Daily Kos

Sheriff Prosecuted for Diverting FEMA Truck to Aid Katrina Victims

Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 10:51:31 AM PDT

Federal prosecutors have pressed charges on local Sheriff Billy McGee for diverting a FEMA truck carrying water and ice a few days after Hurricane Katrina.

September 4 - Hattiesburg, Mississippi. In our county, there were many rural citizens who weren't getting help from ANY recovery agencies - Red Cross, Salvation Army, and of course not FEMA. When FEMA trucks carrying water, ice, food, and clothing were sitting, unused, for hours, then days, while people struggled to survive, a local sheriff (who is now somewhat of a legend) took over one of the FEMA trucks and sent it to where help was needed.

He is now being prosecuted, and is expected to plea guilty. A full story from our local paper is at this address: http://www.hattiesburgamerican.com/...

As far as I know, this isn't any where near national news yet, but it should be. His quote sums it up fairly well:
"I didn't see anything wrong with what I was doing other than it was outside the protocol. This is more an indictment of the federal government than of me. This is a failure of the process."

This shows, on a local level, the true concern of the FEMA clean-up process: that of diverting attention away from those who really screwed up, and punishing scapegoats in an attempt to clear the name of the Bush administration.

It may true that he broke protocol, but what did protocol mean in the days after Katrina? The government broke protocol immediately, by not having a plan in place. No one was concerned about the rural residents who deserved help; maybe they weren't close enough to where the President was going to land and put on a sad face.

I know DailyKos has somewhat moved on. Katrina posts pop up very infrequently. But this is at the heart of the problem of this administration: they ignore the American people in seeking out Cheney's fantasies in the Middle East. When, in hindsight, the administration's motives are questioned, they bring out some more attention diverters.

Billy McGee deserves an apology, not a court hearing. He deserves a "thanks," not jail time.

Pass this on if you find it important. Thanks.

UPDATE: I appreciate all the recommendations. You guys have helped give this story the recognition it deserves. Some of the comments have suggested contacting the prosecuting attorney and the Hattiesburg American. The paper has done a great job at covering the story, so they probably don't need our help. The Governor and the federal prosecutor, on the other hand, deserve more than a few complaints. A local TV station is reporting that Trent Lott has contacted the feds - presumably so they will drop the charges. I'll update if I find any new information. Otherwise, thank you all very much and keep up the good work..

UPDATE II: This link to a Hattiesburg American article dated September 5 (the day after the incident occurred) shows just how chaotic the relief effort was. The article notes that a MEMA (Mississippi Emergency Management Agency) representative hadn't been sent to Hattiesburg, and that FEMA offices had yet to be opened in the area. It also mentions the unusued supply trucks sitting at a local military base. The real crime is that these weren't put to use sooner.

Tags: FEMA, Hattiesburg, Mississippi, Hurricane Katrina, Billy McGee (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 163 comments

  •  important story (4.00 / 11)

    Thanks.  This story needs to get out.  Don't they have better things to do with the limited federal resources than indict someone who was part of the solution?
    •  Complain to Gov. Haley Barbour (4.00 / 4)

      This sorry excuse for a public servant should receive an avalanche of complaints.  Shame on him.

      You can't email Gov. Barbour via his website, though you CAN fill out a form to request his appearance (or his wife's) at a public event ("Do you need a copy of the Governor's biography?".)

      You can, however, phone and/or write snail mail:

      1-877-405-0733

      Governor Haley Barbour
      P.O. Box 139 Jackson, MS 39205
      Phone: 601.359.3150 Fax: 601.359.3741
       

    •  It was all about control, not solutions (4.00 / 9)

      Every report about FEMA at the time indicates they ignored rescue and problem solving in favor of crowd control and resource control. They diverted or turned back other rescue efforts while holding back their own resources. They had lots of plans for control, but apparently few plans for using their own resources to achieve a result.
      You are right, this story needs to get out because it tells the whole story in a nutshell; anybody can understand it; and it carries the story of incompetence to its ridiculous extreme. The Katrina disaster must be kept in the public eye.

      Democrats: Members of the Democratic Party working to advance democracy; Republicons: Members of the Republicanist Party working to advance Republicanism

      by word is bond on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 01:00:08 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Petition now being circulated (4.00 / 5)

      Debbie Burt, assistant superintendent of the Forrest County School District, suggested launching a letter-writing campaign to U.S. Attorney Dunn Lampton, who brought the charges against McGee. And many said they planned to converge at the courthouse whenever the sheriff's hearing is scheduled.

      source


      Perhaps this may be of interest to some of you:
      Dunn Lampton
      United States Attorney
      Southern District of Mississippi

      188 East Capitol Street
      One Jackson Place, Suite 500
      Jackson, Mississippi 39201

      Phone: 601-965-4480
      Fax: 601-965-4409
      email: dunn.lampton@usdoj.gov

      I'm dropping my letter off at the office personally tomorrow.

