Skip to main content

Originally published in Tikkun Daily |

Rabbi Eric Yoffie has penned a Haaretz opinion piece directed at progressive, U.S. Jews that is so deluded and insidious, it's as though it was written in the same political and psychological vacuum inhabited by Netanyahu's government.

Yoffie, former head of the Union for Reform Judaism, argues that progressives should champion Israel's "get tough" Gaza stance. It's a call he makes using shockingly misguided and narrow arguments. It's a call I, and all progressives, should reject.

Here's why:

First, Yoffie fails to understand the strategic motivations behind Israel's current "Pillar of Defense" campaign. He thinks it's all about security - that the targeted assassination of Ahmed Jaabari, a top Hamas commander, as well as the countless bombs killing militants and civilians alike in Gaza are to protect Israeli citizens from a dangerous, militant Hamas.

They are not.

The truth is this: Israel has engaged in its current, escalating military campaign not to protect Israelis from a militant Hamas, but in order to ensure that Hamas in Gaza remains militant. See, while Jaabari was a known terrorist who had his hand in the Gilad Shalit kidnapping, he was also the Hamas leader both willing and capable of enforcing ceasefire agreements. In fact, as Gershon Baskin writes in "Assassinating the Chance for Calm," Jaabari was considering a ceasefire proposal the moment he was assassinated. And Baskin should know, for he was working closely with Hamas officials on the proposal itself.

So why would Israel assassinate a Hamas official, a move guaranteed to provoke extreme outrage and revenge, at a time when Hamas leaders were working on a ceasefire? The answer is simple and twofold: a) Netanyahu's government wants a militant Hamas in Gaza; it wants a situation in which Gaza becomes isolated from the West Bank, hoping eventually Greater Israel will be obtained with Gaza becoming a separate entity, and b) with Israeli elections set for January, electoral motivations are undeniably in play with regard to this sudden military barrage.

This has happened before, this tactic to destroy a cease fire and stoke militant extremism. And it's a tactic I know intimately. See, in 2002, my wife was injured in the bombing of Hebrew University in Jerusalem. The bombing, carried out by Hamas, was a revenge attack for Israel's targeted assassination of a top Hamas terrorist, Sheikh Salah Shehada. The rub? This assassination came 90 minutes after Hamas, Islamic Jihad and the Palestinian Authority's Tanzim had agreed on a long-term ceasefire agreement that included a historic call from all organizations to end all terror attacks on civilians.

In 2002, Ariel Sharon launched an Israeli offensive when Palestinians were on the cusp of an historic ceasefire. Today, Netanyahu has done something similar. Both moments share a singular motivation: ensuring that Hamas remains a militant enemy. It is a desire Hamas has been all too willing to oblige for its own political gain, willing to accept the self-destructive, symbiotic relationship Israel offers repeatedly. Yes, Hamas is equally culpable in accepting Israel's hand in continuing a cycle of violence. But that culpability does not validate Yoffie's position. Instead, it weakens it all the more.

The second reason to reject Yoffie's "progressive" call is due to his stunningly misguided read on the human toll in Gaza. While Yoffie is right to be concerned and devastated about the suffering of Jewish civilians being injured and killed by rocket attacks from Gaza, he is wholly blind to the suffering of those in Gaza. In fact, Yoffie paints a picture of a Hamas that brutalizes Israeli civilians with rocket fire, and an Israel that always responds ethically and "with modest force" such that Palestinian suffering is minimal.

Anyone with even a limited understanding of what life in Gaza is like right now knows that Palestinian suffering is intense and overwhelming. Millions of people are being terrorized by one-ton bombs falling incessantly in residential areas, and scores of civilians - including young children - have been injured and killed so far. And those injured are unable to receive proper medical attention due to medicine and supply shortages caused by Israel's blockade of Gaza, itself a brutal and ever-present stranglehold.

The third reason to reject Yoffie's progressive call is because of the psychological place from whence his entire stance actually comes. In the end of his essay, he reveals why he believes everyone should support tough, massive military responses:

Israel came into being so that Jewish children would never again have to huddle together in fear, terrorized by enemies of the Jewish people, while their parents stood by helplessly. Helping those children is a progressive cause. And doing nothing for them undermines the sovereignty of the Jewish state and strikes a fatal blow at the very raison d'etre of Zionism.
The tragic irony, an irony Yoffie even recognizes is his post? It's this: Jewish families are huddled right now, being terrorized by a barrage of Hamas rockets, precisely because of "tough" Israeli response for which Yoffie advocates. And it's a position he advocates not out of wisdom, but out of those psychological demons that still haunt us from the Holocaust - demons which magnify Jewish victimhood such that brutalizing another people becomes a justifiable, even necessary position.

