Daily Kos

National Emergency, Elections, Privatization, and The Law

Sat May 17, 2008 at 03:01:00 PM PDT

Once upon a time, after nearly 200 years of Republican government, and 50 years of both declared and undeclared class warfare, a citizenship crisis, economic extortion,  corrupted elections, and sweeping military reforms, a Republic was attacked by a highly coordinated criminal organization, which was worldwide in scope, these individuals were non-state actors, and their pirates burned and sacked the primary economic center of the Republic, in very close proximity to the seat of the central government.

The citizenry was offended and terrified. The economy went into shock and debts were called in en masse, further aggravating the political and existential crises in the country. The cost of food skyrocketed, people were desperate, insulted, hungry, and angry, and severe retaliation was demanded by almost the entire population.

It was decided among the Senate that broad military  authority should be given to a group of individuals, or rather to the most effective military commander and a huge staff of his choosing, and that the criminals should be pursued across the known world and punished for their insolence towards civilization.

The man, and his retinue, were to be granted the complete sovereign authority of the nation, to make treaties, to declare wars, to exact tribute and reach economic settlements, and to command any resource of the state.  

Rome was dependent on slaves, slaves whose labor was not merely a necessity but also a kind of household commodity and luxury. While slave labor was used to work large farming estates, an almost equal number of slaves were employed in the sex trade, or by specialty, as gourmet chefs, cooks, doctors, accountants, clerks, etc...

So while punishment and suppression of the anarchic pirates was demanded by nearly every politician and citizen alike, it was also tacitly understood that it was the pirates who transported and coordinated the slave trade, and since many Senators and businessmen were enriched by the industry, the complete destruction of the pirates was a false goal, in that those with economic and political power within the society largely depended on the existence of the industry to preserve their power and pacify the population by providing them with a more comfortable way of living.

So instead of destroying every last pirate and slave-trader, which would be ridiculous, an agreement was reached with the pirates and they were placed under greater control by Roman businessmen and local magistrates, who coordinated legal protection for them as long as they kept their marauding within acceptable limits, and continued to keep the slave trade open. So instead of enacting justice, the governing class, and the business interests, sought to preserve their own power and comfort.

In the midst of this crisis, or rather, as this false crisis was reaching a satisfactory political conclusion and the flow of goods and slaves was once again safe, a new enemy was identified by the great general and his staff, an enemy who had supported the pirates in their attack and unlike them possessed a nation which threatened Roman military dominance in the region.

Once again, the emergency powers that were granted to the general to orchestrate the charade war against the pirates, were extended to fight the new war against the state-based enemy, an evil, demonized leader who threatened the interests of Roman businessmen in the region, and had coordinated a massacre of them before. He was surrounded and provoked and the monied interests within the administration eventually succeeded in breaking his power.

Roman tax collectors and businessmen flocked to the region, and the treasury swelled. Life returned back to normal and Rome appeared to be safe from all external enemies, only she had wrecked her own Constitution.

During the course of the war against Mithridates, the evil Eastern despot,  a few private individuals had followed in the wake of the great general, looking for ways to aggrandize themselves in the midst of the corruption and chaos. Anytime an individual or a small minority is granted all the supreme powers of government, it can be certain that the most ambitious and grasping people will surround them in hopes of gaining their favor and sharing in the exercise of undisputed power. Even those who would undermine their rule.

Under these circumstances, a private individual raised a private army, largely on credit, and carried out a few raids against settlements in the region, largely to extort the population, but also in accord with the general remaking of the region.

That individual's name was Gaius Julius Caesar. And less than 30 years later, after countless businessman and ambitious politicians had grasped for the criminal powers of the perverted Republic, and massacred their enemies at home and abroad, his death signified the end of self-rule, civics, and moral civilization in the West for nearly two thousand years.

I know that the comparisons to Rome are frequent nowadays, and that most of the time they are spoken out of admiration for the military, cultural  and economic dominance of the world's sole superpower. But it's worth noting that the destruction of Republican government and citizen's rights, and the descent of the Roman world into complete anarchy, was essentially a suicide, consented to by a democratic majority, and inspired by fear.

Rome had wrestled with many issues that we confront today, such as the enfranchisement of non-traditional citizens, rampant corruption among businessmen around the world, bribery and fraud at elections, and the perpetuation of a large, aggressive and professional military force, which had only recently been instituted in place of a citizen army.

