Skip to main content

Watching Kieth just now, I heard him mention Antonin "Nino" Scalia's dissenting opinion from today's ruling in regards habeas corpus rights for detainees.  

The lowlight of Justice Scalia's opinion was the paragraph:

"The game of bait-and-switch that today’s opinion plays upon the Nation’s Commander in Chief will make the war harder on us. It will almost certainly cause more Americans to be killed."

While others will surely spend countless hours and buckets of ink and pixels debating the merits or madness of the second sentence, I've a bone to pick with the first.

Scalia has, over the years, demonstrated a profound lack of understanding of the U.S. Constitution and the role of the Supreme Court.  His devotion to the concept of "originalism" selectively ignores the Ninth and Tenth Amendments, key components of the document as "originally" ratified.  The codicil to the majority opinion in Bush v. Gore, in which the nation's ultimate appeals court, where all legal precedent is finally decided, declares that the judgment in that case is not, in fact, legal precedent.  

I have come to expect little in the way of Constitutional wisdom from Justice Scalia.

But he is not alone in the delusion he propounds in the first sentence of today's killer graf.  Nearly every candidate, commentator and speechifier will, at convenient times, refer to the President of the United States as "the nation's commander-in-chief" or "our commander-in-chief."

Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution begins:

The President shall be Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy of the United States, and of the Militia of the several States, when called into the actual Service of the United States

This is a very specific delineation.  When broad powers are claimed for the President, many rightly so, in his role as "commander-in-chief," these broad powers do not automatically apply to those persons not in the armed forces of the United States.  Where they exist at all, they apply to the men and women of the uniformed services of the Army and Navy, the state Guards and other armed services.

The president not only is impotent to hold me without allowing me to demand the charges against me, he is impotent to search or seize my person, goods and papers without a warrant showing probable cause.  He is enjoined from quartering his armed troops on my property.

In point of fact, the president of the United States cannot do a damned thing to me that the Constitution does not specifically allow him to do.  And this limitation to his powers, embodied in the  purposefully broad Tenth Amendment, holds because I am not a member of the armed forces.

In short, the president is not my commander-in-chief.  Odds are, he is not yours, either.  He is not Antonin Scalia's commander in chief, not Hillary Clinton's nor Chris Matthews'.

For us, the citizens of and visitors to the United States, he is the Chief Executive, pledged to take care that the laws of the United States are faithfully executed.  He is not our commander.  He is our servant.

I hope I've not made too much of a much here, but this anointing of the Chief Executive with unlimited powers over all citizens, like some ancient Imperator can't be reversed solely by Court decisions.  It must be dismantled in the minds of us, the citizens.

And refusing to accept the rule of a commander when you don't wear the uniform is a reasonable place to start.

