Skip to main content

I haven't seen this news reported here already, but the Los Angeles Times is reporting that a federal judge has declared DADT unconstitutional.

The story broke at the top of the hour and some information has come since then.
The story is here at: Judge declares U.S. military's 'don't ask, don't tell' policy openly banning gay service members unconstitutional [updated]

This ruling is in the case brought by the Log Cabin Republicans. U.S. District Judge Virginia Phillips is the judge in the case.
As the article says, this ruling comes just a month after Judge Walker's ruling regarding Prop 8 here in California.

update 1:
many thanks to jpmassar for the link to the pdf of the decision: Case 2:04-cv-08425-VAP-E Document 232 It's 86 pages and it's a pdf.

update 2:
jpmassar (who would have written a much better diary than I) has some relevant quotes from the decision below. I'm going to add them here in the body, But you should go give him lot of mojo for finding them.

Plaintiff has proven that the Act captures within its overreaching grasp such activities as private correspondence betweenservicemembers and their family members and friends, and conversations
between servicemembers about their daily off-duty activities. Plaintiff has proven that the Act prevents servicemembers from reporting violations of military ethical and conduct codes, even in outrageous instances, for fear of retaliatory discharge.

General Powell also rejected attempts to draw parallels between exclusion of homosexuals and historical exclusion of African-Americans, because "skin color is a benign nonbehavioral characteristic, while sexual orientation is perhaps the most profound of human behavioral characteristics."

Citing a Pentagon study, he ((Dr. Korb)) opined that for every person discharged after ten years of service, six new servicemembers would need to be recruited to recover the level of experience lost by that discharge.

LCR also produced evidence demonstrating that Defendants routinely delayed the discharge of servicemembers suspected of violating the Act's provisions until after they had completed their overseas deployments. In other words, if Defendants began an investigation of a servicemember suspected of violating the Act, the investigation would be suspended if the subject received deployment orders; not until he or she returned from combat – assuming this occurred, of course – would the investigation be completed and the servicemember discharged if found to have violated the Act.

This evidence, in particular, directly undermines any contention that the Act furthers the Government's purpose of military readiness, as it shows Defendants continue to deploy gay and lesbian members of the military into combat, waiting until they have returned before resolving the charges arising out of the suspected homosexual conduct. If the warrior's suspected violation of the Act created a threat to military readiness, to unit cohesion, or to any of the other important Government objectives, it follows that Defendants would not deploy him or her to combat before resolving the investigation. It defies logic that the purposes of the Act could be served by suspending the investigation during overseas deployments, only to discharge servicemember upon his or her return to a non-combat station.

Taken as a whole, the evidence introduced at trial shows that the effect of the Act has been, not to advance the Government's interests of military readiness and unit cohesion, much less to do so significantly, but to harm that interest.

   The Don't Ask, Don't Tell Act infringes the fundamental rights of United States servicemembers in many ways, some described above. The Act denies homosexuals serving in the Armed Forces the right to enjoy "intimate conduct" in their personal relationships. The Act denies them the right to speak about their loved ones while serving their country in uniform; it punishes them with discharge for writing a personal letter, in a foreign language, to a person of the same sex with whom they shared an intimate relationship before entering military service; it discharges them for including information in a personal communication from which an unauthorized reader might discern their homosexuality.

   In order to justify the encroachment on these rights, Defendants faced the burden at trial of showing the Don't Ask, Don't Tell Act was necessary to significantly further the Government's important interests in military readiness and unit cohesion. Defendants failed to meet that burden. Thus, Plaintiff, on behalf of its members, is entitled to judgment in its favor on the first claim in its First Amended Complaint for violation of the substantive due process rights guaranteed under the Fifth Amendment.

update 3:
And the first response I've seen from a Senator: comes from Kirsten Gillibrand

Fed'l judge in CA has ruled #DADT unconstitutional. Great news! It's my hope that DOJ does not appeal. DADT is immoral & hurts our military.

update 4:
And in a California connection, Judge Phillips was recommended for the bench by Barbara Boxer.

