Daily Kos

The Beginning of the Right Wing Katrina Spam Email Campaign

Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 02:05:40 PM PDT

These forwarded emails are starting to filter in. I really honestly think that the GOP kicks our ass on spinning via forwarded emails. They are probably the most influential thing now. Here's a couple I got today below:
"To my friends and family:

What I have seen since Katrina:

The poor and the wealthy hurt by the storm.

Black, white, Hispanic, Oriental and Indian all hurt by the storm.

Christian people giving, giving, giving.

Churches going all out to minister in Jesus' name.

Neighbors going door to door helping one another.

Thugs and hoodlums going door to door looking for someone vulnerable.

Ice and water being fought over as police tried to keep the peace.

People coming up from New Orleans & taking over empty houses because shelters are full.

Out of town volunteers coming with food and staying for a week now and still serving it.

The Churches all over this part of the country doing what Christians do in a crisis.

Fema doing a wonderful job in getting help to us.

The Red Cross doing a great job in the shelters.

The Salvation Army doing a great job in the community.

Four Hundred crewman from everywhere bringing back the power to our homes, churches and businesses.

Lines at service stations a block to a mile long.

National Guardsman patrolling the streets of McComb along with Kentucky policemen protecting us from the hoodlums and thugs of McComb, Pike County and New Orleans (the most dangerous city in the world before Katrina.)

Drug dealers working outside shelters.

Doctors, nurses and other hospital personnel working tirelessly, even sleeping in the hospital to do the job God called them to do.

WHAT I HAVE NOT SEEN:

The ACLU setting up a feeding line.

People for the American Way helping in the shelters.

The NAACP doing any work whatsoever.

The American Atheist organization serving meals in the shelters.

Jesse Jackson directing traffic at the gas stations.

I could go on but you get my message. Its the Christian people with love and compassion who do the work.

The gripers in Congress should come on down and get in line to pass the water and the ice. Are you listening Hillary, Chuck, Teddy and all the sorry loafers we call senators and congressmen. They don't have a clue as to what this life is all about here on the Gulf Coast.

Boy I feel better now.

David A. Millican"

______

Here's another

© 2000 WorldNetDaily.com-->© 2005 Creators Syndicate Inc.
In his 1935 State of the Union Address, FDR spoke to a nation mired in the Depression, but still marinated in conservative values:

"Continued dependence" upon welfare, said FDR, "induces a spiritual disintegration fundamentally destructive to the national fiber. To dole out relief in this way is to administer a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit."

Behind FDR's statement was the conviction that, while the government must step in in an emergency, in normal times, men provide the food, clothing and shelter for their families.

And we did, until the war pulled us out of the Depression and a postwar boom made us, in John K. Galbraith's phrase, "The Affluent Society." By the 1960s, America, the richest country on earth, was growing ever more prosperous. But with the 1964 landslide of LBJ, liberalism triumphed and began its great experiment.

Behind the Great Society was a great idea: to lift America's poor out of poverty, government should now take care of all their basic needs. By giving the poor welfare, subsidized food, public housing and free medical care, government will end poverty in America.

At the Superdome and New OrleansConvention Center, we saw the failure of 40 years of the Great Society. No sooner had Katrina passed by and the 17th Street levee broke than hundreds of young men who should have taken charge in helping the aged, the sick and the women with babies to safety took to the streets to shoot, loot and rape. The New Orleans police, their numbers cut by deserters who left their posts to look after their families, engaged in running gun battles all day long to stay alive and protect people.

It was the character and conduct of its people that makes the New Orleans disaster unique. After a hurricane, people's needs are simple: food, water, shelter, medical attention. But they can be hard to meet. People buried in rubble or hiding in attics of flooded homes are tough to get to. But, even with the incompetence of the mayor and governor, and the torpor of federal officials, this was possible.

Coast Guard helicopters were operating Tuesday. There were roads open into the city for SUVs, buses and trucks. While New Orleans was flooded, the water was stagnant. People walked through to the convention center and Superdome. The flimsiest boat could navigate.

Even if government dithered for days - what else is new - this does not explain the failure of the people themselves.

Between 1865 and 1940, the South - having lost a fourth of its best and bravest in battle, devastated by war, mired in poverty - was famous for the hardy self-reliance of her people, black and white.

In 1940, hundreds of British fishermen and yachtsmen sailed back and forth daily under fire across a turbulent 23-mile Channel to rescue 300,000 soldiers from Dunkirk. How do we explain to the world that a tenth that number of Americans could not be reached in four days from across a stagnant pond?

