Daily Kos

Drug War Roundup - Where to Build a Wall

Sun Mar 18, 2007 at 12:31:26 PM PDT

Last spring, Mexico's congress passed a bill that would have decriminalized the personal use of drugs.  The bill was similar to what had been done in Portugal five years before (and much of Europe has already decriminalized the possession and use of softer drugs like marijuana).  President Vicente Fox promised to sign the bill, but after a complete freakout by American officials over the perceived consequences of such a move, Fox vetoed it.  The legislature made an effort to override his veto, but nothing came about before the summer elections, when Felipe Calderon was elected in a close, controversial election.

After taking office, Calderon announced an effort to combat drug traffickers in several parts of the country where the traffickers have been particularly violent.  Ethan Nadelmann from the Drug Policy Alliance writes recently in The Huffington Post about Calderon's crackdown:

Mexico's new president, Felipe Calderon, seems to be doing all the right things in cracking down on Mexico's drug traffickers. He's appointed new people to key military and criminal justice positions, deployed troops to quell drug violence, reasserted federal police power, extradited a few major traffickers to the United States, and given a green light to legislation clarifying Mexico's drug laws.

But all this provides little reason to hope that Mexico has really turned a corner in its efforts to control the illegal drug trade. For a guide to what's in store, one need only look at past sexenios (the six year terms of Mexican presidents).

What President Calderon is doing now differs little from what his predecessors did at the start of their terms. But the results are always the same -- encouraging at first but then it all starts up again. Drug trafficking gangs re-group with new leaders and new connections. Previously incorruptible officers are newly corrupted. Police of all ranks, and all shades of probity, tremble in fear of assassins' bullets. And Mexicans once again wonder why the cycle never really stops.

It's very clear that Felipe Calderon knows all of this very well.  In fact, he even reintroduced a toned down decriminalization bill to the new Congress.  But the power of the drug cartels in Mexico is the immovable object, something that the Mexican president will never be able to defeat without help - real help - from the United States.  

President Bush travelled through Latin America last week, meeting with Calderon for two days at the end of his trip.  Of course, the problem of the drug cartels is only part of the headache the Bush Administration has in dealing with Mexico right now.  Another problem is the immigration issue, as roughly 12 million Mexicans have fled the violence and the lack of opportunity to work illegally in the United States.  America's response to this problem has been to focus on border security, and President Bush signed a bill to create a high-tech fence along the border.  Many Americans see the border fence as the solution to the problems of drug trafficking and immigration.  Felipe Calderon does not, and he made that very clear to George Bush last week:

Calderon has lambasted the U.S. decision to build the new border fence — a mix of physical barriers and high-tech virtual fencing. He likens it to the Berlin Wall, and argues that both countries need to improve Mexico's economy to lessen the desire to seek work in the United States.

Calderon also is critical of the Bush administration's efforts to stem the flow of drugs into the United States. The Mexican president says threats his administration has received from drug traffickers will not stop the government's nearly nationwide military crackdown, and he is calling on the United States to do more to help.

"We are, at the end of the day, putting our lives on the line in this battle, and the United States has to come up with something that is more than symbolic gestures, much more," Calderon said in an interview Saturday with The Associated Press.

"Mexico can't diminish the availability of drugs while the U.S. hasn't reduced its demand."

And with that, Calderon makes it very clear that he understands the root of all of these problems.  Americans demand drugs.  Lots of them.  And as long as American consumers drive that multi-billion dollar industry, the drug cartels in Mexico will continue to subvert political forces in Mexico City.  And as long as drug cartels hold that kind of power and influence, the violence that it spawns and the lack of opportunity that it creates will continue to drive more and more people north in search of a way to make a living.

When it comes to the American media, however, these issues are rarely presented accurately.  The primary offender here is Lou Dobbs.  Dobbs is considered to be the authority on these matters, but it's really hard to find anyone who has a poorer understanding of what's going on.  He continues to argue in support of a border fence as a way to stop drug trafficking, even though much of the drugs that come into this country make it through after bribes are paid to border agents.  A fence won't stop that.  He continues to believe that NAFTA is the main reason for the flow of illegal immigrants to the United States and he frequently talks about illegal immigration in terms of national security, pandering to xenophobes who believe that there's a more sinister agenda behind those who come here to make a living.

Dobbs appeared on Anderson Cooper's show on Monday night for a short appearance.  This should give you a good idea of how clueless he is when it comes to the issues of U.S.-Mexico relation, the drug war, and illegal immigration.

COOPER: Lou, the new Mexican president, Felipe Calderon, promised that he would get tough on drug traffickers. Thus far, he's seized, destroyed thousands of pounds of drugs, extradited a couple of drug lords to the country.

How's he doing?

LOU DOBBS, CNN ANCHOR: You know, I think, Anderson, this may surprise some people. I think he may be doing pretty darn well, certainly in his early two months in office.

