Skip to main content

From the New York Blade:

The Connecticut Supreme Court today ruled that denying marriage rights to same-sex couples is unconstitutional.

...

"Interpreting our state constitutional provisions in accordance with firmly established equal protection principles leads inevitably to the conclusion that gay persons are entitled to marry the otherwise qualified same sex partner of their choice," the ruling says.

...

"The guarantee of equal protection under the law, and our obligation to uphold that command, forbids us from doing so. In accordance with these state constitutional requirements, same sex couples cannot be denied the freedom to marry."

Eight same-sex couples sued, claiming their constitutional rights to equal protection and due process were violated when they were denied marriage licenses.

Three states down, 47 to go.

More from the decision below:

The case is Kerrigan v. Commissioner of Public Health.  I'm skipping the procedural history, standards of review, and other legalese.  All emphasis is mine.

We conclude that, in light of the history of pernicious discrimination faced by gay men and lesbians, and because the institution of marriage carries with it a status and significance that the newly created classification of civil unions does not embody, the segregation of heterosexual and homosexual couples into separate institutions constitutes a cognizable harm. We also conclude that (1) our state scheme discriminates on the basis of sexual orientation, (2) for the same reasons that classifications predicated on gender are considered quasi-suspect for purposes of the equal protection provisions of the United States constitution, sexual orientation constitutes a quasi-suspect classification for purposes of the equal  protection provisions of the state constitution, and, therefore, our statutes discriminating against gay persons are subject to heightened or intermediate judicial scrutiny, and (3) the state has failed to provide sufficient justification for excluding same sex couples from the institution of marriage.

Especially in light of the long and undisputed history of invidious discrimination that gay persons have suffered; see part V A of this opinion; we cannot discount the plaintiffs’ assertion that the legislature, in establishing a statutory scheme consigning same sex couples to civil unions, has relegated them to an inferior status,
in essence, declaring them to be unworthy of the institution of marriage
. In other words,

‘‘[b]y excluding samesex couples from civil marriage, the [s]tate declares that it is legitimate to differentiate between their commitments and the commitments of heterosexual couples.  Ultimately, the message is that what same-sex couples have is not as important or as significant as ‘real’ marriage, that such lesser relationships cannot have the name of marriage.’’

Although the legislature has determined that same sex couples are entitled to ‘‘all the same benefits, protections and responsibilities . . . [that] are granted to spouses in a marriage’’; General Statutes § 46b-38nn; the legislature nonetheless created an entirely separate and distinct legal entity for same sex couples even though it readily could have made those same rights available to same sex couples by permitting them to marry. In view of the exalted status of marriage in our society, it is hardly surprising that civil unions are perceived to be inferior to marriage. We therefore agree with the plaintiffs that ‘‘[m]aintaining a second-class citizen status for same-sex couples by excluding them from the institution of civil marriage is the constitutional infirmity at issue.’

Although marriage and civil unions do embody the same legal rights under our law, they are by no means ‘‘equal.’’

Gay persons have been subjected to and stigmatized by a long
history of purposeful and invidious discrimination that continues to manifest itself in society. The characteristic that defines the members of this group—attraction to persons of the same sex—bears no logical relationship to their ability to perform in society, either in
familial relations or otherwise as productive citizens.  Because sexual orientation is such an essential component of personhood, even if there is some possibility that a person’s sexual preference can be altered, it
would be wholly unacceptable for the state to require anyone to do so. Gay persons also represent a distinct minority of the population. It is true, of course, that gay persons recently have made significant advances
in obtaining equal treatment under the law. Nonetheless, we conclude that, as a minority group that continues to suffer the enduring effects of centuries of legally sanctioned discrimination, laws singling them out for disparate treatment are subject to heightened judicial scrutiny to ensure that those laws are not the product of such historical prejudice and stereotyping.

Okay, I'm about a third of the way through the case, but I have to take a break to do some actual work.  I'll try to make my way through the rest of the case as soon as I can.

Originally posted to Kaili Joy Gray on Fri Oct 10, 2008 at 08:49 AM PDT.