The real disaster of Katrina was that society broke down. An entire community could not cope. Liberalism, the idea that good intentions and government programs can build a Great Society, was exposed as fraud. After trillions of tax dollars for welfare, food stamps, public housing, job training and education have poured out since 1965, poverty remains pandemic. But today, when the police vanish, the community disappears and men take to the streets to prey on women and the weak.

Stranded for days in a pool of fetid water, almost everyone waited for the government to come save them. They screamed into the cameras for help, and the reporters screamed into the cameras for help, and the "civil rights leaders" screamed into the cameras that Bush was responsible and Bush was a racist.

Americans were once famous for taking the initiative, for having young leaders rise up to take command in a crisis. See any of that at the Superdome? Sri Lankans and Indonesians, far poorer than we, did not behave like this in a tsunami that took 400 times as many lives as Katrina has thus far.

We are the descendants of men and women who braved the North Atlantic in wooden boats to build a country in a strange land. Our ancestors traveled thousands of miles in covered wagons, fighting off Indians far braver than those cowards preying on New Orleans' poor.

Watching that performance in the CrescentCity, it seems clear: We are not the people our parents were. And what are all our Lords Temporal now howling for? Though government failed at every level, they want more government!

FDR was right. A "spiritual disintegration" has overtaken us. Government-as-first provider, the big idea of the Great Society, has proven to be "a narcotic, a subtle destroyer of the human spirit."

Either we get off this narcotic, or it kills us.

Tags: (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 28 comments

  •  let those e-mails be sent (none / 1)

    they just expose the right wingers as being the anti-govt, everybody for themselves, elitist, racist assholes that they are.
  •  Please put in their email address (none / 0)

    We can send them the truth.
  •  Response: (4.00 / 8)

    What I have seen:

    Al Gore chartering a private jet to get refugees.

    WHAT I HAVE NOT SEEN:

    The Christian Coalition setting up a feeding line.

    The Club for Growth helping in the shelters.

    The 700 Club doing any work whatsoever.

    Focus on the Family serving meals in the shelters.

    Ralph Reed  directing traffic at the gas stations.

    FEMA getting off it's sorry, patronage riddled ass

    Our Christian President taking an interest until it was far, far too late.

    Boy, somehow  I don't feel any better now.

  •  Already been refuted ad nauseum (4.00 / 2)

    The world is so cold and the rhythm is your blanket, wrap yourself up in it, if you love it then you'll thank it.

    by Ajax the Greater on Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 02:19:44 PM PDT

  •  I Was Going To.. (none / 1)

    .. Comment on this. snopes.com, the urban legend website, has already has to respond to half a dozen vicious forwards like this.

    Let's make our stand here. If you get one of these bullshit email, checks with snopes.com, 2/3 of the rightwing emails are complete bullshit, call them on their lies.

    Furthermore, forward BACK something else in return- Michael Brown's resume, Bill Frist insider trading scam, or the death toll in Iraq that has been whitewashed. For ever lie they forward, let's forward back two truths about the GOP.

    We expect our senators to have a spine, we should demand nothing less of ourselves. If you're afraid to hit back because you don't want to ruffle some feathers from your rightwing relatives or friends, then you are no less timid than the MSM DC press Corp. Let it be known that you are liberal who punches back.

    NeoCons' view on torture: if it's good enough for Jesus, it's good enough for anyone!

    by clone12 on Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 02:27:38 PM PDT

  •  who wrote this piece of shit... (4.00 / 2)

    as one of my best friends who is Asian told me about 25 years ago....an Oriental is a RUG. I don't need to read futher than 2 sentences to know whoever sent this is a racist.

    It's Obamazing!!!!!!!!!!!!

    by Chamonix on Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 02:29:25 PM PDT

  •  I just got that same email from my dad (none / 1)

    I asked him if he's ever heard the one about Al Gore and his chartered plane that saved an entire hospital.

    Just imagine, he hadn't heard that one.  That shut him up pretty quickly.

    Blind Faith in Empty Language is Not Patriotism

    by ColdFusion04 on Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 02:29:32 PM PDT

  •  Here's another... (none / 1)

    <<<<<<begin forwarded message>>>>>

    Thought I might inform the few friends I have on my recent traumatic experience. I am going to tell it straight, blunt, raw, and I don't give a damn. Long read, I know but please do read!!!

