Skip to main content

I haven't seen this anywhere else...

In her maiden Supreme Court appearance last week, Justice Sonia Sotomayor made a provocative comment that probed the foundations of corporate law.

During arguments in a campaign-finance case, the court's majority conservatives seemed persuaded that corporations have broad First Amendment rights and that recent precedents upholding limits on corporate political spending should be overruled.

But Justice Sotomayor suggested the majority might have it all wrong -- and that instead the court should reconsider the 19th century rulings that first afforded corporations the same rights flesh-and-blood people have.

Judges "created corporations as persons, gave birth to corporations as persons," she said. "There could be an argument made that that was the court's error to start with...[imbuing] a creature of state law with human characteristics."


If this is a real hint of her views on this matter than I think we have to applaud. Even if it doesn't change the ultimate ruling in this particular case, it is still good to have a new Justice who questions the corrupt foundation of law regarding the relationship between corporations and the government.

Of course, some people's heads started steaming when they heard her talk about the Santa Clara decision being a "mistake".

"I don't want to draw too much from one comment," says Todd Gaziano, director of the Center for Legal and Judicial Studies at the conservative Heritage Foundation. But it "doesn't give me a lot of confidence that she respects the corporate form and the type of rights that it should be afforded."

The linked article has a very good background on the history of Corporate Personhood. It even mentions the little discussed (outside liberal circles) fact that the original court case on this matter (Southern Pacific Railroad v. Santa Clara County) did not actually address this issue but instead that the whole foundation of "corporations are people" argument were the results of an off hand remark by the then chief justice that was written down by the court reporter as if it were part of the official decision.

Justice Kennedy, however, is not so enlightened:

On today's court, the direction Justice Sotomayor suggested is unlikely to prevail. During arguments, the court's conservative justices seem to view corporate political spending as beneficial to the democratic process. "Corporations have lots of knowledge about environment, transportation issues, and you are silencing them during the election," Justice Anthony Kennedy said during arguments last week.

Originally posted to Chris Andersen on Thu Sep 17, 2009 at 02:30 PM PDT.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

