Skip to main content

In this continuing series on the dominionist "parallel economy", we've so far focused on dominionist business directories and dominionism's corporate sponsors; today we focus on a new facet of the dominionist "parallel economy"--the dominionist doctor.

Not only are there dominionist doctors and dominionist healthcare clinics, but entire dominionist medical associations--associations with far more lax standards than the typical mainstream medical association; with dominionist groups pushing hard to get them sanctioned officially as alternative certification boards for licensing, not only is the spectre raised that entire categories of people can be denied medical service, but that certification mills may be a future possibility.

We go through everything from non-dominionist employees being cast out of a dominionist pediatrician's group, to the dominionist "parallel economy" alternative to mainstream pediatricians, to a lesbian couple's unfortunate discovery that their HMO referred them to a dominionist doctor, to implications for not only your safety--but the safety of kids in abusive households--right after the cut.

Part 1: Dominionism at the pediatrician's office

Our story begins with the saga of two employees--Lexi Foster and Vergel Worrell.  Mrs, Foster and Mr. Worrell share a similar story--both Lexi and Vergel were forced out of their jobs at Woodcreek Pediatrics in Puyallup, WA by an incredible climate of religious coercion:

Two former employees of a Puyallup-area pediatric clinic contend in a federal court lawsuit that they were pressured to participate in prayers and subjected to other forms of religious harassment by clinic officials.

Lexi Foster, a medical assistant and Buckley resident, and Vergel Worrell, a nurse living in Tacoma, say in the civil complaint that nursing managers at Woodcreek Pediatrics openly prayed, that prayer often was held at staff meetings and that "employees who didn't participate in the prayers were told they were not team players."

Worrell was fired March 10, 2005, and Foster quit April 27, 2005, because of what she said was a "hostile work environment"

The suit says Foster was pressured to attend church and was told "that she was going to hell and would lead other employees to hell through her poor example," and that both plaintiffs repeatedly were forced by the director of nursing to pray with her.

The complaint says the nursing director told Worrell that he was "Satan himself" and "had to be a born-again Christian to end up in the kingdom of God and that if he did not convert his mother that she would go to hell."

When the Dark Christianity post broke, the team of amateur researchers went into action, and stumbled upon a major player in Puyallup's dominionist "parallel economy".

A quick looksee revealed a veritable hive of dominionist activity.  The roster almost entirely consisted of dominionist docs:

Pullayup facilities (the centre of the lawsuit) include a physician who did his internship at a hospital funded by AmWay and major dominionist funder Richard DeVos (and is apparently also explicitly dominionist according to his bio, including educating his kids through the dominionist correspondence-school "homeschool" system) and a lactation consultant who promotes her "church work".

The Sunrise facility includes a pediatrician who is a member ofan Assemblies of God frontgroup targeting third-world countries and whom has adopted a kid from Guatemala (a nation that has suffered all too much at the hands of Assemblies frontgroups in general) as well as another pediatrician-cum-missionary, a doctor of internal medicine who is a member of a Foursquare congregation (and in fact is the worship director at aforementioned congregation; this is signifigant because Foursquare is a "daughter church" of the Assemblies and holds similar dominionist beliefs), a third missionary doc, and a doctor with links to a group called "In His Image".

("In His Image" itself deserves a bit of explanation--it's a dominionist medical training group (effectively acting as the medical training wing for Oral Roberts University after its dominionist hospital "City of Faith" shut down) whose founder has membership in a dominionist medical society called the "Christian Medical Foundation International.  In turn, "In His Image" is linked with Cornerstone Assistance Network (a dominionist "parallel economy" alternative to the United Way which is heavily connected to neopentecostal churches including the Assemblies of God) as well as Project MedSend (a dominionist "parallel economy" alternative to Doctors Without Borders which is likewise linked with the Assemblies as well as the SBC). It also receives endorsements from the "Christian Medical and Dental Association", a "parallel economy" group we'll get into in a bit.)

The Bonney Lake office also has docs that raise warning flags, including a missionary doc (including operating as a mentor in a group called "Young Life" which has an explicitly bibolatrous statement of faith and is based out of the Colorado Springs complex of dominionist groups--the group itself seems to explicitly operate as an alternative to YMCA et al (yes, YMCA isn't "Christian enough" for a lot of dominionists)), a second doc who promotes stuff about "moral beliefs" on his page, and a nurse practitioner going on about God.