      Perhaps you'd like to fax, email or call? :)

    •  There's a poll (none / 1)

      Register your opinion on the local TV poll.

      http://www.wdam.com/

      The age of journalism as the fourth estate has passed. We blog to survive.

      by enough on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 04:39:47 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Can We Get This FP'd... (none / 0)

      ...So it will get picked up by the RSS Feeds?

      THAT will get it noticed!

      No one can terrorize a whole nation, unless we are all his accomplices. ~Edward R. Murrow

      by mlkisler on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 09:59:57 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  What's an RSS feed? (none / 0)

        Only heard of it once before.  Accidentally stumbled across a diary of mine with that designation, but never saw it again, and don't know what it is.

        Since you seem to know something about it, would you be so kind as to explain something about what it is?

        John McCain voted against health care for kids.

        by Land of Enchantment on Wed Mar 01, 2006 at 07:45:28 AM PDT

        [ Parent ]

  •  Goodness! (4.00 / 25)

    "I was told that I could either plead to this misdemeanor or I and my deputies would be indicted on felony charges," McGee said. "I've asked the government on three separate occasions to indict me and leave the deputies out of it because they were only acting at my direction."

    What a bunch of assholes! That's our tax dollars at work. I realize that plead a greements are kind of a blackmailing of sorts but this just sounds preposterous to me!

    Recommending - because this needs to be known widely.

    •  Yup. Recommended. (4.00 / 15)

      This sort of BS is such a perfect analogy for the entirety of the administration's attitude towards working/suffering americans.  An example should be made out of it, for sure.

      "In all chaos there is a cosmos, in all disorder, a secret order." Carl Jung

      by Unduna on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:22:26 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  Agreed. (4.00 / 17)

        This group lets no good deed nor truth-telling go unpunished.
        For God's sake, I know am not alone in feeling I wanted to drop everything here and go help Katrina victims after watching in horror and trying to make sense of the disconnect with what bushco was saying and the reality we all witnessed.And are still witnessing with the pathetic "reconstuction."
        Unlike the sheriff, I would have been an albatross in rescue and relief and could only donate money.

        "John McCain is a grifter and a scoundrel," dengre

        by cosette on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:41:36 AM PDT

        [ Parent ]

    •  Indeed. (4.00 / 5)

      What a bunch of assholes!

      Contrast this with the utter lack of response from the 'justice' system to the sheriff and mayor of Gretna, a town now famous for denying people trying to escape NO the use of an interstate bridge which they did not build, did not own and which wasn't anywhere near the borders of their town. Has the proper standard of behavior during and after national disasters become to deny aid to taxx paying citizens?

      to the diarist:

      DK may be over Katrina but I'm not anywhere close to being over it.

    •  If I were him... (none / 1)

      I'd let them indict the whole damn Sheriff's department.  This is a clear case of the necessity defense if I ever saw one.

      Failing that (or complementary to that), it's also a damn good case for jury nullification.

      "There is nothing false about hope." -- Barack Obama

      by DC Pol Sci on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 05:53:14 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  Embarrassing (none / 0)

        Wouldn't that be really embarrassing for the prosecutor.  Is the prosecutor elected?  That commercial could write itself.

        Republicans need people to be stupid

        by strengthof10kmen on Wed Mar 01, 2006 at 06:50:04 AM PDT

        [ Parent ]

      •  Can't do that. (none / 0)

        I'd let them indict the whole damn Sheriff's department.  This is a clear case of the necessity defense if I ever saw one.


        Suffice to say, personal honor would never allow me to let my subordinates get indicted for something I ordered them to do, if avoidable.  He feels the same way.


        The don't deserve to have their careers marred just for doing their job.  Arguably he doesn't either, but there's no point draggin them into this.

  •  Recommended - This is INSANE! (4.00 / 12)

    No excuse for this shit.  They screw up and now they're looking for scape-goats.

    Typical!

  •  Why would they prosecute? (4.00 / 15)

    Makes no sense. You'd think they'd want to sweep such incidents under the rug, but hey, if they want the national recognition of "going by the book" while people were suffering more power to 'em. Do your worst.

    Here we are now Entertain us I feel stupid and contagious

    by Scarce on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:02:43 AM PDT

  •  also (4.00 / 52)

    You can check the opinion/editorial page of the Hattiesburg American. The newspaper just published a blistering indictment of the Feds' reaction to this. There have been nothing but pro-McGee letters to the editor.

    You're all right - this deserves national attention. While people are actually having to SUE FEMA for the right to fair housing, they're turning around and using their (OUR) dollars to prosecute a man who tried to help.

    Thanks for the comments, everyone.

  •  Turn the Tables (4.00 / 23)

    I watched the Mississippi FEMA director on C-SPAN a couple weeks ago talk about how "thinking outside the box" and "using what you've got" were the key to what he described as Mississippi's very satisfactory FEMA response to Katrina. That fat clown should be cross-examined on the witness stand in the Hattiesburg sheriff's trial.

