Daily Kos

Owning my Racism - Adoption in America

Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:19:28 PM PDT

I am a white man, and have enjoyed the privilege of being a white man in this country.  I attended a mostly white public school system in a mid-sized mostly white city.  There were two african american families in my high school.

I attended a small liberal arts college with a small but vocal african american community.  

I work for a software company that is mostly white, and male.

And I live in a mostly white suburb of a mostly white city.

And I have denied, for most of my life, that I am a racist.

Today, after listening to Barack Obama, I admit I am.

Since the first time my wife and I discussed children over 8 years ago, we have discussed adoption.  We have discussed it in terms of how we identify with both ourselves and the children of the world, and have decided that while we are not incapable of having our own children, adopting a waiting child or waiting children is really what we feel in our hearts.

We have filled out all of the paperwork, we have our home study completed.  We have attended a lot of training, some of it race specific, much of simply about raising hurt children.

Early on in this process my wife specifically identified that she wanted to adopt african american children.  She is of course open to children of all race, but in her heart she sees herself as the mom of african american children.  I have wrestled with this for over a year now - even after having fostered two beautiful, intelligent african american girls last year.  Even this morning, when the topic came up concerning an african american boy available in our state, I was uncomfortable.

The issues that confront me are all about race.  They are about raising a child that doesn't look like me.  And I have often projected this issue onto the "potential child," often arguing with my wife that my concern was not about my feelings, but with how a child of a different race would eventually view us.

Barack Obama made me realize today, that I need to own my racism and move past it.  I need to recognize it, quit making excuses, quit rationalizing it away, and move past it.  

In America, the largest segment of waiting children are african american.  African American children make up 41% of the over 500,000 children in foster care, even though they make up only 15% of the general population.  By comparison, caucasian children make up 63% of all children in America, but only 38% of foster children are caucasian.

In America, it actually will cost you less money to adopt an african american baby (Baby trade).  Some argue that this is a supply and demand question, but regardless of the argument, cost boils down to race on some level.

I feel the need to be a parent.  I am looking forward to it.  I can envision myself being the father to a child of any color.  I can see it in my mind's eye.  So why do I still have this hesitation, this fear, when I actually see a picture of a real life waiting child of color that needs a home?  

It is because I have not confronted what is really at the heart of the matter.

I have lived a more or less segregated life (with the exception of 4 years of military service).  I have allowed myself to become complacent with the notion of race by simply ignoring it.  And now that it is confronting me in the form of adoption, it is making me uncomfortable.

But thanks to the courageous words of Barack Obama, I now feel deep in my bones something very real:  that we are all people, we all deserve hope, we all deserve second chances, and we all make up this great country.  If I can be a father to ANY child, of ANY race, then that is both the greatest blessing I can receive and the greatest blessing I can bestow.  Skin color does not dictate whether or not someone is loveable.  It does not dictate whether or not someone can be my child.

My wife and I are going to adopt a pair of children who have, so far in life, not been provided with the kind of love, support and opportunity that I have taken for granted my whole life.  Cultural identity will still be an issue.  Dealing with ignorant people around us will still be an issue.

But having a presidential candidate stand up and speak to the issues so directly without any hesitation in his voice, provided me with the one thing that I was not seeing until now:  hope for the future.  

If hope is Barack Obama's message - he has finally gotten through to me, and I cannot wait to be a father.

Poll

Were you adopted?

12%10 votes
87%69 votes

| 79 votes | Vote | Results

Tags: adoption, barack obama, racism (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 36 comments

  •  Good luck! (18+ / 0-)

    I have many, many white friends who have adopted African-American and biracial children through Hope Cottage in Dallas -- and their families are very, very happy.

    I had looked into this program too, getting the "baby" urge again as my Sadie grew older, but my wreck in 2006 put an end to my hopes. As a single mother with mobility issues, one child is enough.

    I envy you!

    Happy parenting!