skybluewater, Sharoney, JUSIPER, jm1963, chase, fly, seamus, nitpicker, bink, Thumb, Jett, JekyllnHyde, davej, Superskepticalman, cdreid, Angie in WA State, KySeattle, Alfred E Newman, vicki, KeithH, Terri, tmo, dwellscho, SteveLCo, coral, herb superb, From the choir, raboof, Paleo, Sean Robertson, AggieDemocrat, Josh Prophet, Chi, catdevotee, sny, Phoenix Woman, itsbenj, Odysseus, thinkdouble, murphy, ogre, RW, Rayne, raatz, SarahLee, mwm341, Marie, patachon, Timaeus, El Zmuenga, Dounia, Trendar, Better Days, gogol, glitterscale, gustafgrapple, Greenkermie in AZ, rhfactor, tikkun, mickT, Geenius at Wrok, abarefootboy, Mountain Don, Nina Katarina, Dem 724, HarlanNY, whataboutbob, tiponeill, maynard, saraswati, madmsf, drmonkey, angrycalifornian, theboz, janinsanfran, RunawayRose, Bob Love, DebtorsPrison, scrape, sphealey, karlpk, dengre, tommurphy, MouseThatRoared, musicalhair, MsSpentyouth, Wintermute, billlaurelMD, cotterperson, meg, CanMan, hyperstation, primeq, mainely49, eeff, Mnemosyne, TX Unmuzzled, Pompatus, route66, figdish, Voodoo, frisco, dash888, caliberal, RFK Lives, SallyCat, shpilk, object16, pollyusa, MarkInSanFran, mataliandy, cgilbert01, Poika, jancw, marge, hubcap, zeitshabba, Creosote, AbyssAndApex, silence, Heart of the Rockies, dcbill, dpc, Morgana, maggiemae, DJ Adequate, bara, eyeswideopen, Gustogirl, srbaxley, EvieCZ, TheMomCat, concernedamerican, Blue Patriot Woman, ReneInOregon, joe m, bronte17, 88kathy, conchita, medaka, litho, Nellcote, Einsteinia, SamSinister, Cassandra77, elveta, nyceve, understandinglife, sja, djMikulec, Baldwiny, Loquatrix, DaleA, ask, Morague, CoolOnion, CatFelyne, KMc, boadicea, Cool Blue Reason, mxwing, scamp, Porfiry, repeat, mkfarkus, barath, Transmission, farmerhunt, roses, Frederick Clarkson, pedrito, dgb, bobinson, javelina, Ignacio Magaloni, kanuk, oceanspray, itsmitch, nargel, RanxeroxVox, luku, drdave, Dem in Knoxville, House, exconservative, jennifree2bme, sngmama, jalbert, egarratt, Nate Roberts, Iberian, bustacap, Beelzebud, Cedwyn, arreay, antirove, Chrisfs, OutOfManyOne, wader, kosophile, Redfire, Braindead, menodoc, caseynm, nicolas, scorpiorising, psnyder, hangingchad, danthrax, TexDem, oldjohnbrown, Dallasdoc, Subversive, Dr Colossus, jlynne, Miss Jones, DeadB0y, Urizen, pat bunny, StuartZ, leevank, brainwave, gmb, grannyhelen, alivingston, Drew J Jones, hoolia, Guinho, peternight, texasmom, pdl ithaca, Nemagaiq, joan reports, Penny Century, noveocanes, defluxion10, cat chew, betson08, snakelass, applegal, Timbuk3, lcrp, sarakandel, forrest, Pohjola, Brian82, Democratic Hawk, Sophie Amrain, MeToo, fritzrth, walkshills, econlibVA, Occulus, djtyg, ybruti, jesses, Curt Matlock, KellyB, skywalker, randallt, smartgo, WisVoter, parryander, lonespark, Lefty Mama, KayCeSF, Vicky, tomjones, DrReason, JayDean, Marcus L Salyer, Wife of Bath, SanDiegoDem, Deward Hastings, Mosquito Pilot, jcrit, xyz, TexasLefty, 3cardmonty, moggie12, lyvwyr101, bablhous, valadon, rickeagle, Daddy Bartholomew, eztempo, Josiah Bartlett, Sybil Liberty, egmacrae, thereisnospoon, TekBoss, Armand451, guyermo, Frank Vyan Walton, donailin, oortdust, BoogieMama, sawgrass727, Gowrie Gal, dvx, sxwarren, Big Tex, rapala, averageyoungman, greenskeeper, nehark, Dirk McQuigley, vcmvo2, Crazycab214, joanneleon, ExStr8, tovan, mediaprisoner, ms in la, historys mysteries, Simian, Tarindel, saodl, marina, radarlady, 3goldens, rini, Jim Hill, Tinfoil Hat, TxTiger, IamtheReason, TexasTom, DianeNYS, McCline36, m16eib, Five of Diamonds, Othniel, LarisaW, baccaruda, CTPatriot, sangemon, arnott, b tex, zeuspapa, Cook, PBen, offred, KnotIookin, Alice Venturi, Flint, willibro, grimjc, kitchen sink think tank, Hotspur18, wpchas, jhutson, elkhunter, frandor55, DocGonzo, ZappoDave, ajsuited, Robin7459, RequestedUsername, TN