    And the sheriff's lawyer should make a big deal about jury nullification, where a jury can acquit despite any evidence under a law when they still say a just act is illegal only under an unjust law. That device is one of the checks on an unjust judiciary, and has a strong precedent history in the South, especially during the Civil Rights revolution.

    "When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro." - HST

    by DocGonzo on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:07:34 AM PDT

  •  thanks for posting this (none / 0)

    hope it gets attention
  •  Important diary (none / 0)

    Recommended.

    Bushco, putting the mock in democracy.

    by Southern Bell on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:28:31 AM PDT

  •  Call Lott's office (none / 1)

    1 202 224-6253

    Why are people being PUNISHED for TRYING to deal with problems when FEMA officials were never held responsible for their screw ups?

  •  Wow, this Administration never ceases to amaze (4.00 / 2)

    Sinking to new depths, constantly. It hardly even seems like incompetence, anymore... how could they be this incredibly awful by accident? Cripes.

    I hope this gets widespread publicity. This case needs to go to trial and we need to get the MSM media to cover that trial in all its glory.

    Renewable energy is homeland security!

    by lil bird on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:38:03 AM PDT

  •  Metaphor for Bush Admin. (4.00 / 3)

    This story is another excellent metaphor for the bush administration.  
    a) The person who tries to do the right thing for the good of the people is punished.
    b) authoritarian government run by cronies
    c) dissent is squashed and punished

    Senate passes expanded GI bill despite Bush, McCain http://www.salon.com/politics/war_room/2008/05/22/gi_bill/index.html opposition

    by ScienceMom on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:38:38 AM PDT

  •  So freakin' typical (4.00 / 7)

    This guy actually demonstrates some of the "can do" spirit and initiative that hypocritical guitar-playing sybarites like Bush are always praising in their canned and meaningless speeches--in order to save human lives--and promptly gets the book thrown at him for it.

    If there's a more fitting example of just how evil these people are--other than, perhaps, the thousands of unused trailers in Arkansas, and the still-homeless people of New Orleans--I can't think of it.

    And I'm sure that this boneheaded and immoral legal action will not only get thrown out, but will ultimately backfire on the cretins who actually had the nerve to initiate it.

    Karma might not be instant when in comes to BushCo, but it's coming, and it's going to hit them HARD--harder than they could possibly imagine. It won't make up for all the damage they've done and ill will they've engendered--how could it?--but it'll come awfully close.

    Sic transit gloria mundi - ancient Roman proverb

    by kovie on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:39:42 AM PDT

    •  amen (4.00 / 2)

      Except I've got to pick a bone about George Bush being a "guitar playing" anything. I know what you mean and understand the reference to the guitar he was given on the day New Orleans drowned, but he ain't no guitar player. The only talent he has is the talent to hypnotize idiots into thinking he's a true, respectable leader. Oh, and the talent to brainwash Christians into thinking he's actually a Christian. Oh, and a gift for turning every company (or State or Country) he's head of into pure crap.
      Just had to speak my mind there because my son is a gifted guitarist and I hate to think he has anything in common with that asshole. Carry on.
      :)

      "Never, never, NEVER give up!" --Winston Churchill

      by rioduran on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 10:34:26 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  Sorry, I didn't mean to insult real guitar players (none / 1)

        let alone talented ones by in any way comparing them to Bush. I should have put quotes around "guitar-playing".

        As with his pathetic and shameful attempt to look like a heroic military fighter pilot during that awful "Mission Accomplished" episode on the Abraham Lincoln in 2003, Bush insults anyone who's actually accomplished something real and substantial by pretending to be one of them--including his current totally make-believe job.

        Sic transit gloria mundi - ancient Roman proverb

        by kovie on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:12:32 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  I agree with you completely (none / 0)

          To me, he is the quintessential, stereotypical, spoiled-brat little rich kid. Mommy has protected him from real experience and Daddy has bailed his sorry ass out so many times, he never learned true responsibility. And he's been able to pay for the essence of an experience without actually having to go through trial and tribulation and the joy of accomplishment as such, like military service for instance. He did just enough to get by and Daddy hid the paper trail exposing the sham. It's turned him into an insufferable little twit but what amazes me most about it is the people who can't manage to see through his transparency. Middle America has really shown their collective idiocy by buying into his lies. He mocks them and they just lap it up. It's pathetic, you're right.
          And no offense taken--I just had to make sure to break that mental link before it established itself in anyone's psyche.

          "Never, never, NEVER give up!" --Winston Churchill

          by rioduran on Wed Mar 01, 2006 at 12:33:34 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

          •  It's not just Bush (none / 0)

            but the whole "culture" that makes someone like Bush possible. And this "culture", I'd argue, goes way beyond the insular, inbred, hyperrich, genuinely "elitist" society that he comes from. John Kerry, for example, while not exactly the best Democrat I can point to, came from a similarly affluent and priviledged background as bUsh, and yet turned out quite different. So did Dean, Gore, Rockefeller, etc. Money, even "old money", does not, in and of itself, make for an immoral and despicable shitbag like Bush.