    "Oh, TV. Is there anything you can't do?" -- Homer Simpson

    by Melody Townsel on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:23:27 PM PDT

  •  Best wishes to you (12+ / 0-)

    I think you will make an excellent father.

    The vote is "Basic Democracy #1". YOU must preserve it. -edscan

    by BoiseBlue on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:25:52 PM PDT

  •  ...I did not see that one coming. (9+ / 0-)

    It's good that there are quite a few pleasant surprises left in the world.

    "The nationalist not only does not disapprove of atrocities committed by his own side, but he has a remarkable capacity for not even hearing about them." Orwell

    by NotablyZen on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:26:49 PM PDT

  •  Wonderful diary! Rescue Rangers, take note. (6+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Sychotic1, boofdah, cfk, kyril, chinchin, marley619

    The author should post a Tip Jar!

  •  I hope others take to heart (7+ / 0-)

    your very thought-provoking message

    an anonymous person once said, "A man who lies about little things, will lie about big things."

    by marley619 on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:29:21 PM PDT

  •  I don't think it's racist as much as bad faith. (3+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    rian90, Sychotic1, kyril

    My intuition - and I'm fully aware that that's all it is - is that people that adopt want to have moments when they can pretend that that child is their child (I thought about writing "is their biological child," but I fully intend the ambiguity of "child" sans any limiting adjectives).

    •  I agree. (7+ / 0-)

      Common terms thrown around in adoption circles are "entitlement" and "claiming."  The first deals with one's feeling of entitlement about being a parent, and deals with believing the child (any child) belongs in your home.  That you have the "right" to be a parent.

      The second, as the word suggests, is about claiming the child as your own.  And this is a critical step in the adoption process.  For most adoptive parents, there is a grieving process that they have to go through, because they are giving up something that is biologically ingrained in most humans - their own biological children.

      Compound that with a special needs kid who is older, and now you have lost years of child development and family development as well.  

      There is a lot of psychology going on - more than this poor old history major can get his head around most of the time.

      -7/-6.26 | "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy" - T. Roosevelt

      by Bogleg on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:36:18 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  what is so cute and hilarious, too (1+ / 0-)

        Recommended by:
        Overseas

        my daughter adopted a Haitian baby and now that he is four and a half, everyone says his personality is so much like my son-in-law's.  

        He is the light of all our lives.  He has a spirit that never stops despite surgery issues and leg braces.

        They are also almost done getting their foster care license and will begin adopting a little girl who is so much fun.  

        We are blessed.  Best wishes to you and your wife.

        Raising any child at all is tough.  I admit to being worn out after three of my own.  So, now, I get the benefits of playing with grandbabies and then sending them back home. :)

        Join us at Bookflurries: Bookchat on Wednesday nights 8:00 PM EST

        by cfk on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:57:13 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

    •  Very true... (1+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      burrow owl

      I am not sure if its the pretending..but it is part of the grieving process of not having a biological child. I know I look for similarities between myself and even more so my husband and my children. Sometimes they are actually there...A child picks up so many mannerisms and traits of their adoptive parent that the resemblance appears to be there simply because of the mannerisms. :)

  •  Trust yourself (10+ / 0-)

    When you fall in love with those children, you will stop seeing the color of skin and see the deep and beautiful color of love coming back at you.

    The Justice Department is no longer a credible defender of the rule of law or the Constitution.

    by Overseas on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:34:00 PM PDT

  •  good luck to you (7+ / 0-)

    in your finding and adopting the children both you and your wife want. And thank you for your courage to speak up. All of us, to varying degrees are "working on" our racism, which I believe stems from isolation and fear and the conditioning that keeps us from realizing we are racist.

    I was taught when I was a child "Don't hang out with black children--they'll bring you down (socially)". This from new immigrant parents from the Philippines. They were afraid of being judged on the same denigrated plane that blacks and hispanics were viewed. Second class. Invisible.

    In time, over the last 50 odd years I've learned so much about being an open, unafraid human being, in no small part from the lessons learned from my African American sisters who are my true down-to-the-bone-until-we-drop-dead-asshole buddies .