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

skybluewater, jaydfwtx, Kimberley, wozzle, gpclay, sipples, Alma, tmo, dwellscho, JR, Glenn in NYC, Bill in Portland Maine, Cowalker, Ray Radlein, Phoenix Woman, taylormattd, hester, pucknomad, ogre, Adam B, Oregon Bear, klugerEsel5, Doctor RJ, finocchio68, 2pt5cats, Mountain Don, Nina Katarina, Nancy in Berkeley, Rolfyboy6, gaspare, TrueBlueMajority, Unstable Isotope, HarlanNY, tiponeill, mem from somerville, MeanBoneII, Bob Love, newjeffct, scrape, tnichlsn, bosdcla14, dengre, annalivia, littlesky, scrutinizer, Hummingbird, Victor, LuvSet, Charles CurtisStanley, ThatTallGuy, cookiesandmilk, KateG, John Campanelli, celdd, eeff, DemDachshund, osterizer, freelunch, Schtu, HarlemUSA, blogswarm, theran, SallyCat, Joe B, exNYinTX, Arthur Dent, silence, Vitarai, deaniac83, strengthANDwisdom, sardonyx, alou73, Scott in NAZ, RumsfeldResign, jackspace, dmooney, RCK, parker parrot, Wee Mama, nyceve, bhf, Loquatrix, peace voter, KMc, jonah in nyc, fishhead, Scoopster, boilerman10, mkfarkus, roses, allysonsta, javelina, peraspera, Larry Bailey, L0kI, juslikagrzly, exconservative, nuket, internationaljock, jpadgett, navajo, jhklawyer, jted, lirtydies, CocoaLove, celticshel, OldYellerDog, wader, revsue, lulusbackintown, SneakySnu, Explodingkitchen, mayan, hopesprings, danthrax, oldjohnbrown, Dallasdoc, Dr Colossus, Chicago Lulu, grannyhelen, kdrivel, LordMike, TiaRachel, exiledfromTN, pdl ithaca, GN1927, ohiolibrarian, noveocanes, arielle, welshvalleymaid, lulu57, pdxRita, mungley, WisVoter, tomjones, sfluke, Marianne Benz, ScienceMom, mdsiamese, homogenius, vacantlook, califdweller, Ioo, oortdust, Big Tex, luvmovies2000, davidincleveland, Slgalt, mrmango, ExStr8, Tarindel, radarlady, pattyp, deBOraaah, christineNYC, Skaje, IntotheAbyss, bellevie, freakofsociety, m16eib, Othniel, baccaruda, LisaZ, wuweitim, Chinton, indycam, tolerant, PBen, DocGonzo, craigkg, terrypinder, ChemBob, krsbar, Dobber, boofdah, eru, goldrick, cfk, Viceroy, Pam from Calif, uato carabau, Inland, jcitybone, QuickSilver, blue jersey mom, Yamara, Isara, AnotherMassachusettsLiberal, wiscmass, serrano, Rogneid, Hannibal, Ekaterin, jct, Dania Audax, grada3784, begone, lgmcp, martini, third Party please, Shirl In Idaho, juliewolf, twoducks, tarheelblue, GeoGrl, PatsBard, SFJen, keeplaughing, Clytemnestra, Rippe, edwardssl, BlueInARedState, Themistoclea, Be The Change, Still Thinking, euterpe, Samwoman, Audri, fou, sailmaker, hideinplainsight, blueoasis, Eloise, triv33, tecampbell, atrexler, twigg, cRedd, PomperaFirpa, bubbanomics, dedmonds, nilocjin, Bob Sackamento, JVolvo, NearlyNormal, CTLiberal, bleeding heart, MarciaJ720, MBNYC, ShowMe Indie, Turbonerd, SingerInTheChoir, DemocraticLuntz, fezzik, rsie, zhimbo, JuztMe, Jbearlaw, HRs Kevin, RantNRaven, beatrix, ethanthej, Slatefish, Picot verde, anabelle, Jiffylush, coolsub, blueintheface, slksfca, illusionmajik, Pandoras Box, Batbird, AmericanRiverCanyon, One Pissed Off Liberal, pgm 01, anotherdemocrat, Cronesense, Fredly, Mom to Miss M, Loudoun County Dem, jsyaruss, PhantomFly, Kaity, ColoTim, gloriana, moosely2006, Stwriley, DvCM, LisaR, la