The website itself describes the company as a "ministry" which is itself a subtle--but important--sign that the company could be operating as an explicit "missionary front" without revealing too much.  Per at least one other report on the lawsuit, the order to essentially "shut out" non-dominionists from working at Woodcreek may well have come from Reitzug himself.

More warning signs that we are dealing with a potential front show up in research of the company's founder; as it turns out, Dr. Henry Reitzug is a member of Northwest Medical Teams, a group with explicit links to the Full Gospel Businessmen's Fellowship International (enough that it can almost be considered an medical front of the FGBMFI; FGBMFI is an Assemblies of God frontgroup that has been involved in some foul behaviour, including (on the nicer end of their activity) welcoming groups against allowing LGBT people to adopt and (on the downright despicable end) assisting the steeplejacking of the SBC and targeting pretty much any other non-dominionist church for the same treatment, assisting in steeplejacking the Republican Party, and involving themselves in blatant interference in Latin American politics, ranging from the use of the Miskitu first nation to funnel aid to the Contras in Nicaragua to literally hailing Guatemalan genocide architect Gen. Rios Montt (who is, of note, not only an FGBMFI member but spoke at one of its conferences less than a year after he was overthrown by his own junta leaders).

Of note here (especially in regards to our own exploration of front groups), no less than three of the staff pediatricians are members of the American College of Pediatricians (specifically, Drs. Paul Billing (internal medicine) of the Pullayup facility and Drs. Cal Kierum (pediatrics) and Kathy Brewer (allergist) of the Sunrise facility are known to have signed a statement calling for the US Constitution to be amended with a "defense of marriage" bill).  

And here, we get to focus in detail on the first of the dominionist "parallel economy" medical groups--the American College of Pediatricians.

ACPeds is a dominionist-run "parallel economy" alternative to the legitimate American Academy of Pediatrics which formed in 2003 when the AAP issued statements stating that allowing LGBT people to raise and adopt children would not permanently warp the little sprouts.  Roughly 100 dominionist members of AAP left to essentially "take their ball and go home".  NARTH (a dominionist group promoting "de-gaying" and also a focus with dominionists trying their own "alternate certifying bodies", as we'll get into later) and Concerned Women for America still have the initial press releases on formation of the group.  Of note, ACPeds has been trying to get itself certified as an alternative "accreditation board" for pediatricians--that is, a group authorised to give certification to practicing pediatricians, issue "Continuing Medical Education" credits, and whose membership can be used by state medical boards to license physicians.

This should scare the hell out of people, frankly.  ACPeds has much looser standards for membership, for starters (you just have to be a practicing physician and pay a yearly membership fee); secondly, their positions on things are...shall we say...more than a bit skewed towards dominionist positions that most legit doctors would probably find a bit horrifying.

Among other fun statements:

  1. ACPeds has issued statements claiming same-sex parenting is "harmful, in one of the most egregrious misuses of a study I've seen (the study in question actually reached a very different conclusion--namely, it's more important that kids have two parents than whether they are same-sex or opposite-sex partners).
  1. ACPeds has literally lobbied the UN to exempt almost all physical punishment from the UN's working groups on child violence.  This is not surprising, seeing as
  1. ACPeds actively promotes the works of James Dobson, a leading promoter of religiously motivated child abuse.  They also have used info from Family Research Council to promote the idea of Bible-based baby-beating.

(Seriously, it is very hard to overstate how bad this is.  Physicians are mandatory reporters for child abuse, and are often the first (and increasingly only) persons outside of closed communities to see signs of abuse.  There is a very real risk that ACPeds docs will not report religiously motivated child abuse (not seeing it as abusive); already, dominionist groups are referring parents explicitly to ACPeds pediatricians as a method of avoiding reports of religiously motivated child abuse, and seeing as it is almost impossible otherwise for kids in abusive dominionist households to report abuse without being subject to retaliatory abuse by other mandatory reporters such as pastors--there is a very real risk that these kids will in fact not have abuse reported at all (with potentially very serious or even fatal consequences--religiously motivated child abuse is one of the horrible, dark secrets of dominionism today.)

