer is:

        "strengthen the hands of those who work for peace."  

      •  I disagree (3.00)
        "Yes, we are all responsible. But responsibility is not fulfilled through self-flagellation, but by taking what action we can to stop the ongoing wrong, and then to do what can be done to make amends, though the harms done can never be, in fact, undone."

        I am not responsible for what is happening.. I am totally opposed to the war and where our country is headed.  And the vast majority of the people are so propagandized that have no idea what the truth in fact is..  Our "elected" officials are totally unresponsive to what the people want, so the blame needs to be placed not upon us.  

        •  I respect your right to feel that way (4.00)
          personally, I feel less responsible than many within the united states, but far more responsible than most of rest of the world.  
          •  Lord knows (none)
            I have felt that way myself on more than one day!
            •  It's Time to Turn Up (none)
              some Operation Ivy on your Ipod and scream the lyrics all the way home.

              "Our Vulnerability!"
              "Is all our Insensitivity!"
              "And it's gonna be the death of us!"
              "Just you wait and see..."

              The GOP and the Elephant are both Introduced Species

              by roboton on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:04:32 PM PDT

              [ Parent ]

              •  asdf (4.00)
                On the turning away
                From the pale and downtrodden
                And the words they say
                Which we won't understand
                Don't accept that what's happening
                Is just a case of others' suffering
                Or you'll find that you're joining in
                The turning away.

                It's a sin that somehow
                Light is changing to shadow
                And casting its shroud
                Over all we have known
                Unaware how the ranks have grown
                Driven on by a heart of stone
                We could find that we're all alone
                In the dream of the proud.

                On the wings of the night
                As the daytime is stirring
                Where the speechless unite
                In a silent accord
                Using words you will find are strange
                And mesmerised as they light the flame
                Feel the new wind of change
                On the wings of the night.

                No more turning away
                From the weak and the weary
                No more turning away
                From the coldness inside
                Just a world that we all must share
                It's not enough just to stand and stare
                Is it only a dream that there'll be
                No more turning away?

                (Pink Floyd)

                "Salvation is by way of the truth, not by way of the fatherland" -- Chaadaev

                by sagesource on Wed May 11, 2005 at 04:15:00 PM PDT

                [ Parent ]

  •  And there are the problems we won't see (4.00)
    the invisible disabilities.  Reports project an incredible number of neurological injuries from this war, the kind of injuries that used to kill but now leave them walking wounded in the brain.

    Reports project incredible learning problems for these vets -- and so many of them were in the Guard or reserves not to go to war but to go to college.  And the campuses are not ready for this, and it will take a lot of funding to help them and help us learn how to help them, and this war already is bankrupting us, and state budgets already are so bankrupt that the cutbacks at public universities are bad, bad, bad.

    Without going into details, I know of what I speak when it comes to neurological injuries (TBA) and the impact on learning.  I know of what I speak when it comes to how campuses already deal -- or don't -- with this.  And I fear that we are going to really let these vets down, unless we all get ready for their return now.

    "Let all the dreamers wake the nation." -- Carly Simon

    by Cream City on Wed May 11, 2005 at 11:19:32 AM PDT

  •  Every act in a war (4.00)
    Has about 100 untold victims.

    If this person has a child, for example, they will also be affected.  And maybe the grand-child as well, etc. etc.

    This is why war is such a bad thing.

    Not only does it kill people and destroy things that have taken a lot of people a lot of time to build/make/create, but it harms people's psyches, and those people then go out and harm other people, and so on.  It's something insidious and very hard to make right again.  It takes a lot more effort to fix it, and very few people are aware of how to do the fixing.  

    I know, because my mother and father were in the Second World War, and have yet to recover from it.  

  •  Yes, an excellent interview. For those of you (none)
    that do not listen to Amy Goodman's show, please check out the website, find a local station that broadcasts it or stream online. By mid afternoon there is typically a transcript to forward along to others.

    And please donate what monies you can.

  •  Thank you for Posting this (4.00)
    I don't know what to say.  I had an older friend who  was a helicopter door gunner in Viet Nam.  He came back and became a Minister.  My mother's interpretation at the time was that he came back screwed up.  She's an atheist.  For a long time I thought she was right.
    But just now, your diary has caused me to understand that he was one of the lucky ones.

    ...get rid of that DoD "Total Information Awareness" program that's right out of George Orwell's 1984.... AL GORE, 2003

    by TeresaInPa on Wed May 11, 2005 at 11:52:28 AM PDT

  •  Girl in a cafe (4.00)
    I watched a girl shoot up in the back of a San Francisco cafe once.  Not a common sight in this city and fairly shocking to me that someone would do it so openly.  The thing that got me most though, was what this young woman had done to her face.  From ear to ear, over her cheekbones and the bridge of her nose was a black, one-inch wide band of tatoo.  I thought to myself that this woman wanted to die, to x herself out.  It's the same feeling of nihilism that comes from hearing Hersch's report.
  •  Oh, God (none)
    I'm sitting here shaking in my office.

