I. Preventing Another FISA Capitulation
As kos, Glenn Greenwald, and others have written, Congress' enactment of additional eavesdropping powers for the executive branch in the name of "fixing" FISA cannot be described as anything other than a complete capitulation to the Bush administration. The only good thing about the bill is that it was passed with a sunset provision under which the law is to expire six months after enactment.
This sunset provision, however, is highly unlikely to solve any problems given that almost immediately after the bill passed, the administration started demanding even more from Congress. Specifically, Bush inisted that Congress simply must provide retroactive immunity to the phone companies that enabled the administration's illegal warrantless wiretapping:
While I appreciate the leadership it took to pass this bill, we must remember that our work is not done. This bill is a temporary, narrowly focused statute to deal with the most immediate shortcomings in the law.
When Congress returns in September the Intelligence committees and leaders in both parties will need to complete work on the comprehensive reforms requested by Director McConnell, including the important issue of providing meaningful liability protection to those who are alleged to have assisted our Nation following the attacks of September 11, 2001.
So really, the writing was on the wall as soon as this horrible bill passed. And folks, please remember - this bill to allegedly "fix" FISA was indeed horrible. Under the (already bad enough, and thoroghly illegal) warrantless wiretapping program started in 2001, wiretapping was permitted only if one party to the call was a suspected terrorist. Under the new bill, by contrast, the "terrorist" requirement was dropped. In other words, every single American who calls a person abroad is subject to being spied upon by the Bush administration.
Meanwhile, it appears the Democratic leadership might be leaning toward again capitulating to the administration, this time on the immunity issue. From the New York Times:
[Director of National Security Mike McConnell] also pushed for a provision that would grant legal immunity to the telecommunications companies that secretly cooperated with the N.S.A. on the warrantless program. Those companies, now facing lawsuits, have never been officially identified.
Democratic Congressional aides say they believe that a deal is likely to provide protection for the companies.
Greenwald explains in his typically clear fashion exactly why Congress granting retroactive immuity to these companies for their past illegal activities is dangerous:
First, retroactive immunity turns the "rule of law" into an even greater mockery than it has been for the last six years. The central premise in granting immunity is that telecom companies did nothing wrong -- even if they violated the law -- because they cooperated with warrantless spying at the behest of the President.
But we don't actually live in a country where private actors are permitted to commit crimes and violate laws provided that the President tells them that they should. The President has no greater power to authorize others to break the law than he does to break the law himself. Quite the contrary, Article II of the Constitution imposes the opposite obligation: "he shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed." Lawbreaking is still illegal even if George Bush says it should be done. Does that principle really need to be explained?
Second, the Bush administration -- by refusing to disclose whose conversations were illegally surveilled -- has successfully prevented any direct legal challenges to its warrantless eavesdropping activities.
. . .
The pending lawsuits against AT&T and other telecommunications companies for having violated the law by enabling warrantless eavesdropping on Americans' telephone conversations is one of the very few remaining avenues (though not yet the only one) for obtaining a court ruling as to whether the NSA spying program -- which the President ordered for five years at least -- was illegal.
. . .
Third, and perhaps most importantly, a Congressional grant of immunity for past lawbreaking would amount to a bipartisan endorsement of Bush's illegal eavesdropping program. To remove consequences for illegal behavior is, by definition, to approve of that behavior. Laws with no consequences for violations are meaningless. And those who seek to shield lawbreakers from accountability are endorsing the lawbreaking.
So the question is: what do we do about this? It's a little difficult without a specific bill, but that most certainly doesn't mean we have no recourse. It seems to me we need to be calling our Congressfolk on this issue starting right now. They need to understand we know and care deeply about this. Please call your Congressional representative and tell them (1) the recent FISA amendments should not be reinacted and should instead be permitted to expire; and (2) Congress should not even consider granting retroactive immunity to telecommunication companies that assisted in warrantless surveillance.