Originally posted to Crashing Vor on Thu Jun 12, 2008 at 09:08 PM PDT.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Kimberley, chase, wozzle, Ottoe, Thumb, Canadian Reader, paradox, Ed in Montana, Angie in WA State, ljb, Danny Boy, privatewl, DavidW in SF, tameszu, Terri, tmo, Katydid, northsylvania, J mid, Cowalker, Chi, Irfo, Ray Radlein, catdevotee, nolalily, mtnbkreric, ogre, Rayne, SarahLee, georgiacmt, leftcoast, XOVER, Trendar, gogol, AaronInSanDiego, Gooch, moon in the house of moe, Geenius at Wrok, Cali Scribe, limulus, Nina Katarina, Fenric, gaspare, TrueBlueMajority, Tuffy, BigOkie, theboz, mattman, PeterHug, TocqueDeville, Knut Wicksell, John Carter, JTML, sphealey, Avila, Disillusioned, Shockwave, jabb, Schmuck, muji, EdinPHX, Vaughan19, LynChi, donna in evanston, m maddog, Wintermute, mlharges, bramish, shycat, Jay C, bellatrys, LEP, rhubarb, AWhitneyBrown, Veritas78, Sandy on Signal, commanda, zknower, marjo, Carnacki, BenGoshi, object16, Joe B, bumblebums, mataliandy, expatjourno, nanoboy, redtravelmaster, Birdman, strengthANDwisdom, Heart of the Rockies, Plan9, sardonyx, bigforkgirl, maggiemae, lgrooney, checkmate, alain2112, jackspace, karenc13, tsurube, dadanation, tyler93023, ReneInOregon, RichardG, 88kathy, indybend, wonkydonkey, ProfessorX, SamSinister, VermontGriz, SecondComing, djMikulec, ehavenot, grassroot, ask, CoolOnion, biscobosco, RabidNation, Mlle Orignalmale, KMc, joe pittsburgh, Dont Just Stand There, cosmic debris, MisterOpus1, JJG Miami Shores, roses, someRaven, sgilman, nargel, CodeTalker, Bearpaw, BruinKid, itskevin, jjhalpin, thingamabob, rioduran, dmsilev, Alna Dem, OldYellerDog, dksbook, Janet Strange, JimDev, ZekeNY, webweaver, CydeWeys, kharma, hhex65, Dube, Mxwll, Getreal1246, Moody Loner, annan, emmasnacker, danthrax, sockpuppet, TexDem, oldjohnbrown, jlynne, CitizenOfEarth, pat bunny, Sycamore, laderrick, Builderman, bloomster, churchylafemme, jlamkin, Bulldawg, mnguitar, ohiolibrarian, politichic, joliberal, snakelass, Neighbor2, applegal, AbsurdEyes, lecsmith, Timbuk3, bwintx, zett, zerelda, side pocket, TexasLefty, bablhous, kmbo, rickeagle, kd texan, stas61690, Josiah Bartlett, xxdr zombiexx, eyeball, pat208, bibble, Marc in KS, thereisnospoon, Timroff, pontechango, gsbadj, murrayewv, Shapeshifter, mm201, Sol Fed Joe, TexH, sawgrass727, chimpwatch, weelzup, luvmovies2000, rapala, Anglico, greenskeeper, nehark, Skennet Boch, davidincleveland, chumley, J R Hand, Danjuma, Tarindel, marina, ZZZzzz, 3goldens, ManOnTheBench, jrooth, kingubu, Jeffersonian Democrat, rimstalker, Dromedary512, LarisaW, baccaruda, unclejohn, revbludge, ek hornbeck, mjd in florida, LostInTexas, democracy inaction, OpherGopher, El in New York, PBen, Oaklander, laird, Osiris, Luetta, panicbean, clammyc, Simplify, truong son traveler, Clem Yeobright, karpinsky, ChemBob, catleigh, TigerMom, Brooke In Seattle, chidmf, Gary Norton, boofdah, Spoc42, dansk47, cfk, buckeyedem08, Viceroy, majcmb1, SaraBeth, teknofyl, Sharon in MD, Frank Palmer, concerned, Mr X, jimstaro, eastvan, lcbo, Inland, GreyHawk, jcitybone, Kayakbiker, optimo, lotlizard, Skid, gerardbellavita, wgard, jane123, Hastur, Yamara, RElland, newtonsthird, exmearden, FunkyEntropy, Marcus Junius Brutus, Savvy813, Tarantula Lady, HiBob, Ginny in CO, pacotrey, sodalis, dazed in pa, loggersbrat, LithiumCola, biffmush, LisainNYC, Ekaterin, ZinZen, Erevann, Alan Arizona, Snud, Sister Havana, noweasels, CJnyc, begone, debedb, lgmcp, forbodyandmind, lcork, Mother Mags, makeitstop, occams hatchet, Coherent Viewpoint, kovie, dus7, Showman, keefer55, Nance, trashablanca, downunder newt, gwilson, potownman, MissInformation, Icy, steve nelson, mcronan, Compound F, Debbie in ME, Keone Michaels, PatsBard, cas2, sherlyle, DrSpalding, 417els, Clytemnestra, tung sol, BlueInARedState, DC Scott, dopper0189, rl en france, Yellow Canary, Hear Our Voices, kestrel9000, smokeymonkey, buhdydharma, The Wizard, fromer, poichick, a gnostic, TheBlaz, hideinplainsight, SarekOfVulcan, KozmoD, Blue