The $millions put into Super Bowl advertising cannot, in general, be seen as anything approaching environmentally friendly considering what is core to most of the messages: consume and, well, consume more.
Sadly, the worst of the worst in 2010 is packaging what a company claims is a 'green product'
Audi chose to promote their new car as a great environmentally friendly product, one that could evade 'green police' crackdowns on the highway.
This advertisement is offensive and counterproductive on many levels.
There are, of course, some advertisements that are wrapped in "green" and which have at least a (debatable) case to made that they are environmentally-sensible communications. For example, tthe General Electric 2009 advertisement re the Smart Grid (after the fold) could be looked at as part of educating the public about the power and value of moving forward toward a Smart Grid. From a different angle, the PepsiCo decision to forgo Super Bowl ads (first time ever, $33 million in ads at the 2009 Super Bowl) to give grants for nominated causes based on online voting (see the Pepsi Refresh site -- note, they want to collect email addresses for, we can assume, advertising purposes) could be framed as 'green non-advertising at the Super Bowl'.
Notable for the 2010 Super Bowl, no "Hemi" or super max McSUV advertising. Despite the bad beer ads and the amusing Dorito ads that are far from environmentally friendly, without question the most environmentally ad served a product that seeks to claim a green label.
Audi chose to promote their new car as a great environmentally friendly product, one that could evade 'green police' crackdowns on the highway.
This advertisement is offensive and counterproductive on many levels.
The Ornungspolizei
The 'green police' is a term for Nazi police who were, among other things, implicated in the Holocaust.
The Ordnungspolizei (Orpo) was the name for the uniformed regular German police force in existence during the period of Nazi Germany, notably between 1936 and 1945. It was increasingly absorbed into the Nazi police system. Owing to their green uniforms, they were also referred to as Grüne Polizei (green police). ... The Order Police played a central role in carrying out the Holocaust, as stated by Professor Browning:
It is no longer seriously in question that members of the German Order Police, both career professionals and reservists, in both battalion formations and precinct service or Einzeldienst, were at the center of the Holocaust, providing a major manpower source for carrying out numerous deportations, ghetto-clearing operations, and massacres
Thus, the German automobile manufacturer, Audi, has chosen to contain an oblique reference to a Nazi police unit that had a role in helping carry out the Holocaust. Evidently, Audi believes that Americans (or at least those watching the Super Bowl) know nothing of history.
Damaging framing of what it might mean to go green
The Audi advertisement has "Green Police" cracking down hard for real and imagined environmentally unfriendly actions. We see police taking a man down for taking a plastic bag at the supermarket checkout. A horde of police are shown arresting someone at the door for (evidently) having incandescent bulbs on their porch. What seems to be a SWAT team hit hot tub partiers and chase a man running from it in a bathing suit (his underwear?). And, well, there are other "Green Police" take downs of other real or imagined environmentally-unfriendly behavior, actions, and/or possessions. This is a promotion of a view of 'going green' that suggests heading toward a police state, destroying liberty, rather than any sort of vision of a more positive future.
While Audi intended this advertisement to boost the Audi TDI Clean Diesel which was, mistakenly in my opinion, named "green car of the year", this advertisement in the most prominent advertising venue of the year serves to promote a very destructive perspective on what might happen as the United States moves toward more environmentally-friendly policies and regulations.
EnviroNAZI and Ecofascist are "used as a political epithet by political conservatives to discredit deep ecology, mainstream environmentalism, and other left and non-left ecological positions".
The Audi advertisement feeds directly into this "political epithet", feeding a tea bagger-type framing of threats to civil liberty, serving to undermine public support for serious action to address America's oil dependency, energy profligacy, and the challenges/opportunities that Global Warming present us (the U.S.).
Some might view this advertisement as 'snark', a humorist way to call attention to their car. However, if Audi was underestimating (at least some) Americans ability to check Wikipedia re "Green Police", perhaps they overestimate the general public's ability to detect satire late in a Super Bowl game.
It is simply astounding that a German company would play against such a framing, making oblique references to a Nazi police unit and providing what many will see as a broadside against environmentalism as somehow fascist in nature.
Such horrible framing in an advertisement for a green product makes
Audi's "Green Police": The most environmentally unfriendly Super Bowl advertisement of 2010.
Audi's Pre Super Bowl promotional video re Green Police
GE Scarecrow Smart Grid Ad from the 2009 Super Bowl. Note, this was the first (only to date) GE ad placed during the Super Bowl.
UPDATE / NOTE: JeremyBloom provides some examples from around the web to this ad:
...if you, too, are fed up with curly coiffed 18-year-old boys attempting to tell you to throw trash into the right-colored can and boasting of their ability to get their Prius to coast on the freeway, then the Audi spot might just be for you.
Audi's Green Police: love it or hate it, that's what it's going to be like. Welcome to government interfering in every part of your life
.
Green Police Audi Commercial. I don't think we're too far away from this being the status quo. #libertarian
The green police AKA the LAPD in 2012. #tomanydamnhippiesinCali
And, along with a good share of the commentators, David Roberts doesn't agree with my interpretation.
the more the teabaggy interpretation just doesn’t quite fit. The thrill at the end, when they guy gets to accelerate away from the crowd, turns on satisfying the green police—not rejecting or circumventing them, but satisfying their strict standards. The authority of the green police is taken for granted, never questioned. If you’re looking to appeal to mooks who think the green police are full of it and have no authority, moral or otherwise, why would you make a commercial like that? Why offer escape from a moral dilemma your audience doesn’t acknowledge exists?
The ad only makes sense if it’s aimed at people who acknowledge the moral authority of the green police—people who may find those obligations tiresome and constraining on occasion, who only fitfully meet them, who may be annoyed by sticklers and naggers, but who recognize that living more sustainably is in fact the moral thing to do. This basically describes every guy I know.
Nor does Sebastio Blanco at AutoBlogGreen who comments that "we've seen the Super Bowl ad (there's a teaser companion spot here) and can tell you that it's not offensive in any way". [Well, Sebastio, "in any way" isn't a comment that all agree with.] That post also has Audi's response to criticism over the ad.
Jeffrey Kuhlman, the chief communications officer for Audi of America, told AutoblogGreen that he personally talked to two Jewish leaders – Abraham Foxman, head of the Anti Defamation League, and Fred Zeidman, Chairman of the U.S. Holocaust Memorial and Museum – about the green police ads and that they did not see a problem with the spot
the issue of green police vs. Ordnungspolizei. Ordnungspolizei is directly translated to mean Order Police. It's more than just the difference between capital letters and small letters, it's official versus nicknames. And in our research not one person drew any other distinction other than "environmental".
We researched the term. We tested the ad concept with focus groups. We sought input and reaction from key organizations, including the Jewish community, and we sent out a press release that went to thousands of media, and not one reaction. I then worked again with key Jewish leaders after the blogger raised the issue, just to make sure that we hadn't missed something, and again, we were reassured that the term is not one that has historical significance, and that reactions to the term are completely in line with our intent ... environmental enforcement.
See Danny Brown's Audi and the Super Bowl Social Media Shit Storm
The problem is, there’s already been a Green Police enforcement organization, but not one that you’d want to be associated with. This Green Police was part of the Nazi persecution and execution of millions of Jews in the Holocaust of the Second World War.
The implications of Audi’s choice of name for their campaign could be huge, especially since Audi is a German company.
And, to be clear, I see paths for having fun with the idea of over zealous driving of environmental messages. There is the Will Ferrell / et al "Green Team" skit which does not, imo, drive home the 'enviro-fascist' type message and is quite clearly comedic. It has also spawned many spoofs (good and bad).