Here are phone numbers for your House members (stolen from BarbinMD - thx!):
Finding you Representative
link
A
Abercrombie, Neil (202) 225-2726
Ackerman, Gary L. (202) 225-2601
Akin, W. Todd (202) 225-2561
Allen, Thomas H. (202) 225-6116
Altmire, Jason (202) 225-2565
Andrews, Robert E. (202) 225-6501
Arcuri, Michael A. (202) 225-3665
B
Baca, Joe (202) 225-6161
Baird, Brian (202) 225-3536
Baldwin, Tammy (202)225-2906
Barrow, John (202) 225-2823
Bean, Melissa L. (202) 225-3711
Becerra, Xavier (202) 225-6235
Berkley, Shelley (202) 225-5965
Berman, Howard L. (202) 225-4695
Berry, Marion (202) 225-4076
Bishop, Sanford D. (202) 225-3631
Bishop, Timothy H. (202) 225-3826
Blumenauer, Earl (202) 225-4811
Boren, Dan (202) 225-2701
Boswell, Leonard L. (202) 225-3806
Boucher, Rick (202) 225-3861
Boyd, Allen (202) 225-5235
Boyda, Nancy E. (202) 225-6601
Brady, Robert A. (202) 225-4731
Braley, Bruce L. (202) 225-2911
Brown, Corrine (202) 225-0123
Butterfield, G. K. (202) 225-3101
C
Capps, Lois (202) 225-3601
Capuano, Michael E. (202) 225-5111
Cardoza, Dennis A. (202) 225-6131
Carnahan, Russ (202) 225-2671
Carney, Christopher P. (202) 225-3731
Carson, Julia (202) 225-4011
Castor, Kathy (202) 225-3376
Chandler, Ben (202) 225-4706
Clarke, Yvette D. (202) 225-6231
Clay, Wm. Lacy (202) 225-2406
Cleaver, Emanuel (202) 225-4535
Clyburn, James E. (202) 225-3315
Cohen, Steve (202) 225-3265
Conyers, John Jr. (202) 225-5126
Cooper, Jim (202) 225-4311
Costa, Jim (202) 225-3341
Costello, Jerry F. (202) 225-5661
Courtney, Joe (202) 225-2076
Cramer, Robert E. (Bud) Jr. (202) 225-4801
Crowley, Joseph (202) 225-3965
Cuellar, Henry (202) 225-1640
Cummings, Elijah E. (202) 225-4741
D
Davis, Artur (202) 225-2665
Davis, Danny K. (202) 225-5006
Davis, Lincoln (202) 225-6831
Davis, Susan A. (202) 225-2040
DeFazio, Peter A. (202) 225-6416
DeGette, Diana (202) 225-4431
Delahunt, William D. (202) 225-3111
DeLauro, Rosa L. (202) 225-3661
Dicks, Norman D. (202) 225-5916
Dingell, John D. (202) 225-4071
Doggett, Lloyd (202) 225-4865
Donnelly, Joe (202) 225-3915
Doyle, Michael F. (202) 225-2135
E
Edwards, Chet (202) 225-6105
Ellison, Keith (202) 225-4755
Ellsworth, Brad (202) 225-4636
Emanuel, Rahm (202) 225-4061
Engel, Eliot L. (202) 225-2464
Eshoo, Anna G. (202) 225-8104
Etheridge, Bob (202) 225-4531
F
Farr, Sam (202) 225-2861
Fattah, Chaka (202) 225-4001
Filner, Bob (202) 225-8045
Frank, Barney (202) 225-5931
G
Giffords, Gabrielle (202) 225-2542
Gillibrand, Kirsten E(202) . 225-5614
Gonzalez, Charles A. (202) 225-3236
Gordon, Bart (202) 225-4231
Green, Al (202) 225-7508
Green, Gene (202) 225-1688
Grijalva, Raúl M. (202) 225-2435
Gutierrez, Luis V. (202) 225-8203
H
