Skip to main content

The financial crisis is so complex and intractable that no one knows what to do about it. Get eleven economists together and get eleven different opinions. Right?

Well, no, not really.

You wouldn't know this from reading or watching the MSM, but among economists who've been right about most things over the last few years, there's virtual consensus. The "only answer" ( in the words in Joseph Stiglitz), "the obvious answer" (in the words of Dean Baker) is to nationalize the banks. While these leading economists might differ in the specifics, they agree that we need some form of government ownership.

Here's Nobel Prize winner Joseph Stiglitz

The U.S. government has poured in hundreds of billions of dollars to very little effect. It is very clear that the banks have failed. American citizens have become majority owners in a very large number of the major banks. But they have no control. Any system where there is a separation of ownership and control is a recipe for disaster.

Nationalization is the only answer. These banks are effectively bankrupt.

Here's Nobel Prize winner Paul Krugman

But bank stocks are worth so little these days — Citigroup and Bank of America have a combined market value of only $52 billion — that the ownership wouldn’t be partial: pumping in enough taxpayer money to make the banks sound would, in effect, turn them into publicly owned enterprises.

My response to this prospect is: so? If taxpayers are footing the bill for rescuing the banks, why shouldn’t they get ownership, at least until private buyers can be found? But the Obama administration appears to be tying itself in knots to avoid this outcome.

Here's Nouriel Roubini, who predicted the crisis in 2006.

You have to eventually nationalize U.S. banks, you have to take the problem by the horns,” Roubini told Bloomberg Television in Davos today. “In my view actually most of the U.S. banking system is insolvent.”

Here's iconoclastic financial analyst Nassim Nicholas Taleb

Bank nationalizations are “absolutely necessary” to stop them damaging the financial system further with more losses, said Nassim Nicholas Taleb, author of the best-selling finance book “The Black Swan.”

“You cannot trust the banks in taking risks,” Taleb said in an interview with Bloomberg Television in Davos. “We have a very strange situation in which it’s the worst of capitalism and socialism, a situation in which profits were privatized and losses were socialized. We taxpayers have the worst.”

Here's the Center for Economic and Policy Research's Dean Baker

The idea that we would give one more penny to this crew that has wrecked the economy should make taxpayers furious. There is a legitimate public interest in keeping the banks operating; a modern economy needs a well-operating financial system. But, there is zero public interest in rewarding shareholders and overpaid banks executives.

These executives bankrupted their banks and brought the economy down with them. They belong in an unemployment line not collecting multi-million dollar paychecks in their designer office suites.

The obvious answer is to take over the insolvent banks, just as we did with the insolvent S&Ls. The government should form an RTC as we did in the 80s, which would dispose of the assets over time, collecting as much money as possible for the government. The bankrupt banks would be restructured and sold back to the private sector as soon as their books were straightened out. The point of the exercise is not have the government run the banks, the point is to keep the financial system running without giving even more money to the richest people in the country.

Unfortunately, none of these economists works for the Obama administration, which has rejected nationalization for ideological reasons:

Explicit nationalization of financial companies has little support among key Obama officials, sources said. Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner and top White House economic adviser Lawrence Summers think governments make poor bank managers and cannot efficiently manage a vast number of institutions, according to some of their associates.

Poor bank managers compared to whom? The banks right now are essentially bankrupt; obviously the current managers could have done a wee bit better.

Here's Geithner:

"We have a financial system that is run by private shareholders, managed by private institutions, and we'd like to do our best to preserve that system."

Yet right now American taxpayers are majority shareholders in many banks. What we don't have is control.

Obama seems to have settled of a plan that try to get wealthy private investors to buy toxic assets by using taxpayer money to protect them from risk.

The plan, I fear, won't work. And Obama is underestimating how poorly it will go over. Here's Josh Marshall:

What's as troubling as the big rip-off of taxpayer money is that what Obama's attempting on the side of rebuilding the real economy could founder on the public backlash against what looks like a very misguided way to get a handle on the banking crisis.