    I went to volunteer on Saturday at the George R. Brown convention  for two reasons.
    A: I wanted to help people to get a warm fuzzy.

    B: Curiosity.

     I've been watching the news lately and have seen scenes that have made me want to vomit. And no it wasn't dead bodies, the city under water, or the sludge everywhere. It was PEOPLE'S BEHAVIOR. The people on T.V., (99% being Black) were DEMANDING help. They were not asking nicely but demanding as if society owed these people  something.

     Well the honest truth is WE DON'T. Help should be asked for in a kind manner and then appreciated. This is not what the press (FOX
    in particular)was showing, what I was seeing was a group of people who are yelling, demanding, looting, killing, raping, and SHOOTING back at the demanded help!!!!!

    So I'm thinking this can't possibly be true can it????

     So I decide to submit to the DEMAND for help out of SHOCK. I couldn't believe this to be true of the majority of the people who are the weakest of society. So I went to volunteer and help folks out and see the truth. So I will tell the following story and you decide:

     I arrived at the astrodome only to find out that there were too many volunteers and that volunteers were needed at the George R. Brown Convention Center. As I was walking up to the Convention Center I noticed a line of cars that wrapped around blocks filled with donations.
    These were ordinary Houstonians coming with truckloads and trunks full of water, diapers, clothes, blankets, food, all types of good stuff.

     Lots of it was NEW. I felt that warm fuzzy while helping unload these vehicles of these wonder ful human beings. I then went inside
    the building and noticed approximately 100,000 sq. ft. of clothes, shoes, jackets, toys and all types of goodies all organized and ready for the people in need. I signed up, received a name badge and was on my merry way excited to be useful.
     I toured the place to get familiar with my surroundings; the entire place is probably around 2 million sq. ft. I noticed rows as far as the eye can see of mattresses, not cots, BLOW UP MATTRESSES!!! All of which had nice pillows and plenty of blankets. 2 to 3 bottles of water lay on every bed.
    These full size to queen size beds by the way were comfortable, I laid in one to see for myself. I went to look at the medical area.
    I couldn't believe what my eyes were seeing!!! A makeshift hospital created in 24 hours!!!

     It was unbelievable, they even had a pharmacy.

    I also noticed that they created showers, which would also have hot water.
    I  went upstairs to the third floor to find a HUGE cafeteria created in under 24 hours! Rows of tables, chairs and food everywhere - enough to feed an army! I'm not talking about crap food either. They had Jason's deli food, apples, oranges, coke, diet coke, lemonade, orange juice, cookies, all types of chips and sandwiches. All the beverages by the way were put on ice and chilled!!!! In a matter of about 24 hours or less an entire mini-city was erected by volunteers for the poor evacuees.

     This was not your rundown crap shelter, it was BUM HEAVEN. So that was the layout: great food, comfy beds, clean showers, free medical help,
    by the way there was a library, and a theatre room that I forgot to mention. Great stuff right????

     Well here is what happened on my journey -

     I started by handing out COLD water bottles to evacuees as they got off the bus. Many would take them and only 20% or less said thank you.
    Lots of them would shake their heads and ask for sodas! So this went on for about 20-30 minutes until I was sick of being an unappreciated servant.  
    I figured certainly these folks would appreciate some food!!!

    So I went upstairs to serve these beloved evacuees some GOOD food  that I wish I could have at the moment!

    **The following statements are graphic, truthful, and discuss UNRATIONAL behavior*

     Evacuees come slowly to receive this mountain of food that is worth serving to a king! I tell them that we have 2 types of great deli  sandwiches to choose from - ham and turkey. Many look at the food in disgust and DEMAND burgers, pizza, and even McDonalds!!!! Jason's deli is better than McDonalds!!!!

     Only 1 out of ten people who took something would say "thank you" the rest took items as if it was their God give right to be served without a shred of appreciation!!! They would ask for Beer and liquor. They complained that we didn't have good enough food. They refused food and laughed at us.

     They treated us volunteers as if we where SLAVES. No not all of them of course, but 70% did!!!!!! 20% were appreciative, 10% took the food without any comment and the other 70% had some disgusting comment to say.

     Some had the nerve to laugh at us. And when I snapped back at them for being mean, they would curse at me!!! Needless to say I was in utter shock. They would eat their food and leave their mess on the table. Some would pick up their stuff, many would leave it for the volunteers to pick up.