  1. Not only this, but ACPeds also (almost alone of all medical groups) promoted abusive "degaying" therapy of kids.  Most of ACPeds' info on homosexuality is from its resource list which almost entirely consists of dominionist groups (and a very few token legit medical associations); almost all of these groups use the bogus "research" of Paul Cameron (who has been disbarred from practically every non-dominionist medical and psychological association he has ever been a member of, is incredibly virulently anti-LGBT, and has even advocated locking up LGBT people in concentration camps as a "public health measure" and has in fact (in terms that risk serious Godwinning of this thread) advocated the literal genocide of LGBT people in remarkably similar terms to how the Holocaust against Jews was promoted in Hitler's Germany as a "public health measure").
  1. Almost alone of all medical associations (outside of the dominionist community), ACPeds promotes the idea that life begins at fertilisation and thus claims both Plan B and the "Pill" are abortifacients due to prevention of implantation.  (Firstly, generally Plan B and the "Pill" are not thought to work this way, but to prevent fertilisation; secondly, practically all mainstream medical science sees pregnancy beginning upon implantation of a fertilised ovum, not at the point of fertilisation.)
  1. Again, almost alone of all medical associations, ACPeds opposes making the HPV jab mandatory and uses similar arguments to dominionist groups who fought approval of the HPV jab (of note, ACPeds also fought against approval of the HPV jab).  (Almost all legit medical groups advocate making the jab mandatory, because it makes good public health sense to have girls vaccinated early before they ever engage in sexual activity; also, even "good girls" in monogamous relationships can STILL get HPV from a partner who was faithfully married to another person then divorced (or who was a victim of rape, or many other ways you can get HPV without being promiscuous).)

Of note, ACPeds' main support is NOT from mainstream groups but rather from other dominionist organisations--normally legit medical associations cross-reference with other legit medical associations.

If it were merely dominionist pediatricians and medical offices one had to worry about, that'd be one thing.  Unfortunately, dominionist medical associations are broader than just pediatrician associations.

Much broader.

Part 2: Dominionists at the OB/GYN (and the pharmacist, and the nurse's station, and the dentist, and...)

Our next story shows how the juxtaposition of the dominionist medical "parallel economy" and the decidedly poor state of medical insurance in the US often snare people in a catch-22--leading, in an increasing number of cases, to people being denied healthcare outright.

Guadalupe Benitez was in a situation increasingly common for women--seeking the services of a reproductive technology assistant so that she and her partner could have a baby of their own.

Mrs. Benitez was also in a situation that all too many Americans can say they feel her pain in--namely, her healthcare coverage was through an HMO, specifically Kaiser Permanente, which required company referrals to visit specialists and which had only a limited network of doctors whom she could see.

So she did what thousands of Americans do yearly--called up the insurance company and her primary-care physician, got the referral (to the one clinic in her area that offered services and which was in Kaiser Permanente's network), and proceeded to see the doc.

Unfortunately, Mrs. Benitez ran into a rather major snag.  

You see...Mrs. Benitez is a lesbian, and Kaiser Permanente just happened to refer her to the local dominionist OB/GYN:

Guadalupe Benitez filed a sexual-orientation discrimination suit against the doctors at a San Diego women's clinic after they refused to artificially inseminate her in 2000.

Benitez claims that on her first visit, Brody informed her that while her religious principles precluded her from performing the procedure on a gay woman, another doctor in the clinic would.

Benitez says, however, that after 11 months of costly, painful tests and surgeries, when the time came for the insemination procedure, she was turned down and told that she "would not be treated fairly" or "get timely care" at the clinic because of Dr. Brody's and other staff members' religious beliefs.

The doctors' lawyer, Carlo Coppo, said his clients were committed to fair treatment of Benitez — from fertilization to pregnancy and birth — but that aiding the actual act of conception compromised their religious views.

"[Brody] believes that participating in the [fertilization procedure], she is acting as the male," Coppo said. "It is an elective, invasive procedure, and to be there for the moment of conception, she religiously can't participate."

Unfortunately, merely going to another provider is rarely an option when one is in an HMO.  It's not uncommon for only one or two specialists in a field to be covered in an HMO plan; Mrs. Benitez was stuck, and so she sued.  