Originally posted to david mizner on Mon Feb 09, 2009 at 11:47 AM PST.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Meteor Blades, skybluewater, Chris Bowers, Kimberley, chase, claude, Alumbrados, boydog, DeminNewJ, vicki, Terri, nofundy, dwellscho, SteveLCo, tgs1952, coral, Mogolori, Peace JD, mbc, eugene, hester, SMucci, skyesNYC, ferg, Ben P, raatz, SarahLee, slinkerwink, Paul in Austin, acquittal, casamurphy, Trendar, glitterscale, cedubose, Detlef, Maxlongstreet, MarkC, Mountain Don, TKinVT, alisonk, MontanaMaven, sen bob, Unstable Isotope, whataboutbob, maynard, msl, ScientistMom in NY, existenz, theboz, TocqueDeville, Bob Love, DebtorsPrison, tommurphy, Dean Nut, MsSpentyouth, Wintermute, meg, Jim in Chicago, Private Keepout, oysterface, eeff, Mnemosyne, dkistner, HootieMcBoob, leftyboy666, Mumon, enthusiast, marjo, RFK Lives, lzachary, Zach in Phoenix, object16, MarkInSanFran, expatjourno, Creosote, Heart of the Rockies, DJ Adequate, eyeswideopen, rwsab, Justina, Zinman, conchita, mentaldebris, wonkydonkey, Cassandra77, elveta, clarkent, groggy, nyceve, SecondComing, whenwego, Janie, OCD, marsbardem, DaleA, Morague, macleme, CoolOnion, KMc, wanderindiana, Cool Blue Reason, chuckvw, Minerva, kalman, cosmic debris, ksh01, Aquarius40, roses, JuliaAnn, Ignacio Magaloni, oceanspray, bincbom, luku, exconservative, Nate Roberts, thingamabob, ctsteve, Jesterfox, kimberlyweldon, enough already, Cedwyn, antirove, NotFuzzy, dksbook, wader, LawStudent, Melanchthon, Redfire, jersey organic, tidalwave1, emmasnacker, danthrax, sockpuppet, TexDem, Dallasdoc, apotropaic, Miss Jones, sooner, gmb, RaulVB, alivingston, JimWilson, desmoinesdem, Chirons apprentice, MmeVoltaire, betson08, Neighbor2, rlharry, Timbuk3, Liberaljentaps, Brian82, Democratic Hawk, dkmich, walkshills, firetop, Oaktown Girl, bwintx, Bendra, econlibVA, AllisonInSeattle, Redbug, jen, Deward Hastings, xyz, zannie, kd texan, ganymeade, greeseyparrot, Illissius, Gowrie Gal, Jersey Joe, Tonal Crow, rapala, nailbender, greenskeeper, joanneleon, Fabian, ExStr8, bloomer 101, Bluesee, Simian, radarlady, 3goldens, NoMoreLies, tle, munky, yuriwho, baccaruda, JanetT in MD, Justin Lee, Alice Marshall, irate, PBen, Flint, willibro, Alien Abductee, elkhunter, frandor55, Robin7459, drewfromct, Laurence Lewis, reflectionsv37, Mz Kleen, owlbear1, GUGA, mojo workin, LNK, Pam from Calif, Sun Tzu, jorndorff, pandawoman, GreyHawk, Burned, Skid, bluemanredtex, brenda, illyia, antiapollon, jane123, techno, buddhafrogsaypeace, wigwam, neroden, alisonc, wiscmass, LivesInAShoe, deepsouthdoug, distraught, dsteffen, benny05, Cory Bantic, Rogneid, playtonjr, ZinZen, RainyDay, fhcec, Jim R, Jim P, lgmcp, reddbierd, martini, third Party please, Legolas, LeftOverAmerica, kovie, Showman, gwilson, propitious2, danmac, MissInformation, tarheelblue, Pacifist, jsamuel, vigilant meerkat, cybersaur, alefnot, ferallike, Opakapaka, BlueInARedState, trentinca, quotemstr, andydoubtless, Ptah the Great, Gorette, borkitekt, seefleur, victoria2dc, smokeymonkey, buhdydharma, KenBee, mrobinson, ccmask, The Wizard, IvanR, greenearth, Lefty Coaster, goodasgold, Blue