            Not that you were saying or implying this, of course, but I just wanted to make that clear at the outset.

            The "culture" that I refer to is one that spans the spectrum from superrich to superpoor, from right-wing to left-wing, from brilliant to stupid, etc. It's not about money, region, race, ethnicity, politics, etc., but about what I'll call "values" (but not in the way that the right defines this word). It's about being a genuinely good, decent, open-minded, hard-working, responsible, mature, considerate person, who takes only what's rightfully theirs and gives back in return, versus being the exact opposite, which is what Bush is, in a way that has nothing to do with his silver spoon background. It's about the kind of person that you are and how you were brought up, and not which part of society you come from.

            And this is where people like Bush intersect with the masses of idiots who love him to death. No, these people aren't necessarily "bad" people the way that Bush is. But there's a certain "spiritual" emptiness in them that allows them to completely not see just how horrible and worthless a person Bush really is (and which, I'd argue, allows all those phony megachurches to prey on them).

            In this respect, Bush and these people are very alike: there's no soul there, just a big, dark vacuum waiting to be filled by whatever comes along. In Bush's case it was a life of reckless and unaccountable living that others always made possible and cleaned up for him. In their case it's been a life defined by the spiritual emptiness that is middle America, e.g. Walmart, strip malls, trash tv, fast food, talk radio, etc. The two were made for each other, in a match made in hell.

            And, of course, the practical link between the two are the folks who define this spiritually empty "culture", like Limbaugh, Robertson and Geraldo, who straddle the line between trashy upper-class power and trashy lower-class supporters of that power. They pretend to be folksy to connect with the hoi polloi, but are really totally tied into the power structure and have nothing at all in common with the masses. And Bush is part of a new generation of faux folksy politicians who have been able to do much the same.

            There's a certain political "genius" that folks like Rove and even Bush have shown in being able to exploit this spiritual emptiness for political gain. But that in no way excuses or makes up for their own spiritual emptiness. Rich or poor, educated or uneducated, smart or dumb, both BushCo and their fanatical (and in some cases opportunistic) supporters are the same load of crap to me, part of the same overall problem, and to be dealt with equally: clean up your act and start acting like human beings, or face the inevitable consequences headed your way.

            There's a Cat 5 storm about to hit these folks--all of them--and I'm not sure they even know it. But they certainly deserve it, and it might be the only thing capable of shaking them back to reality, and hopefully decency. I just hope it doesn't hit the rest of us.

            Sic transit gloria mundi - ancient Roman proverb

            by kovie on Wed Mar 01, 2006 at 09:40:35 PM PDT

            [ Parent ]

  •  DON'T PLEAD GUILTY!! (none / 0)

    fight the bastards - what a crock.

    -4.63,-3.54 If the people will lead the leaders will follow

    by calebfaux on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:41:31 AM PDT

    •  Exaclty! (none / 1)

      Can't he get a jury trial?  I'd love to plead his case to a jury.  Easiest win ever.

      He not busy being born is busy dying.

      by jarrrettg on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:03:24 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Lawyers, isn't necessity a defense here? (none / 1)

      If not, they should try for jury nullification. This should be the trial of the millennium. Jesus, it just doesn't end.  

      Has anyone started a legal defense fund?

      "Rupert Murdoch Loves Hillary Clinton"--CBS News headline.

      by Thistime on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:47:59 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  He wants to protect his deputies. (4.00 / 4)

      The threat is that not only would he face felony charges, his deputies who were with him would as well.

      He wants to prevent them having to go through that prosecution.  I respect that.  

      John McCain - all aboard the lobbyist express!

      by jrooth on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 01:08:53 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  It blackmail really - it shouldn't be allowed (4.00 / 2)

        to stand.

        -4.63,-3.54 If the people will lead the leaders will follow

        by calebfaux on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 01:30:26 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  Fairly Typical Courtroom Result (4.00 / 4)

          This case is certainly a load of crap, but it is something one would expect to here in Bush's Wonderland in its spectacular temerity, its arrogant inversion of justice, and its astounding idiocy.  The deal is obviously designed to force the Sheriff to plead to save the deputies, exactly the moral dilemna Bush and his family and the kleptocracy they represent would never do: they would sacrifice thousands of deputies to save their own hide, hell, they would sacrifice them for profit and convenience, let alone to save their hide.

          What doesn't seem to be recognized in this portion of this thread is that injustice in the criminal justice system is fairly routine.  That is not to say that it is preponderant, though considering the barbarity underlying the system one could make that argument, most criminal cases have the surface facts right, however it is certainly a weekly occurrence in most criminal courtrooms that pretty terrible injustices are done.  I'm sure that a sheriff has good reason to be worried about the good sense of going to trial on a felony and counting on jury nullification if one were faced with a proveable case.  In my jurisdiction an attorney can't easily outright argue jury nullification as an option; its there, and no one can control a jury, but arguing to them that they are not bound by the law and can just do as they like is not an argument judges will countenance.  best chance is to delay a change of plea, delay a trial and hope that discreet pressure takes the heat off the DA.  That discreet pressure is the job of people offended by this, pressure points are listed above.