     I left that real quick to go down and help set up some more beds. I saw many  young ladies carrying mattresses and I helped for a while.
    Then I realized something. There were hundreds of able bodied young men who could  help!!

     I asked a group of young evacuees in their teens and early twenties to help. I got cursed at for asking them to help!!! One said "We  just lost our fucking homes and you want us to work!!" The next said "Ya Cracker, you got a home we don't" I looked at them in disbelief. Here are women walking by  carrying THEIR BEDS and they can't lift a finger and help themselves!!

     WHY SHOULD I HELP PEOPLE WHO DON'T WANT TO HELP THEMSELVES!!!!

     I waved them off and turned away and was laughed at and more "white boy jokes" were made at me. I felt no need to waste my breath on a
    bunch of pitiful losers. I went to a nearby restroom where I noticed a man shaving.
    I used the restroom, washed my hands and saw this man throw his razor towards the trash can...he missed. He walked out leaving his
    disgusting razor on the floor for some other "cracker" to pick up.

    Even the little kids were demanding. I saw only ONE white family and only TWO Hispanic families. The rest where blacks. Sorry 20% to 30% decent blacks, and 70% LOSERS!!!!!

    I would call them N*S, but the actual definition of a n**r  is one who is ignorant, these people were not ignorant..they were  ARROGANT ASSHOLES.
    The majority of which are thugs and lifetime lazy ass welfare recipients. We are inviting the lowest of the low to Houston, and like idiots we are serving the people who will soon steal our cars, rape, murder, and destroy our city while stealing from our pockets on a daily basis through the welfare checks they take.

     We will fund our own destruction. By "US" I don't mean a specific race, I mean the people who work hard, work smart, have values and
    morals. Only people who want to help themselves should be helped, the others should be allowed to destroy themselves.

    I do not want to work hard, give the government close to half the money I earn so they can in turn give it to a bunch of losers. I don't believe in being poor for life. My family immigrated here, we came here poor, and now thank God, and due to HARD WORK we are doing fine.

    If immigrants, who come here, don't know the language can work and become successful... WHY CAN'T THE MAJORITY OF THE HOMEGROWN DO IT!!!

    If we continue to reward these losers then we will soon destroy our great country. I just witnessed selfish, arrogant, unappreciative
    behavior by the very people who need help the most. Now these same people who cursed me, refused my cities generosity, who refuse to
    help themselves are DEMANDING handouts on their own terms!!!!!!!

    They prance around as if they are owed something, and when they do receive a  handout, they say it's not good enough! Well you know
    what..these types of people can go to hell for all I  care!
    <<<end forwarded message>>>>>

    The urban legends website at about.com has not been able to discredit this e-mail.  They tracked down the writer, who insists every word is true.  It's flying around all the conservative circles right now.  Nice.

    Ahh, I love the smell of oversight in the morning. -Christy Hardin Smith, FDL

    by Exurban Mom on Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 02:31:20 PM PDT

    •  Poisonous, racist crap. (none / 1)

      Anybody who buys that, wants to buy it -- they want to have all their racist assumptions validated.

      Preaching to the white robed and hooded choir.  

    •  I saw this one (none / 1)

      a couple of days ago, and it's particularly poisonous because it purports to be from a medical doctor.

      If it really was written by an M.D., he's not someone I'd ever let within ten feet of any human being I cared about.

      The degree to which you resist injustice is the degree to which you are free. -- Utah Phillips

      by Mnemosyne on Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 02:58:44 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Gag! (none / 1)

      "I went to volunteer on Saturday at the George R. Brown convention  for two reasons.
      A: I wanted to help people to get a warm fuzzy.
      B: Curiosity."

      You don't help people to get a warm fuzzy - you help because it is the right thing to do. And sometimes you get the bonus of a warm fuzzy.
      If you are curious you go to a museum or a zoo or something. Don't expect gratitude and appreciation from a human being you are viewing a "sight seeing" exercise.

      (And those people on TV "DEMANDING" help had been left abandoned in for days with no lights, no drinking water, no food, and no security. Should they have done an Oliver Twist - "please, sir, may I come out of hell now?"

      It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. - Aristotle

      by Catte Nappe on Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 03:08:35 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Sorry rudeness and entitlement.... (2.50 / 2)

      are completely American. Some people may be louder about it but most Americans are selfish lazy jackasses.

      Anyone who has worked retail could tell you 70% of people say nothing, display no appreciation and are put out when they do not get precisely what they want when they want it.

      That is consumerism for you not liberalism.