As soon as Rome's military was professionalized, and soldiers did not fight in order to gain a land pension upon retirement, but in order to jockey for position within the military establishment and industry, a professional group of violent mercenaries was always available for a price, and their loyalties were often transferred between the highest bidders.

Rome also transformed itself economically and morally after acquiring territory, taxes and riches in the East. Merchants were largely under-represented within the Republican government, and only landowning businessmen were allowed access to what we would consider government agencies and courts.

But once a majority of business was based on speculation and trade in Eastern commodities, the perpetuation of the slave trade, and most of the large farming estates had been consolidated under a small group, the only way that wealth could be distributed among the business and financial elites was through more expansion, more war, or by the occasional massacre and dispossession of rivals by the politically empowered. During the  shakeup following the war against the pirates, businessmen were essentially allowed to have their own courts and thus, were allowed to self-regulate, so that another means of acquiring resources and wealth was to bring false charges against another businessman, even though corruption and fraud were widespread, and purchase the services of a good lawyer.

How many of us can look at this brief history of an Empire trying to preserve it's Republican origins and not see more than just a few similarities?

Rampant corruption by a monied elite dedicated to the preservation of aggressive enemies of the state, private mercenary armies and the seemingly permanent establishment of violent men dedicated to perpetual warfare and domestic security services for the wealthy, a temporary emergency used by politicians to consolidate power and secure resources, surely, these are all things which we should consider, things which the Founders of the country, and almost every person involved with public service within this country was aware of up until the middle of the last century.

There are very substantial lessons to be learned from the history of the last Republican Empire that claimed dominion over the world, lessons that we should keep in mind as we approach this next election.

Trading one corrupt, ambitious, and selfish leader for another, who would simply seek to privately aggrandize an opposing group of manipulative, money-hungry interests at the expense of our Constitution and civil liberties, is not a great solution to the problems that our society faces.        

Unless the criminality and irregularity of this administration is recorded by history and admitted by whichever administration succeeds it, we will have crossed a threshold on the way to sheer despotism and will further realize tyranny with a distinctly imperial character.

And as the current administration gets ready to "leave office," but not power, since it is clear that they determine policy by acting both within and outside of our elected government, we should pay particular attention to the possibility that they will ratchet up the current conflict in Central Asia and the Middle East, and try to lay the seeds for a crisis which will allow them to take political power once again.

I can't help but think that the current leaders of this administration, like the war-hungry, grasping, Roman mercenaries and militants who preceded them, are taking great care to make sure that their industry of intrigue, sabotage, espionage, murder and extortion, will be safe from the designs of a popular government.

That being said, it is clear that democrats must demand transparency within the government, must demand free and fair publicly-funded elections, and must demand the retraction of  the Cold War military forces, as well as a calculated redeployment of our armed forces so that we are protected at home instead of provoking nations and people around the world. The courts must repair and clarify the damages that have been unleashed on the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, and the criminal leaders of this administration must be tried in the criminal courts, or the court of public opinion, so that men and women who share their designs will never be allowed near the controls of our government again.  

Our unwillingness to confront the realities of a Post-Cold War epoch has cost us dearly, and if we are to regain any of our rights and liberties as defined by the Constitution and exercised by U.S. citizens for nearly 200 years, we must consider ending the many national emergencies that have been declared since the end of the second World War, or else we will face perpetual emergency and find ourselves without a nation.      

   

Tags: Election, Empire, Civil Liberties, Military, Privatization, Executive Power, National Emergency, Rome, History, Corruption, Fraud, Business, Rescued, teaching (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 19 comments

  •  A "nation" is... (7+ / 0-)

    a large body of people, associated with a particular territory, that is sufficiently conscious of its unity to seek or to possess a government peculiarly its own.

    We have been strained to re-build this "nation" after the Civil War and it still has not been accomplished.

    The vastly different ideologies held between right and left in this country remain.  We have seen that African-Americans still struggle to be considered as full members of this nation.  Increasingly, hispanic people are being alienated from the national identity.

    Our "nation" is fracturing and only Barack Obama recognizes this and proposes a new form of governance that will broaden our idea of nation.

    This is why I vote for him and support him.

    •  Then let's hope (7+ / 0-)

      He restores the rule of law. Because a multi-ethnic, multi-cultural nation, if it is to be just, is impossible without the law.