          "I said, 'Wait a minute, Chester, you know I'm a peaceful man.'" Robbie Robertson

          by NearlyNormal on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 02:16:29 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

          •  I agree, it is not unheard of (none / 1)

            for federal prosecutors to threaten to indict your wife/husband/significant other and/or children if you don't take a deal.  The Judge, of course, could/should reject the plea as a sham because s/he can only accept a plea where the defendant is guilty and admits guilt.

            In some respects, this is not much different from the scenario that happens everyday in state courts, where a defendant is told, "you can go home today with time-served on a misdemeanor, or wait in jail until your speedy trial date comes up in 60 or 90 days and risk a felony conviction."  Somehow courts have said that the threat of continued incarceration pending trial does not render your waiver of rights and guilty plea to be involuntary.

            "Speak out, judge fairly, and defend the rights of oppressed and needy people." Proverbs 31:9

            by zdefender on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 03:09:46 PM PDT

            [ Parent ]

            •  3-Strikes (none / 0)

              The worst that I've ever had to deal with is the damn 3-strikes law in Ca, that does not require a serious felony for the trigger count.  What has happened is that you have a client with a bad past and a decent case, the prosecution offers to strike the strike and so you have to go to your client and tell him that he has a choice:  he can go to trial and walk if he wins, do 25-life if he loses, or take a mid-term plea on the felony and do 2 yrs in state prison.  This could be on something as silly as a petty theft with a prior theft offense.  Takes a lot of gall to roll the bones.  I've seen terrible injustices based upon the terrible power this law puts in the state's hand.

              "I said, 'Wait a minute, Chester, you know I'm a peaceful man.'" Robbie Robertson

              by NearlyNormal on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 04:59:38 PM PDT

              [ Parent ]

  •  Contact (4.00 / 4)

    contact the Hattiesburg American
    They published the story to get some attention so don't be hard on them.

    Switchboard: (601) 582-4321

    Might ask them is we can get a number to the states prosecuter handling the charge.

  •  Silver Lining (none / 1)

    The Bushies are not winning any hearts and minds with this action. Could it help turn Mississippi blue?

    "There are no happy endings in the Bush Administration". - Randall L. Tobias

    by MadRuth on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:47:55 AM PDT

  •  I see. (4.00 / 23)

    And can someone tell me when the feds are going to be charging the sheriff and deputies of Gretna who fired shotguns over the heads of New Orleans residents who tried to cross the bridge to get out of NO after Katrina? I assume their indictments are forthcoming?
  •  recommended (4.00 / 10)

    and I sent a link for this to the Olbermann show - he's keeping tabs on what goes on here, and this should rate as a "worst" on Countdown.  Thanks for diarying this information!

    When will our consciences grow so tender that we will act to prevent human misery rather than avenge it? Eleanor Roosevelt

    by seefleur on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:49:41 AM PDT

  •  an outrage (4.00 / 11)

    Reading the linked article, it's clear that this prosecution is politically motivated:


    "I feel like he's probably getting some pressure from the Mississippi National Guard," McGee said. "He told me the governor personally demanded I be prosecuted for this."

    It's also a sham evidenced by the heavy handed tactics to prevent the case from going to jury trial:


    "I was told that I could either plead to this misdemeanor or I and my deputies would be indicted on felony charges," McGee said. "I've asked the government on three separate occasions to indict me and leave the deputies out of it because they were only acting at my direction."

    One idea I have is when the case is over that the Mississippi Democratic Party should approach Sheriff McGee about running for office as a Democrat.  If McGee ran for office, say for the statehouse, I think it would turn on the tables on the governor by making his unjust prosecution a political issue.

    "Reality has a well-known liberal bias." -Stephen Colbert

    by Monkey In Chief on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 11:50:10 AM PDT

    •  Great idea. (4.00 / 3)

      I thought of what a great ad it would be for the sheriff having some of the lucky recipients say how they lost their house, but thanks to the quick work of Sheriff McGee, they didn't lose their lives. After a moment, I couldn't believe I had such a callous thought. I made myself sick.

      Then I sat pondering the thousands of countrymen we lost because of these evil, inexcusable @#*ts who now seek to punish those who helped save lives. I f@*king hate them. Oh, how I hate them.

      "I'm not an actor, but I play one on TV."

      by zeitshabba on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:09:12 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  Question (none / 0)

    The guy's a sheriff. What will this do to his career? Could he loose his job because of this?
  •  So... (4.00 / 2)

    Prosecute this guy, but not the cops who kept refugees stranded on the bridge at gunpoint. Great.
  •  So are you all going to call (4.00 / 3)

    or is this just a "talk about it" blog?