      •  customer service is dead (none / 1)

        Sorry, but since when is it the customer's responsibility to thank the retail worker for doing their job?  How many times do I find myself thanking the cashier when they hand me my receipt when they have not said one single word to me?  

        If a retail clerk is helpful, I always thank them but the majority have no clue that they are working and part of their job is to make sure the customer is happy.  I do not believe that the customer is always right, but I do not believe that I should be grateful for a retail clerk doing their job by helping me.  

        Just because you're self-righteous doesn't mean you're not a hypocrite.

        by AMcG826 on Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 03:27:37 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

  •  I Recieved This (none / 0)

    exact email today.

    I got it from a friend who is apathetic when it comes to politics.

    At first I was angry..then I thought, maybe it was meant as a joke...I mean how delusional do you have to be to think FEMA did their jobs?!

    This email, as well as others like it, are very racist in their tone. And are a blatant effort to deflect responsibility away from George W. Bush.

    •  Hillary Clinton (none / 0)

      Here's an update on some of Hillary's current work:

      * She is leading an effort in the Senate to establish an independent panel to investigate the inadequate response to Hurricane Katrina, saying, "Only through an independent Katrina Commission will we ever be able to know that no storm or act of terrorism will ever again leave us so unable to respond."

      Republicans defeated the effort on a party-line vote, but Hillary and Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid said they will continue to work for an independent panel. And Hillary will also continue work on her legislation establishing FEMA as an independent agency once again, with competent professional leadership.

      * Hillary co-sponsored legislation which was unanimously approved by the Senate, requiring the Federal Trade Commission to begin an immediate investigation into the cause of soaring gas prices following Katrina. The provision, which she co-sponsored with Senators Mark Pryor (D-AR) and Barbara Mikulski (D-MD), is part of the appropriations bill for the Commerce, Justice, and State Departments and calls for a report to Congress and recommendations for action within 30 days. On Wednesday, the FTC announced that it would begin such a probe.

      "No one anywhere in the country should be able to get away with profiteering from a disaster like Hurricane Katrina," Hillary said in comments reported in the Buffalo News. "This investigation will help make sure that New Yorkers and consumers around the country are not gouged at the gas pump."
      -------------------------------------------------

      The person who wrote that vile email crap wanted to know what Hillary was doing...so there's an update for anyone to use.

      I have to say as a big supporter of Howard Dean, I was sad to see that he wasn't vilified in that email like he usually is! ~Snark~

  •  The truth is... (none / 1)

    The writer attempts to applaud typically Christian and right-wing charity organizations by contrasting their response to left-wing political organizations. The Salvation Army, whose mission is to clothe and feed the poor, is contrasted with the American Civil Liberties Union, whose mission is to protect the civil liberties of Americans, and the reader is asked - no, begged! - to draw the conclusion that the Salvation Army is somehow morally better because they were in New Orleans feeding and clothing the poor. The ACLU, it is suggested, should be doing the same thing. Of course, a logical person might assume they would be helping out in a manner in keeping with their mission - that, while the Salvation Army clothes and feeds the poor, the ACLU would be defending the civil liberties of the victims. And lo and behold, they were doing just that:

    Whatever course the government takes, we must ensure that the victims of this horrible tragedy are not made victims again because of political games in Washington and faulty policies. The government also must ensure that aid is not only distributed in a timely manner, but in a manner that is fair to all, regardless of their race.

    The reason this comparison is expected to work is because each example is put into a group with other examples similar in their political affiliation [from the perspective of Christian Right-Wing people, anyway, since left-wing Christians might disagree.] The Salvation Army is shown among Christians, the republican-controlled FEMA, etc., etc. in a way that enhances the "goodness" of these organizations (it even claimed FEMA, whose director resigned amid disgrace at his handling of the Katrina disaster, was doing a good job getting food out to people.) The ACLU, People for the American Way, the NAACP, all traditionally liberal organizations, were shown in a manner enhancing their selfishness. The American Atheist organization was also mentioned, contrasting Christianity with literal godlessness. These people are evil. These people are good because they are these people. Since these people are good, and these people are associated with these people, these people must also be good...

    Or something.

    This part pisses me off the most:

    The gripers in Congress should come on down and get in line to pass the water and the ice. Are you listening Hillary, Chuck, Teddy and all the sorry loafers we call senators and congressmen. They don't have a clue as to what this life is all about here on the Gulf Coast.

