Skip to main content

Cross Posted at Legal Schnauzer

How bad was the recent appellate ruling that upheld the convictions of former Alabama Governor Don Siegelman and former HealthSouth CEO Richard Scrushy?

So bad that even a lawyer publicly criticized it.

Experience has taught me that some lawyers will, in private, admit that our justice system is a mess. Some, in hushed tones, will even tell you about specific lawyers they know to be shysters and judges they know to be corrupt.

But a lawyer criticize the system in a public forum? That's real man bites dog stuff.

I'm guessing there are several reasons for that. One, most lawyers make a far better living in the legal profession than they would make in another field of endeavor--say, journalism. Two, angry judges can take quite a toll on a lawyer and his clients in the courtroom--over time that can cause the bottom line of a law practice to take a serious hit. And three, I suspect state bar associations have interesting ways of making life miserable for a lawyer who dares to publicly pull the mask off the legal beast.

So there are many factors that discourage lawyers from rocking the professional boat. But Julian McPhillips, a prominent attorney in Montgomery, Alabama, was so disgusted by the ruling on the Siegelman/Scrushy appeal that he decided to rock the boat anyway--at least a little bit.

Some might say that McPhillips is not an objective observer in this case. He is a longtime Democrat, running for the U.S. Senate in 2002, and he has represented Richard Scrushy. But McPhillips makes a number of compelling points about the ruling from the U.S. 11th Circuit Court of Appeals. In the end, he actually goes easy on the court.

Given the all-Republican makeup of the three-judge panel, we've noted that the Siegelman team probably expected to be cheated. McPhillips apparently was thinking along the same lines:

To say the court split hairs, bent over backward to reach ill-founded conclusions and ignored important issues is a vast understatement.

The court also established a bad precedent in glossing over out-of-court juror e-mails, which revealed great bias of the jurors involved. The trial court dismissed these e-mails without investigation, and the 11th Circuit ignored this oversight.

McPhillips says the appellate court got it wrong on the central issue in the Siegelman case: Was there an explicit quid pro quo, a something-for-something agreement, as required by law?

The 11th Circuit also split hairs in distinguishing the difference between "explicit" and "express" on the quid pro quo issue. That is, was there enough evidence of "you scratch my back and I'll scratch yours?" The court said there was sufficient circumstantial evidence, primarily the contribution itself.

Yet, it is undisputed that former Siegelman aide Nick Bailey, a government witness, never witnessed a single conversation between Siegelman and Scrushy indicating agreement for a Certificate of Need Board seat in return for a lottery fund contribution. Remember, also, the goal of the lottery was to promote public education, not the election of Siegelman.

Even the 11th Circuit was strained, bending over backward, to explain the difference between the alleged Siegelman-Scrushy bribery and the widespread practice of a politician doing a favor for a contributor.

McPhillips points out that neither Siegelman nor Scrushy were newbies to the area of political contributions. So it's hard to figure why either would knowingly violate the law:

It is significant that Siegelman was a former Alabama secretary of state, attorney general, lieutenant governor and governor. He was no bumbling novice. Through his 20 years of government service, he learned well the parameters of permissible behavior. He knew well what was kosher in the murky field of contributions and appointments. Neither Siegelman nor Scrushy possessed the most remote idea that what they were doing was illegal--or that what they were convicted of was illegal.

Who is the biggest loser from the 11th Circuit's warped reasoning? McPhillips has some disquieting thoughts on that subject:

Sadly, the biggest casualty resulting from this conviction and affirmation by the 11th Circuit is the Alabama and national political system. In the past, children yearned to be governor of a state or president of the United States. College-age students found excitement in the political process and saw political power as a means to achieve worthy results, such as improved education for all students, regardless of station in life.

Today, with this conviction and affirmation, few people with sense would want to be governor, recognizing that, while politics is the vehicle for election, politics also makes you a target for prosecution for campaign contributions you receive. The bigger you are politically, the more you are "big game." Regrettably, but undoubtedly, our judicial and political systems are broken.

For another take on the Siegelman appellate ruling, check out Glynn Wilson's analysis at Locust Fork News-Journal.

As for McPhillips, I applaud his willingness to stand up and criticize a clearly botched ruling. But because he's a lawyer, he still has to pull his punches somewhat.

I'm not a lawyer, and I don't have to pull any punches. We've been studying the 68-page ruling and will present a detailed critique in the coming days.

Our conclusion? The three judges on the 11th-Circuit panel pulled a colossal screw job. And we will show you exactly how they did it.

