Skip to main content

(I am a blogger fellow for Brave New Films on their Sick For Profit campaign.  Follow us on Facebook.)

A wild story out of Maine.

Anthem Health Plans of Maine, a subsidiary of WellPoint, is suing the state because they want to increase premium rates by 18.5% on their 12,000 individual insurance policy holders, so they can guarantee themselves a 3% profit margin.  This story shows how silly it would be to solely rely on regulation to rein in insurance industry practices.

Like many other states, Anthem Health Plans hold a monopoly on the individual insurance market in Maine, controlling 79% of all the plans.  Also like many other states, they are licensed to sell insurance through the Department of Insurance, who must clear all rate increases prior to implementation.  Originally, Anthem Health Plans were a nonprofit Blue Cross and Blue Shield corporation licensed to practice in Maine since 1939.  In 1999, Anthem bought the business and began to operate it as a for-profit company.  Since that point, Anthem has raised premium rates 10 times, and 8 of those times have been double-digit rate increases.

Jan-99: 20.4%
Nov-99: 15.7%
Jan-01: 23.5%
Feb-02: 12.7%
Jan-03: 3.4%
Mar-05: 14.5%
Mar-06: 16.3%
Jan-07: 16.7%
Jul-07: 1.3%
Jan-08: 12.5%

The average individual Maine rate-payer is paying four times as much for insurance than they did ten years ago.

But this isn't good enough for Anthem Health Plans.  They first proposed a 14.5% rate increase for its individual insurance products, then they revised it up to 18.1% and finally 18.5%.  This is an average increase.  Some plans would see increase of 24.5%, some 38.4%, and for its Preventive Care and Supplemental Care Accident rider, which is part of 1/3 of all their policies, Anthem proposed a rate increase of 58.2%.  This amounts to Maine consumers paying $12 million more in annual premium dollars for the exact same level of benefits.

Anthem isn't hurting for profit.  Their Maine operations have generated an average annual return of $70 million dollars over the last five years.  Anthem paid dividends to their parent company, WellPoint, of $75 million dollars last year alone, and $152 million since 2006.  Their nine highest-paid employees totaled over $4.3 million in compensation.  The individual market, while a smaller portion of their overall business, still generated $5.4 million in profit over the last two years.

The reason Anthem desires these rate raises is because their actuarial charts show they can guarantee a 3% profit through this increase.  That's an estimate, however, and in 8 of the last 10 years the profit margin achieved has actually been higher.  The Maine Superintendent of Insurance ruled in May 2009 that the 3% profit and risk margin sought was "excessive and unfairly discriminatory," as per the laws of the state, and instead approved a rate increase of 10.9% for Anthem.  Given the recession, the financial health of the company, and the years of large rate increases, there was no way she could approve anything higher.

So Anthem sued the state.  But not after filing revised rates at a 10.9% increase so they could get that going while they litigated for an even higher rate.

The Superintendent of Insurance explained in a court filing that there is no statute mandating that Maine must provide Anthem or any other insurer with a guaranteed profit.  Given Anthem's ability as a large operation to cut costs, just as any family must do during a recession, the Superintendent argued there is nothing preventing them from making a profit with a 10.9% rate of premium increase.  But Maine is under no obligation to guarantee one.  That would be a "socialized profit," which Anthem is asserting the right to without any legal basis in fact.  Furthermore, policyholders have contributed $17.4 million in profit to Anthem's bottom line over the past decade, which should be more than enough to cover potential losses from just the individual insurance line this year.

Anthem argued that they were discriminated against relative to other companies in Maine because one other individual insurer was provided a 3% profit and risk margin (that company, MEGA, asked for 2.2% rate increase back in 2007, a far different scenario).  This, the corporation said, violated their equal protection rights under the federal and state Constitutions.  This is a laughable claim, that the state must guarantee a profit for every insurance company licensed to provide a product.  It's nowhere to be found in the Maine Insurance Code, and the Superintendent of Insurance is allowed under Maine law to consider each company's situation individually.  In this case, she ruled that a 18.5% increase in premiums would be unfair and excessive.

This is a very revealing case.  Those arguing against a public option claim that insurance regulations alone will be sufficient to provide an affordable product for everyone.  Here's a case where Maine is attempting to regulate the industry, and the industry sues the state in an effort to grab more profit.  While claiming to be on the side of reform, they will fight tooth and nail, and can be expected to do so for every regulation in the national health care bill, right down the line.