    Two-step, lockstep, goosestep: Herr Busch's three-step plan to a righter tomorrow.

    by The Termite on Wed May 11, 2005 at 11:57:15 AM PDT

  •  This reminds me of a slogan from the 60's (3.80)
    War is not healthy for people and other living things. I also cry... for the soldiers who pose like ghouls with dead bodies, for the faceless Iraqi children who now know the heartless truth of war and death, for the families who welcome home their soldiers only to find a disturbed stranger. Most of all, I cry for my country that has lost it's capacity to feel, to care... America has lost it's heart and I'm afraid that it is loosing it's soul.
  •  Self-Mutilation (4.00)
    is a behavior throughout history done by those who believe they must atone for sin, an act they committed, or feelings of guilt -- whether or not they personally have any reason to feel that way.

    It can be an outward expression of disgust with the self, or self-loathing.

    Not all of the time, of course.  But difficult to believe that this woman is happily engaging in a bit of body decorating to enhance her identity image.  Tragic.

    They burn our children in their wars and grow rich beyond the dreams of avarice.

    by Limelite on Wed May 11, 2005 at 12:03:27 PM PDT

  •  Avoiding reality (4.00)
    My husband told me that one of his friends has stopped listening to NPR on the way to work in the morning.  I asked why.  He said his friend was tired of hearing bad news about Iraq.

    When I heard this, my outrage meter went absolutely over the top.  This is a man who not only voted for Bush but has been a loyal supporter of our military approach in the mideast. This is also a man who went through a period of anxiety while his son was stationed in Kuwait.  Now he's turning off NPR because he doesn't want to hear the bad news.

    The point here, however, is that his friend never used the phrase "bad news."  His reasons for turn off the news were entirely vague and non-specific.  This fine hawk can't even admit to himself that things are not going well;  that admission would clearly bring him face to face with the fiction created around this war.

    So, he's turned off one of the few sources we have left of honest (or at least not dishonest) coverage of the situation in Iraq.

    Our miserable press is allowing the citizens of this nation to hid from this war and its devastation.  As Hersh suggests, one of these days we will have to deal with the truth and it won't be pleasant -- it won't be something my husband's friend can simply turn off.

    •  Not ENTIRELY dishonest... (none)
      I remember, not too long ago, an interview on NPR in which some Neocon or Religious Right-ist (can't remember which) was spouting some pretty vile stuff and the host was doing his best to bail said person out of the fire. As i was listening i got the distinct impression someone had made a decision to put this person on-air with a specific result in mind and (when it was clear the person was self-destructive and not an effective advocate for the position) the host tried to help out. I actually wrote something up on that but i can't remember where i stashed it.

      The Shapeshifter's Blog -- Politics, Philosophy, and Madness!

      by Shapeshifter on Wed May 11, 2005 at 02:19:40 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  My cousin flies an F-18 (none)
        I swear to god if he dies over the skies of Iraq I will never forgive a single person who supported this war.

        It was bullshit from day one, you were all lied to. Accept it, and get pissed off about it.

        The GOP and the Elephant are both Introduced Species

        by roboton on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:09:16 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  You're preaching to the choir (none)
          ...At least, on my account.

          I'm one of those people who was opposed to the war from the very start. In fact, my opposition might have helped push my father away from the Republicans.

          Let me tell that story, actually:

          To begin with, i never believed Iraq had WMD or whatnot. Sure, there was a possibility they did--but lots of things are possible and in the case of WMD and Iraq the facts were all very skewed and diagonal to the actual matter.

          My father and i got into a discussion about this when i mentioned i didn't buy it. At the time he was a moderate Republican (had been a party-line Republican for his entire life) and he more or less thought it was inconceivable that the Republicans would lie about something like this. It would be, he thought, such a gross violation of their duty as elected officials that it was unthinkable. In other words, he trusted them.

          But unlike some others (f'rinstance, Mr. B.O. himself: Bill O'Reilly) he realized early on (post-invasion) that, no, there weren't going to be WMD in Iraq. That was, i believe, the start of his real break with the Republican Party. In 2004 he voted Kerry.

          The Shapeshifter's Blog -- Politics, Philosophy, and Madness!

          by Shapeshifter on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:51:10 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

      •  I lost a lot of faith in NPR (4.00)
        during the run up to war. On at least three separate occasions ATC ran long interviews with Khidhir Hamza who billed himself as "Saddam's Bombmaker" (and who just happened to have written a book by the same name and was available for speaking engagements). He claimed to have been forced to build Saddam's nuclear arsenal until he escaped to the west. NPR breathlessly listened to his "inside scoop" on Iraq's nuclear program-- how many bombs they could produce, how big, where they were hiding them...on and on.

