Skip to main content

The six part PBS miniseries God in America that began on Monday features a glaring error that merits highlighting and correcting.  

God in America seeks to present a fresh narrative of the story of religion in America, including how that story shaped the writing of the Constitution. While the first two chapters, presented back to back seem good, (albeit overly slanted towards the role of evangelical Christians), there is a glaring error (partly of omission, partly of commission) I want to highlight that goes to the heart of the story of religious freedom and the right of individual conscience. Getting this important element of our history right helps us to answer the Religious Right's theocratic aspirations as well as claims the various claims of Christian nationalism.  

That this PBS documentary joins the Religious Right in eliding this important part of our history is disturbing.

So let's correct the record.

The film and the related web site contradicts itself each time the role of religion in the Constitution is mentioned:

The section on the drafting of the Constitution on the web site's "time line" of religious liberty is headlined:  "U.S. Constitution drafted; no guarantee of religious liberty."

The discussion under this headline states:  

God and religion are scarcely mentioned in the document. Wanting to create "a more perfect union," some of the Constitution's framers fear that statements on religion would be divisive.

While it is true that there was concern about how best to approach the matter of religion, in fact there was a major statement regarding religious liberty in the Constitution thus it was not "scarcely mentioned" nor can anyone fairly say that there was "no guarantee of religious liberty" when in fact, Article Six made an extraordinary and unprecedented first cut at doing just that. (The First Amendment came later.)

But even the dubious claim that religion is "scarcely mentioned" is more accurate than what is stated in the film itself.

NARRATOR: And when, a year later, the Constitution was being drafted in Philadelphia, Jefferson and the Baptists hoped that their hard-fought principle of separating church from state would be part of the country's founding document. But when the Constitution was presented in September 1787, in not one of the seven articles was there any guarantee of religious liberty or other individual rights.

But this is a semantic spin on the facts.  Article Six of the Constitution declared:  

The Senators and Representatives before mentioned, and the Members of the several State Legislatures, and all executive and judicial Officers, both of the United States and of the several States, shall be bound by Oath or Affirmation, to support this Constitution; but no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States.

This was a real break between the theocratic norms of the colonial era and the democratic values of religious equality that stand at the center of the struggle of the American experiment to this day. It meant that for the first time in the history of the world, what one believed or didn't believe, or if one changed one's mind, would not be criteria for  determining eligibility for public office. (And while it took a long time to make that principle real, and arguably we are still working on it, that only underscores how deeply radical Article Six really was.)

Understandably, it was a big issue at the time, since religious oaths had been standard (and perennially controversial) in most of the colonies.  The abolition of "religious tests" set in motion the disestablishment of the state churches.  (I wrote about the significance of Article Six in an essay, History is Powerful:  Why the Christian Right Distorts History and Why it Matters in The Public Eye magazine in 2007.)

Indeed, a great deal of opposition to ratification of the Constitution centered on religion. While it is true, as the film emphasizes, many were concerned about the absence of any mention of God or Christianity in the text, many opponents were also opposed to the banning of religious tests for public office.  

The Constitution was of course, ultimately ratified by a majority of the states, but part of the politics of getting there was a deal made with civil libertarians like Jefferson that they would support ratification for a document that they felt insufficiently guaranteed religious liberty, in exchange for the promise that the Constitution would be amended later. They did, and it was.  

In an online debate at Religion Dispatches (an outgrowth of a panel at Netroots Nation in 2009), I added:

"Barring religious tests for public office in Article 6 also obviously meant that there would be no religious test for citizenship. (You can’t be elected to office if you are not a citizen.) Thus the framers were clearly not solely concerned with whether or not we had official federal or state churches, but first that the right of belief resided with individual citizens.

The plumb line of this principle is clear.  When Thomas Jefferson first proposed the Virginia Statute of Religious Freedom in 1777, he stated that this right of individual conscience must be extended to everyone, including: "the Jew, the Mohametan, and the Hindoo." Jefferson was not arguing the demographics of majority and minority religions, but first principles. It took time to advance them, even then. James Madison as governor of Virginia managed to push Jefferson’s bill through the legislature in 1786—the year before the drafting the federal Constitution, of which Madison is credited with being the principal author—as well as the principal author of the First Amendment. Virginia had already disestablished the Anglican Church, the day after it joined the revolution in 1776. So there is no mistaking the meaning of formally extending religious liberty to all in the wake of disestablishment and as a famous forerunner to the Constitution itself.