    Your President was on vacation, asswad;
    Your Secretary shopping for new shoes;
    Dick dithered in the woods. Al Gore flew in.
    Compassionate conservatives? My ass.

  •  Last week a colleague (none / 1)

    sent me an e-mail which regurtitated the content from the following article: http://tiadaily.com/php-bin/news/showArticle.php?id=1026
    It took me a while to find the source, but when I did, I let him know exactly what kind of website this came from.  He honestly believed that these were the musings of some "regular Joe".

    This is what TIA stands for:
    The Intellectual Activist is especially dedicated to understanding and promoting the revolutionary ideas of the 20th-century novelist and philosopher Ayn Rand -- the great champion of the power of reason, the supreme value of the individual, and the unfettered liberty of a capitalist society. TIA serves as a forum for those who are working to gain a deeper understanding of Ayn Rand's fiction and philosophy and applying her ideas to gain new insights in every field of human knowledge.

    Vision without action is a daydream. Action without vision is a nightmare!

    by 1040SU on Thu Sep 22, 2005 at 03:08:54 PM PDT

  •  re: (none / 1)

    "I really honestly think that the GOP kicks our ass on spinning via forwarded emails. They are probably the most influential thing now."

    Honestly, contrary to what everyone on here likes to think, I think we're losing the Internet battle as a whole.  Despite our growing blog hits, Drudge and FreeRepublic still have obscenely high traffic, and we're losing in terms of the amount of misinformation people take at face value.  I loathe how my favorite sports sites (JJHuddle, Buckeyeplanet and Yappi) are basically FreeRepublic lite on their general discussion boards.

  •  Hey!!! The First LIBERAL Katrina forward!!! (none / 0)

    Leave Katrina Relief Efforts to Government

    By Ted Rall
    Tue Sep 13, 8:06 PM ET

    NEW YORK--Hurricane Katrina has prompted Americans to donate more than $700 million to charity, reports the Chronicle of Philanthropy. So many suckers, so little foresight.

    Government has been shirking its basic responsibilities since the '80s, when Ronald Reagan
    sold us his belief that the sick, poor and unlucky should no longer count on "big government" to help them, but should rather live and die at the whim of contributors to private charities. The Katrina disaster, whose total damage estimate has risen from $100 to $125 billion, marks the culmination of Reagan's privatization of despair.

    The American Red Cross leads the post-Katrina sweepstakes, quickly closing in on the $534 million it took in just after 9/11. But Red Cross spokeswoman Sheila Graham told the AP it needs another half billion "to provide emergency relief over the coming weeks for thousands of evacuees who have scattered among 675 of its shelters in 23 states."

    Shell! ey Borysiewicz of Catholic Charities USA, which has raised $7 million thus far, also continues to solicit donations: "We don't want people to lose sight of the fact that this is going to take years of recovery, and we're going to be there to help the people who fall through the cracks."

    What "cracks"? Why should New Orleans' dispossessed have to live in private shelters? We live in the United States, not Mali. There's only one reason flood victims aren't getting help from the government: because the government refuses to help them. The Red Cross and its cohorts are letting lazy, incompetent and corrupt politicians off the hook, and so are their donors.

    It's ridiculous, but people evidently need to be reminded that the United States is not only the
    world's wealthiest nation but the wealthiest society that has existed anywhere, ever. The U.S. government can easily pick up the tab for people inconvenienced by bad weather--if helping them is a priority. That goes ! double for Katrina, a disaster caused by the government's conscious decision to eliminate the $50 million pittance needed to improve New Orleans'
    levees.

    For our leaders the optional war against Iraq is such a priority, which the Congressional Budget Office expects to cost $600 billion by 2010. That's four or five Katrinas right there. (That's also where the levee money went.) Because rich people are always a political priority, their taxes have been slashed by $4 trillion over a decade--the equivalent of 32 Katrinas. So worried are our public servants about the tax burden placed on the rich that they're looking out
    for rich dead people. This is why they've gutted the estate tax that, at a cost of $75 billion annually, will run half a Katrina a year. Trickle-down economists beginning with Milton Friedman shout "starve the beast," but while the social programs are put on a diet, the mean and powerful pig out more than ever.

    Disaster relief is too important to be! left to private fundraisers, with their self-sustaining fundraising expenses, administrative overhead (nine percent for the Red Cross) and their parochial, often religious, agendas. It's also way too expensive. In the final analysis, after the floodwaters have receded and the poor neighborhoods of New Orleans have been razed
    under eminent domain, major charities will be lucky if they've managed to raise one percent of the total cost of Katrina. Congress, recognizing the reality that only the federal government possesses the means to deal with the calamity, has already allocated $58 billion--over 70 times the amount raised by charities--to flood relief along the Gulf of Mexico. As Bush says, that's only a "down payment."