        Obviously, he was full of shit. He was in charge of a small portion of the enrichment process in the late 80's. He retired before the first Gulf war. Telling of his "critical" role in Iraq's nuclear program, he emmigrated a year before sending for his wife. Not exactly a mad dash for the barbed wire.

        The sad thing was, all this was known before his first interview to anyone who did the slightest bit ofgoggling. I emailed NPR on several occasions pointing out that Hamza was a fraud, but there was no indication they ever read my message.

        The warnings intensified: Saddam could have nukes in a few months, at the push of a button, by the twitch of his nose. By the second interview, the French were deeply involved in Saddam's scheme (no doubt Germany and Russia as well).

        Finally though, on his last known interview, it was obvious NPR was getting suspicious. The interviewer politely asked why we hadn't found anything yet (this being sometime after the fall of Baghdad). Hamza launched into totally new allegations that chemical weapons and terrorist training grounds-- subjects he had no expertise in-- would be found in the next few days.

        And that's where ended. Suckered. Used. No follow up. No investigation. No following the money. Just a non-event.

        Somewhere around 2001, Mr. Spock grew a beard.

        by Olds88 on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:42:11 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

  •  my god (none)
    by the time i was done reading, i didnt realize that my mouth had dropped. literally gaping wide open. this is insane.

    With great power, comes great responsibility - Spider Man, my favorite philosopher

    by grinnellian on Wed May 11, 2005 at 12:35:38 PM PDT

  •  I was at that talk (3.50)
    yesterday...and while I agree it IS an amazing statement...I just wish he had some documentation to back it up.

    Sponge Bob, Mandrake, Cartoons. That's how your hard-core islamahomocommienazis work.

    by Benito on Wed May 11, 2005 at 12:37:19 PM PDT

  •  This is the fourth or fifth time in a year (4.00)
    that I have heard Hersh tell the black tattoo story, and one other time it was on Democracy Now, in a direct interview with Goodman.  It was in the Progressive recently.  He retells this in speeches all the time.

    Why this has not already been ground into the American conscience I do not know.

    What the hell is happening to us?

  •  So sad (none)
    The depth of that sorrow and pain is unfathomable.  This administration is doing a huge injustice to our servicepeople.
  •  As Edwin Starr sang . . . (none)
    "War can't give life, it can only take it away."

    I feel so lucky that my husband got out of the Army when he did, so that he did not have to go to Iraq-who knows what would have happened then.

    I too, feel so guilty about what is being done in our name in Iraq.  We have to keep having these conversations so that others realize how bad things are in Iraq.

    "Freedom means freedom for people who think differently." Rosa Luxemburg

    by earnersparks on Wed May 11, 2005 at 12:54:32 PM PDT

  •  Not the only victims (none)
    Our soldiers who were directed to take part in torture also suffer incredibly.
    •  Just the PTSD Vietnam Vets (none)
      Who live out of shopping carts in our major cities, we are breeding another generation of emotionally devastated vets who will look forward to the same cruel treatment. Welcome back, soldier. What do you mean you're disabled? You got all your limbs and senses, now get along.

      We the undersigned urge you to support Federal funding for research using human pluripotent stem cells. -80 Nobel Laureates to Pres. Bush

      by easong on Wed May 11, 2005 at 02:13:09 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  By the way (none)
        My husband's second opinion came in as PTSD.  They attempted to say that he had Generalized Anxiety Disorder, but his PTSD markers are off the charts according to the eval we paid to have done.
        •  and why would they deny him that? (none)
          how could they ignore the elephant in the room (the fact he was in a FRIGGEN WAR, for gods sake) and attribute his anxiety to a generalized disorder?  
          •  as far ast teh VN vet goes (none)
            they are  just now going in for eval of PTSD...after all these years and getting their status qualified....can you imagine after all these years!!  

            Some are just now getting their Agent Orange status qualified....after all these years...

            So now for a VERRRRRY long time now we have to look forward to all t he ppl who will be trying for their status qualification, if at all.

            This young lady is not just deteriationg her outer self, it is her inner self that she is trying to hide.  Just think of it for a min or so...Please.....now do you think she will ever get away with it?  NO for if she ever has a chance to become healthy again in her mind thought, she will have all those tattoos to remind her of her depression and denial of herself.  It will go on for a very long time for her...in afraid.

        •  Don't let go... (none)
          ... make them acknowledge the real harm done to your husband, and all the others involved in this disgusting mess.