California's courts have so far ruled on the side of the OB/GYN clinic--in part because California, like other states, has "moral refusal clauses" that apply to reproductive healthcare workers.  Meant to originally allow healthcare workers to "opt out" of performing abortions, the use of the "Moral refusal clause" has expanded.

. . .

As I noted, dominionist medical associations often have some pretty bizarre concepts on just when life begins; whilst most mainstream doctors see pregnancy beginning upon implantation, dominionist groups see it as beginning at fertilisation--a concept that has led to some rather bizarre promotions (including adoption of "snowflake babies"--leftover zygotes resulting from in-vitro fertilisation that are not used in implantation attempts).  

It has also led to expansion in "moral refusal" clauses to include (increasingly) pharmacists and--in some states--nurses and EMTs, and has been expanded to include end-of-life directives.

This has led, in part, to a dominionist War on Birth Control aided by dominionist "parallel economy" providers; among other things, dominionist groups consider the IUD and "the Pill" (including "the pill" in its megadose form as Plan B) as "abortifacient".

This, in turn, has led to the expansion of the "moral refusal clause" to pharmacists--in part because of stunts that involved pharmacists belonging to dominionist medical societies tearing up birth control scripts in front of women.  This is, of note, a Bad Thing--"the Pill" is used for things besides actual birth control, notably for control of polycystic ovary syndrome (which causes severe pain to women who have it and increases their risk of cancer and diabetes if untreated; my own sister is a PCOS sufferer who was refused medical treatment by my mom (who refused to let her go on "the pill"), ended up in hospital with a suspected gallbladder attack which turned out to be a PCOS flareup, and is now a type II diabetic--likely as a result of delayed treatment).

In turn, the passing of the pharmacist "moral refusal clause" led to the expansion of "moral refusal" to things like refusing to fill prescriptions for antibiotics and pregnancy vitamins because the scrip issuer was a women's clinic, attempts to refuse HIV antiretroviral scripts and prescriptions for the antiherpetic Valtrex, and so on.  (Valtrex and antiretrovirals are often used for things not related to STDs--Valtrex is essential in treatment of and prevention of chickenpox in immunocompromised individuals (and in adults; chickenpox is, sadly, occasionally fatal in adults) and in prevention of the invariably-fatal simian herpes B virus in primate workers, and certain antiretrovirals are now used in treatment of hepatitis C (which is primarily a bloodborne disease).  Even HIV is often not from homosexual contact; het cases of HIV are rising, and there is a non-negligible percentage of the population who contracted HIV from tainted blood and blood products.)  For that matter, the same dominionist medical associations are also pushing to allow "moral refusal" to give the potentially lifesaving HPV jab.

This in turn led to nurses in dominionist medical associations pushing for the right to expand "moral refusal" clauses further, as well as EMTs (these efforts got a big boost during the fiasco with Terri Schiavo and dominionist groups working to keep her in a vegetative state rather than allowing her husband to let her die in peace as she would have wished).  As a result, we now have states like Mississippi that have such broad "moral refusal" clauses that legally a physician, nurse, or EMT can refuse to provide lifesaving treatment to a pagan because they have "strong moral objections to rendering treatment".  (Georgia is also attempting to pass a similar law.)

This becomes highly problematic in small towns and with folks on HMOs--frequently they don't have the choice to go to a non-dominionist doc.

It doesn't help that most of the time dominionist doctors don't always advertise their links to dominionist groups outside of the "parallel economy".

. . .

The two biggest dominionist "parallel medical economy" associations are Pharmacists for Life (promoting dominionist pharmacists and pharmacy techs) and the Christian Medical and Dental Associations; both are hardcore dominionist groups, and CMDA in particular has been pushing to be seen as an alternative accreditation board to the American Medical Association.

