Daily Kos

Difference between these Republicans and us -- explained?

Fri Oct 06, 2006 at 01:34:19 PM PDT

While running amok on the web yesterday I came across an article written by E.J. Mundell for HealthDay that I can't seem to get out of my brain.  It seems to me, as I have for many years believed that one day we would discover that Republicans were mentally ill in some way, that this particular study on the brain may suddenly make all of the pain we've been experiencing as a nation make some sense.

Basically it seems our country is being run by folks without a functioning dorsolateral prefrontal cortex.  Yep, this little part of the brain helps people suppress selfishness and taking unfair advantage of others.  When this part of the brain is impeded, folks still know right from wrong but can't help taking advantage of the situation to gain in a selfish way.  

Here are three snippets from the article:

Experiments involving a "fairness" game show that the right side of this region -- called the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex -- helps people suppress selfish urges in obviously unjust situations, even at their own expense.

snip

People with disabled right-side dorsolateral prefrontal cortexes grabbed whatever money they could from lopsided transactions -- even when they knew the deal they were getting was grossly unfair.

"They understood the unfairness of it all, but they simply couldn't inhibit their need for getting the money," said Paul Sanberg, director of the Center of Excellence for Aging and Brain Repair at the University of South Florida College of Medicine in Tampa.

snip

The Swiss and American team behind this research noted that, despite a long history of crime, wars and rapaciousness, human beings are innately cooperative. In fact, Homo sapiens is the only species to exhibit "reciprocal fairness" -- the punishment of others' unfair behaviors, even in situations where doing so hurts the punisher.

snip

"The big surprise," Fehr said, "is that a relatively minor inhibition of the right DLPFC removes or weakens the subject's ability to override their self-interest."

Players whose right-side DLPFC's were "switched off" accepted even very low amounts of cash nearly half (45 percent) of the time -- even though they knew the offer was terribly unfair.

But under normal conditions, barely one in 10 players accepted such insulting low offers, the researchers found.

The experiment shows that this part of the cortex "is clearly very important for our social behavior, our societal evolution," Sanberg said. The right side of the DLPFC helps people resist those strong urges for sex, money and general acquisitiveness that come from more primitive sites outside the cortex, he said.

So, Kossacks, are we dealing with people whose brains function differently?  Who know right from wrong but don't care who they screw over in order for personal gain?  To me it seems like this is a slam dunk for the brain disorder that makes one Republican.  What say you?
link - http://news.yahoo.com/s/hsn/20061005/hl_hsn/studyspotsthebrainsselfishnessoffswitch

Poll

Do you agree? --DLPFC indeed causes Republicanism.

53%8 votes
40%6 votes
6%1 votes

| 15 votes | Vote | Results

Tags: selfishness, brain disorder, Republicans (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 6 comments

Permalink | 6 comments