Daily Kos

Strategy For Obama: Let Michelle Debate Bill. Leave SC.

Wed Jan 23, 2008 at 09:31:48 PM PDT

Senator Obama, I love your campaign and what you stand for, but it's time - past time - to leave South Carolina or risk falling into the Clinton trap. The expectations game burned you in New Hampshire and now they're setting you up for Saturday. Read on for my argument why you should get out of South Carolina now, and should have already...

With Hillary gone, the message from the media and foolish pollsters is that South Carolina is yours to win in a blowout. You've done nothing to tamp down the ridiculous expectations that you will win by a double-digit margin. But we all know that is not going to happen. The Clintons will paint anything less as voters rejecting your attacks, and anything more as a race-driven response from African-American voters, ensuring a white "backlash" a few weeks later. Welcome to the world of Dick Morris politics, Senator Obama.

It's time to stop playing their games and go on your own offensive to play catch up where it really matters now: the Feb. 5 states. Your competition is Hillary - not Bill - and she's off getting a head start, leaving her husband behind - hiding behind him even - so he can bait and goad you into foolish fights that you can't win. You should be going right after her, Senator, sending a message that you're in this race to win. She's campaigning in post-SC states and you should be going there as well. You're not taking the state for granted by getting on a plane immediately and heading to California. You're showing that you refuse to let the Clintons dictate the campaign to you. And you're responding to reality: South Carolina just isn't going to be as important now as it was. The media and everyone else have already declared this race is going to Feb. 5 and beyond. South Carolina is already old news.

It's time to change the dynamics. Tell the voters of South Carolina that you're off to campaign in the states of Hillary's focus, to try and hold her accountable for the things she says about you, and that you're leaving them in the hands of a capable campaigner who can give Bill more of a fair fight: your wife, Michelle. Build her up as your South Carolina campaigner for the end of the week and let her play the lovable underdog to Bill's pit bull. While she's at it, maybe she can ask him why the Clinton health care strategy this time around is going to go any better than last time around? If Americans want universal health care, why should they keep sending the same cast of characters to the White House, playing the same political games, expecting different results? Everybody's got a health care plan. We're not voting for a plan; we're voting for a leader.

That's why it's time to speak to a broader audience. Everywhere you have been Senator, voters have responded to your inspirational message. You were far behind in Iowa and New Hampshire and South Carolina before voters there got a chance to know you. Now you claim 2 wins and a very close second in those 3 states. Fly to California, and back to Tennessee and Georgia where you can win through Memphis, Nashville and Atlanta. Do it now. And don't let Bill and Hillary knock you off your message. There's only one place she can beat you soundly - polls have proven this - and that's wherever you are not campaigning.

So long as you stay behind in an increasingly irrelevant South Carolina, and let Hillary speak to voters on her own, her big advantage will remain. You have 50-state money, a 50-state organization, and a 50-state message. Leave Michelle behind in South Carolina and let the spouses duke it out - a fairer fight for sure. Meanwhile, you take it to the candidate. And do it now. The Feb. 5 campaign will decide whether Hillary runs away with the nomination or is in a fight all the way to the end. The race now is won in California, Missouri, Tennessee and Georgia. It's a race that is passing you by, and can't wait for South Carolina to come to an end. We will hope the Palmetto State is yours - and could use some lowered expectations anyway. Meanwhile, the rest of America awaits you. Go get her.

Tags: barack obama (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 34 comments

  •  Where's the nearest SC Airport? (5+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    DrKate, nicejoest, Puffin, kyril, ggottlie

    Sticking around and fighting with Bill is just what the Clinton team wants him to do. Time to change the story!

  •  Get to DC....NOW (20+ / 0-)

    Stand with Sen Dodd. The free press would be huge. Tell the SC voters I'll be back on Friday!

  •  i think you've got something here (7+ / 0-)

    have senator obama come back on friday night for a big rally and local tv news interviews...

    have michelle challenge bill to a debate!

  •  Hey, you're pretty smart. (2+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    DrMicro, kyril

    Did you go to college or something?