CMDA's ethics statements are particularly telling; among other things, they promote the "life and pregnancy begin at fertilisation" concept (again, this flies in the face of legitimate medical science which holds that implantation is the start of pregnancy--no implantation, no pregnancy), believes that reproductive assistance technology should be denied to non-married couples and that amniocentesis and reduction abortions should be avoided (amniocentesis is a cornerstone of good reproductive care, especially for pregnancies of women over the age of 35 or who have had a history of miscarriage--besides, most people who find they are carrying a kid with a chromosomal defect don't abort; reduction abortion is sometimes a necessary thing for IVF pregnancies to survive (ask the Morrison family about their ongoing heartbreak--they refused reduction, had sextuplets only 18 weeks into the pregnancy, five of the six are dead, and the odds aren't good for the sixth; if a few of the fetuses had been aborted, it's likely she could have carried the pregnancy to near term and had healthy babies)), believes that prosyletisation in the doctor's office is not only acceptable but to be encouraged, has advocated against making the HPV jab mandatory (and likewise fought its approval), and claims (in almost complete contradiction to every legitimate medical association in the US) that people choose to be gay and that abusive "degaying therapy" is to be encouraged (more on this in a bit).

In addition, CMDA uses statements from NARTH (to back up "degaying" claims) and even quotes from literature from the Holocaust-revisionist "Abiding Truth Ministries" to back up its claim that LGBT people are more likely to be paedophiles ("Abiding Truth Ministries" is publisher of a horrid bit of Holocaust revisionism known as  The Pink Swastika; for those unfamiliar with this book, it is a bit of Holocaust revisionism that claims not only that gays were not murdered en masse by the Nazis but that the gays were, quite literally, not only Nazis but the very architects of the Holocaust, that LGBT people are of an explicitly criminal and sociopathic nature, and that LGBT people are in a worldwide conspiracy with the Moslem population to wipe out Jews and "born-again Christians" (as Jews and "Joel's Army" dominionists are seen as God's two "chosen people"); in the same section, they also reference the debunked work of disbarred "therapist" Paul Cameron (noted earlier in this chapter) and in the section on "Human Sexuality" makes the claim that sex education for unmarried individuals constitutes pornography.

The group also promotes the work of groups linked to Army of God domestic terrorists in its abortion ethics guidelines (Operation Rescue's leaders, along with Operation Save America, have been linked to clinic violence, clinic harassment, and Operation Rescue founder Randall Terry has actively worked with "Christian Patriot" militia groups linked to domestic terrorism and Operation Rescue members have included "Army of God" assassins) and (again, against practically every legit medical association) makes the claim that "the Pill" and other hormonal birth control are abortifacient--in addition, they promote "moral refusal" explicitly in regards to birth control.

The associated ministry groups are also a dead giveaway we're dealing with the dominionist "parallel economy" (as if the search tool for dominionist doctors wasn't enough of a cluehammer for you): it's a veritable laundry-list of dominionist charity fronts (including "MAP International", a dominionist "parallel economy" alternative to Medecins Sans Frontieres/Doctors Without Borders), dominionist orgs (including Focus on the Family, Family Research Council, and Concerned Women for America), various other dominionist medical associations dealing with other non-physician specialties of practice, a dominionist investment scheme called "Crown Financial Concepts" (we'll get into them in a future installment on dominionist investment), and Zondervan (a dominionist book publisher and bookstore chain we'll focus on in later installments).  Notably not listed in their medical resources are legitimate peer-reviewed medical journals like Journal of the American Medical Association or Lancet.

PFLI is considerably less formal; in a Bill O'Reilly-esque move, they like to post their hate mail online, and laughably refer to states which have enacted "pharmacist shall fill" legislation as "abortaholic" states.  Like most dominionist "parallel economy" business associations, they have their own directory of dominionist pharmacists; in probably the most bizarre endorsement I have ever seen for open-source software, the group promotes Firefox, Thunderbird and OpenOffice under the guise that Microsoft are apparently abortionists.  (No word, of course, on Apple.)

The links page is also a veritable laundry list of dominionist "pro-life" and anti-contraception groups, including the radical "American Life League" (which has claimed that spermicides cause cancer, among other things).

Especially if you're in an HMO with a limited network, the worry about dominionist docs and pharmacists may be enough to drive you crazy.  You increasingly need to be careful in seeing a therapist, though, for things like marriage counseling or psychotherapy--dominionists have a "parallel medical economy" for THAT, too.

Tomorrow, we continue the focus on this part of the dominionist parallel economy--specifically, the extensive promotion of alternatives to mental health providers.

Originally posted to dogemperor on Wed Jul 25, 2007 at 09:27 PM PDT.

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site