Hall, John J. (202) 225-5441
Hare, Phil (202) 225-5905
Harman, Jane (202) 225-8220
Hastings, Alcee L. (202) 225-1313
Herseth Sandlin, Stephanie (202) 225-2801
Higgins, Brian (202) 225-3306
Hill, Baron P. (202) 225-5315
Hinchey, Maurice D. (202) 225-6335
Hinojosa, Rubén (202) 225-2531
Hirono, Mazie K. (202) 225-4906
Hodes, Paul W. (202) 225-5206
Holden, Tim (202) 225-5546
Holt, Rush D. (202) 225-5801
Honda, Michael M. (202) 225-2631
Hooley, Darlene (202) 225-5711
Hoyer, Steny H. (202) 225-4131
I
Inslee, Jay (202) 225-6311
Israel, Steve (202) 225-3335
J
Jackson, Jesse L. Jr. (202) 225-0773
Jackson-Lee, Sheila (202) 225-3816
Jefferson, William J. (202) 225-6636
Johnson, Eddie Bernice (202) 225-8885
Johnson, Henry C. "Hank" Jr. (202) 225-1605
Jones, Stephanie Tubbs (202) 225-7032
K
Kagen, Steve (202) 225-5665
Kanjorski, Paul E. (202) 225-6511
Kaptur, Marcy (202) 225-4146
Kennedy, Patrick J. (202) 225-4911
Kildee, Dale E. (202) 225-3611
Kilpatrick, Carolyn C. (202) 225-2261
Kind, Ron (202) 225-5506
Klein, Ron (202) 225-3026
Kucinich, Dennis J. (202) 225-5871
L
Lampson, Nick (202) 225-5951
Langevin, James R. (202) 225-2735
Lantos, Tom (202) 225-3531
Larsen, Rick (202) 225-2605
Larson, John B. (202) 225-2265
Lee, Barbara (202) 225-2661
Levin, Sander M. (202) 225-4961
Lewis, John (202) 225-3801
Lipinski, Daniel (202) 225-5701
Loebsack, David (202) 225-6576
Lofgren, Zoe (202) 225-3072
Lowey, Nita M. (202) 225-6506
Lynch, Stephen F. (202) 225-8273
M
McCarthy, Carolyn (202) 225-5516
McCollum, Betty (202) 225-6631
McDermott, Jim (202) 225-3106
McGovern, James P. (202) 225-6101
McIntyre, Mike (202) 225-2731
McNerney, Jerry (202) 225-1947
McNulty, Michael R. (202) 225-5076
Mahoney, Tim (202) 225-5792
Maloney, Carolyn B. (202) 225-7944
Markey, Edward J. (202) 225-2836
Marshall, Jim (202) 225-6531
Matheson, Jim (202) 225-3011
Matsui, Doris O. (202) 225-7163
Meek, Kendrick B. (202) 225-4506
Meeks, Gregory W. (202) 225-3461
Melancon, Charlie (202) 225-4031
Michaud, Michael H. (202) 225-6306
Miller, Brad (202) 225-3032
Miller, George (202) 225-2095
Mitchell, Harry E. (202) 225-2190
Mollohan, Alan B. (202) 225-4172
Moore, Dennis (202) 225-2865
Moore, Gwen (202) 225-4572
Moran, James P. (202) 225-4376
Murphy, Christopher S. (202) 225-4476
Murphy, Patrick J. (202) 225-4276
Murtha, John P. (202) 225-2065
N
Nadler, Jerrold (202) 225-5635
Napolitano, Grace F. (202) 225-5256
Neal, Richard E. (202) 225-5601
O
Oberstar, James L. (202) 225-6211
Obey, David R. (202) 225-3365
Olver, John W. (202) 225-5335
Ortiz, Solomon P. (202) 225-7742
P
Pallone, Frank Jr. (202) 225-4671
Pascrell, Bill Jr. (202) 225-5751
Pastor, Ed (202) 225-4065
Payne, Donald M. (202) 225-3436