    Today, reading the speech--I was amazed at what was spoken and felt. Not just because it was Obama, but because finally, at last SOMEONE WAS SAYING IT. That it came from the candidate I support was icing on an already amazing cake. He put us on the road to something I never thought I'd see in this country. A better place to talk openly about our differences.

    We've all taken a big step forward today.

    My needs are getting simpler as the campaign season wears on. Therefore---Unite or Die!

    by Fe Bongolan on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:36:44 PM PDT

  •  Adoption is complicated, especially for adoptees. (3+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    rian90, Sychotic1, kyril

    Even within so-called "same race" adoptions, adopted persons have to struggle with identity issues in ways that children raised by their biological parents do not.

    The struggle may be even more difficult when the adoption cuts across national or "racial" boundaries.

    Accordingly, while, in some cases, white prospective adoptive parents may be reluctant to adopt a non-white child for reasons based on, or tinged by, their own racism, in other cases that reluctance may well stem from a good faith concern about the best interests of the child.

  •  I'm adopted (17+ / 0-)

    That's why I don't know what religion or race I really am.
    I'm not white, black, asian, jewish, christian, muslim.
    I'm Amy.
    I'm grateful that my parents adopted me.

    I'm proud of Americans today!

    by Stop Pandering on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:37:02 PM PDT

  •  I think we all learned something today (5+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Bogleg, cfk, Overseas, kyril, Fawkes

    At least most of us did.  
    It shows us that Obama has the insight and courage to lead this nation.  

  •  Good for you (3+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    cfk, Overseas, kyril

    I hope it's the start of a trend, and that Sen Obama can be credited with helping start it.
       I'm know our parents and grandparents thought our racial and ethnic isolation and segregation were keeping you and me safe and sound, but the unintended consequence is the racism latent in our bones that we have to constantly keep from continuing to damage us and those around us.

       It's truly pernicious.

       I do my best.
     
       Good luck.

    Obama...Hope McCain...Nope

    by KenBee on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:39:31 PM PDT

  •  Adoptive parent here (5+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Chun Yang, cfk, KenBee, kyril, Fawkes

    Trans-racial, even, though in my case it's an international adoption and the child is Asian.  This raises issues which are in many ways the same as what you're grappling with, but not all the same.  Being african-american is not the same as being asian-american, and I don't for a second pretend that it is.

    I'm glad Obama's speech prompted this reflection.  You may or may not be being too hard on yourself.  Feeling not entirely comfortable with raising children who are a different race from you is not necessarily racist.  It's a whole lot more than that, though in the process of answering those questions, you have to grapple with your own preconceived notions of what various people are like.  It is not an easy process.

    No better journey on the planet than the one you're about to take.  Good for you for taking on the internal roadblocks.  Obama would be proud.

  •  Congratulations (4+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    cfk, Overseas, kyril, Fawkes

    That child will have a great home and great father.

    I think a Obama presidency will not just change our politics but the people as well. A president like him will inspire a lot of people to do generous, noble things. I think we are witnessing history. There will still be hunger and disease and poverty and racism after 8 years of Obama presidency but there will substantially less of each.

  •  you will be fine! (0+ / 0-)

    but it won't be easy. i'm sure. just like raising any child under any circumstance, your biological or an adopted one, is never easy.

    i have two good friends, who with their partners have each adopted beautiful bi-racial girls as infants. they have, and will continue to confront many issues of identity and culture, as well as probably some meanness or racism once the girls are of school age, but they are all happier than i've ever known them to be in our entire lives.

    as for your being "racist" -- we all are, in that we see things in such terms. and many white folk of my generation and region have also grown up amidst the much worse kind of racism from neighbors, older family members, sometimes even teachers back in the 70's around here. i hate those attitudes, but i also know that i am at some deep level always going to be a product of that.