          After my dose of dKos today, I am in danger of inflicting serious damage on the next SUV I see with a stupid yellow ribbon magnet on it.

      •  I've said this for the longest time (none)
        I live in the center of Denver.  During rush "hour" on all well-traveled intersections you are likely to find a homeless Vietnam vet with a sign and a haunted, hopeless stare.  Nearby is a very large high school.  How many of them, these young people -- children really -- who are so, so innocent (in their jaded little way) will be haunting these intersections in the years to come?

        Sometimes I can't bear to contemplate it.

        The chips are down. Find your outrage.

        by sj on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:23:36 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  San Francisco is Full of Them (4.00)
          Living in Golden Gate park, sleeping under the freeways, haunting building fronts in the Tenderloin, horrible way to treat your vets. Of course they have substance abuse issues, wouldn't you?

          We the undersigned urge you to support Federal funding for research using human pluripotent stem cells. -80 Nobel Laureates to Pres. Bush

          by easong on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:43:23 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

      •  Does it have to be every generation? n/t (none)

        Infidels in all ages have battled for the rights of man, and have at all times been the advocates of truth and justice... Robert Ingersol

        by BMarshall on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:50:10 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

    •  My thoughts too (none)
      They pull people out of their worlds, put them in Hell, then send them to prison when they act like devils. "When in Rome" isn't always a conscious choice. Sometimes it's a defense mechanism. Sometimes it's produced by terror.

      How do we make a measuring stick for people who are strong enough to resist in such situations? How do we put a bright light on them, point to them and say, "This is how to act if you find yourself in a horrible situation like that?" The military is obviously not teaching this.

      Anything by Loudon Wainwright III

      by Earl on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:25:13 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  Very well-done diary .. (none)
    I am so glad you did this story, and so well.

    I could listen to Seymour Hersh anytime, anywhere.  

    Susan in Port Angeles (my cat)

    by SusanHu on Wed May 11, 2005 at 01:16:31 PM PDT

  •  I have wondered often about this. (4.00)
    angry
    angry

    I had a comment, but I decided to just delete it all and say that I'm angry.

  •  Thank you (none)
    for sharing this. It is incredibly tragic...
  •  My favorite short story (none)
    ...has always been Flannery O'Connor's "Parker's Back," about a tortured soul who has a tattoos covering every inch of his body except his back.  It made me cry when I read it all those years ago in high school, and the same tears are welling up right now.
  •  R. Crumb and his dad (none)
    From The R. Crumb Handbook:
    When my father came home to Philadelphia in 1947, after the war, it was very traumatic for me. I didn't like him. He was very strict and hard on us, and he had a violent temper. We were all afraid of him. My dad used to say that he could easily kill a man with his bare hands. He was a trained killer.

    Sometime on the 1950s I asked him how many Japs he thought he'd killed during the war. "Well," he told me, "It's hard to say because we killed so many from a distance, but, that I know of ... Oh, 45 or 50."

    Wow! My dad the mass murderer! All our dads were killers if they were in the war. They had that under their belt. They had killed other humans.


  •  Here's the whole article from Demo Now (none)
    Pardon me if this is duped.

    But in the middle of all of this, I get a call from a mother in the East coast, Northeast, working class, lower middle class, very religious, Catholic family. She said, I have to talk to you. I go see her. I drive somewhere, fly somewhere, and her story is simply this. She had a daughter that was in the military police unit that was at Abu Ghraib. And the whole unit had come back in March, of -- The sequence is: they get there in the fall of 2003. Their reported after doing their games in the January of 2004. In March she is sent home. Nothing is public yet. The daughter is sent home. The whole unit is sent home. She comes home a different person. She had been married. She was young. She went into the Reserves, I think it was the Army Reserves to get money, not for college or for -- you know, these -- some of these people worked as night clerks in pizza shops in West Virginia. This not -- this is not very sophisticated. She came back and she left her husband. She just had been married before. She left her husband, moved out of the house, moved out of the city, moved out to another home, another apartment in another city and began working a different job. And moved away from everybody. Then over -- as the spring went on, she would go every weekend, this daughter, and every weekend she would go to a tattoo shop and get large black tattoos put on her, over increasingly -- over her body, the back, the arms, the legs, and her mother was frantic. What's going on? Comes Abu Ghraib, and she reads the stories, and she sees it. And she says to her daughter, "Were you there?" She goes to the apartment. The daughter slams the door. The mother then goes -- the daughter had come home -- before she had gone to Iraq, the mother had given her a portable computer. One of the computers that had a DVD in it, with the idea being that when she was there, she could watch movies, you know, while she was overseas, sort of a -- I hadn't thought about it, a great idea. Turns out a lot of people do it. She had given her a portable computer, and when the kid came back she had returned it, one of the things, and the mother then said I went and looked at the computer. She knows -- she doesn't know about depression. She doesn't know about Freud. She just said, I was just -- I was just going to clean it up, she said. I had decided to use it again. She wouldn't say anything more why she went to look at it after Abu Ghraib. She opened it up, and sure enough there was a file marked "Iraq". She hit the button. Out came 100 photographs. They were photographs that became -- one of them was published. We published one, just one in The New Yorker. It was about an Arab. This is something no mother should see and daughter should see too. It was the Arab man leaning against bars, the prisoner naked, two dogs, two shepherds, remember, on each side of him. The New Yorker published it, a pretty large photograph. What we didn't publish was the sequence showed the dogs did bite the man -- pretty hard. A lot of blood. So she saw that and she called me, and away we go. There's another story.

