Daily Kos

Interesting - "In Defense of Bill Cosby"

Sat Jan 21, 2006 at 12:11:31 PM PDT

In Defense of Bill Cosby
January 18, 2006
Robert Lashley

On the week that Bill Cosby made his remarks two years ago, I was at my grandfather's house for a funeral in the family. The day before, I decided to walk to Sam and Terry's barbershop to get a hair cut. For 50 years Sam and Terry's has been one of the few enduring institutions in the African American community in Tacoma. I got my first haircut there in 1983, at the tender age of five, from Sam Moore, the co-founder still going strong in his 9th decade. Anyone with a inkling of sense, history or any sort of cultural sophistication knows that the African American barbershop is one of America's great conservative institutions, a sort of folk lyceum, where a democracy of Ideas is permitted to flow free from politically correct discourse and dogmatism. A lot of my pragmatic Hurstonian conservative philosophy comes from the hundreds of conversations I have overheard and had at Sam and Terry's, as well as my taste in soul music and African American literature. I also owe a lot more to Sam personally, because he was the last man to cut my father's hair when he was in the hospital, rife from the spiral meningitis and complications from diabetes that would kill him only a few weeks later; an act he didn't have to do, because for the last 20 years of his life my father was a degenerate dope fiend.

Over the past several years, however, my contrarian paradise has crumbled. The barbers that I was raised with have either retired or died off, and a new generation of kids, raised on the brutal ethos of the streets and filled with the same sense of brutal entitlement that gangstadom has spawned, have made it a different place altogether from my memory. A deep division between young and old (over the discovery that one of the younger barbers was just cutting hair as cover for his burgeoning crack dealership, which explained why he drove to work in a Bentley), led to a mass exodus of people, and the tacky gangsta nationalism of most of the young barbers, demands you accept their psycho-racial-sexual dogma but ostracizes you if you don't.

On that particular day, my number was called. My crimes that afternoon were two. I committed the transgression of wearing a tweed jacket, black sweater, black slacks and glasses, a no-no for the " thug barbers" there because to be an appropriate African American by their standards was to wear saggy pants, sport jerseys and doo-rag caps. My second transgression was to bring a book, James Baldwin's Notes of A Native Son. It didn't matter that Baldwin was one of the greatest prophets on race relations in the history of the 20th century. The fact that I brought a book to read deeply offended their sensibilities, because to read, in their mind, was acting white.

As I was reading, one of the barbers cracked up. Looking to see what was funny, I saw that the butt of his joke was me.

    "What's wrong with you," n*gga," he asked

    "Excuse me?" I replied

    "Why you acting like an herb?"

For those who don't know, "herb" is a derogatory name that the hip hop generation of African American's has for people who seek knowledge and don't want to be gangstas. Now, it would be something different altogether if I "wore" whatever knowledge on my sleeve, condescending to whoever was there. But being tagged with the " dumb ghetto n*gger" label for most of the first 22 years of my life, I'm highly sensitive about that.

"What's your problem, brother? Why you on me so much? Im just trying to get a haircut?" I said. But it went on, a kind of vulgar grilling on my blackness, with Sam being my only defender in the shop. I consider myself a relatively tough SOB, ( both living on the hill and taking the bus to white schools will do that to you) but leaving that shop that afternoon, I was emotionally cut deep. One of the few safety zones I have ever had, one of the few places in my life that people saw my intelligence and not my color, was gone. I had to prove, and to an extent still have to prove to too many white people that I am a person of substance, and not a beast who was going to rob and brutalize them. (Yes I have my half-dozen racial profiling stories with the police, but that's another article). I didn't have to do that at Sam and Terry's, people used to respect me and appreciate the fact that I liked to read books. Not anymore.

But halfway back home, I looked at broader aspect of what happened and started to cry. Because if those thugs did that to me, a 25-year-old college student, imagine the hundreds of young kids they have done it to also. Kids younger than me, who didn't have my brilliant loving mother or my beautiful griot of a grandmother. Kids who faced the same brutal disadvantages I had, and personally, lord knows what I went through to get to where I am. Kids who had the chance to discover the love of knowledge snatched away from them by some monosyllabic racist thug. Is there anything legal that is more destructive, more pernicious and more horrifying than the death, no execution, of an inquisitive mind.

So how does this relate to Bill Cosby's remarks?

It continues at:
http://blogcritics.org/...

Poll

After reading the whole article, is there any truth to it?

84%28 votes
9%3 votes
6%2 votes

| 33 votes | Vote | Results

Tags: race, black, Bill Cosby (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 7 comments

  •  did you write this article? (none / 0)

    I can't tell. If not, can you break up the quotes with some analysis and maybe not quote so much?

    Don't wanna get Kos in trouble on copyright infringement.

