Daily Kos

Fears Republicans Live With

Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 05:15:31 PM PDT

For most of my adult life I've been an ESL (English as a Second Language) teacher. Now I'm a professor, training other ESL teachers. Every winter my advanced students and I organize and conduct adult ESL classes for immigrants in our city. The classes are free for English language learners, and give my students a chance to get some serious hands-on experience. I encourage my students to invite immigrants that they know or meet, and usually mention restaurants as a place where they may find people interested in the classes.

One of my grad students (let's call her Anastasia) came to me last night and told me she thought she'd made a Terrible Mistake. She and her husband had gone out to dinner Saturday night, and she'd told their waiter about the class. He'd been their waiter once before, she stressed.

I waited to hear what the Terrible Mistake was.

He'd said he might bring his wife or his sister to the classes, Anastasia said. They both wanted to learn English. His English was pretty good. Anastasia said she didn't really think about what she'd done until they left the restaurant, when her husband turned around and said "Do you realize you just told him where you'll be every Wednesday night? What if he's some kind of stalker or something?"

Anastasia looked at me anxiously.

"I really doubt that your waiter is some kind of stalker or something, Anastasia," I said.

"You think not?" she said. "I was so frightened after talking to my husband that I actually thought about dropping your class. I've been worrying about it all week."

I said many reassuring things, including that I have taught hundreds of people English and none of them has ever stalked me. As she walked away looking mollified I couldn't resist adding "Your husband will just have to get used to your hanging around with foreigners, I'm afraid."

"Oh, no, no, he loves foreigners," she assured me.

I used to teach an adult class in a bad neighborhood in Anchorage, and leave work around 9:30 p.m. It never occurred to me to be afraid of my own students, even though they all knew I was a single woman who lived alone. And even though many of them were waiters. Walking out to my car at night I'd scan the parking lot and look in the back seat, but more with the sense that that's what one does in a bad neighborhood than with any real fear.

This talk with Anastasia really set me thinking. She and her husband belong to a megachurch and undoubtedly voted for Bush. If they're subject to so many fears that they can't talk to their waiter without freaking out, what must they hear when they listen to the political discourse? Bugbears and boogeymen everywhere! I'm surprised they're not scared of me.

But which came first, I wonder, the Republicanism or the fear?

Poll

Which came first?

36%20 votes
56%31 votes
7%4 votes

| 55 votes | Vote | Results

Tags: immigration, education, Republicans, megachurches (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 17 comments

  •  Fear is an old friend of humanity. (4.00 / 3)

    It waits for something new to come along so it can start giving people visions of what is good and bad. What is 'wrong' with new ideas, and lashes out at anything that disturbs it's home, the ego.
    It was there at the beginning of man, when we went from fearing the sounds in the night to fearing what might be out in the night without hearing the sounds.
    It is our gift and our curse, this base fear. It keeps us alive in true danger, and yet can lead us to death even unto the species.
    And it's greatest strength?
    The capacity to keep it from being confronted directly.

    The surge worked huh? Really? Are the American soldiers out of Iraq? Then the surge FAILED!

    by RElland on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 05:21:09 PM PDT

  •  Which came first, the fear or... (4.00 / 3)

    ..the ignorance?

    "It's just like the 60's, only with less hope." -Justin Bond in the film "Shortbus" (-6.38/ -4.21)

    by wonkydonkey on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 05:25:59 PM PDT

    •  In Rethug terms, (4.00 / 4)

      ..keep "them" ignorant and they'll always be susceptible to a message of fear.  Then you can tell them a lie about how you'll protect them and they'll send their kids to die for you.  What possible reason other than fear would anyone outside the corporate white elite ever have to vote for a Republican?
    •  had this convo yesterday (none / 1)

      says it all historically

      http://www.dailykos.com/...

      and once you know you've done wrong, you are always in fear of retribution. From those you have wronged or above.

      Imo that was Nola.They couldn't believe the black folks wouldn't kill them if they went in to help. So they made up snipers as an excuse for cowardice.

      After all, they think, If I had been enslaved and treated like that i would be so angry i would kill every whitey I see! So we see that the fear is bade on guilt. And since it is not even completely their wrongdoing ( their ancestors etc.) they are also very, very angry and confused.

      Should be an interesting year

  •  I think this has more to do with another type of (4.00 / 3)

    class. And keeping them separate.

    The idea that the woman was going to help the person who had been their servant was repulsive to the "keep it all for us" republican mentality.

    You can't be on the team, if you're not in the choir. Sorry.

    by peeder on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 05:26:43 PM PDT

  •  And you wouldn't believe the soup of the day (4.00 / 3)

    Probably cyanide bisque...that's a great story.