    See the numbers up thread

  •  asdf (4.00 / 3)

    This man should be put in charge of FEMA instead of being prosecuted by them.  

    Anyone who shows this Administration up for the assholes they are promptly gets punished.

    Also, Bush, Cheney et al could learn a lesson in taking responsabilty from Mr. McGee.  Instead of passing the buck, he is taking the bullit for his deputees by pleading guilty to these bogus charges.

    •  Wujiman (4.00 / 6)

      How can you say this Sheriff is qualified to run FEMA? Did he raise hundreds of thousands of dollars for the Bush campaign? Is he a Bush croney? Will he guarantee rebuilding contracts goes to friends and contributors to George W. Bush? If you answered no to any of the above, he's not qualified to be a member of the Bush cabinet. /snark

      Thrice is he armed who hath his quarrel just. Sherlock Holmes.

      by Carnacki on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:17:07 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  Good diary (4.00 / 2)

    Fivefour,
    Thank you for this contribution.  You're right, this is still important.  We can make it national news.  There is no excuse for this.  It clearly is a diversion, just tack onto the litany.  The people of the Gulf Coast certainly won't let this issue down.  It's absurd.  How does the prosecutor feel about this?  Is he being tried by a jury or just a judge?  

    I'm so pissed off right now.  Billy McGee is a hero.  Thank god he had enough wits about him during the disaster to make a logical decision in order to save lives.  Somehow, he is forced to plead guilty for saving lives.  What an awful thing.

  •  See how far the prosecution gets (none / 1)

    with a trial by a jury of HIS peers.
  •  I am Spartacus (4.00 / 5)

    In my three weeks as a shelter volunteer I violated dozens of regulations-including some state-level felony type thingies. It's how things got done for the first month at least. If anyone had successfully gotten between me and the resources I needed for my client's welfare, it would have been knuckle sandwiches all 'round (I was sneaky instead).

    I miss Nixon. There was a certain grandeur to his evil

    by mrwizard on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:21:08 PM PDT

  •  My slogan... in caps (4.00 / 3)

    JAIL BUSH, NOT MCGEE!

    If the Democrats were serious, and most people here know I've pratically given up on them, they would pay to have a commercial interviewing McGee. Let him tell his tale, then intercut with shots from Katrina, Brownie, Bush with the birthday cake, the House report.

    They would let the American people KNOW what has happened to their country... not in boring speeches and position papers only, but in the media that everyone watches.

    War is the statesman's game, the priest's delight, The lawyer's jest, the hired assassin's trade Invictus

    by Valtin on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:23:49 PM PDT

  •  Hey gang! Remember where FEMA (4.00 / 5)

    insisted on putting all the ice?

    Maine!

    Selected portions of an article from last September:

    HURRICANE KATRINA
    Truckloads of ice to be stored in Portland

    By DAVID HENCH
    Blethen Maine Newspapers

    "The federal government is diverting hundreds of truckloads of bagged ice cubes from the Gulf Coast hurricane relief effort to cold storage in Portland and other cities.

    The Federal Emergency Management Agency says it has more ice than it can use in the hurricane zone and wants to keep it in storage for use in a future emergency. But critics, including some truck drivers who have been paid $800 a day while hauling the same loads for a week or more, say the process seems like a waste of taxpayers' money.

    'The $9,000 they're paying me to move this load should have gone to some family down there," said Loren Reeves, who hauled his load of ice from Long Island, N.Y., to Alabama before being sent to Maine. "There is definitely millions being wasted that could go to people who need it.'

    Reeves' truck was one of several lined up at AmeriCold Logistics refrigerated storage facility on Read Street, offloading pallets stacked with 25-pound bags of ice.

    Local officials said they are expecting 220 truckloads of ice to be delivered here through Thursday.

    In Portland, ice ranges from $64 per ton when purchased in bulk to $300 per ton when purchased retail by the bag. Trucks coming to Portland from the Gulf Coast have been carrying between 15 and 23 tons."

    I sure hope the Hattiesburg paper and the Sheriff's defense counsel call this to everyone's attention.  I second all the posts preceding this one!

  •  thank you (none / 0)

    for this diary. this could and should be extremely embarrassing for anyone with a lick of sense. oh, right. i forgot who we're talking about (again).

    "This year, it's on like Donkey Kong." --dkos user PresentMoment

    by birdbrain64 on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:37:33 PM PDT

  •  An honorable man (none / 1)

    In view of his wish to preserve his deputies from harm by pleading guilty, I suggest that it would be appropriate to fine him rather than imprison him. It would of course have to reflect the seriousness of his crime - maybe one cent would be about right.

    "That's an entirely valid point" - MBNYC

    by londonbear on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:37:59 PM PDT

  •  Welcome to the Police State. (none / 1)

    This is how they do it. Full force of the law against anyone who doesn't obey orders from above. Send the message via swift, harsh reprisals. That's why the PUTRID Act includes a provision for a national police force.