Originally posted to shayera on Thu Sep 09, 2010 at 06:45 PM PDT.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Meteor Blades, Sharoney, Malacandra, norm, JekyllnHyde, Doug in SF, tmo, Bill in Portland Maine, grollen, ogre, eleming, mwm341, deben, leftcoast, askew, cali, Todd Beeton, glitterscale, badger, Nina Katarina, Dem 724, TrueBlueMajority, mem from somerville, mattman, Bob Love, DebtorsPrison, tnichlsn, bosdcla14, TechBob, Emerson, ortcutt, musicalhair, Shockwave, byteb, bramish, LuvSet, SF Bay, KateG, jdld, eeff, object16, mataliandy, marge, nanoboy, strengthANDwisdom, Heart of the Rockies, PBCliberal, kissfan, Scott in NAZ, agoldnyc, opinionated, concernedamerican, bronte17, missLotus, Davidsfr, wonkydonkey, elveta, understandinglife, sja, rhp, Stumptown Dave, shanikka, mkfarkus, otto, pedrito, Ignacio Magaloni, Larry Bailey, Fe, BruinKid, navajo, Cedwyn, lirtydies, SneakySnu, EntrWriter, jump23, psnyder, hangingchad, danthrax, Dallasdoc, missliberties, brainwave, grannyhelen, jaywillie, GN1927, Steven Payne, MmeVoltaire, Greg in TN, alizard, lulu57, PerfectStormer, pdxRita, Matt Esler, zett, ybruti, side pocket, Kitsap River, WisVoter, lonespark, CanYouBeAngryAndStillDream, gavodotcom, DarkSyde, lyvwyr101, Irish Patti, Sybil Liberty, llellet, rogue5, davidkc, Julie Gulden, Big Tex, joanneleon, G2geek, ExStr8, maybeeso in michigan, bloomer 101, marina, radarlady, Othniel, baccaruda, Marching Orders, CTPatriot, furiousxxgeorge, PBen, Flint, DoGooderLawyer, Tod, Brooke In Seattle, YucatanMan, Dobber, Laurence Lewis, eru, cfk, indiemcemopants, grog, majcmb1, Pam from Calif, jimreyn, Inland, cassidy3, sofia, Overseas, gerardbellavita, Carnivorous Plantling, rb608, AnotherMassachusettsLiberal, Savvy813, wiscmass, Rogneid, peacestpete, Ekaterin, kathny, soyinkafan, jay23, noweasels, begone, SSMir, salvador dalai llama, SoulCatcher, elliott, rserven, jimraff, pico, atdnext, hlee1169, Debbie in ME, Patriot Daily News Clearinghouse, myboo, Kingsmeg, vigilant meerkat, katynka, edwardssl, BlueInARedState, dharmafarmer, Arclite, koNko, Triscula, fou, luckydog, jwhitmill, blueoasis, birdbrain64, cRedd, gooderservice, bleeding heart, sceptical observer, Demena, ER Doc, MBNYC, Phthalo, Nancy Hartley, SingerInTheChoir, WarrenS, Dreaming of Better Days, blueoregon, djalix976, zedaker, bstotts, pseudopod, blueintheface, AllanTBG, markthshark, Nulwee, BentLiberal, GoldnI, sephius1, One Pissed Off Liberal, tonyfv, bear83, john07801, lightfoot, bluicebank, BeninSC, EdSF, puakev, FishOutofWater, Richard Lyon, la urracca, Nespolo, noofsh, Jimdotz, ezdidit, Calvin Jones and the 13th Apostle, deepeco, sfbob, Strabo, kingyouth, Orange County Liberal, jayden, steamkettle, mudslide, Killer of Sacred Cows, jnhobbs, millwood, Moderation, NorthlandLiberal, Rumarhazzit, uciguy30, Got a Grip, leonard145b, JML9999, sable, Predictor, roycej, TomP, alba, gizmo59, Lady Kestrel, dsgood, gundyj, mconvente, sk4p, ScottyUrb, GlowNZ, Senor Unoball, lamzdotes, dave1042, bythesea, elwior, brooklynbadboy, Laughing Vergil, CDH in Brooklyn, thetadelta, VL Baker, Lujane, Cassandra Waites, TokenLiberal, DanK Is Back, rubine, Seamus D, S C B, Gemina13, Drewid, kyril, glendaw271, meldroc, costello7, SpamNunn, luckylizard, Radio Free Thought, doppler effect, joustchr, rodentrancher, ekyprogressive, dmhlt 66, cactusflinthead, watercarrier4diogenes, papicek, Stroszek, ZhenRen, lostboyjim, oldliberal, LaFeminista, R Rhino from CT4, maggiejean, Rei, 1BQ, multilee, pileta, cybrestrike, smellybeast, rsmpdx, snackdoodle, greengemini, Scott Wooledge, Chino Blanco, be the change you seek, Partisan Progressive, StuHunter, tr GW, millwx, JesseCW, cjenk415, DefendOurConstitution, Daily Activist, borndem, ZilV, johnosahon, sricki, stevenwag, sfarkash, 57andFemale, Muzikal203, sherijr, reesespcs, deviant24x, jpmassar, citisven, Larsstephens, ETF, commonmass, smileycreek, Christy1947, coppercelt, BrighidG, mamamorgaine, marabout40, Theis, Vacationland, princss6, jethrock, catwho, candysroom, taiping1, angelajean, tubacat, No Looking Back, Eddie L, pixxer, ItsSimpleSimon, ThisIsMyTime, DailyDrew, Looking for Mauve, sharonsz, halef, Betty Pinson, elengul, farrelad, slice, weathertom, Jake Goad, Onomastic, PaDemTerry, kerflooey, heart of a quince, SuperBowlXX, Skylarking, rationalcauses, BlueUU, nicethugbert, Zooey Glass, cjinca, cooper888, BlueJessamine, palm springs progressive, m00finsan, Eclectablog, Mistral Wind, Situational Lefty, deeproots, skip945, princesspat, lawyernerd, Ebby, marleycat, Cinnamon Rollover, dle2GA, Sabazinus, KVoimakas, CherryTheTart, Vtdblue, whoknu, COkdub, peregrine kate, zapus, PhilJD, MinistryOfTruth, Archie2227, mfprtoo, Curiosity, Willa Rogers, RLMiller, Nightshade Q, Apost8, ChiTownDenny, Mike Peterson, ParkRanger, MichaelNY, Rejoinder, fgsfds, YaNevaNo, CalliopeIrjaPearl, weatherdude, QES, ridemybike, WaryLiberal, sjterrid, RhodaA, Flying Goat, buzzybodhi, Williston Barrett, Chrislove, We Won, IndieGuy, effervescent, barkingcat, Joieau, AreDeutz, banach tarski paradox, talismanlangley, congenitalefty, glassofmilk, peachcreek, belinda ridgewood, readerwriter

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site