    ::cheers and applause::

  •  she would be such an underdog (4+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Puffin, kyril, ggottlie, flatoutspent

    that she would kick his ass.....

    plus i'd luv for her to say to bill, "you know president clinton i dont go around trashing your wife i talk about the great things mny husband has to offer. how come u spend all your time trashing my husband. as a former president  i think you should be upholding the honor and dignity of the office of president.  I mean
    I know thats not always been easy for you, but please."

  •  I agree with your overall point.... (3+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    DonBinTN, Puffin, kyril

    Bill Clinton plays in the mud and if Obama sits around SC fighting with him it really does not help him at all.  I like the idea pointed above of having him return on Friday night with a huge rally.  It is too late now though so I am really hoping he does have a really big win Saturday.  This will bring him a lot of coverage across the country and put him on fire before the Feb 5th vote.  

    I really think though that Hillary can be stopped.  With this win in SC - if it is over 10 points - can help Obama sell himself in NY and CA.  

    And I really hope the people start seeing what bullies the Clintons are.  And I would like to see Obama continue to call them out on their lies.  And hits like the Wal-Mart one are exactly what we need.

    Next time I'd like to see him bring up the scandals of the Clinton years - "When I'm President the Lincoln bedroom won't be a hotel for those that give me the most money."

    •  SC is becoming a lose-lose (1+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      kyril

      There is no way he wins by that much imo. But the bigger point is: I can't believe the Obama team is letting such high expectations fly around unchallenged.

      •  right (1+ / 0-)

        Recommended by:
        kyril

        he should have learned from SC

        and the Clintons love these high expectations for Obama because now even if he wins by 5 they can play their usual distortions and say "we cut into his numbers"

        Obama's people should play the Nevada Clinton game - if I loose it is because of x and y - he should talk about Clinton's dirty tricks and what not

        but I do not agree SC is lose - lose because it will be a great PR move if he does win by 10-15 points - that would really shake up things going into Feb 5th

        •  I hope you are right!! (3+ / 0-)

          Recommended by:
          highacidity, kyril, bottsimons

          He's got to find a way to win CA...

          •  i am really nervous about CA (3+ / 0-)

            Recommended by:
            highacidity, Cwhitesox1917, kyril

            I'm living in NY and just hope we can keep Hillary limited here to perhaps 10 - 15 points, but CA needs to be at least very close in delegate counts to give Obama a chance in the overall delegate count.  It would be great for him to win it, but it is highly unlikely.

            I really am waiting to see Obama's strategy after SC.  I don't know what he's going to do.  Where will he put his focus?  I would say go for a few days in CA and spend the rest of the times in places besides NY and CA.  Hope to counterbalance her that way.

            I swear if Obama wins this damn nomination I'll follow him as if he were a messiah in the general.  He has had everything against him from day one and just what he has done so far is amazing.

  •  Bad idea. (0+ / 0-)

    At least the debate. Michelle should certainly stay above the fray - putting her up against such a formidable political legend is quite unfair to her, nevermind the pressure.

    He should definitely not stick around SC for too long. Hopefully the polls are going in his direction and he can safely exit.

  •  The media narrative will be different if he wins (2+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    ptmflbcs, Free Spirit

    by a substantial margin.

    There are already significant signs of Clinton Fatigue among the punditry.  She has just about exhausted her earned media from her wins in New Hampshire and Iowa and the media will be inclined to play up the too-close-to-call narrative heading into Super Tuesday.  Storylines that the media feels ambivalent about today (Barack versus Bill) could easily become favorables.

    Some combination of the following is possible/probable if undecideds break away from Clinton:

    1. Obama beats Hillary by 15+ points.
    1. Edwards beats Hillary among white voters.
    1. Edwards beats Hillary, period.
    1. Obama comes within 10 points of Hillary among white voters.

    Any of these outcomes IMO would produce a big bounce.  Obama needs to be on the ground to facilitate that.  The media will catch up.

    fivethirtyeight.com: electoral projections done right.

    by poblano on Wed Jan 23, 2008 at 10:04:39 PM PDT

    •  Don't you think a 15-point win (0+ / 0-)

      is expecting too much, and is exactly what the Clintons want everyone to expect?