Wind, DarkestHour, tecampbell, birdbrain64, global citizen, Lashe, jasonbl, ekruegr, gooderservice, uniqity, gatorcog, nilocjin, Bush Bites, SadieSue, imabluemerkin, NC Dem, FireCrow, FatPath, joe shikspack, old possum, NearlyNormal, bleeding heart, Preston S, el cid, ZombyWoof, totallynext, Unitary Moonbat, Andy30tx, middleagedhousewife, pfeffermuse, justiceputnam, llbear, raindrop, spotDawa, rsie, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, FiddleDeeDee, va dare, viriginia liberal, suspiciousmind, Lovo, Stripe, means are the ends, Dreaming of Better Days, kurt, MadMs, Jbeaudill, shaharazade, Statusquomustgo, ebs42, kurious, bstotts, Snarcalita, louavul, thepdxbikerboy, AllanTBG, mapman, Cartoon Messiah, Aaa T Tudeattack, NonnyO, BentLiberal, seabos84, One Pissed Off Liberal, Sansouci, old wobbly, J Royce, c0wfunk, ailanthus, mcwafflestix, Cronesense, hockeyrules, Wanda517, Loudoun County Dem, oklacoma dem, moodyinsavannah, SemDem, ricsec7, offgrid, UU VIEW, suburi, dallasdave, drbloodaxe, Alfonso Nevarez, yoduuuh do or do not, Sam from Ithaca, Allogenes, edsbrooklyn, FishOutofWater, Busted Flat in Baton Rouge, Nespolo, yowsta, HeartlandLiberal, Jimdotz, Calvin Jones and the 13th Apostle, Shadowmage36, bnasley, gatorbot, 99 Percent Pure, dolphin777, jayden, stratocasterman, vbdietz, crose, DemMarineVet, netguyct, TheCorkBoard, Junglered1, jnhobbs, millwood, Moderation, jhop7, gchaucer2, rogereaton, uciguy30, 2ajpuu, journeyman, Got a Grip, echohotel330, madgranny, LWelsch, JML9999, tj iowa, TexasTwister, Captain Nimrod, kdnla, Endangered Alaskan Dem, Terra Mystica, mall teacher, rmonroe, Theghostofkarlafayetucker, Winter Rabbit, 123man, Miss Snarkypants, ExPat Zuzzguzz, FishBiscuit, Dem in the heart of Texas, rogerdaddy, RiverCityMadman, lisastar, JeffW, LightningMan, Hippokleides, pullbackthecurtain, wheelsme, RickMassimo, Phil N DeBlanc, middle child, rontun, scooter in brooklyn, zerone, Chilean Jew, Youffraita, AshesAllFallDown, dave1042, urban raptor, Renaissance Man, mind unseen, wagdog, Akonitum, Randgrithr, Oliver W Holmes the 3rd, hilllady, Greasy Grant, Mardish, Haplogroup V, Cassandra Waites, geomoo, Jake Williams, MsWings, Quicksilver2723, TheLoneliestMonk, Punditcrat, gildareed, mofembot, noddem, royalscam, kyril, bubbalie 517, phrogge prince, Alex Z, ht dave, CA Libertarian, xysea, GoracleFan, DixieDishrag, omegajew, Dewey Kneadleeders, Uncle Bob, BYw, nklein, little liberal, ScienceRocks, CatfishBlues, allie123, Executive Odor, sargoth, marketgeek, magicsister, Robobagpiper, palantir, Redneck Liberal, debheadley, Scubaval, Anjana, shortgirl, jlms qkw, TulsaDemocrat, legendmn, satanicpanic, wv voice of reason, bottsimons, 1BQ, multilee, Rhysling, WhizKid331, arainsb123, Texanomaly, rsmpdx, james1108, Unseen majority, sarah coletta, gdwtch52, An Affirming Flame, ManahManah, cantelow, eltee, CanyonWren, dark daze, Carey A, SciVo, ocdemgal49, cultural worker, zip95843, EquationDoc, Fixed Point Theorem, polara, Fawkes, DefendOurConstitution, politicalrunt, Daily Activist, virginwoolf, Virginian in Spain, UnaSpenser, Karin J, MKSinSA, MySobriquet, isucyclones94, soms, paintitblue, kevinpdx, Craig Hickman, Shuddering Noise Machine, Shelley99, Joeytj, IreGyre, notksanymore, VALuddite, vadasz, sherijr, fitz2, FundaMental Transformation, BA BarackUS, futureliveshere, voila, Wisteacher, AussieJo, eva lobach, JAMill, Chris in West Seattle, gihrose, Hunter Huxley, Clyde the Cat, rossir, NCrissieB, Amber6541, BigVegan, Fairy Tale, dalys, Bobs Telecaster, TruthandTrust, Progressive Sconny, BrighidG, mamamorgaine, darsh, Alohilani, Caringthinkingperson, rb137, NMDad, rasher, mrs hops, Gut Check, TDreamer, ArtSchmart, veracityus, LaughingPlanet, ChicagoPat, NJpeach, Dirk Thrust, nsfbr, stonepier, insomniakv, CandyKat, KayEmarr, The Free Agent, OldPhart, hjamil, fleisch, rrussell, citizen31, felix qui cautus, kemetcc, gnomer, msmo1918, Kate Patience, JJC, lostmypassword, xhibi, Dave1955, BonnieSchlitz, quelclaire, slyle

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site