In fairness, any story necessarily includes some facts and leaves out others in order to keep the narrative clear. But in this case, the result is a gross distortion of the history of religious liberty in the U.S.  

[Crossposted from Talk to Action]

Update [2010-10-12 12:14:52 by Frederick Clarkson]: Commenter Prince Nekhlyudov makes an excellent point that underscores the unambiguous intentions of the framers with regards to the right of individual conscience in the Constitution consistent with the meaning of Article Six.  He writes:

Another subtle indication of the separation of church and state in the original constitution can be found in Article Three, which specifically states that the President may "swear or affirm" upon taking office, and what we usually call the "oath of office" is actually an "oath or affirmation."  Oaths had distinctively religious quality and many religious sects such as Quakers, as well as free-thinkers, strongly objected to any legal requirement of "swearing" to an "oath" so the constitution specifically provides for the option of an oath or affirmation (which is an usworn statement subject to penalty of perjury).  This framing is carried forward in the Bill of Rights (i.e., the 4th Amendment says that search warrants must be based on "oath or affirmation" establishing probable cause).

Update [2010-10-12 14:7:54 by Frederick Clarkson]: Apparently, we have a hatemail troll.  One Jonathan Tellman writes me to say:


 Shut up idiot

   show details 1:22 PM (32 minutes ago)

   from johnathan tellman <john_tellman@XXXX <br>to
   date Tue, Oct 12, 2010 at 1:22 PM
   subject Shut up idiot

   hide details 1:22 PM (33 minutes ago)

   The 3 branches of the government extend from the bible.  Gee, maybe really our founders were illegal immigrants, African and Asian Americans and the key contributors were Muslims and Hindus?  Does this fit your hateful idiocy?

   The nation is found on Judeo Christian values...Don't like it ? Move to Mecca.

Apparently, this is his modus operandi at Daily Kos.