    It was okay for the NOLA police department to commandeer 200 Cadillacs off a car lot, but it's not okay to sustain life with water?

  •  Another hero (4.00 / 4)

    I have always wondered about what happened to the guy that got an abandoned school bus going and went around picking up lost and suffering people and drove them all to Houston at a time when FEMA could not produce any transportation, medical care, water or food. Instead of being celebrated by the nation for initiative he was arrested for stealing a bus.

    We have only just begun and none too soon.

    by global citizen on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:51:07 PM PDT

    •  Jabar Gibson (4.00 / 4)

      Also reported as Jabbar, Jabbor.

      AFAIK, he was never charged for using the bus (he and plenty of others on the bus said a policeman had authorized it).

      An AP story reported his arrest in New Orleans last November for "possession with intent to sell" -- don't know what became of that.  FWIW, there has been some blog speculation (including on the right/libertarian side) that he was targeted by NOLA mayor/police because he made them look bad (the thousands-of-stranded-buses thing).

      If you scroll down this page to the story dated 10/18/2005, you'll find the most complete story of the "renegade bus" ride that I've seen to date.

      •  Interesting... (none / 1)

        It's interesting that Gibson dropped off the hero-worship radar once he fessed up to being on parole -- apparently shortly after he got to Houston.  Just too much cognitive dissonance for some people, I guess: the hero kid (20 years old) was actually also known around his housing project (by the very people he rescued) as a bit of a thug -- of the entrepreneurial type, not of the robbing-old-ladies type.  Also doesn't square with the "criminals preying on the vulnerable in the Superdome" scenario: in this case, the criminals (Jabar and friends) were organizing transport to get their neighbors to safety.
  •  Damn (none / 1)

    That's really sh*tty.  I don't care if he's a dem or repub.  Right is right.  It's just the principle of the matter.  He stuck to his values and he was right for doing so
  •  yet again... (4.00 / 2)

    the folks who created the f***ing disaster prosecute the folks who took the FUBAR situation & did the best they could under the circumstances. It's the horror show version of Groundhog Day.

    This is beyond appalling.  As is the fact that doctors who were left with a hospital full of patients and no power, water, medicine, support, food,  or staff and are being investigated & prosecuted for murder.

    Recd.

    Do not be overwhelmed by the enormity of the world's grief...You are not obligated to complete the work, but neither are you free to abandon it.

    by Albatross on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 12:53:28 PM PDT

    •  You know, I'm beginning to believe that if any FBI (none / 0)

      Special Agent or U.S. intelligence officer had tried to arrest the 9/11 hijackers before the attack, he would have been shot dead by this Administration.  3,000 Americans died.

      The White House attempted to destroy those in the CIA and DIA who tried to tell the truth about Iraq. 2,300 Americans have died.

      Similarly, we're learning that those officials who attempted to break the blockade or bring relief to the victims of Katrina were punished.  4,000 Americans died.

      Bush-Cheney has committed multiple mass murders.  It is the duty of U.S. law enforcement, U.S. Attorneys and, ultimately the U.S, military, to arrest and try those responsible for these crimes.

      •   4,000 Americans died? (none / 0)

        Is that the last Katrina count?  The count of the human cost of the Bu$hCo Katrina sacrifice dropped off the radar.

        Apparantly hurricanes CAN be as deadly as terrorists.  However, rescuing people after hurricanes is not as sexy as rounding up the pose to go after the bad guys.  And, you surely could not justify illegal wiretaps nor the rest of The Patriot Act.

        Will November ever get here?  Tick.....(forever)...Tock ...

        •  hm (none / 0)

          I'm pretty sure a more accurate count is around 1300. It's really sad to throw numbers around like this, but the point is still valid: under the ever-watchful eye of this administration, we've spent the last five years beefing up security (or not), involving ourselves in unnecessary wars in order to prevent terror attacks -  and, suddenly, an entirely PREDICTABLE natural event was able to ravage two states and take away so many lives..
  •  Recommended! (none / 0)

    Plus I just sent the link to Keith!
  •  No good deed goes unpunished (4.00 / 2)

     
    As a sheriff, I feel he has the right to comandeer any resource in a time of emergency and to direct it to the people in greatest needs.  If he's keeping it for himself, that's a crime.  If he is dealing with a disaster in a responsible way, it's a heroic action, deserving of high praise, not prosecution.  
  •  Speaking of sheriffs (none / 1)

    Did anyone ever prosecute the one who blocked one of the bridges leading out of New Orleans that that the (black) residents couldn't get out of the disaster zone into the (white) suburbs?
  •  moronic government (none / 1)

    I just emailed CNN's American Morning (since they're in the area anyways).  Tried to email Gov. Barbour, but apparently he doesn't currently offer 'constituent services', or contact other than by phone or snail mail.  I'll be calling as soon as I'm done typing this reply.

