Daily Kos

Harper's Garret Keizer calls for a Nov. 6 General Strike

Sun Sep 23, 2007 at 11:21:30 AM PDT

In Harper's October issue Garret Keizer writes Specific Suggestion: General Strike.  He looks the reality that the system is broken straight in the eye and, like me, sees impeachment as the solution.  He calls for "not working until the president and the shadow president resign or [are] impeached."

Think it won't work?  Follow me down to see how he addresses the loss of hope.

Of all the various depredations of the Bush regime, none has been so thorough as its plundering of hope. Iraq will recover sooner. What was supposed to have been the crux of our foreign policy-a shock-and-awe tutorial on the utter futility of any opposition to the whims of American power-has achieved its greatest and perhaps its only lasting success in the American soul. You will want to cite the exceptions, the lunch-hour protests against the war, the dinner-party ejaculations of dissent, though you might also want to ask what substantive difference they bear to grousing about the weather or even to raging against the dying of the light-that is, to any ritualized complaint against forces universally acknowledged as unalterable. Bush is no longer the name of a president so much as the abbreviation of a proverb, something between Murphy's Law and tomorrow's fatal inducement to drink and be merry today.

If someone were to suggest, for example, that we begin a general strike on Election Day, November 6, 2007, for the sole purpose of removing this regime from power, how readily and with what well-practiced assurance would you find yourself producing the words "It won't do any good"? Plausible and even courageous in the mouth of a patient who knows he's going to die, the sentiment fits equally well in the heart of a citizen-ry that believes it is already dead.


Read the rest.
 And please pass his article on to everyone you know.  Let's make this happen.

Crossposted at Docudharma.

Tags: impeachment (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 40 comments

  •  I was in Paris in 1968 for la greve generale (5+ / 0-)

    It was fantastique! Le peuple on strike against themselves!

    I would certainly take the day - or a week - off without pay. Just for the hell of it.

    You kids behave or I'm turning this universe around RIGHT NOW! - god

    by Clem Yeobright on Sun Sep 23, 2007 at 11:23:53 AM PDT

  •  I hate to say this... (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Clem Yeobright

    ... but it sounds like an useless gesture.  There hasn't been the steady, organic build-up of popular anger and protest that would create the conditions for a successful national general strike.  

    Maybe some targeted boycotts of defense companies with consumer arms, like GE, could accomplish more, especially if they had mass-movement support from groups like MoveOn.  But short of starting with a base of millions of potential supporters, I don't know how to galvanize public action at this point.

    Hanoi didn't break John McCain, but Washington did.

    by Dallasdoc on Sun Sep 23, 2007 at 11:28:35 AM PDT

    •  Uhm (4+ / 0-)

      the point isn't to suggest it will be successful.

      It's a masterful, unmissable piece of writing, if nothing else.

      Everyone should go read it.

    •  my mother asked me the other night why (2+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      Dallasdoc, keikekaze, Empower Ink

      My mother, a Massachusetts liberal who had the whole family out campaigning for McGovern, asked me why I am still working for impeachment when "it'll never happen, they'll never do it."  I told her that it is the most important thing, possibly the only thing, that can be done to turn this country around and reverse the damage of a rogue administration.  I also told her that once you accept that things will not happen and that you cannot effect change, then you have already lost; you must never lose sight of and you must never allow those you elect into office to lose sight of the fact that they are accountable.  This administration clearly does not see itself as accountable.  My question is what does this say about the elected Democrats who do not hold it accountable?

      •  What this says about elected Dems... (2+ / 0-)

        Recommended by:
        clyde, conchita

        ... is that they are opportunists or collaborators.  Perhaps we cannot expect more:  politicians have ever been craven creatures, quick to turn in flight and unencumbered by basic honesty or decency.

        I agree that we have to make Democratic politicians more afraid of us than they are of Republicans.  It's the only way we'll get better behavior.  The question is which tactics are most likely to achieve this result.  

        A continuing fusillade of angry communications will form a foundation of pressure, but won't change anything on its own.  Pushing more progressives into the Democratic caucus will help shift opinion within the party and make it easier for leaders to move things our way.  Focusing our energy on public campaign financing would do a lot to create a cleaner electoral system, one more responsive to public opinion.  Judicious primarying of conservatives and sell-outs will help a lot:  we need several more Liebermans, preferable ones who won't squeak back into office regardless.  And we need to get in the faces of our current and would-be leaders, letting them know in no uncertain terms that we won't be sold a pack of bullshit anymore.

        Steny Hoyer is mad at the base.  That's not good enough.  He needs to be infuriated at the base for pushing him out of the leadership.  

        Hanoi didn't break John McCain, but Washington did.

        by Dallasdoc on Sun Sep 23, 2007 at 11:47:35 AM PDT

        [ Parent ]

      •  A thousand recs for that comment. (2+ / 0-)

        Recommended by:
        conchita, Empower Ink

        I also told her that once you accept that things will not happen and that you cannot effect change, then you have already lost.

        Evil works by causing people to accept the unacceptable.

        "Do not forget that every people deserves the regime it is willing to endure." -- White Rose letter no. 1

        by keikekaze on Sun Sep 23, 2007 at 12:50:57 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

    •  hey, we can dream, can't we? (0+ / 0-)

      I'm in agreement that this sort of thing is the ONLY way to bring about change anymore in this country.  Elections won't.  

      Do I think it will really ever happen?  

      Uh ........

      No.  I don't think Americans have it in them.  That's the sad, pathetic truth.

      I think the vast majority of Americans would get right on those trains, if you know what I'm saying, without a peep ...

  •  and get justifiably fired? err, I don't think so! (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Clem Yeobright

    "not working until the president and the shadow president resign or [are] impeached."