yellow dog, karpinsky, juliesie, stagemom, Brooke In Seattle, YucatanMan, Dobber, trinityfly, Kevskos, LindaR, Gary Norton, kldave, melissa p, reflectionsv37, boofdah, eru, Mz Kleen, howardfromUSA, mattwynn, owlbear1, GUGA, Chaoslillith, NLinStPaul, cfk, LNK, SaraBeth, Pam from Calif, truebeliever, JoieDe, Mr X, jorndorff, pandawoman, uato carabau, jimreyn, thered1, Old Hippie, where4art, aaraujo, John DE, Inland, Gordon20024, Burned, Kayakbiker, rosabw, Overseas, Ice Blue, Little Lulu, gerardbellavita, ivorybill, markdd, bmaples, lasky57, Rex Freedom, chasewho, Isara, Cyber Kat, woobie, brentut5, dspivak, Bob B, minidriver, Savvy813, collapse, shiobhan, farmergiles, Aint Supposed to Die a Natural Death, FightTheFuture, neroden, alisonc, wiscmass, FindingMyVoice, Lisa Lockwood, deepsouthdoug, dsteffen, Cory Bantic, Rogneid, rsr, playtonjr, Hannibal, Spathiphyllum, empathy, sgary, jct, murasaki, JanF, Erevann, timba, Snud, Land of Enchantment, kathny, jay23, Sister Havana, accio, fhcec, bently, xaxnar, Jim R, Jim P, Wayneman, begone, Mehitabel9, skywriter, SoulCatcher, aimzzz, Mother Mags, martini, LeftOverAmerica, Tismo70, SoniaS, hlee1169, snazzzybird, danmac, BalanceSeeker, BobzCat, LeighAnn, tarheelblue, Patriot Daily News Clearinghouse, Keone Michaels, ainwa, myboo, Sam the Wolfdog, vigilant meerkat, sherlyle, cybersaur, 417els, WhyWhat, Clytemnestra, ferallike, Annilow, BlueInARedState, emeraldmaiden, DC Scott, Gorette, Yellow Canary, seefleur, buhdydharma, KenBee, Loonesta, The Wizard, fromer, Magnifico, johnsonwax, Texas Blue Dot, Wary, armadill, greenearth, Sassy725, Lefty Coaster, goodasgold, SherriG, bren, NBBooks, DarkestHour, TalkieToaster, tecampbell, birdbrain64, Tanya, A Siegel, Lashe, 4Freedom, gpoutney, cRedd, bubbanomics, Dissentinator, gatorcog, nilocjin, Libby Shaw, pi1304, imabluemerkin, justalittlebitcrazy, tapestry, Doctor Frog, NC Dem, real world chick, Sagebrush Bob, FakeNews, NewAmericanLeft, CF Perez, el cid, MarciaJ720, ZombyWoof, ER Doc, Randolph06, Dinclusin, dirtfarmer, doinaheckuvanutjob, middleagedhousewife, quantumspin, sharilynn, Pilgrim X, engine17, blitz boy, dirkster42, rage, rsie, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, va dare, fiddlingnero, Stripe, means are the ends, cherryXXX69, kurt, blueness, Statusquomustgo, Bernie68, louavul, pseudopod, christomento, markthshark, illusionmajik, OHdog, Aaa T Tudeattack, NonnyO, AntKat, BentLiberal, DBunn, eastmt, ammasdarling, bigchin, One Pissed Off Liberal, old wobbly, Wordie, Noor B, Boreal Ecologist, out of left field, lightfoot, Polacolor, asilomar, nobody at all, Cronesense, Fredly, Ann Galloway, Loudoun County Dem, Mr K, byDesign, blue armadillo, dmh44, ninkasi23, moodyinsavannah, grelinda, mmaureen7, LV Pol Girl, momoaizo, slb36cornell, DAO, gloriana, moosely2006, aravir, threegoal, Alfonso Nevarez, Outrider, Foxwizard, Proud Moonbat, FishOutofWater, power2truth, DvCM, rgjdmls, Mary Mike, la urracca, wildweasels, Nespolo, ebiker, Cofcos, HeartlandLiberal, starfall18, noofsh, blackeyedsusan, Jimdotz, terabytes, ezdidit, Calvin Jones and the 13th Apostle, lurks a lot, ilex, sfbob, dissonantdissident, MonsterSound, Unbozo, aliasalias, newpioneer, TK1, masslib, bnasley, gatorbot, malharden, Canyon Lefty, Seneca Doane, artisan, getlost, Heyroot, chicago jeff, vbdietz, albaum, tcdup, SeaTurtle, thursdays child, jnhobbs, millwood, Moderation, Jack the R, jhop7, carpunder, owl06, pioneer111, Rumarhazzit, uciguy30, technolinguist, madgranny, number six, M Sullivan, ImpeachKingBushII, JML9999, Korkenzieher, keikekaze, eyesoars, sable, Predictor, oxon, mall teacher, TomP, Empower Ink, gizmo59, pidge not midge, JDWolverton, GANJA, FirstValuesThenIssues, fayeforcure, Dem in the heart of Texas, mayrose, Shane