It is neither.

As Dahlia Scheindlin writes, there was another way. There always is.

Author's Note:

For those who reject my last paragraph treating the psychology of perspective, read Daniel Bar-Tal's "Why Does Fear Override Hope in Societies Engulfed by Intractable Conflict, as It Does in the Israeli Society?"

For in it, he shows the correlation between Jews' fear of annihilation (as a people) and the unwillingness to empathize or negotiate with the Palestinians -- making it a competition for victimhood, a zero-sum game.

Most interestingly, the study shows that Israeli Jews who fear for their own personal safety are just as willing to compromise and negotiate with Palestinians as those who fear no personal harm. It's the national fear of destruction that paralyzes everyone.

Originally posted to Writing by David Harris Gershon on Thu Nov 15, 2012 at 10:48 AM PST.

Also republished by Adalah — A Just Middle East.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Pat K California, elishastephens, Alfred E Newman, DeminNewJ, mickT, PeterHug, wu ming, lysias, Troutfishing, TX Unmuzzled, treehugger, Florida Democrat, Dumbo, bronte17, ask, sayitaintso, MillieNeon, stevej, chuckvw, mrblifil, Rujax206, Nate Roberts, Cedwyn, wader, Texknight, Eric Blair, hangingchad, crankypatriot, gerrilea, i dont get it, Catte Nappe, Oaktown Girl, FlyingToaster, AllisonInSeattle, Rusty Pipes, lyvwyr101, vacantlook, eve, sb, joanneleon, humphrey, blueyedace2, corvo, terrypinder, Brooke In Seattle, chidmf, YucatanMan, ratzo, sofia, lotlizard, LucyandByron, Philpm, martini, kovie, poco, esquimaux, The Sheeping of America, Keone Michaels, hideinplainsight, Lefty Coaster, el cid, callmecassandra, doingbusinessas, fiddlingnero, blueoregon, Statusquomustgo, Mr Horrible, ZenTrainer, GoldnI, old wobbly, pinkhighway, A Mad Mad World, Polacolor, greytdog, Deadicated Marxist, FishOutofWater, david mizner, daveygodigaditch, sfbob, FischFry, newpioneer, Swill to Power, artisan, Aunt Martha, OIL GUY, uciguy30, leonard145b, skaye19, Quanta, Assaf, South Park Democrat, hkorens, TruthFreedomKindness, OleHippieChick, Alexandre, elwior, skohayes, beltane, tofumagoo, RandomNonviolence, MrJayTee, pademocrat, carver, BYw, Karl Rover, In her own Voice, protectspice, rhutcheson, Celtic Merlin, maggiejean, malibu1964, McGahee220, cybrestrike, divineorder, CanyonWren, jennylind, Last Years Man, I give in to sin, mkor7, JesseCW, petral, RageKage, lastman, Riyaz Guerra, Leslie in KY, sfarkash, Christy1947, Johnnythebandit, Crabby Abbey, FrankCornish, Simple, Johnny Q, ericlewis0, science nerd, soaglow, stevenaxelrod, Lost Left Coaster, slowbutsure, La Gitane, ardyess, asterkitty, rcatbarr, Seek Truth, Wolf10, SueM1121, marianevans, Fire bad tree pretty, stargaze, The Rational Hatter, Tyto Alba, bluedust, mali muso, PhilJD, cailloux, Friendlystranger, SoCalSal, zenox, Ranger1, dradams, Mentatmark, DEMonrat ankle biter, Mathazar, Rejoinder, quill, stormicats, Sneelock, Liberal Granny, anodnhajo, Flying Goat, angry marmot, Jakkalbessie, rexxnyc, Joieau, Deep Texan, 420 forever, InAntalya, Mr Robert, Hunter Acosta, peachcreek, ricklewsive, splintersawry, Diane Gee, CitizenScientist, Glen The Plumber, DarkLadyNyara, BradyB, BobTheHappyDinosaur, Dumas EagerSeton, TheLawnRanger, Chaddiwicker, remembrance, softserve, Smoh, Avilyn, rigcath, Jim Domenico, TheDuckManCometh

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site