    i guess being a woman (and of a certain age) makes it slightly easier for me to accept that and deal with it? i am familiar with sexism from the side of the "minority" and so at least i have some slight handle on how racism might feel? and i've certainly tangled with white men who continue to believe that there is no such thing as sexism in our nation today--no doubt they probably think the same about racism or other "-isms".

    they just can't SEE it, is all. because it has never affected them. so in the same way, i know that i might look blindly at racism that happens right under my nose to someone else, and not even realize it if they don't tell me what happened, because i am white and in the "majority" in that regard. it also helps me realize that i can never truly understand what it is like to be in that position, just as even the most well-intentioned man is not going to ever completely "get" what it is like to be discriminated against or thought of in certain ways because of being a female.

    but i think you have made the most important step--you realize what you didn't see before, exists and is real. i think you will be alright!

    best of luck!

    éí 'aaníígÓÓ 'áhoot'é

    by Librarian on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 12:48:25 PM PDT

  •  My adoption of a black child.. (4+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Bogleg, HeyMikey, Overseas, revgerry

    I went through many of the same feelings you did when we decided to adopt a multi-racial child. I tried to bury them, insisting that it wouldn't make a difference. My husband I attended an interracial adoption class that really did help us. We met families who had adopted outside their race.

    Our daughter is now 7 years old. She is very proud of her AA/Cuban/European/Native American heritage. We show her pictures of multiracial/biracial people. She looks like a little Halle Berry. :) If we go somewhere and see people like her, we discuss it later. Just as we celebrate St. Patricks day by eating corned beef and hash with my Irish daughter, we also eat Cuban food and go to Pow Wows with my multiracial daughter. I haven't found an AA restaurant yet in my area but we have had Carri bean food. :)

    My daughter has a huge crush on Obama..and had it even before I became a supporter. I cried when I read his speech because it said so much for me, for my daughter and for the American that I see out there.

    When we adopted our daughter, we were no longer a white family. We have three white children and one black child but that one child changed the way others saw us and how we saw ourselves. Yes, I do experience racism now..blatant racism, where people actually make comments to me, usually older people, and subtle, such as stares, shaking of the head, especially when my white husband is not around. However, most people of all colors tell me she is beautiful. :)

    And she is..beautiful, smart and sensible. Her personality is more similar to mine than any of my other children. I remember once wondering deep inside if I would feel differently when kissing a curly head, but now I kiss her head all the time and I love her more than life itself.

    Funny how a baby can teach you so much about yourself and your own deep prejudices. Congrats to you and your wife. You are very lucky and while your world will change, you will realize how much more colorful and multi-dimensional it can be.

  •  I'm an adoptee. (0+ / 0-)

    One thing to consider when adopting a child of a differnt race than yourself. If you can't see yourself kissing in a romantic way a Black person, then how could you possibly parent a Black child? And the next question could be whether you have enough friends in your life of that race so he/she will be surrounded with positive Black roll models as they grow up.

    Then, should you adopt, make sure you do everything you can to preserve your child's history and health history. The medical history of a 21 year old isn't much of a medial history. Most of us are pretty healthy at that point.

  •  Am I the only one that feels... (0+ / 0-)

    Something wrong with this? For one, adopting children to assuage guilt, especially guilt that I find really silly to begin with, is just wrong.

    I am racist. Everyone who reads this is racist. It's wired into the primate brain to dislike monkeys from the other tribe.

    Now, that said, I don't wallow in this natural behavior. I acknowledge it, and I fight it. I didn't need Obama to tell me before I realized it, I've known this for years. I suppose I could pretend or ignore and act properly "progressive", but that would be a lie. I am racist, as all humans are, and the best that can be managed is to fight it every day.

    And besides, adoption is a tricky thing. Orphans and such do deserve a home and a family. But neither should one think of them as luxury pets once that you trade up to from show dogs.

    If you're adopting, do it for the other person, the child, not yourself. Making a point of adopting a black child just because they're black is no better than not adopting them just because they're black. Go adopt, and whatever color they happen to be, that's that.