Pelosi, Nancy (202) 225-4965
Perlmutter, Ed (202) 225-2645
Peterson, Collin C. (202) 225-2165
Pomeroy, Earl (202) 225-2611
Price, David E. (202) 225-1784
R
Rahall, Nick J. II (202) 225-3452
Rangel, Charles B. (202) 225-4365
Reyes, Silvestre (202) 225-4831
Richardson, Laura (202) 225-7924
Rodriguez, Ciro D. (202) 225-4511
Ross, Mike (202) 225-3772
Rothman, Steven R. (202) 225-5061
Roybal-Allard, Lucille (202) 225-1766
Ruppersberger, C. A. Dutch (202) 225-3061
Rush, Bobby L. (202) 225-4372
Ryan, Tim (202) 225-5261
S
Salazar, John T. (202) 225-4761
Sánchez, Linda T. (202) 225-6676
Sanchez, Loretta (202) 225-2965
Sarbanes, John P. (202) 225-4016
Schakowsky, Janice D. (202) 225-2111
Schiff, Adam B. (202) 225-4176
Schwartz, Allyson Y. (202) 225-6111
Scott, David (202) 225-2939
Scott, Robert C. ``Bobby'' (202) 225-8351
Serrano, José E. (202) 225-4361
Sestak, Joe (202) 225-2011
Shea-Porter, Carol (202) 225-5456
Sherman, Brad (202) 225-5911
Shuler, Heath (202) 225-6401
Sires, Albio (202) 225-7919 1024
Skelton, Ike (202) 225-2876
Slaughter, Louise McIntosh (202) 225-3615
Smith, Adam (202) 225-8901
Snyder, Vic (202) 225-2506
Solis, Hilda L. (202) 225-5464
Space, Zachary T. (202) 225-6265
Spratt, John M. Jr. (202) 225-5501
Stark, Fortney Pete (202) 225-5065
Stupak, Bart (202) 225-4735
Sutton, Betty (202) 225-3401
T
Tanner, John S. (202) 225-4714
Tauscher, Ellen O. (202) 225-1880
Taylor, Gene (202) 225-5772
Thompson, Bennie G. (202) 225-5876
Thompson, Mike (202) 225-3311
Tierney, John F. (202) 225-8020
Towns, Edolphus (202) 225-5936
U
Udall, Mark (202) 225-2161
Udall, Tom (202) 225-6190
V
Van Hollen, Chris (202) 225-5341
Velázquez, Nydia M. (202) 225-2361
Visclosky, Peter J. (202) 225-2461
W
Walz, Timothy J. (202) 225-2472
Wasserman Schultz, Debbie (202) 225-7931
Waters, Maxine (202) 225-2201
Watson, Diane E. (202) 225-7084
Watt, Melvin L. (202) 225-1510
Waxman, Henry A. (202) 225-3976
Weiner, Anthony D. (202) 225-6616
Welch, Peter (202) 225-4115
Wexler, Robert (202) 225-3001
Wilson, Charles A. (202) 225-5705
Woolsey, Lynn C. (202) 225-5161
Wu, David (202) 225-0855
Wynn, Albert Russell (202) 225-8699
Y
Yarmuth, John A. (202) 225-5401
A reminder. Please keep sending in those top comment nominations to:
topcomments[at]gmail[dot]com
II. Tonight's Top Comments
Via llbear:
In a rather unfortunate diary denegrating American troops, clonecone explains why the diarist is, well, full of crap.
In the same diary, Kifaru1 speaks for military spouses
Via khereva:
In Kagro X's story questioning the Democrat's tactics on filibusters, user fat old man skewers Congressional cowardice.
Via citizenx:
IndyScott has a great list of things that our Senate didn't bother to condemn.