Wind, NBBooks, DarkestHour, tecampbell, StrayCat, Tanya, need pr, jasonbl, merryberry, gooderservice, Libby Shaw, imabluemerkin, NearlyNormal, joeshwingding, el cid, boatsie, dirtfarmer, middleagedhousewife, quantumspin, Pilgrim X, llbear, Turbonerd, profh, GiveNoQuarter, kurt, shaharazade, Mary2002, bstotts, Picot verde, blueintheface, AllanTBG, Aaa T Tudeattack, DBunn, cjallen, ammasdarling, lams712, bigchin, One Pissed Off Liberal, bear83, Noor B, lawman, out of left field, lightfoot, DorothyT, ibonewits, asilomar, Fredly, C Barr, wa ma, Loudoun County Dem, oscarsmom, Deadicated Marxist, FWIW, WeBetterWinThisTime, drbloodaxe, FishOutofWater, Richard Lyon, yowsta, Cofcos, NCDem Amy, Jimdotz, ezdidit, deepeco, londubh, Unbozo, bnasley, ProbStat, NoMoJoe, jayden, Midwesterners, Aunt Martha, chicago jeff, letsgetreal, AznInCali, bobswern, millwood, Moderation, Rumarhazzit, JML9999, Zydekos, keikekaze, eyesoars, Hens Teeth, Predictor, Terra Mystica, TomP, rmonroe, BustaVessel, MKinTN, GANJA, FirstValuesThenIssues, fayeforcure, rogerdaddy, Visceral, condorcet, ScottyUrb, karin x, Fossil, dennisk, VA gentlewoman, Archangel, jakebob, tofumagoo, boatjones, toddpw, Wek, geomoo, daddy4mak, pickandshovel, Jeff Y, Thought Crime, mofembot, Gemina13, pragprogress, Horsefeathers, PMA, LaFajita, Notreadytobenice, True Independent, luckylizard, echatwa, xysea, Bartimaeus Blue, DixieDishrag, BYw, Athenocles, allie123, priceman, dont think, tristan57, Ellinorianne, PrnCaspian3, bucadibeppo, shortgirl, 4km, lancecote, cameoanne, Bule Betawi, multilee, smellybeast, number nine dream, Mr Tentacle, arendt, driftwood, Texanomaly, hannahlk, aufklaerer, two roads, emboyo, Unseen majority, snackdoodle, divineorder, emmabrody, holger smed, An Affirming Flame, burlingtonexplorer, jaf49, Partisan Progressive, SciVo, JesseCW, erin r, manonfyre, John Shade, zbbrox, RageKage, followyourbliss, worldly1, Framlingham, ZilV, MySobriquet, papahaha, Riyaz Guerra, obscuresportsquarterly, synductive99, Septima, IreGyre, notquitedelilah, MrDeadeye2U, fernan47, FundaMental Transformation, Wings Like Eagles, futureliveshere, deviant24x, RogerDodger, Cleopatra, Colorado Billy, Larsstephens, Words In Action, ruscle, cassandraX, gohmak, ZAP210, oohdoiloveyou, TNThorpe, awcomeon, Areopagitica, robertacker13, eXtina, amk for obama, MarkMarvin, whisperinghope, boriquasi, fidellio, eponymouse, chrome327, MiscastDice, Crabby Abbey, wvmom, Ronald Singleterry, JJC, lostmypassword, polar bear, Klaus, ctlrick, NY brit expat, Benintn, Kristina40, DrFitz, albrt, damned if you do, Funkygal, Johnny Q, itswhatson, washunate, Betty Pinson, Urtica dioica gracilis, SunsetMagnolia, roystah, MsGrin, Floande, Murchadha, USHomeopath, fiercefilms, Virgil RK, jeanma, slice, yellow dog in NJ, BrowniesAreGood, al ajnabee, JD04, atheistben, joshb, Gracian, nicethugbert, Kharafina, wahine, Susipsych, renfro, sallym, barflyer, AfroPonix, thethinveil, Liyamei, BicycleDave, Wheever, matthewj, muddy boots, sjr1, Jenny Cash, enhydra lutris, Mumsty, corvaire, Wayback, chira2, EnlightenedRogue, pecosbob

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site