    My white middle class coworker expressed today that she thought Minnesota was being overrun by "Mexicans"...I just moved here from the San Francisco Bay Area, and I'm having a hard time locating anyone who doesn't look like Bjork. If she dropped into East San Jose, California, I think she'd turn into a jiggling pile of flan.

    •  She's looking at the future. (none / 1)

      Apparently about as much of it as she can take :).

      -9.0, -8.3. History is more or less bunk.--Henry Ford
      Henry Ford is more or less bunk.--history

      by SensibleShoes on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 06:38:14 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Oh, please! (4.00 / 2)

      Maybe some parts of E. Lake St., and the old West Side of St. Paul are largely Mexican, which is cool by me, they're really OK, but the whole state "overrun" by Mexicans?  I don't think so.

      As if parts of it ('burbs) being overrun by Republicans wasn't far, far worse!

      Your co-worker definitely needs to get out more.

  •  The list is long (4.00 / 3)

    I would hate to be a Republican.  The ones I know do indeed live in terrible fear every waking moment.

    They fear:

    Homeless people.  Poor people.  Black people.  Brown people.  Yellow people.  People with tattoos.  People with pink hair.  People with long hair.  People who drive VW vans.  People who are "liberal".  Homosexuals.  Burglars (who could be ANY of these people).  The "liberal media".  

    Public schools.  Government (unless it's the military or the cops).  Taxes.  Artists (unless it's the "painter of light").  Scary subversive music.  Scary subversive books.  Scary subversive videogames.   Scary subversive internet sites.  People who want clean air and water for their families.  People who want to protect the earth.  

    It goes on and on and on ....

    "Letting a Republican govern is like letting a pedophile babysit"

    by Nordic on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 05:57:21 PM PDT

    •  The sad reality is (none / 1)

      that while they fear them, they also control and exploit them.  In fact, its a source of pride to exploit other these people to do their shit work.  As if somehow keeping them under your economic thumb can diminish some of the fear of them.
  •  well, you know... (4.00 / 3)

    ...those foreign waiters are often armed with sharp ballpoint pens or even, horror of all horrors, waiters' corkscrews...

    <>snark

    this makes me think of a scene in michael moore's "bowling for columbine." he posits the theory that americans thrive on fear. he shows a tv newsclip from an apparently slow news day. it's about some obscure thing, say, ebola virus and it's designed to strike fear into our hearts. then he shows some folks in a bar in canada watching the local news. the talking head: "this just in, there's a huge pothole on 1st street."

    that's haunted me ever since...

    most of the wingnuts are so damned afraid of anything that they can't even elucidate what scares them. it's sad, really.

    The radical invents views. When he has worn them out the conservative adopts them. - Mark Twain

    by FemiNazi on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 06:26:29 PM PDT

    •  Well, I hope Anastasia (none / 1)

      may learn something over the next few months, as she interacts with numerous big scary foreigners, and none of them attacks.

      -9.0, -8.3. History is more or less bunk.--Henry Ford
      Henry Ford is more or less bunk.--history

      by SensibleShoes on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 06:34:34 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  i remember.... (none / 1)

        ...years ago, i dated an iranian. when i told my mom she flipped smooth out. said i'd better not marry him because he'd just take me back to iran and let his family hold me prisoner. i very patiently explained that he could never go back to iran because he left, at his mother's urging, so he wouldn't have to be forced into the military and fight against iraq. i figured it would be good to introduce him to her. out of all my ex-boyfriends (and there's been quite a few) she thinks of him most fondly, lol.

        my mom's a bleeding heart liberal, but i think all the propagandizing news reels she saw in the movie theater as a kid during world war two really had a strange effect on her.

        The radical invents views. When he has worn them out the conservative adopts them. - Mark Twain

        by FemiNazi on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 06:39:48 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

    •  He was bang on. (none / 0)

      The forced fear in America is truly sickening.   You're being told to be afraid of everything - every news clip is played up to be huge even if it's about the terrible danger of ...marshmallows or something.  

      Of course, I'm a nasty foreigner so what do I know.  

      The state has no business in the bedrooms of the nation. - Pierre Trudeau

      by lonestar canuck on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 07:42:20 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  even though many were waiters (none / 1)

    guffaw

    brilliant

    fear is the enemy!

  •  Don't you liberals realize - (none / 1)

    they're all THEM!  Every damn one of 'em!  If they weren't them they'd be us, but they're obviously not us so they must be them!  Do you want them to decide who gets elected?  Do you want them teaching your children?  Do you want them next door, where they can watch your comings and goings?  What if one of them starting dating your daughter?  What if your son showered with one of them at the gym?  

    It's a dangerous world out there, and it's us versus them!

    "You can't negotiate with reality" - James Kunstler

    by Bob Love on Thu Feb 09, 2006 at 07:29:57 PM PDT

Permalink | 17 comments