    Link is here from Democracy Now, January 2005 via Andymatic.

    Kos has something of the same thing in the archives.

    One-fifth of the people are against everything all the time.--Bobby Kennedy

    by blksista on Wed May 11, 2005 at 01:53:28 PM PDT

    •  So . . . (none)
      so why aren't more of those photos out there?  And as noted a few posts up, why aren't we hearing from this girl?  Privacy might be the first reasonable answer, but then again, Hersh is talking about it all over the place, and I don't imagine there are too many women covered from head to toe in black tats.  

      He tells powerful stories.  But the people who are willing to take him at his word are not the people who need to hear it most.  Those people need not just the story, but the pictures and people behind the story.

      •  photos??? (none)
        this story, i think it first came out in january. that's when hersh talked about it. and i just wonder, has he seen this girl ever?

        i don't know--it's a powerful, symbolic act, but until i see a photo, i'll wonder if it's true.

      •  Photos. (none)
        From what I've read there are a lot of photos out there that show what happened at Abu Ghraib.  I recall reading about some that showed young people being sexually assaulted by Iraqi prison guards (I think this was from Hersh again but was confirmed by a Congressional staffer).  I know there were other photos that were deemed too gruesome to print, like the ones referenced above.  Some Congresspeople commented about them during hearings that happened when this stuff came out.  They wouldn't release that stuff.

        The media backs off of the photos.  They took a big hit for publishing them in the first place.  They won't touch this.  They are scared shitless of being called "liberal" or "disloyal" or whatever.  They are spineless cowards and deserve as much blame for this as our so-called leaders.

        My father is a faithful Fox News viewer.  He and I used to be able to talk about politics, but since the war if we get started it ends in an argument.  He says, without apology, that the media had no business publishing the photos.  He says nothing about whether the soldiers are doing wrong, whether their superiors are doing wrong.  Just that the photos should never have been published.

        I understand now how fascism works.  My own father would turn a blind eye on any atrocity if he was lead effectively.

  •  Kafka's Penal colony (none)
    that woman just peformed the Harrow on herself.
    gads...
  •  Hersh has discussed this (none)
    several times, and I am thankful, it is powerful metaphor.

    May every budding freak of a baby neo con, every wishful lustful "Liberal" hawk, and without a doubt, every single god damed congress person, R and D alike, who voted for that war be forced to hear and read this horrifying story.  

    That young woman stands as symbol for the war and America.  We are obliterating ourselves thru war, led there by Bush.  ANd so many happily enabled him.  Took decades to bring us to enabling the likes of Bush, but the nation did it, and continues.

    FOR SHAME AMERICA.

  •  Just recently (4.00)
    I was in Florida for a friend's wedding.  She was marrying a retired Marine, so many of the groomsmen were also ex-military, though most got out just before the Iraq war started.

    There was, however, one young man there who did go to Iraq...twice.  Over the course of the week I stayed there, my pregnancy insomnia and refusal to adjust to the time change and his absolute refusal to sleep made us pretty regualr nighttime companions... talking mostly about the war, about all the things that went wrong.

    Growing up with military parents, this young man always wanted to give back to his country, to join the Marines and help make the world a better place.  Going in, he earned the distinction of the one guy in his platoon to answer "no" to a disturbing psych test question : "Would you be willing to take the life of a child if children had previously posed a threat to your life?"

    He went in a good, solid kid.  Now he's killed... "7 people in self defence," he told me, "1 in what the Marines call a 'fatal error' (the man wouldn't respond to calls to halt, freeze, or desist, and ran upon the Marines)."  Then he paused, and added quietly "and 438 kids."

    I didn't ask (how could I?) so I just waited.  Eventually the story unraveled.  An insugent had been firing on them all day and all night, and eventually ran into a building for shelter.  As the guy firing the rockets that day, he was told to take the building down around the guy's ears.  "What's in the building?" he asked over and over, only to be repeatedly told that it was abandoned and empty.  The man shot at them from the building again, so my young Marine took the building down.