Originally posted to RogerShuler on Mon Mar 23, 2009 at 06:47 PM PDT.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Joe Bob, chuck utzman, vicki, Piotr, ROGNM, Ray Radlein, Common Sense Mainer, murphy, Buckeye BattleCry, Rayne, copymark, Killer, XOVER, Mountain Don, Nina Katarina, jimG, Gooserock, am, drmonkey, kainah, mattman, sacrelicious, bosdcla14, Robespierrette, TechBob, Emerson, dengre, tommurphy, Shockwave, MsSpentyouth, LynChi, Hesiod, LEP, GayHillbilly, Midwest Meg, eeff, Mnemosyne, figdish, recentdemocrat, robkallopednews, Woody, frisco, marjo, RFK Lives, SallyCat, wenchacha, MarkInSanFran, bumblebums, expatjourno, Birdman, dpc, dadanation, 88kathy, conchita, EricS, kalihikane, wonkydonkey, magnetics, groggy, whenwego, OCD, jiffykeen, ask, macleme, peace voter, Mlle Orignalmale, KMc, Xapulin, chuckvw, buckhorn okie, roses, khloemi, Tejas Geek, luku, superba, BruinKid, PeteZerria, Nate Roberts, KCBearcat, bustacap, Cedwyn, high uintas, Alna Dem, admiralh, celticshel, OldYellerDog, wader, NMRed, scorpiorising, psnyder, danthrax, TexDem, oldjohnbrown, gmb, grannyhelen, Ready2fight, Chirons apprentice, TX Scotia, Greg in TN, papercut, arielle, faithnomore, inclusiveheart, Oaktown Girl, Matt Esler, econlibVA, AllisonInSeattle, tomjones, JayDean, CanYouBeAngryAndStillDream, rambler american, Daddy Bartholomew, Josiah Bartlett, rmx2630, Dave in RI, greeseyparrot, wolverinethad, sawgrass727, Gowrie Gal, skippythebox, luvmovies2000, nehark, Dirk McQuigley, chumley, humphrey, bloomer 101, Bluesee, Tarindel, marina, radarlady, 3goldens, beagledad, DianeNYS, Ckntfld, enough, LarisaW, seesdifferent, revbludge, HudsonValleyMark, Cook, Halcyon, irate, PBen, electricgrendel, JohnB47, panicbean, ajsuited, basquebob, david78209, Laurence Lewis, kldave, reflectionsv37, lennysfo, GUGA, pandawoman, ladylib, GreyHawk, smkngman, lotlizard, Little Lulu, libbie, lasky57, jane123, kaliope, Isara, deep, AnotherMassachusettsLiberal, Marcus Junius Brutus, Shotput8, wiscmass, Cory Bantic, Lindy, Ekaterin, proudprogressiveCA, SocioSam, jeffinalabama, Snud, zozie, kathny, ChuckInReno, fhcec, xaxnar, coffeeinamrica, Jim P, begone, Abacab, Philpm, SoulCatcher, martini, Showman, trashablanca, Icy, Nightprowlkitty, Orinoco, judyzola, tarheelblue, Keone Michaels, sherlyle, tung sol, ferallike, BlueInARedState, trentinca, quotemstr, Russgirl, Ellicatt, Hear Our Voices, InsultComicDog, ccmask, deha, rhetoricus, triv33, tecampbell, MJ via Chicago, Lashe, nonnie9999, uniqity, imabluemerkin, Clifflyon, NC Dem, Caoimhin Laochdha, JVolvo, armadillo, sceptical observer, Demena, snafubar, OMwordTHRUdaFOG, ER Doc, Pilgrim X, SingerInTheChoir, rsie, Timothy J, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, kurt, bstotts, Snarcalita, thatvisionthing, blueintheface, Little, illusionmajik, Aaa T Tudeattack, embra, GoldnI, One Pissed Off Liberal, RagingGurrl, marykk, Haningchadus14, Ann Galloway, MrChip, gailwax, Wide Awake in NJ, gloriana, terryhallinan, FishOutofWater, yowsta, Cofcos, HeartlandLiberal, greenchiledem, dclawyer06, MonsterSound, RosyFinch, Seneca Doane, Kentucky Kid, ca democrat, Heyroot, Aunt Martha, vbdietz, albaum, quadmom, Uberbah, jnhobbs, dryfoo, millwood, Moderation, jhop7, rogereaton, madgranny, M Sullivan, Korkenzieher, cacamp, vet, wuod kwatch, Terra Mystica, Empower Ink, Red no more, sand805, MKinTN, tfatha, fayeforcure, rogerdaddy, lisastar, RickMassimo, weegeeone, califdem, NewDealer, Fe Bongolan, golconda2, Wes Opinion, billvb, jakebob, Happy Days, Lujane, Cassandra Waites, toddpw, geomoo, pickandshovel, TokenLiberal, Jeff Y, catly, mnguy66, Thought Crime, a lien on everything, SmileySam, LaFajita, LCA, Abra Crabcakeya, luckylizard, chalatenango, bitchinabluestreak, BYw, red 83, allie123, binkycat, billybam, lgcap, cameoanne, 1BQ, meatwad420, ge0rge, ewmorr, bsmechanic, CanyonWren, RustyCannon, dark daze, janmtairy, Partisan Progressive, velvet blasphemy, earicicle, Hopeful Monster, babajimbob, followyourbliss, ZilV, deedogg, soms, MooseHB, obscuresportsquarterly, Denise Oliver Velez, The BBQ Chicken Madness, IreGyre, realwischeese, netgui68, Lava20, serecovery, Denversk, Leftcandid, SweetMartha, Larsstephens, Just Bob, cricket456, glaukopis, dalys, TruthandTrust, Phaseshift360, marabout40, pyegar, ArtSchmart, LaughingPlanet, robertacker13, kjoftherock, fidellio, CcVenussPromise, chrome327, msmo1918, your neighbor, 2questions, Man from Wasichustan, Balanz, RJP9999, ctlrick, samanthab, juturna, Quijibow, plays in dirt, rja, elengul, MsGrin, ericlewis0, Floande, Loose Fur, josebrwn, alexa100, jeanma, slice, gobears2000, Colorado is the Shiznit, Quite Contrary, sfcouple, thebluecrayon, republicans scare me, FarWestGirl, misskitty64, rvdee, Haf2Read, Wolf10, gregbas, whaddaya

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site