    Cutting a check to the Red Cross isn't just a vote for irresponsible government. It's a drop in the bucket compared to what you'll end up paying for Katrina in increased taxes.

    Granted, in terms of popularity of likelihood of success, trying to make! a case against giving money to charities compares to lobbying against puppies. The impulse to donate, after all, is rooted in our best human traits. As we watched New Orleanians die of thirst, disease and anarchic violence in the face of Bush Administration disinterest and local government incompetence, millions of us did the only thing we thought we could to do to help: cut a check or click a PayPal button. Tragically, that generosity feeds into the mindset of the sinister ideologues who argue that government shouldn't help people--the very mindset that caused the levee break that turned Katrina into a holocaust and led to official unresponsiveness. And it
    is already setting the stage for the next avoidable disaster.

    It's time to "starve the beast": private charities used by the government to justify the abdication of its duties to its citizens.

  •  My response (none / 0)

    I just got that email today & fired off a "Reply to All".  (I origainally posted this as a diary, then found this one & deleted mine.)  My broadcast reply follows:
    I was sent an email "FROM A McCOMB, MISSiSSIPPI RESIDENT" with the subject heading, "What do you think?"  I took that to be a genuine question.  My answer follows.  The original email text is indented with > symbols.

    >FROM A McCOMB, MISSiSSIPPI RESIDENT
    >To my friends and family: (From a McComb Resident)
    >What I have seen since Katrina:
    >The poor and the wealthy hurt by the storm.

    I saw people with adequate means driving away from the city, finding shelter with friends or family or securing hotel reservations out of the path of the storm without offering a ride or assistance to their poorer neighbors left behind.  For those whose opportunities and options were limited by poverty and the color of their skin, I saw them desperate, stranded, and dying on rooftops with no food, no water, no help, and no place to go.  

    >Black, white, Hispanic, Oriental and Indian all hurt by the storm.
    >Christian people giving, giving, giving.
    >Churches going all out to minister in Jesus' name.

    I also saw Jews, Muslims, Hindu, and atheists giving, giving, and giving simply in the name of human kindness.

    >Ice and water being fought over as police tried to keep the peace.

    I also saw victims, devastated by days without food & water, helping rescue crews unload supplies for their neighbors.  I saw the desperation of people feeling abandoned by a government that took days to fully mobilize any meaningful relief effort.  

    >People coming up from New Orleans taking over empty houses because shelters are full.

    I saw the President's mother insensitively worrying that these people might "God forbid" want to stay in her state, while asserting that these unfortunate souls who had lost everything "had it pretty good" in the shelters because they were underprivileged anyway.

    >Out of town volunteers coming with food and staying for now a week still serving it.

    I saw the President of the United States stopping by from out of town for a photo op, disrupting the relief efforts while providing no real help.  I saw the President's PR staff bring generators and stage lights to light a portion of New Orleans for his speech, and a few hours later, they took it all and left the city in the dark once more.

    >The Churches all over this part of the country doing what Christians do in a crisis.

    I saw people of all faiths all over this country doing what people do in a crisis.

    >The Red Cross doing a great job in the shelters.

    Amen to that.  (It's probably worth a mention that the American Red Cross is a non-religious organization recommended on the website of American Atheists.)

    >The Salvation Army doing a great job in the community.

    Another amen.

    >Lines at service stations a block to a mile long.

    I saw oil companies jack up the price of their products overnight in response to the crisis.  

    >National Guardsman patrolling the streets of Mc Comb along with
    >Kentucky policemen protecting us from the hoodlums and thugs
    >of Mc Comb, Pike County New Orleans (the most dangerous city
    >in the world before Katrina.)

    I saw policemen from Gretna, LA firing guns over the heads of homeless people trying to get out of New Orleans (the fifth most dangerous city in the US. before Katrina.)  

    >Doctors, nurses and other hospital personnel working tirelessly,
    >even sleeping in the hospital to do the job God called them to do.

    I saw health care workers of all faiths caring as best they could for their patients under the worst possible conditions.  Sadly, I also saw two Christian nursing home owners fail to evacuate 34 elderly patients who drowned in their beds.