    Interesting sidenote, Anderson Cooper's show tonight:

    Tuesday's show
    Tuesday's show

    Fat Tuesday in New Orleans: Has Katrina made the streets less safe? Courts struggle to keep up with the criminals. Tune in at 10 p.m. ET.

    Maybe the streets would be more safe if they prosecuted criminals rather than heros.

    -8.38, -6.21 If you're not outraged, you're not paying attention

    by Mat in IL on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 01:06:02 PM PDT

  •  This should be Page 1 news ... (none / 1)

    And not just today, the first Fat Tuesday since the Deluge hit the Crescent City.

    BushCo. seem to want nothing less than Absolute Authority at all times to make whatever decision tickles their corporate fancies ... or to prevent any decision from being made, by anyone else, that doesn't.  

    Above all else, they seem to want the entire world to wait in suspense for them to do anything at all, which is what actually seems to happen much of the time.

    So, when a private citizen (even if he's an officer of the law) 'usurps' this divine right they have awarded to thremselves, they want to put him in jail?  How typical of them.

    I hope he beats the rap, sues the Feds for a pile of money, and has a movie made out of his story---which ideally would open in theatres nationally, late in October of 2008...!

  •  A soldier jumped on the truck to stop it? (none / 0)

    As it was being driven out to get help to victims of Katrina, he wanted to stop it?  How many other things are our soldiers being trained to do that will interefere with rescues of Americans in future emergencies?  Or are most all of them going to be rounding us up and transporting us to the interment/concentration camps prepared for somebody which I have seen photos of on the internets.

    I also remember the helicopter pilot who was repremanded for resucing some people from roofs.  Harsh times, these, for freedom and democracy that we are attempting to spread in the USA.

    ...do the elites...actually believe that society can be destroyed by anyone except those who lead them? - John Ralston Saul -

    by Silverbird on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 01:32:26 PM PDT

  •  I had hoped it was the Greta Parish Sheriff - the (4.00 / 2)

    one who's white deputies fired in the air to drive fleeing (mostly black) NOLA residents back away from the entrance to a freeway bridge that would have taken them out of downtown and to safety inland.

    There really hasn't been ANY justice done in the Katrina region, has there?

  •  Thanks! (4.00 / 2)

    I've been telling people how rural folks were screwed over in all this. They cleared downed trees off their own roads with their own chainsaws, then the agencies said "oh good, the roads are cleared now" and drove right on through to the cities. They did NOT stop the trucks in any of these towns, and people literally stood in front of the trucks to force them to stop and give them water.

    It's always this way for the rural folks -- the city folks get everything and get it first, every time. It's that way everywhere, even in my rural corner of California. The city folks don't give a shit about us.

    Case in point: On the June ballot the county has a bond for a new school gym... in the largest town in the county. They want to tax everyone in the county $60/year per $100,000 of property value for this facility only they can use. Oh, and they're cutting teachers for OUR school, possibly forcing a combined 2/3/4 grade class (1/3 of the school's kids into ONE class... no joke) for next year.

    This is the typical shit that gets pulled on us rural folks. We're not a big enough voting base for them to care.

  •  Gretna assholes - you're next (4.00 / 2)

    •  Oops (none / 0)

      Didn't mean to imply this guy should be prosecuted!  It could have looked that way.

      What I meant:

      The Gretna police that stopped the evacuees from crossing that bridge are the kind of fuckers that REALLY need to be prosecuted...

      And let's not forget Brownie and Chertoff.

      But no, they shift the blame yet again, surprise!

  •  Related News (4.00 / 4)

    Oxfam America released it's report on Gulf Coast recovery today, and it's not pretty.

    http://www.oxfamamerica.org/...

    "Be yourself; everyone else is already taken." - Oscar Wilde

    by greendem on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 01:58:24 PM PDT

  •  Title ambiguous (4.00 / 4)

    Your current title, "Local Sheriff Prosecuted for Diverting FEMA Truck", sugests he was preventing the truck from getting through to deliver goods to needy citizens, when in fact the contrary is the case.  How about "Local Sheriff Prosecuted for Using Sidelined  FEMA Truck To Deliver Aid"?

    Thanks, though - important story.

    "You can't negotiate with reality" - James Kunstler

    by Bob Love on Tue Feb 28, 2006 at 02:35:13 PM PDT

  •  protocol? there was not protocol. (none / 0)

    except maybe screw you and hooray for me.
  •  Why should he be treated any differently (none / 0)

    than the soldiers of the 372nd Military Police Company at Abu Ghraib?

    Precient that the Washington Post had this editorial about the lack of accountability for homicides at Abu Ghraib.

    And this quote from ret. Brig. Gen. David R. Irvine is still quite apt:

    "What is unquestionably broken is the fundamental principle of command accountability, and that starts at the very top."

  •  Barbour's office just called me back (4.00 / 4)

    Swears Barbour had nothing to do with it. Suggested calling Congressman.

    Hattiesburg is in the 4th district which would be Gene Taylor (a DEM!). Office phone in DC is 202-225-5772.

    I'm calling him now.