    Walking past it later, he'd had to be removed by the medic as he knelt in the rubble inconsolable.  It had been a children's hospital, and his CO had known that.

    This young man has been so disillusioned, so betrayed, so angered, that he just sort of drifts, now.  It isn't just the horror of what goes on over there, as the diary points out, but what it does to our guys and girls...the permanent physical and psychiatric scars that they'll never get away from.

    How do we stop this?

    Rescued, Reformed and Recovering Former Republican

    by Round Peg Inna Square Hole on Wed May 11, 2005 at 02:13:57 PM PDT

    •  Take to the streets in droves (none)
      Demand them home now!
      •  Will that change anything, you think? (none)
        'Cause I'm not sure it will.  All BushCo needs to do it point out that we're marching to make "America safe for the terrorists" and that we can all be ignored since we're "Godless babykilling, hippies on welfare who want to raise taxes."

        Sometimes, this country is so depressing to live in.

        Rescued, Reformed and Recovering Former Republican

        by Round Peg Inna Square Hole on Wed May 11, 2005 at 02:36:19 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

    •  Media Alert (none)
      I know this is a painful story.. but this should be sent to local and national news. It is particularly horrifying that this soldier tried to do the right thing and his CO overroad him with an immoral order.
      •  But the soldier in question (none)
        Just wants to avoid dealing with those people ever again.  He's so shaken, I don't think he could handle all the interviews and problems that the infamy would bring.

        Sad, though.  It would make a point about how the government isn't only lying to us, but to the men and women out there as well.

        Rescued, Reformed and Recovering Former Republican

        by Round Peg Inna Square Hole on Wed May 11, 2005 at 02:41:09 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  if there is any universal justice (none)
          each soul that has been lost in this war will visit its pain on Bush and each of those who make his reign possible.

          There is no universal justice.

          These babies have died for chimpy's profit.  I can not imagine a greater sin, honestly.

          Anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job. - Douglas Adams

          by nika7k on Wed May 11, 2005 at 05:24:12 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

        •  He doesn't have to tell it himself (none)
          He could tell one reporter, one writer, one minister.  
          He could release a signed transcript.
           He could have someone send the signed transcript to his congressperson and get it entered into the congressional record.
          There must be something.
          Shouldn't have to carry it around all by himself.
          •  I agree (none)
            And I've mentioned as much.  I think he's just recovering still, and doesn't want anymore problems.  Eventually I'm sure he'll seek out someone to give the story to, but other than a few friends and a shrink, I don't think he's told anyone.

            Rescued, Reformed and Recovering Former Republican

            by Round Peg Inna Square Hole on Thu May 12, 2005 at 08:05:15 AM PDT

            [ Parent ]

    •  Oh my God (none)
      I had heard this story of Hersh's before and so was able to react with deep sadness but decorum.

      But this story, this young man, this deliberate lie... my heart is breaking all over again.  And tears are streaming down my cheeks in this very public place.

      The chips are down. Find your outrage.

      by sj on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:16:19 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Oh Fuck (4.00)
      I was coping with the thread up to that moment. I can do psychologically wierd, but being the guy that pulled the trigger on 438 kids when the man who said go knew what he was about to do is such a deep fucking betrayal I have nowhere to go.

      You want evil? You got it. And it wears a US flag. Yes, Bush is the fucker who should wear this, but the CO is a living in the moment, genuine war criminal and he is also the global face of the US.

      When the backlash for this arrives, and the boot is on the other foot, I wonder how Americans will feel as their enemies scream "kill them all, and let god sort them out"

      Oh, holy fuck what a mess.

      "Till the Last Dog Dies"

      by Deep Dark on Wed May 11, 2005 at 09:14:06 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  This is a war crime. (4.00)
      Bombing a hospital is a war crime. If the CO knew he should be in prison.
      I can't help wondering how many other war crimes have been committed in the name of freedom and democracy.
  •  Tattoos- It's an obsession (none)
    I certainly don't want to make light of the subject but I wouldn't necessarily correlate the tattoos to the psychological trauma this soldier has experienced.  I have a daughter who has never seen war, torture or abuse but for some reason, she feels she must cover herself with tattoos.  She is an middle class spoiled white kid from the 'burbs.  For her it's an obsession.  It gives her a strange pleasure that I can not comprehend.  The tattoos are colorful and artistic but they cover the most flawless, translucent, ivory skin.  It's heartbreaking.  I worry day and night and wonder where I went wrong but the simple truth is that tattoos are more than a trend or fad.  They are part of some people's lifestyles these days.  I recently met with a couple her age who were all excited when I told them about her sleeves.  They think that's the coolest thing in the world.  
    The good news is that lasers are improving all of the time and there is research that will someday make tattoos just a fond memory of reckless youth.  The bad news is that it is still very expensive and imperfect.  In the meantime, I wouldn't say that tattooing oneself to death is the worst thing in the world.  If the work is done well, the effect can be quite stunning.  It's just something most of us wouldn't choose for ourselves because we are older and we know that our personalities change but our skins generally don't.  