Originally posted to Frederick Clarkson on Tue Oct 12, 2010 at 08:21 AM PDT.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Meteor Blades, Sharoney, N in Seattle, chase, MoDem, Tookish, RakDaddy, Alumbrados, Ed in Montana, boydog, zane, RF, libdevil, Upper West, taylormattd, ogre, Rayne, copymark, alyosha, teacherken, Liberal Thinking, abarefootboy, GreenSooner, Gooserock, flatiron, TrueBlueMajority, saraswati, madmsf, BigOkie, Bob Love, jethropalerobber, Emerson, karlpk, ortcutt, Wintermute, kpardue, Troutfishing, eeff, Mnemosyne, xynz, devtob, expatjourno, hubcap, sardonyx, Dumbo, tarminian, Gustogirl, NoisyGong, bronte17, BlackSheep1, wonkydonkey, annrose, OCD, maxschell, ask, CoolOnion, chuckvw, gayntom, mkfarkus, barath, chimpy, roses, Ignacio Magaloni, poe, josephk, Nate Roberts, fumie, splashy, antirove, SnyperKitty, wader, JimDev, psnyder, danthrax, TexDem, Miss Jones, DeadB0y, pat bunny, grannyhelen, TiaRachel, BoxerDave, gerrilea, ccr4nine, chriscol, jaywillie, potatohead, roselynde1, dwahzon, Chirons apprentice, Steven Payne, Catte Nappe, betson08, whyvee, kalmoth, Timbuk3, lcrp, Dave925, walkshills, side pocket, Kitsap River, mungley, Vicky, lyvwyr101, vacantlook, Sybil Liberty, Frank Vyan Walton, Gowrie Gal, Julie Gulden, nailbender, John3, ExStr8, marina, radarlady, jrooth, JanetT in MD, SherwoodB, LostInTexas, OpherGopher, PBen, Philoguy, Alice Venturi, Simplify, DocGonzo, caliberal2001, basquebob, RequestedUsername, terrypinder, myeye, drewfromct, stagemom, chidmf, Laurence Lewis, Kevskos, boofdah, eru, bleeding blue, GreenPA, SaraBeth, HugoDog, Sara R, Inland, elbamash, smkngman, lotlizard, Ice Blue, ivorybill, SheriffBart, jane123, Sandino, woobie, Savvy813, HiBob, Shotput8, neroden, wiscmass, serrano, coolbreeze, dsteffen, Rogneid, Ekaterin, Arsenic, mrchips46, xanthippe2, Snud, zozie, kathny, Oye Sancho, fhcec, Jim R, CJnyc, begone, reddbierd, salvador dalai llama, SoulCatcher, Nowhere Man, Mother Mags, martini, third Party please, danmac, irishwitch, Pinko Elephant, BlueInARedState, Kimball Cross, Gorette, Yellow Canary, seefleur, martyc35, poleshifter, Magnifico, fiddler crabby, TheBlaz, anastasia p, jwhitmill, blueoasis, DarkestHour, MJ via Chicago, aloevera, StrayCat, cRedd, bubbanomics, gatorcog, imabluemerkin, Doctor Frog, Caoimhin Laochdha, JVolvo, NearlyNormal, Frank Cocozzelli, bleeding heart, el cid, sceptical observer, soccergrandmom, Dinclusin, doinaheckuvanutjob, Pilgrim X, profh, zhimbo, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, Madam Deb, kurt, zedaker, Bernie68, bstotts, Picot verde, Temmoku, AllanTBG, markthshark, Aaa T Tudeattack, GoldnI, tegrat, One Pissed Off Liberal, pinkhighway, pgm 01, BeninSC, uncomfortably numb, Ann Galloway, Loudoun County Dem, ColoTim, atmplant, yoduuuh do or do not, beth meacham, FishOutofWater, LillithMc, Mary Mike, hold tight, Jimdotz, terabytes, ezdidit, sfbob, joedemocrat, Strabo, NoMoJoe, jayden, jedennis, sabishi, BLUE YETI, ubertar, Uberbah, millwood, Moderation, yella dawg, Rumarhazzit, journeyman, madgranny, M Sullivan, JML9999, Prof Haley, Hens Teeth, South Park Democrat, gizmo59, VA Breeze, JDWolverton, hkorens, revm3up, adamsmo, NotGeorgeWill, mn humanist, lockewasright, Involuntary Exile, dadadata, bythesea, slapper95, Akonitum, monkeybrainpolitics, Lujane, royce, RandomNonviolence, geomoo, pickandshovel, bluesheep, rubine, mofembot, Seamus D, Horsefeathers, sam storm, kempsternyc, luckylizard, Parthenia, auctor ignotus, BYw, pelagicray, ptolemynm, Executive Odor, magicsister, Robobagpiper, tristan57, ekyprogressive, Mike Taylor, watercarrier4diogenes, squarewheel, maggiejean, Pris from LA, Ripeness Is All, DontTaseMeBro, arendt, emboyo, snackdoodle, greengemini, divineorder, Matisyahu, CanyonWren, Rabbithead, RandomActsOfReason, Methinks They Lie, Partisan Progressive, CamillesDad1, JesseCW, DefendOurConstitution, Daily Activist, Prince Nekhlyudov, marzook, allep10, Shelley99, IreGyre, sfarkash, vadasz, 57andFemale, ArthurPoet, jfromga, nancat357, futureliveshere, davespicer, deviant24x, Leftcandid, nocynicism, susan in sc, Larsstephens, kydoc, hillgiant, pyegar, p gorden lippy, hippiechick13, Tea and Strumpets, jethrock, yellowdogsal, Crabby Abbey, trixied13, sullivanst, missississy, elginblt, ItsSimpleSimon, PvtJarHead, Egalitare, rfall, sharonsz, addisnana, rja, Betty Pinson, DrTerwilliker, elengul, ericlewis0, USHomeopath, cocinero, ZedMont, llee, soaglow, wrpereir, slice, Onomastic, spindr27, Front Toward Enemy, Bluefin, cultjake, StateofEuphoria, Mr MadAsHell, freesia, poorbuster, We Want Change, BillyElliott, kevin k, Teiresias70, CoExistNow, mawazo, PedalingPete, marleycat, grannysally, Wolf10, dle2GA, BarackStarObama, KVoimakas, Vtdblue, IL JimP, corvaire, peregrine kate, whaddaya, MinistryOfTruth, Aquagranny911, VTCC73, Strange New World, wide eyed lib, Archie2227, cailloux, mfprtoo, Niphead, daveusf, Aphrodottie, weinerschnauzer, Redwood Rhiadra, DEMonrat ankle biter, MichaelNY, No one gets out alive, Rejoinder, Monsieur Georges, James Robinson, miles2go, sow hat, buzzybodhi, damfino, Siri, Eric Nelson, orangecurtainlib, DMLjohn, HighPlainsBlue, peachcreek, nyskeptic, supercereal, radical simplicity, Justice Hildebrand, mattie53

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site