    Cats, err, Pooties! for Obama "The president doesn't have a magic wand." The President

    by PhillyGal on Sun Sep 23, 2007 at 11:30:46 AM PDT

  •  Doubt It Could Work Here (0+ / 0-)

    Yes, it's pessimism before the first action has been taken. But in order to base the success of a general strike, ask how successful citizens have been with the "gas-out" day?

    With so many people being one paycheck from homelessness, would they be willing to stay out of work?

    I suspect that you'd probably find more people in the rural conservative areas who would go out than you would in the more liberal, progressive and cut-throat-businesswise cities of New York, Boston and San Francisco.

    •  please read the whole piece (0+ / 0-)

      he acknowledges your concerns and has suggestions.  i probably should have included more quotes in the diary, but just don't have time.  i thought this was so well written and made so much sense that i jsut wanted to get it out there.  please go back and read what he has to say and pass it on.

      •  I Did Read It ~ It's Stirring . . . (0+ / 0-)

        But it's the problem of the tree falling in the forest.

        Sadly, this country hasn't had its Archduke Ferdinand moment. We taste the unease; we feel the sands of our democracy slipping away; we see the despair all around us. But whatever that precipitous moment -- the blue touch paper, the igniting fire -- hasn't happened yet for the masses to rise up in collective fury.

        Or worse, it did happen on 9-11 and revealed itself to be little more than a whimper, a distraction from the important things like American Idol, The Sopranos or Survivor.

        •  you can make it happen (0+ / 0-)

          or you can write about it on the internet.  i'm doing all i can to make it happen and write when time allows.  there are people out there working on this.  like keizer, we are not giving up.

        •  It may be you misunderstand 'the AF moment' (1+ / 0-)

          Recommended by:
          conchita

          An 'Archduke Ferdinand moment' (as defined by Suzanne Nozel and propagaged by Kevin Drum here) is noteworthy for its absurdity.

          The logic of August 1914 is the logic of Blackwater 2007: innocent Iraqis must die on their own streets, because if we tell them how to protect themselves from us it will allow the 'evil-doers' to protect themselves from us ...

          It is the logic of the Beirut Barracks explosion of 1983, and it is an inexorable logic that will compel our rapid withdrawal (Did I say 'cut and run'? Not I!) from Iraq.

          We did not plan our way in, and we will not plan our way out ... 5 will get you 10 we are under 50,000 by Jan 2009. Don't know how, just know that ...

          You kids behave or I'm turning this universe around RIGHT NOW! - god

          by Clem Yeobright on Sun Sep 23, 2007 at 12:03:04 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

  •  as gandhi would have (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    conchita

    don't call it a strike. too difficult a term, for many people. a national day of prayer and fasting ought to go down more easily...

  •  I love "Notebook" and was sad (2+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    conchita, StrangeAnimals

    when Lapham decided to write fewer of them. This essay is an awesome piece and I sent it to my e-mail list which is something I generally do not do because for most normal people, a little politics goes a long way.

    I am a member of a modest art/ music/ etc. group called the green and bold cooperative. we are in, so to speak, and plan on doing events in new york city and charleston sc on nov. 7 2007.

    if a movement swells to indeed settle on a better day to begin, we will certainly get behind that.

    i hope the general strike idea and a link to the haper's piece will be diaried every day in as many locales as possible in the coming weeks and months.

    all the best!
    randy  

  •  Work stoppage is fine, but try working it the (4+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    conchita, yourhost, chigh, parakinesis

    other way. Let's have a consumption stoppage. And not the kind where you don't buy gas on Monday but instead buy it on Sunday. I mean a long-term omnibus boycott. I mean a refusal to buy all the extras we Americas are so used to considering NEEDS.

    If you stop work, you may find it hard to eat. And you may be able to tough it out, but growing kids shouldn't have to. They need the nutrition. And working it the other way allows more selectivity in where the system is monkeywrenched. You can still buy food for your kids, but cancel your cable subscrption. Just do it. Cut the shit off. It's not worth anything anyway.

    And what else do we buy that we don't need? Cinema tickets? Concert tickets? CDs and DVDs and video games and all the rest? We are an overly amused culture anyway. Stop buying all that stuff.

    And what about clothes? Good lord, Americans buy a lot of clothes. Just stop. You have enough. And you have enough shoes too. You don't need another pair. Don't buy them. No more shoes, shirts, pants, and most certainly no more accessories. Just stop.

    Just stop buying all the crap that is peddled in the American market. And do it until George Bush is impeached. Every day, make a decision not to buy something that you would otherwise buy.

  •  Haper's Magazine (0+ / 0-)

    The voice of the working class.
    Now, If they were joined by Architectural Digest and Food & Wine, they might be on to something.

  •  I'm in (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    conchita

    Someonme has already been making a push for strike on Nov. 11th - but hell - I can sure avoid spending money or doing anything else but being in the way more than one day a month.

  •  "We don't have the votes" . . . (4+ / 0-)

    . . . is another one of those sentiments that comes straight from the mouths of the living dead.

    Thanks for this diary, conchita.

    "Do not forget that every people deserves the regime it is willing to endure." -- White Rose letter no. 1

    by keikekaze on Sun Sep 23, 2007 at 12:39:45 PM PDT

  •  Thanks for this, conchita. (4+ / 0-)

    As ybruti so graciously mentioned above, I diaried on this several days ago, and in response I was made aware of a website built to expand on Mr. Keizer's idea:

    http://www.whystrike.blogspot.com

    In it is a very interesting interview with Mr. Keizer in which he expounds on his article. Consider checking it out!

Permalink | 40 comments