      Ceterum censeo Iran esse delendam

      by tullyccro on Sat May 17, 2008 at 03:13:51 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Obama (5+ / 0-)

      AND his youthful supporters, I'd add. It will take great strength to stand up to Bush if he decides to try to remain in power.

      Executive Directive 51 was "posted on the White House website on May 9, 2007, without any further announcement or press briefings":

      specifies the procedures for continuity of the federal government in the event of a "catastrophic emergency." Such an emergency is construed as "any incident, regardless of location, that results in extraordinary levels of mass casualties, damage, or disruption severely affecting the U.S. population, infrastructure, environment, economy, or government functions."

      The directive specifies that, following such an [catastrophic] emergency, an "Enduring Constitutional Government," comprising "a cooperative effort among the executive, legislative, and judicial branches of the Federal Government," coordinated by the President of the United States, will take the place of the nation's regular government, presumably without the oversight of Congress.[3] .... The directive specifies that the president has the power to declare a catastrophic emergency and does not specify who has the power to declare said emergency over.

      http://en.wikipedia.org/...

      "This chamber reeks of blood." -- Sen George McGovern, 1970

      by cotterperson on Sat May 17, 2008 at 03:13:53 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Bill Clinton oversaw the most radical privatiza- (3+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      snakelass, tullyccro, pickandshovel

      tion. For example Clinton privatized the national nuclear company USEC, which has turned into a monumental disaster of corruption which almost no one mentions.

  •  Thank you, tullyccro, (6+ / 0-)

    for the excellent diary. The comparisons are clear and startling. It's going to be a long, hard fight.

    "This chamber reeks of blood." -- Sen George McGovern, 1970

    by cotterperson on Sat May 17, 2008 at 03:15:09 PM PDT

    •  he certainly did. (4+ / 0-)

      Bill Clinton's vague internationalism cost plenty of American's a substantial amount of liberty, security, and economic stability. And this argument goes beyond party lines. That's why we need to be having it. Nothing would endear the democratic party to the populace more than the Democratic party becoming the voice of reason in an imperial, corporate world.

      Ceterum censeo Iran esse delendam

      by tullyccro on Sat May 17, 2008 at 05:12:50 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  And there are many more other than.... (3+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Avila, trashablanca, Youffraita

    The ones I stated above. Many, many, many more.

    The vices and virtues of human beings reveal themselves time and time again, in similar ways.

    Ceterum censeo Iran esse delendam

    by tullyccro on Sat May 17, 2008 at 03:18:24 PM PDT

    •  You are not the first to make this comparison (3+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      Avila, trashablanca, SciVo

      but you've done a great job, and I too thank you.  The question is: how do we make our case to the greater populace, not just the choir?  That is the problem going into November:  you are right, we are right, but the mediabots still seem to stick to the GOP talking points.  How do we get our message out?

      Our economy is a house of cards. Don't breathe.

      by Youffraita on Sat May 17, 2008 at 03:35:19 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  Well... (8+ / 0-)

        First of all, we call it what it really is. Once you name the devil, you've partly exorcised the evil.

        The words "empire" and "republic" need to have meaning again when they're used between citizens. Because we can't have both.

        We have to talk, talk, talk about both of these things until they're on everyone's minds and lips, to the point where the mainstream media will be so far removed from the discussions that real citizens are having, they'll see a complete lack of interest.

        When everyone subscribes to the narrow, win/lose, hype surrounding the election, and the substantive issues are taken out of the forum, then we submit to the unreality of the punditry they push on TV.

        Talk about it, make sure you know what a republic is, what it requires, and exactly how it was designed to work in this country.

        Talk about the empire, make sure you know exactly how it operates, what it is requiring of us morally and economically, and make sure that no one is calling it anything other than it's rightful name.

        I think that's where we start.

        Ceterum censeo Iran esse delendam

        by tullyccro on Sat May 17, 2008 at 05:17:16 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

  •  imperial character (3+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    snakelass, tullyccro, SciVo

    Great diary.  You conclude:

    Unless the criminality and irregularity of this administration is recorded by history and admitted by whichever administration precedes it, we will have crossed a threshold on the way to sheer despotism and will further realize tyranny with a distinctly imperial character.

    meaning, I think, "whichever [Obama] administratin succeeds it".  It is too late to avoid tyranny with a distinclty imperial character, in U.S. international affairs (stretching back to the Monroe Doctrine with the subsequent history of our invasion of countries in central America), but perhaps we can begin to step back from that poisoned heritage.  It would, I think, be a distraction to engage in "war crime trials" against the torturers and designers of the neo-con imperial policy.  Rather, I think, the task will be two-fold:  (1) reversing tax policies that favor WTO-type corporate expansionism; and (2) beginning to dismantle the network of US military bases around the world.  

