Daily Kos

Hey, read *this*, Einstein!

Sat Jul 12, 2008 at 08:59:24 PM PDT

This is a silly Saturday night diary with limited political relevance and less redeeming social value, but I think it might be fun.  Actually, it is two small games in one, so it might be double the fun.

I expect that others have thoroughly plowed this intellectual ground before, but I haven't, and it's more fun to be told a story than to sift through dry books looking for it.  So, here we go:

The surnames (occasionally with given names) of some people, like Albert Einstein, have become shortcuts in our culture for certain characteristics.  To call someone "Einstein" -- but, oddly, not Galileo or Newton -- is to call them a genius.  To call them a "Rembrandt" -- but, oddly, not Picasso or van Gogh or Michelangelo -- is to call them a great artist.  To call them "Benedict Arnold" -- but not, say, Joe Lieberman -- is to call them a traitor.

I'm not sure what this class of linguistic appellations is called, but it may have something to do with metonymy as well as possibly prototypes and exemplars.  (Someone here will know.)

So, your task, you Einsteins, is as follows:

(1) Let's come up with a definitive list of names that serve this function in common American English -- or through in foreign examples if you'd like, I'm easy -- as well as (in the case of Picasso versus Rembrandt), names that seem like they would have made more sense as the prime example for that characteristic or role.

(2) OK, so much for the intellectual part.  Now for the fun, and perhaps political, part.  Let's propose some more metonymic (I'll change that term when someone tells me what the right one is) names that aren't yet in popular usage.

  (a) Some of these names should apply to society in general.

  (b) Some of these names should apply to the netroots, and especially our own beloved Daily Kos.

  (c) Names under (b) should not be insulting unless it is very, very funny.

Oh, the third task is: have fun.

Poll

My favorite phrase using someone's name in this manner is:

13%7 votes
1%1 votes
5%3 votes
15%8 votes
23%12 votes
5%3 votes
33%17 votes

| 51 votes | Vote | Results

Tags: metonyms, community, fun, creative (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 127 comments

Permalink | 127 comments