      •  I think they're getting in your heads (2+ / 0-)

        Recommended by:
        nevadadem, ptmflbcs

        On paper, writing off a big win sounds easy.  In practice, after a victory speech and a one-sided night of television coverage (there isn't even a GOP primary to compete with this time), I don't think it can be managed away so easily.  Part of this, as I suggested above, is because my sense is that the media pendulum is already liable to shift back toward Obama and just needs a good excuse to do so.

        fivethirtyeight.com: electoral projections done right.

        by poblano on Wed Jan 23, 2008 at 10:21:15 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

    •  I agree... (1+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      ptmflbcs

      SC can become a huge PR move for Obama.  If he does in fact beat Hillary by 15 plus I can't imagine that not shaking EVERYTHING up.  People will wake up on Sunday morning to newspapers acting like Obama is a messianic figure going into Feb 5th.  

      Just getting close with the woman and whites will put all the Clinton racist crap out the window and possible bring back that Iowa universal race neutral Obama.

      I am really scared to see the numbers on Saturday.  I do not trust polls since NH, but I did read one that had Obama up by 12.  That is a very hopeful sign.  

      We can still do it!  We can still beat her!  Just keep up the hope.

  •  Why is SC irrelevant? (3+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    ptmflbcs, lirtydies, DrMicro

    an increasingly irrelevant South Carolina

    Why is SC irrelevant?

    •  because... (0+ / 0-)

      pundits and the media and the campaigns are already declaring this a Feb. 5 election. Even if he wins in a blowout, they will all declare that it was expected, because of African-American turnout. The only thing that can happen of note, is for Hillary to beat expectations, something that is becoming increasingly easily done.

      •  I think Hillary is more likely to... (0+ / 0-)

        ...beat expectations if Obama leaves the state to go campaign elsewhere. It will make him look reactive...following, not leading.

        Leaving to go support Dodd, that would be a different matter. I think that would play well with the SC Dems.

    •  Why is Edwards irrelevant? (1+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      Potus2020

      He is campaigning in SC and calling for all to support Dodd ...

      I agree Obama with diarist in that he can afford to be somewhere else.

      But the Obama has a jet ticket to where ever he wants to go, I know this because i am a donor .... lol. He can hop around and go to wherever he wants.

      He still has time to do both.

      Edwards stands to make great gains against hillary in SC, which puts him firmly in the position of this being a 3 person race again.

      Obama can't simply ignore SC completely, John is still a worthy opponent. Whom I also support.

  •  I'm tired of being told that S.C., because of (7+ / 0-)

    its large Black voting base is irrelevant. It's condescending, rude, and disrespectful.

  •  Unless... (3+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    ptmflbcs, Potus2020, DrMicro

    by a confluence of events, Edwards ends up ahead of Clinton.  I think that your advice would be on point, except for the fact that this outcome seems remotely possible.  

    Obama campaigning in SC has the potential to whittle away Clinton's support, thus leaving an opening for Edwards.

    If Edwards were to beat Clinton, I think that we could actually see a momentum shift, as it wouldn't be possible for Clinton to simply chalk up her loss to "black voters."  

  •  I agree. He needs to start campaigning elsewhere (0+ / 0-)

    Maybe, he could start each day in South Carolina, but he could certainly squeeze in Georgia on the same day, without losing that much travel time. Maybe, an appearance or two in Tennessee, while he's in the neighborhood. From there, he could make a splash with an appearance in Little Rock. Maybe, that would be a waste, but it would get noticed.

    Alternatively, he could get out of the South entirely, and hit New York/NJ/CT for a couple of days. Then go west.

    I think there's time for that, though. Were I running the campaign, I'd stay in the South. A couple of appearances in southern Georgia will get him on the news in some Florida markets, too. While Hillary is elsewhere, he can set the stage for a win in Georgia.

    There's a diary supposing that the NY Times endorsement is expected this weekend. He might want to be in New York on Sunday to play that up, just in case he gets it. Otherwise, he can go down to Wilmington, and then up to Newark, NJ -- before jetting out to LA Sunday night, for next week's debate. He needs a little rest, so he can be sharper and quicker in the debate there, than he was in SC.

    Coming Soon -- to an Internet connection near you: Armisticeproject.org

    by FischFry on Wed Jan 23, 2008 at 10:55:43 PM PDT

Permalink | 34 comments