    "Choose something like a star to stay your mind on- and be staid"

    by goldberry on Wed May 11, 2005 at 02:32:28 PM PDT

    •  That Beautiful Butterfly Tattoo (none)
      Looks pretty hot on the rear end of a 20 year old, but wait until she's 63 -- it'll be one stretched out old turkey.

      We the undersigned urge you to support Federal funding for research using human pluripotent stem cells. -80 Nobel Laureates to Pres. Bush

      by easong on Wed May 11, 2005 at 03:46:07 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Among the many iengaging characters (none)
      which people the hundreds of thousands of Chinese Folk Tales is the Embroidered Man, or the Brocaded Hero, endowed with mythical strength and combativity. He immediately sprang to mind because his skin is described exactly as you describe your daughter's. I sympathize, but there are ways of taking it into consideration on a lighter note. Some young over-respond to peer group pressures; it seems to me to be a lateral response. I don't know whether that helps, I hope so, which is why I have been so bold as tolay it on you.

      There is a difference of light-years between "emebellishment" and blotting out.

  •  "Jacob's Ladder" (none)
    Time to rewatch the movie for an example of the damage war can do to the human mind, especially with the aid of military experiments.

    To thine own self be true - W.S.

    by Agathena on Wed May 11, 2005 at 02:52:23 PM PDT

  •  I have a tattoo (none)
    Of a red om sign, representing my hindu upbringing, on my left bicep. It looks hardcore, and I love it.
    I feel bad for this person who is tattoing their whole body.
    Fuck Bush for pushing this war on our generation of soldiers.

    John Kerry 2008, the leader of the youth of America.

    by desiunion on Wed May 11, 2005 at 02:59:56 PM PDT

  •  Sad. She's one of too many damaged by this war. (none)
    And, Seymour Hersh should release all abuse/torture photos in his possession.  Bombard the American public with too many photos to ignore.  Rumsfield was running scared(of worse images to follow) when this story broke but Hersh never followed through.
  •  pain cleanses (none)
    From personal experience I can tell you that sometimes the only way to break through shock and mental anguish is through physical pain.

    The physical pain shocks you back into your body and clears the fog of horror.

    That she chose black boxes that eventually covered her body is even more telling.  

    Since she can't erase the mental pain she's tried to move the darkness in her mind outside of herself.

    My heart breaks for her.

    May she find peace.

  •  I worry too about her skin (none)
    It can't be good for it all to be tattooed solid black - that just doesn't sound at all healthy.  Skin is our largest organ.  

    Just sounds like it would lead to medical problems on top of all the rest.

    Tattoo artists are supposed to be licensed, aren't they?

    •  not that bad (none)
      Tattoos don't interfere with anything, really.  If you PAINT somebody black, they can't sweat and that isn't good, but tattoos don't do that.  Unless you're allergic, the ink gets absorbed into the cells and just sits there.  It's not part of anything the cells do so they just ignore it.  The problem would be that poking that many holes in somebody makes infections pretty easy.  If they're doing it in sections it's probably not that bad though.
  •  If this can be confirmed (none)
    If this can be confirmed, I'd be seriously interested in putting up a Web site where, week by week, a photograph of Bush is obliterated as this young woman has been. Once Bush is totally tatooed over, we can start on Cheney, then Rumsfeld, etc.

    The hope would be to send a collective shiver down people's spines and call attention to the toll the war is taking on our troops. (Of course, the actual result is more likely to be a visit from the Secret Service. Oh well, maybe it would bump me to the top of the line to Canada if that time comes.)

  •  Weeping (none)
    with you and a lot more  frequently lately.  I weep for our country.  The way it was; what it has become now in 5 years.  I  shudder to think of the next 3 1/2.  Will anything be salvagable then, even assuming that we get our power back?  And will we (dems) make a change? Seems like far too many dems vote in lock step with the repugs.  I am beginning to believe, with few exceptions, that both parties are corrupt.  
  •  and even better than the self-inflicted pain... (4.00)
    is the pain the PTSD'd vet will inflict on the  spouses and sadly the kids, who will be the hidden casualties of this conflict.

    My 3 tour vietnam conflict combat vet dad gave me a childhood that would make a lot of you shit your pants.

    what a shame that we don't learn from history, but i suppose you'd actually have to study it to do any type of learning from it.