    >WHAT I HAVE NOT SEEN
    >The ACLU setting up a feeding line.

    I have seen the ACLU fighting tirelessly for equal rights and opportunities for all Americans so that they might be able to secure jobs, housing, and education to put food on their tables.  I have seen the ACLU do their patriotic work for decades leading up to Katrina, not just to grab a few headlines in a crisis.

    >People for the American Way helping in the shelters.

    I have seen PFW working to ensure our elected officials support legislation to provide fairness, civil liberties, and equal access to the political process for all Americans, not just wealthy political contributors.  I have seen PFW work so that the American dream of a better life is rooted in genuine opportunities to work hard, receive fair wages, and live with dignity so that in times of crisis, they are more able to care for themselves.

    The success stories:
    Without doubt, the job training, fair employment laws, health care, and other social programs sponsored and championed by those darned "liberals" have helped many people acquire the means to a better life.  For many, that meant availability of transportation, shelter, and finances to allow them to get out of New Orleans in advance of the crisis.  Of course, I didn't see any of those people on TV.

    >The NAACP doing any work whatsoever.

    I have seen NAACP leaders working to provide relief of all kinds to victims of Katrina, financially, spiritually, and legislatively.  The NAACP, in addition to its hands-on work in the field, has set up a relief fund to aid the victims, urged Congress to establish a national victims' fund, and is working to rebuild communities by ensuring that local restoration projects are equitably awarded to local community businesses, not just to well-connected outfits like Halliburton.

    >The American Atheist organization serving meals in the shelters.

    To the contrary, American Atheists, both in person and through fund raising efforts have helped feed victims in the shelters as well as elsewhere.  The suggestion that human compassion is the sole property of Christians is absurd an insulting.

    >Jesse Jackson directing traffic at the gas stations.

    Regrettably, I have seen an ugly re-emergence of racism, as evidenced by this remark.  In an email message lauding the generosity of Christian America, it seems as though Reverend Jackson is excluded from that Christian warmth, despite being a Christian minister himself.  One can easily conclude that the color of his skin is the reason.  In fact, love him or hate him, Rev, Jackson is a man of God who has, in his own way, championed Christ's concern for the poor and needy far more strongly that most "Christians" who criticize him.  

    >I could go on but you get my message. Its the Christian people with love and compassion who do the work.

    I could go on, but the religious intolerance, hypocrisy, and racism oozing from this piece of baloney disgusts me.  

    >The gripers in Congress should come on down and get in line to
    >pass the water and the ice. Are you listening Hillary, Chuck, Teddy
    >and all the sorry loafers we call Senators and Congressmen. They
    >don't have a clue as to what this life is all about here on the Gulf Coast.

    And all of this administration's clueless officials who sent millions of dollars of levee repair funding to Iraq instead along with the National Guard troops, who ignored those pesky tree-hugging environmentalists' warnings about the impact of wetland destruction, who hired incompetent political cronies to head Homeland Security and FEMA, who still pretend the science proving climate change is inconclusive, George, Dick, Michael, Brownie, Tom, Arlen, and the rest of you, how about living on a rooftop without food & water for a few days.  How about you guys grabbing some shovels & fixing the dikes now.  How about helping collect and identify the thousands of decomposing bodies your incompetence has caused. And while you're at it, try living on cots & eating MREs until you're finished.

    >Boy do I feel better now.

    I don't.  I'm as angry as ever, perhaps more so, that the gross negligence of this administration continues to be excused by too many Americans because of misplaced ideology.   I'm as angry as ever that the suffering and death of fellow human beings is being twisted to serve as a mere political backdrop for a corrupt administration.  I'm as angry as ever that the wealthiest 1% of this nation can't live without a tax giveaway to help the poorest of New Orleans, and I'm as angry as ever that Americans aren't shouting from their own rooftops at their representatives in Congress to make it so.  I'm as angry as ever that Christianity is so poorly served by its adherents, especially when the poor are vilified in the name of Christ.  I'm as angry as ever that racism continues to flourish in this great nation, that an entire race and class of people are demeaned for the televised actions of a desperate few.  I'm as angry as ever that anyone who knows me would think I would find the original report from McComb, Mississippi to be in any way entertaining, affirming or amusing.


    When the oak is felled the whole forest echoes with its fall, but a hundred acorns are sown in silence by an unnoticed breeze. -Thomas Carlyle

    by rb608 on Mon Sep 26, 2005 at 01:56:42 PM PDT

Permalink | 28 comments