This -- this president, Calderon, has already done since taking office on December 2nd of last year -- so we're really at three months -- he has really done more than Vicente Fox in his entire five-year term as head of Mexico. Whether this is public relations posturing, it is a great beginning and something that could be built upon if the Bush -- and I have less problem, frankly, with the Mexican president than I do the U.S. president.

If they could work together, then sensibly they can actually create border security, they could actually go after the drug cartels that are shipping, you know, up to $100 billion worth of illegal drugs into the country. I think it's very encouraging, frankly.

As Nadelmann explained above, what Calderon is doing is no different than what Fox did when he was into office.  Considering that Calderon also strongly opposes Dobbs' idea of building a border fence, I'm not sure I even understand what it is that has endeared him to Calderon.  But it gets worse as Cooper asks even more pointed questions.

COOPER: You've argued in the past the U.S. hasn't really had the will to win the war on drugs. What are they doing wrong?

DOBBS: Well, a number of things that they are doing wrong. They're acting like this border, which is -- Mexico is the principal source of heroin, cocaine, marijuana and methamphetamines into this country. The numbers rise to $125 billion, that's the highest estimate. It's low is $25 billion going across that border.

But the fact is, a million lives are at stake every year in the country. And if for no other reason, forget there's a small item called a war on terror that we're waging, forget that there are issues with illegal immigration, to stop the drug traffic alone is all that should be required of this government to insist on securing that border and securing our ports.

I originally watched this exchange on TV, and the transcript really doesn't do it justice.  Dobbs was completely unable to come up with anything.  The only answer he ever has to this question is to "secure the border," a solution that has never worked - and never will work - for stopping drug trafficking.  It's not a matter of will, just as it's not a matter of will for us to succeed in Iraq.  It's a matter of practicality.  Instead, he talks about how "a million lives are at stake," a statistic that comes directly from his own ass, but is perfect for scaring people into not realizing that he doesn't have a clue what he's talking about.

COOPER: Last year, Mexico, Vicente Fox, basically legalized small amounts of some narcotics.

DOBBS: Right.

Um, no, he vetoed the bill.  How is it that Dobbs doesn't even know basic facts like this?  Why is he still considered an expert?

COOPER: What kind of impact has that had? I know you were very critical about it at the time.

DOBBS: I'm very critical then, I'm very critical of it now. The idea that he would -- just another example of him rolling over for the drug cartels, which as you know are dominating northern Mexico and now are in a very violent struggle for control of those drug trafficking routes into the United States for distribution.

Despite the absurdity of Dobbs commenting on the impact of something that never actually happened, this isn't even a good reading of what the impact would have been.  Decriminalizing the personal use of illegal drugs would have had absolutely no effect on the power of the cartels.  Selling drugs, even marijuana, would have remained illegal, and in fact, the bill would have made it even easier for lower ranking Mexican officials to go after the cartels.  But again, Lou Dobbs has the same mentality about waging the war on drugs that many neocons have about waging the war on terror.  Anything that deviates from the hardest line possible is seen as a weakness and helps the bad guys.  That's not a strategy, it's a paranoid psychosis.

COOPER: For all of the attention that's been paid to the immigration issue, and I guess some would argue lack of attention from Washington, but at least attention in the media, has -- have things on the border really changed?

DOBBS: No, they have not. As a matter of fact, they've worsened in many respects, whether we're looking at Nuevo Laredo or whether we're looking down to Mexicali, to the western part of northern Mexico. The violence is unending. The police in Tijuana, 2,100 of them, disarmed because of suspected complicity in the assassination, the brutal assassination of other police officers, as well as drug cartel rivals.

Calderon has a great deal to do, and one hopes he can be successful and one hopes he has the true will and support of what has been an incompetent and corrupt government. I wish Felipe Calderon nothing but the best of luck. He has the opportunity to be historic in his achievements.

Recently, Terry Nelson from Law Enforcement Against Prohibition appeared on Lou Dobbs' show.  Dobbs introduced the segment by referring to Nelson's viewpoint as 'idiocy'.  Law Enforcement Against Prohibition is an organization of current and retired law enforcement officials who have figured out that the war on drugs is unwinnable and are advocating an end to the incarceration strategy for combatting drugs.  They have figured out what prominent voices on both the left and the right figured out a long time ago; that trying to stop drugs by criminalizing the behavior of adults is a counterproductive strategy that only leads to greater violence and more drug use among young people.  

The progressive movement that's building in this country does share some of the middle class angst that Dobbs occasionally targets when it comes to health care and other economic issues.  But it's very clear that he doesn't understand the war on drugs, and his continued status as an 'expert' on both that and illegal immigration continues to paint a very misleading picture for America about how to deal with these issues.  Progressives do need to look into building a wall.  We need to build one between ourselves and Lou Dobbs.

Over the past two weeks...

Major News


Opinions and Blogposts


Regional News - U.S. and Canada


Regional News - International


Fun Stuff and Pop Culture

Tags: War on Drugs (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 8 comments

Permalink | 8 comments