Via Lucky Ducky:
Agathena wrote this comment, which came in response to a question asking why Sen. Reid let the MoveOn ad resolution come up for a vote.
Top Mojo (thanks BeninSC, you rule!)
Top Mojo - excluding search-identifiable tip jars, first diary comments and C&J comments (top 30 of each plus ties):
1 Why did Reid allow a vote in the first place? by Geekesque - 120
2 Consultants said this to him... by Dump Terry McAuliffe - 116
3 Money isn't everything in politics by Dallasdoc - 107
4 Dodd deserves huge credit for his work on this. by Geekesque - 102
5 Yes, because our nuts aren't crushed enough. by Bill in Portland Maine - 93
6 my reply by Michael Schiavo - 84
7 Resolved... by djtyg - 84
8 Dude -- by bonddad - 74
9 Count me out. by HollywoodOz - 73
10 They fucked us over. by Bill in Portland Maine - 71
11 He voted against it, but I prefer the by Geekesque - 69
12 Exactly - this resolution should have disappeared by Marinesquire - 68
13 I signed the petition, made a contribution by jhutson - 66
14 Yesterday at the Bronx Zoo by Eddie C - 65
15 Is it insane by kestrel9000 - 62
16 I am a MOVEON Member by KnotIookin - 60
17 RE: Why is it by Rep Barbara Lee - 59
18 Why did Reid let that damn thing by Geekesque - 58
19 Mean spirited and nasty by Dburn - 56
20 Count me ***in*** on Mike's plan by The Lighthouse Keeper - 56
21 Your Less-Than-Daily BabyKos by John Campanelli - 55
22 I Personally Know 2 Old GOP Conversions by Empower Ink - 54
23 no need to to start picking each other off. by jstott1701 - 53
24 Thanks for the smile by rf7777 - 50
25 Me you! you made my day!!! Recommend! by arogue7 - 50
26 post humpday by khereva - 50
27 Oh for god sake by anastasia p - 49
28 asdf by brownsox - 48
29 True John Cornyn story by Whiskey Sam - 48
30 Thank you for missing the point of the diary by Geekesque - 48
Top Mojo - everything included:
1 I love Dick Durbin and Barbara Boxer! by beachmom - 307
2 Tips to keep our eyes on the ball by Geekesque - 282
3 Tips for MoveOn by TomP - 263
4 I seriously didn't expect by wmtriallawyer - 221
5 tips, flames comments by testvet6778 - 210
6 Tip jar by truong son traveler - 167
7 This is a worthy venture. Check it out! by markthshark - 167
8 Habeas Corpus Restoration Act by ttagaris - 158
9 Force them to filibuster by IntertubeGuy - 127
10 Why did Reid allow a vote in the first place? by Geekesque - 120
11 Thank you for your by DMiller - 116
12 Consultants said this to him... by Dump Terry McAuliffe - 116
13 Money isn't everything in politics by Dallasdoc - 107
14 there should be a resolution by clammyc - 105
15 Dodd deserves huge credit for his work on this. by Geekesque - 102
16 dammit by Turkana - 101
17 Yes, because our nuts aren't crushed enough. by Bill in Portland Maine - 93
18 my reply by Michael Schiavo - 84
19 Resolved... by djtyg - 84
20 Tip by Carnacki - 77
21 Dude -- by bonddad - 74
22 Count me out. by HollywoodOz - 73
23 They fucked us over. by Bill in Portland Maine - 71
24 Thor s Day Lightning Hoorahs!!! by Predictor - 70
25 He voted against it, but I prefer the by Geekesque - 69
26 Exactly - this resolution should have disappeared by Marinesquire - 68
27 I signed the petition, made a contribution by jhutson - 66
28 Yesterday at the Bronx Zoo by Eddie C - 65
29 Well, OK, I'll start by New Deal democrat - 65
30 Tip jar by truong son traveler - 64