    See, e.g., "Review Article: The Worldwide Network of US Military Bases, The Global Deployment of US Military Personnel" by Prof. Jules Dufour (with great maps and photos) link; and even Alternet's excerpt from Chalmers Johnson's, "Nemesis: The Last Days of the American Republic."

    Without dismantling these bases, it will be impossible to reassert civilian control over U.S. foreign policy, which is now conducted by the invisible pro-consulate of the officers stationed in our 700+ bases around the world.  

    I think Obama is smart enough to begin the task, but it will be huge and extremely dangerous.  

    •  Thanks... (0+ / 0-)

      I corrected it. Succeeds is what I meant.

      Comprehensive Tax reform has never been more necessary. And C. Johnson does an excellent job of describing the extent to which we have colonized the world, militarily. I think a lot of people think that American culture, and economic practices are somehow inherently superior and that we're resented because of how pervasive they are. This is demonstrably false. It's the American military base guaranteeing the rights of the corporation that draws resentment.

      And yes, it will be extremely dangerous. The last two presidents who have threatened to disarm the corporate military establishment suffered from assassination and character assassination, respectively.  

      Ceterum censeo Iran esse delendam

      by tullyccro on Sun May 18, 2008 at 11:38:57 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  Justice (2+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    snakelass, SciVo

    Unless the criminality and irregularity of this administration is recorded by history and admitted by whichever administration precedes it, we will have crossed a threshold on the way to sheer despotism and will further realize tyranny with a distinctly imperial character.

    If the Bush administration escapes justice for its extreme criminality, then there will be no future limits on the action of our ruling elite.  The law will only apply to the masses.

    It is very important the elite are held accountable for crimes just as the masses because the potential damage done by an uncontrolled and powerful elite is too dangerous.  And currently, the political and the economic elite are beyond the law and out of control.  

    The most powerful, Bush/Cheney, must be brought to justice to set future limits on the powerful.

    •  I agree... (0+ / 0-)

      And I'll take it one step further and say that if we allow the criminal leadership of this country any kind of clemency, as we did after Nixon's resignation, as we did after the election of Reagan and his interference with Middle Eastern foreign policy before his election, and as we did after Iran/Contra, we will pay for it.

      This is largely the same group of criminals and hacks who went down with Nixon. And we had better make it clear that their style of government is illegal and unacceptable, or else you've got a whole new generation of crooks, thieves, liars, and murderers beneath them, who will follow their example.  

      Ceterum censeo Iran esse delendam

      by tullyccro on Sun May 18, 2008 at 11:43:22 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  Well said, and HEAR HEAR **** (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    snakelass

    The courts must repair and clarify the damages that have been unleashed on the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, and the criminal leaders of this administration must be tried in the criminal courts, ....

    ... period !

    ~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~

    ~if you're not outraged then you're not paying attention~move sooner, not faster~
    ~for those with eyes to see, let them see~

    ~we study the old to understand the new~from one thing know ten thousand~to see things truly one must see what is in the light and what lies hidden in shadow~

    by ArthurPoet on Sat May 17, 2008 at 11:24:40 PM PDT

  •  One very important thing (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    snakelass

    a new, Democratic (in every sense of the word) government must do immediately, is take the control of the message away from the corrupt elite IMMEDIATELY and roll back the FCC rules so that one group will never again be able to stifle the truth and propagandize the nation.
       Then, this country needs  nationally televised truth and reconciliation hearings with plenty of drama, music, Kabuki, etc.

    after the farce comes the tragedy.

    by slouching on Sun May 18, 2008 at 02:06:01 AM PDT

    •  Agreed... (0+ / 0-)

      The whole trend of deregulation is ridiculous and clearly feeds the corporate military power structure. In no way is it free-market practice, it is corporate socialism and needs to be called what it is.

      Ceterum censeo Iran esse delendam

      by tullyccro on Sun May 18, 2008 at 11:44:48 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  I added the 'teaching' tag (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    snakelass

    and this diary will be in Daily Kos University, which goes up every Saturday, around 9 AM Eastern, but stays open all week: Yesterday's DKU

Permalink | 19 comments