    I want to win. You want to beat him, and that's a problem for me, because I want to win. -The West Wing

    by AnnArborBlue on Sat Jan 21, 2006 at 12:15:38 PM PDT

  •  I don't know... (none / 0)

    ..I'm not black. In fact I am literally the whitest (palest) person I know.  Though at work I've been dubbed an honorary "Sistah".  There's these two guys that rib on each other all the time about not being black enough but it's all done in a playful manner and not meant to be taken seriously.

    I don't know if it's a problem but I don't think it's all meant to be serious.  But if there is a trend to find disrespect in education and intellegence it's not just in the black community.  There seems to be that trend in the entire country to have a prefrence for the dumbed down and sensational.

    You are entitled to express your opinion. But you are NOT entitled to agreement.

    by DawnG on Sat Jan 21, 2006 at 12:29:03 PM PDT

  •  sad (none / 0)

    I'm white. I came of political age in Harlem working for the NYC welfare department at ages 22-25.

    I appreciate the report from where I can't really be. I've read James Baldwin too. As a kid I can remember being seen as wierd for reading too much or looking too much like I read too much. Kids need islands of acceptance and they are hard to find outside your house or maybe inside it.

    The scary thing is African-Americans may be America's last, best hope. Almost none buy the let's go have a war, America is great, if you are down its your fault line. That's why media industry has another line for them that is probably even more destructive of what is right.

    Cosby's kind of caught in the middle on this -- sounds like blame the victim, but it also carries a lot of truth in the world you describe. Thanks for the insight.

    We have only just begun and none too soon.

    by global citizen on Sat Jan 21, 2006 at 12:46:00 PM PDT

  •  I saw this working in the South Bronx (4.00 / 5)

    White Irish guy with a blazer.... everyone on Southern Boulevard would take you for a DT - detective.  Worked in the largest (then- now gone) employer in the Bronx.  A few hundred women - most single heads of household minority (black or hispanic).  They were working like hell to do the best they could for their kids - many sent to parochial schools.  BUT the whole "culture" was stacked against "success". Thier kids all wanted to be NBA stars or dealers (stereotype, yeah, but sadly too prevelant.  Never heard one talking about being a doctor or engineer or even an accountant, no thought to trying to get ahead via realistic paths).

    Saw the result later working for the NY Fed.  More than a few black women in managerial or executive ranks.  NO black men. It was easier for a girl to keep her distance and focus on school without getting harrassed over it. Not so easy for the boys. AND - lke the military - civil service and quasi-governmental agencies ARE provide far better career path options - less discrimination (which is still a factor if at lower levels).

    As another put it - if all of this were being imposed on the black community by whites, there would be unending screams of racism and detailed critiques of the damage being done by the mysoginistic, gangsta, anti-intellectual, anti-family, anti-responsibility mindset being promoted by rap, videos and all else.  ANd like it or not, the fundies are right in saying that FAMILY is important.  THe unmarried mother trying to raise kids (often from multiple fathers, NONE of whom give a damn about their kids) is doomed to poverty.

    This happens to more than just blacks at the lower rungs of society BUT it is interesting that ni groups where family "values" are stronger, the damage is not as bad.

    But this is a loaded topic racially.  NOBODY can criticize this - especially someone who's not black - politically incorrect.  Sad thing is that the "dumbing down" is EVERYWHERE in this country BUT the white kid in affluent suburbia will get bailed out by his parents (even if they're divorced) who'll still manage to get them into college somewhere and get them a decent job afterwards.  

    One friend from Brooklyn came up the parochial school route.  Has a black friend now in CA.  An accountant who's done very well in life coming out of Bed-Sty.  BUT even he admits it was not easy and the ONLY reason he made it out was ONE teacher who pulled him aside and mentored him, keeping him on track.   Most don't have that.

    And ironically, the end of segregation means that the middle and upper class blacks are no longer visible to the lower end, these role models are not visible.  But the irony is that the kids of successfuul middle class blacks are under the same pressure to "be black" in really good suburban schools......

    flame away.... it's not liberal to say personal responsibility counts or criticize "culture" that's destructive  but that's why I'm an ex-repub and not a die hard dem.  There's a middle ground neither party is filling.

  •  Nitpick (4.00 / 2)

    I know you lifted this off a newspaper. What I'd like to see is how is it relevant to your life.
  •  this reminds me of a chris rock special (none / 0)

    on books as kryptonite to niggas.

    if you really wrote the piece, WRITE MORE.  it was really good.

    I used to admire you for pointing out that it takes a village. Now, I just wonder how many villages have been destroyed and children killed by this war.

    by lostinbrasil on Sat Jan 21, 2006 at 03:32:47 PM PDT

  •  I read the whole thing (none / 0)

    and I'm not sure what the point is. Should the mostly white readership of daily kos get involved in an internal debate within the black community over political strategy?

    If Lashley wants to praise Cosby and trash Sharpton and Jackson, that's fine I suppose. But if he's really concerned about black-on-black violence, it seems to me he's chosen a fairly sterile way of combatting it.

Permalink | 7 comments