Brave New Films has put together a video exposing the practices of Anthem and its parent company WellPoint.  You can send your friends in Maine the news about this lawsuit, to highlight this practice.  Maine Superior Court will consider this case on Wednesday.

From Maine Superior Court, Civil Action, Docket No. AP-09-29
Anthem Health Plans of Maine, Inc., d/b/a Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield v. Superintendent of Insurance, et al.

Rate this story up on Digg and Reddit.

...Arthur Delaney now has this story up at The Huffington Post.  He notes that Anthem lied about their individual market performance:

In its filing, Anthem said it had lost $3.7 million on its individual insurance products over the past five years. The AG says Anthem has made $5.4 million from individual consumers over the past two years, and points out that Anthem paid $75.7 million in dividends to WellPoint in 2008, $40.4 million in 2007, and $35.6 million in 2006. And its executives paid themselves pretty well, too.

Originally posted to dday on Mon Oct 05, 2009 at 10:30 AM PDT.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

VA6thDem, bink, mwjeepster, Hunter, cdreid, JWC, DeminNewJ, Terri, tmo, coral, RF, Bill in Portland Maine, Sean Robertson, Josh Prophet, hannah, filkertom, Phoenix Woman, eugene, lanshark, decembersue, copymark, teacherken, slinkerwink, Oregon Bear, Joan McCarter, Nina Katarina, flatiron, sen bob, Unstable Isotope, NYmom, am, BigOkie, mattman, sacrelicious, bosdcla14, TechBob, lobbygow, tommurphy, Heather in SFBay, Ed Drone, Wintermute, CaptUnderpants, shayera, mslat27, xynz, elfling, acuppajo, swamp possum, HarlemUSA, RFK Lives, lzachary, SallyCat, grndrush, bumblebums, Poika, jancw, marge, Ruth in OR, deaniac83, sardonyx, unterhausen, Scott in NAZ, DJ Adequate, eyeswideopen, DemInGeorgia, concernedamerican, emmanuel, bronte17, missLotus, cskendrick, cyberKosFan, understandinglife, djMikulec, Morague, CatFelyne, KMc, Cool Blue Reason, Dburn, mkfarkus, Paradox13, Aquarius40, chimpy, Ignacio Magaloni, nargel, Boston to Salem, Miss Blue, BruinKid, itskevin, Nate Roberts, ctsteve, Iberian, Southern Bell, TheCrank, dmsilev, Cedwyn, antirove, Alna Dem, admiralh, Chrisfs, wader, danthrax, Dallasdoc, Subversive, 2laneIA, alivingston, jsquared, JimWilson, desmoinesdem, NYFM, GN1927, Penny Century, On The Bus, lcrp, Pohjola, kfred, Hillbilly Dem, tomjones, CanYouBeAngryAndStillDream, Marcus L Salyer, xyz, d to the f, Daddy Bartholomew, rmx2630, bibble, thereisnospoon, pontechango, jeffwtux, Julie Gulden, Big Tex, averageyoungman, chumley, humphrey, mediaprisoner, maybeeso in michigan, radarlady, NoMoreLies, Ckntfld, m16eib, CTPatriot, Technowitch, PBen, clammyc, ajsuited, Brooke In Seattle, deega, reflectionsv37, ratzo, eru, Mz Kleen, bleeding blue, majcmb1, truebeliever, jimstaro, Sara R, Inland, libbie, jane123, Carnivorous Plantling, Isara, SBandini, wiscmass, sodalis, distraught, Rogneid, Hannibal, bookwoman, Detroit Mark, empathy, JanF, Alan Arizona, Snud, CJnyc, Philpm, SoulCatcher, martini, trashablanca, gwilson, BachFan, Do Tell, tarheelblue, Debbie in ME, Patriot Daily News Clearinghouse, myboo, rcbowman, vigilant meerkat, virgomusic, BlueInARedState, Malachite, Gorette, seefleur, buhdydharma, Wary, anastasia p, carolita, Lefty Coaster, Joshua