    •  Response (0+ / 0-)

      I acknowledge that I am racist, that's the whole point of the diary.  I don't "wallow" in it either - in fact, I pretty much have ignored it for most of my life because I haven't had any reason to confront it.  

      The fact is, that when considering adopting waiting children, the majority of children in foster care, that are legally free for adoption, or african american.  This forced me to confront something that was deep seated within me and hidden.  

      We are adopting because we are doing it for both the adoptee and for ourselves.  Adopting because you think are doing someone else a favor is a bad reason to adopt - adopting because you want to be a parent is a good reason to adopt.

      We will not adopt someone because they are or are not black.  The point is, chances are we will end up adopting black children because that's where the odds are.  We are "color blind" in terms of our stated preferences - I am not naive enough to think I am "color blind" in terms of my, as you stated, "primate brain."

      And I don't think anyone suggest that kids - adopted or otherwise - are luxury pets.  

      -7/-6.26 | "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy" - T. Roosevelt

      by Bogleg on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 02:19:42 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  I'm somewhere between you and the diarist on this (0+ / 0-)

      in part because this is similar to discussions that my better half and I have had re: adoption.  We both want to adopt in the future, and the prospect of trans-racial adoption has led me to do some reading up on the topic.  

      The diarist can definitely expect tension from some people in the white community (for obvious reasons) but also from some people in the black community, for reasons you hint at in your comment.  Trans-racial adoptions, especially of black children by white parents, are sometimes seen as "vanity purchases".  And, let's be honest, sometimes they are.

      But I think the diarist is right to take the angle that s/he does: there's a legitimate motivation to adopt black children based on the numbers alone.  A black child is far less likely to be adopted than a white child.

      Saint, n. A dead sinner revised and edited. - Ambrose Bierce

      by pico on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 03:50:44 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  The best to you! (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Overseas

    Have faith -- love breaks down all kinds of barriers.

    -4.25, -4.87 "If the truth were self-evident, there would be no need for eloquence." -- Cicero

    by HeyMikey on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 01:41:29 PM PDT

  •  Let me get this right... (0+ / 0-)

    You've adopted two black girls, yet you claim to be a racist, someone who HATES blacks. You actually HATE your adopted daughters? Yeech.

    •  No. (0+ / 0-)

      We fostered two black girls.  They were eventually adopted by someone else.

      Symantically I don't equate racism with hate.  I equate it with a believe in superiority of one race over another for whatever reason, or, if you would prefer a more "mild" term, just bigotry in general.

      Racism to its extreme is of course hate.  Racism by and large is using race, in my opinion, to hold a position of power over someone else.  But the kind of racism that we see and engage in in this country today is more subversive, not overtly "hate" so much as it is a dislike or uncomfortableness with a more or less minor difference between types of people.

      -7/-6.26 | "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy" - T. Roosevelt

      by Bogleg on Tue Mar 18, 2008 at 02:22:31 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  The power of words... (0+ / 0-)

    cannot be underestimated!

  •  I hope you check back and see this reply (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Bogleg

    GOD BLESS YOU.

    GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR WIFE.

    I mean that.

    I am NOT against inter-racial adoption. What I am against is inter-racial adoption by people who truly and really haven't thought about the consequences of having a child of a different race and what that means.

    This post, and your wrestling with it is proof that you are more than ready for the challenge.

    There are too many Black children that need LOVING HOMES.

    I'm always of the belief that though there will be troubles, and the children will have some issues, if they come from loving homes; from homes that teach them the basics of what is means to love and to support and be a part of a successful family...then the kids can take out a loan later on in life to deal with ' issues' with a good therapist.

    I don't make light of the struggles of Black children in White homes..

    But, I can't even fathom uttering the words that they'd be better off in ' The System' waiting for that ' Magical Black Family'.

    No way.

    I love those children too much and want them in stable homes.

    I hope you know that God will bless you, as he does all the angels that bring into their lives the 'lost' children of all colors.

Permalink | 36 comments