urracca, kath25, david mizner, Cofcos, flumptytail, NCDem Amy, SJLeonidas, Jimdotz, terabytes, Calvin Jones and the 13th Apostle, sfbob, ballerina X, St Louis Woman, davehouck, Strabo, jayden, dhaemeon, st minutia, akdude6016, vbdietz, Killer of Sacred Cows, Newzie, jnhobbs, Moderation, gchaucer2, SBE, Rumarhazzit, Chico David RN, Got a Grip, electric meatball, Puffin, JML9999, mrbubs, Captain Nimrod, rf7777, keikekaze, cloudbustingkid, sable, Predictor, gizmo59, Dem in the heart of Texas, martydd, condorcet, APinMI, wayoutinthestix, califdem, scooter in brooklyn, Liberal Pride, filby, John Barleycorn, Pragmaticus, lineatus, Pegasus, Its any one guess, beltane, LucyMO, MrJayTee, TH Seed, Jake Williams, Nick Blas, Populista, Punditcrat, lettuce kucinich, mofembot, ClapClapSnap, the new, J V Calin, clew74, bubbalie 517, jarhead5536, auctor ignotus, Uncle Bob, BYw, psilocynic, dont think, ErinW43, Ellinorianne, Simply Agrestic, watercarrier4diogenes, Robinswing, scrubjay, mamamarti, Sarah Ann, oldliberal, ryangoesboom, multilee, Rhysling, imgstacke, Mr Tentacle, DontTaseMeBro, Texanomaly, snackdoodle, not a cent, juca, Discipline28, ManahManah, happy in MA, eroded47095, fearisthemindkiller, Dopeman, STephen Trask in KY, banjolele, DemocraticOz, fatbeagle, Stranded Wind, CarrieNYC, Partisan Progressive, history geek, mrchumchum, cn4st4datrees, Yalin, millwx, Fortschreitend, EquationDoc, fastpathguru, MaqOuzo, DefendOurConstitution, Daily Activist, ThompsonLazyBoy, subframe, Mercuriousss, Night Train, zbbrox, chiefscribe, MySobriquet, soms, az dem, jazzence, sanglug, Denise Oliver Velez, jennifersr, Shelley99, synductive99, zealotus, BlueMama, RadioGirl, CityLightsLover, audiored, notksanymore, foldingBicycle, Houston Gardener, Katie71, A Voice, FundaMental Transformation, JAMill, joehoevah, Vita Brevis, capasb, rossir, Apocalypse Please, BigVegan, ladygreenslippers, swaminathan, TruthandTrust, BrighidG, CajunBoyLgb, Red Reign, angelesmartian, pyegar, p gorden lippy, Jez, Vacationland, Commoditize This, OneOfThoseBitterPeople, My mom is my hero, Blue Blood, amk for obama, seishin, Firecrawler09, MarkMarvin, Capn Sassy Jas, SmartAleq, stunzeed, El Ochito, randomsubu, Spaceboy, KentuckyKat, msmo1918, Mara Jade, AlexXx, Lost and Found, JellyBearDemMom, atxcats, Dave1955, legalchic, BonnieSchlitz, snaglepuss, Eddie L, deboChicago, Herse182, Grange95, MelKnee, drnihili, Jommy, Tim Q, Ink Asylum, French Guy, gembree, NY brit expat, sullivanst, Marja E, ypsiCPA, HartfordTycoon, axel000, Grumpy Young Man, DiegoUK, Perfektion, abrauer, Casual Wednesday, roystah, chambersc, MsGrin, bottles, Rnedewa, jamgirl86, W Z Foster, wrpereir, jms263, Irony Raygun, TichMarie, Kate from CT, Vega, weathertom, Shelbyville Manhattan, Pakalolo, JMA, Kai99, Dismantling the Masters House, Benjaphar, JeremyLegg, heart of a quince, Lorelei, Philly526, V in Tuff City, Palicro, Airmid, bluebluelady, atheistben, tibagaii, canadaboy37, captenaj, dshepherd, Cintimcmomma, rgm, krabal, Amayi, palm springs progressive, frozndevl, jeghm, jaysmith, drsue, JaneDoe, stonedoubt, JRCMYP

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site