Lyman, TalkieToaster, tecampbell, StrayCat, gooderservice, NearlyNormal, bleeding heart, myrealname, doinaheckuvanutjob, middleagedhousewife, Dagoril, Turbonerd, Dyana, a small quiet voice, IL clb, Helpless, profh, rsie, va dare, means are the ends, Dreaming of Better Days, kurt, revgerry, AmySmith, bstotts, expatyank, AndrewOG, pale cold, AmericanRiverCanyon, bigchin, One Pissed Off Liberal, Noor B, asilomar, Duke S, Blue Eyed Buddhist, mbaer, Loudoun County Dem, dmh44, moodyinsavannah, Dartagnan, DAO, gloriana, yoduuuh do or do not, Marcus Graly, edsbrooklyn, FishOutofWater, Mary Mike, la urracca, Cofcos, terabytes, Calvin Jones and the 13th Apostle, burlydee, sfbob, Ninepatch, bnasley, gatorbot, Kyle the Mainer, TerribleTom, HCKAD, Heyroot, vbdietz, Oreo, TheCorkBoard, thursdays child, jnhobbs, millwood, pioneer111, cececville, Rumarhazzit, Got a Grip, Dar Nirron, M Sullivan, JML9999, Captain Nimrod, MichiganGirl, Hens Teeth, Predictor, TomP, MKinTN, GANJA, Clio2, condorcet, DraftChickenHawks, ynp junkie, RickMassimo, sunshineonthebay, The Bagof Health and Politics, rontun, elwior, skohayes, pkohan, rssrai, royce, pamelabrown, TH Seed, Jake Williams, temptxan, sam storm, tlemon, luckylizard, James Kresnik, LogicBot, BYw, A Man Called Gloom, Athenocles, allie123, angelino, cactusflinthead, dzog, rhutcheson, GrannyOPhilly, shortgirl, papicek, MicahT0078, statsone, squarewheel, Tennessee Dave, TennesseeGurl, lostboyjim, LaFeminista, Celtic Merlin, clent, maggiejean, Bule Betawi, multilee, Calouste, An Affirming Flame, vs1skos, Dopeman, banjolele, forestgreen, Gorilla in the room, h bridges, jodygirl, indres, mrchumchum, markhaverty, Hopeful Monster, WorkingClassHero, DefendOurConstitution, John Shade, BDsTrinity, badger1968, igwealth5tm, RationalThoughtProcess, obscuresportsquarterly, Shelley99, IreGyre, RadioGirl, PhotogHog, MrDeadeye2U, 57andFemale, Bene Gesserit1, spicecakes69, etara, futureliveshere, Enrika, AkaEnragedGoddess, Tommymac, Larsstephens, ozarkspark, Amber6541, Just Bob, Lazar, dalys, brentbent, BrighidG, hillgiant, marabout40, Jampacked, pyegar, p gorden lippy, flitedocnm, Vacationland, dditt, drainflake77, leftywright, seanwhit, Obamacrat, Crabby Abbey, Devichan, wvmom, polar bear, gulfgal98, sullivanst, samanthab, Lady Libertine, ItsSimpleSimon, SlackwareGrrl, Mariken, scarlet slipper, juturna, shoelady, cai, JRandomPoster, sluggahjells, rja, swansong50, farbuska, dclarke, roystah, Murchadha, USHomeopath, Nada Lemming, DirkFunk, science nerd, Dems in 08, HylasBrook, not4morewars, Actbriniel, Jonze, andycon, slice, Nick Zouroudis, High Tide, theKgirls, kitchy7, Angelica Jo, BrowniesAreGood, CornSyrupAwareness, tlouise, the mom in the middle, StuffOfInterest, Fletcher Christensen, CaliKitty, mateohussein, Sand Hill Crane, Nicci August, Victory of Renegades, futilitismo, Liberal Panzer, trumpeter, lovespaper, PedalingPete, marleycat, Lorikeet, majii, Muskegon Critic, Wheever, KVoimakas, bamabikeguy, Laurie Gator, gokinsmen, merrily1000, fabina12, Sark Svemes, antooo, corvaire, Gay In Maine, ilovecheese, jediwashuu, The KINship Project, pensivelady, stuey46, Liberal Mole, Wom Bat, abetterperson, Ezekial 23 20, RLMiller, StepLeftStepForward, CoyoteMarti, jaebone, glower, Dakit, ThothXXI, boredwitnuts, James Robinson

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site