Hensinger, seriously70, mconvente, gzodik, TimetoGovern, left turn, condorcet, Ms Citizen, Mr SeeMore, ShadowSD, DraftChickenHawks, RickMassimo, Concern Troll, dotster, TheFatLadySings, Phil N DeBlanc, ScottyUrb, karin x, Cordwainer, Yemtex, mamamedusa, shanay, BlueTape, Youffraita, spencerh, Involuntary Exile, VA gentlewoman, NuclearJo, treesrock, mcthatch, jamess, beltane, monkeybrainpolitics, pkohan, alliedoc, kaolin, LearningCurve, Lujane, rssrai, tofumagoo, pamelabrown, Ministerbruce, boatjones, Cassandra Waites, smartdemmg, Jake Williams, pickandshovel, exMnLiberal, TokenLiberal, Quicksilver2723, Jeff Y, rubine, mofembot, Seamus D, S C B, change the Be, the new, Gemina13, pragprogress, meldroc, o the umanity, jsb1000, bob zimway, luckylizard, mikeymike68, echatwa, a night owl, James Kresnik, Parthenia, xysea, DixieDishrag, BYw, Keninoakland, eddienutzak, Karl Rover, Blueslide, lenzy1000, Tross, allie123, priceman, Zikar, Guadalupe59, caps lock on, pilotmama, Mayfly, SpiffPeters, Yoshi En Son, dmhlt 66, Mike Taylor, revelwoodie, Robinswing, greenpunx, Diogenes2008, papicek, Reframing the Debate, statsone, Leo in NJ, fidel, squarewheel, ZhenRen, forgore, fayea, lostboyjim, oldliberal, legendmn, 4km, Fiddlegirl, clent, FudgeFighter, maggiejean, lancecote, cameoanne, Tom Enever, 1BQ, malibu1964, Bule Betawi, jjackso1, multilee, pileta, WhizKid331, nippersdad, Ripeness Is All, Stephen Daugherty, unwillingsuburbanite, Mr Tentacle, DontTaseMeBro, BennyToothpick, Searching for Pericles, driftwood, Neon Vincent, MTmarilyn, Ravenstream, rsmpdx, UkieOli, ARS, Valatius, emboyo, litoralis, tbird, No Gods No Masters, snackdoodle, Magick Maven, Pariah Dog, socalmonk, PapiGonzo, An Affirming Flame, wikoogle, cantelow, bsmechanic, Notus, RustyCannon, mudgod, Nebraskablue, Rabbithead, Jdories, Jack Danger, weltshmertz, Gorilla in the room, notrouble, Partisan Progressive, slaney black, h bridges, velvet blasphemy, bigmikek7, mrchumchum, MingPicket, cn4st4datrees, Yalin, zackamac, WobegonGal, gchap33, WorkingClassHero, DefendOurConstitution, jmknapp53, wmdrpa, Night Train, jabuhrer, BDsTrinity, followyourbliss, worldly1, marzook, DHinIA, TheOpinionGuy, ZilV, bfitzinAR, soms, Lopez99, papahaha, igwealth5tm, jazzence, kw7777777, obscuresportsquarterly, sanglug, Denise Oliver Velez, deutschluz, Shelley99, Keith Pickering, Joeytj, Mom in Maine, IreGyre, Eyz, XNeeOhCon, realwischeese, PhotogHog, CityLightsLover, stevenwag, Lava20, vadasz, whatnext, RoCali, 57andFemale, maxzj05, jimmylutherking, serecovery, Knarfc, brushysage, sherijr, mcnamarm, Bene Gesserit1, mahakali overdrive, astral66, schnecke21, futureliveshere, math4barack, Black Kos, Leftcandid, RogerDodger, Barackthestablishment, Super Grover, Cleopatra, Larsstephens, Words In Action, ozarkspark, EdwardsAvenger, lh114, ruscle, kfd313, Just Bob, bohemian darling, gohmak, cezariusz, Lazar, Its the Supreme Court Stupid, ladygreenslippers, dalys, parse this, smileycreek, swaminathan, raf, PrincessPinkyPie, coppercelt, BrighidG, hillgiant, mudmanor, CajunBoyLgb, pyegar, p gorden lippy, hippiechick13, veracityus, Pebbles, LaughingPlanet, The Jester, eXtina, brunoboy, gramofsam1, amk for obama, PurpleMyst, kjoftherock, Interceptor7, fidellio, TheWesternSun, DrFerbie, CS11, cms126, Tcoopy, LeanneB, Crabby Abbey, felix qui cautus, msmo1918, ko62, LA Person, Lost and Found, LadyParadox, freeport beach PA, ronin122, JJC, Simple, legalchic, leftist vegetarian patriot, ATFILLINOIS, BonnieSchlitz, Balanz, RJP9999, SpawnOfJerry, melpomene1, JoanMar, Nurse Jeckell, tomnobombadil, pixxer, elginblt, ItsSimpleSimon, paradise50, ebbv, DrFitz, Jaimas, WattleBreakfast, albrt, JRandomPoster, plays in dirt, Johnny Q, shel3364, Publius2008, Weaselina, roystah

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.