The sudden weekend change in the ratings classifications changing 1s from "troll" to "unproductive" is a very stupid move. Unproductive is such a massively subjective term and invites more abuse than the "problem" it was attempting to solve.
Is a humorous Monty Python aside "unproductive" in the heat of an in-depth discussion on flat-tax caps on FICA withholdings?
More than likely.
Is it something that should be actively discouraged and beating on someone's mojo?
Hell no.
BAD, bad move. I suggest in the most strong of terms to not have the 1s mean "unproductive"
Update [2005-4-4 18:2:55 by Lestatdelc]:
My suggested structure/naming of ratings
0 = Remove (TU only)
1 = Unacceptable
2 = Marginal
3 = Good
4 = Exceptional