  •  A good friend of mine totally tattoo'ed himself (none)
    after 3 tours of duty in Vietnam.  It didn't happen all at once, but he built it up incrementally and steadily over about 10 years or so.  Flowers and treads and designs.  Anthropomorphized skulls around his neck.  A huge Jesus and crown of thorns on his back.  

    He was raised Jewish.  

  •  It's called (none)
    Post traumatic stress disorder. And a lot of soldiers have it. A lot of people coming straight out of basic (where the real point is to train people to function under extreme stress) do. A lot of nonsoldiers have it. It's a horrible horrible disease. Its a horrible hallmark of a society that hasnt the slightest interest in mental health or even advancing the psuedoscience of psychology into a real one.

    The little stories touch us. Or the stories that fit our ideological needs. Or the stories that are unusual.. or unusually tragic.

    The real tragedy is much bigger. The real tragedy is much older. The real tragedy will slip quietly back under the carpet once this minicycle of history is over. Its' signs are abundant. The viet nam vets living in alleys we still ignore. The world war two vets who never recovered and died as the town drunk.. or lived out their lives in now-nonexistant mental institutions. Or who snapped and went wild.. or committed violence on others or themselves.

    We're creating more of them. And not just the right. Or the generals. Or the politicians. Americans have a larger appetite for third person violence than any other people on earth. We love sending the poor and the nonwhite off to live our hollywood created fantasies. To fund covert armies based on the same. To find new enemies of all that is white and upperclass and send the poor and the "other" off to die killing it. The thing we never understand is that they come back. That they arent all the same as when they left. That a lot of them are no longer healthy and will spend their lives fighting the disease service to us inflicted on them.

    We must take mental health seirously in this country. As something more than a means of selling (prescription) product. As something more than a means of playing legal games. As something more than a way to demonise. As something more than a way to create a new guild for the 'professional class'. A good place to start would be with the victims who are coming home. We know america will never admit fault, much less attempt to heal the foreign victims of our ego. But at least maybe we can for once begin to heal the ones we sent. Physically, mentally and even financially. Just this once.

    They really arent disposable.

    The Democratic party needs to adopt its own moral and values principles (clawed)

    by cdreid on Thu May 12, 2005 at 03:22:31 AM PDT

  •  Blessed are the truth-tellers (none)
    I don't know what else to say.  
Meteor Blades, shari, RobertInWisconsin, MichaelPH, Baseballgirl, sj, buffalo soldier, easong, thsisnotanexit, Hubris Sonic, hazey, Irfo, Ray Radlein, randompost, Rayne, SarahLee, teacherken, gaianne, gogol, yerioy, tikkun, RHunter, Joan McCarter, Blue the Wild Dog, Groper, Unstable Isotope, NYmom, ScientistMom in NY, gorlim, OtherDoug, naderhader, Stoy, Titian, mlkisler, Wintermute, TeresaInPa, Lufah, nimc, beagleandtabby, Heteraetcaetera, Pesto, shetquaker, Page van der Linden, Round Peg Inna Square Hole, hfiend, Voodoo, blksista, dash888, Abou Ben Adhem, object16, redtravelmaster, HStewart, strengthANDwisdom, Plan9, daaawi, RubDMC, catnip, alain2112, mrsdbrown1, Miss Devore, bronte17, KB, RichardG, Dr Know, silas216, daisy democrat, jem6x, saint, colinb, maxschell, b2witte, duckyindc, astanhope, boadicea, ksh01, foolrex, ZanderOC, mrblifil, biggb23, Aquarius40, chimpy, ides, L0kI, yamalicious, lauri, Fe, sophiebrown, mystified, ethans mom, ArkieOkie, Spindizzy, fumie, high uintas, Bob Quixote, byebyeblinkie, Nag, MCL, ems mom, NYC Sophia, cscs, Miss Jones, PeterLee, missliberties, mrigney, Estragon, dissident, Nina, Clever, wont get fooled again, original practice, Persimmon, purplebutterfly, khowell, Magorn, Maria in Pgh, Ascendent, beachmom, socal, Eddie Haskell, sommervr, Earl, alizard, Noisy Democrat, parkslopper50, ybruti, Man Eegee, simplesinger, DrReason, NapaJulie, Marianne Benz, Steven D, HK, Ioo, Shapeshifter, Limelite, mdgluon, supersoling, MichDeb, vcmvo2, Fiction59 Fool On The Hill, DCleviathan, pattyp, redcloud54, j sundman, deepintheheartoftx, greycat, coloradobl, reichstagfire, Revel8n, revbludge, chinook, wobblie, cdicely

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site