Skip to main content

Public education in the U.S. has featured state control of human development since Horace Mann and other educational “reformers” within the New England Protestant elite brought this novel approach of Prussian state-run universal compulsory schooling to America in the 1830s.  Canadian educational policy followed a similar “melting pot” social engineering of immigrants path while accepting a greater role for Protestant and Catholic education in the mix with secular public schools.  Today in both countries the bulk of public schools chart their course in sync with (or under the yoke of) continuing state efforts at high-stakes OSFA (one size fits all) standardization, though more so in the U.S. than in Canada.

I find this top-down “command and control” approach to public education at best boring and at worst very depressing, based on how I believe it diminishes the human imagination in particular and the human spirit in general.  So as an advocate for what I call “many educational paths”, I celebrate and take heart from those rare educational alternatives that manage to find a way to exist within the leviathan of standardized public education.  Sure there are a fair amount of private schools (for the more economically privileged among us) that follow these more human development supporting educational models, but I take my hat off to a community that can conceive and support a public school that challenges the hegemony of conventional standardization.

One such school that I recently read about in an online discussion on the AERO (Alternative Education Resource Organization) listserv is the Alpha II school in Toronto Ontario.  It is the more recent incarnation of the original Alpha school, set up in 1972 in the heyday of the progressive education movement in Canada and the U.S.  A movement that produced alternative public schools in many communities, including two - Earthworks and Community High School - begun a year earlier in my own hometown of Ann Arbor Michigan.  FYI... Earthworks eventually merged with Community High and the latter is still going strong, but many of these unorthodox public schools have been forced to close due to the increasing standardization of education over the past twenty years.

The story of Alpha and Alpha II in particular I find fascinating, an insight into a chapter of education history and highlighting perhaps a somewhat more open-minded approach to public education in Canada.  The story is courtesy of AERO members Carol Nash, a co-founder of the unorthodox school, and Deb O'Rourke, the school’s current volunteer coordinator.

The Hall-Dennis Report & the Creation of the Alpha School

In 1965, anticipating the Canadian centennial in 1967 and stewing in the milieu of 1960s progressive thought, the province of Ontario set up a commission to consider new approaches to public education consistent with the 1948 United Nations Declaration of Human Rights.  The two commission co-chairs were E.M. Hall, a well-respected judge and reformer, and L.A. Dennis, a small-town high school principal.  The Hall-Dennis Commission set out to consult with an array of experts (including one of my personal “gurus”, media philosopher Marshall McLuhan) and survey the world’s most innovative educational approaches.  

After visiting the Summerhill School in England, the commission decided that the school’s democratic-free school approach was the most consistent with the human rights Declaration and should be the model for all public schools in Ontario going forward.  The commission’s 1968 report, Living and Learning, recommended that the province move towards free school education in all Ontario’s public schools to best develop the unique talents of all its future citizens.  

The recommendation was accepted by the provincial government which set a path to implementation that involved retraining teachers and allowing each school to make their own transition to the free school model.  Some public schools in Ontario successfully made the transition but most did not, and growing teacher dissatisfaction with a poorly implemented retraining program (culminating in a lengthy teacher’s strike) led to the abandonment of the entire effort and the return of public schools in the province to the conventional teacher-directed education model.

An exception was the Alpha Elementary School, opened in 1972, which quietly continued with its free school philosophy despite the sea change by the provincial education bureaucracy.  With its dedicated teachers and intense parental support it was able to continue and thrive under the Summerhill democratic-free school model.   According to O’Rourke, it was the strong commitment of the school to its democratic governance model that has allowed it to continue and buck the larger trend of standardization of public education in the most recent decades...

Its core principles, over the years, prioritize the children and lead the teachers and parents back to a highly responsible form of community schooling, based on participatory democracy... One of the most vital parts of  “The ALPHA Experience” is under governance: “School to be governed by a staff-community council.” That’s all it says, but this single simple sentence made a huge difference to ALPHA’s survival. The School Board has always resisted community-controlled schooling, which was an important movement in Toronto in the sixties/seventies. The Board doesn’t officially recognize local school self-governance, but whenever there is an attempt to impose a systemic norm on ALPHA, it faces a well-organized, articulate, thoughtful, argumentative community of parents.
We are talking about a small group of committed and determined people (the most effective cadre for change as anthropologist Margaret Mead famously pointed out) saying no to top-down control and standardized education, and saying yes to the democratic process within an egalitarian learning community.  Most other progressive alternative schools spawned by the Hall-Dennis report fell by the wayside writes O’Rourke because they did not focus on their governance...
Many of the other long-standing alternatives began in the seventies as free schools... They stuck with a typical form of PTA, with an elected executive. Without the power of community consensus behind them, the school's arguments usually don't have a chance with the Board. ALPHA's community council (referred to as "Parent Meeting") is not an elected representation but everybody who chooses to attend meetings. Consensus takes time, and though it's simple, it's difficult for European-based cultures to understand. ALPHA originally learned from community members who were Quakers, and experienced in peace movements. It is a process we keep having to re-teach ourselves. With three new teachers next year as well as a parent community that changes about 15% each year, we are in such a period. Consensus is the traditional governance process of the Anishnaabe and the Haudenosaunee, the Indigenous people of this region. I hope that ALPHA will look to all these sources for its democratic renewal.
Starting & Continuing Alpha II

The Alpha elementary school has weathered the storm of educational standardization and continues to be be a small but profound educational alternative for children in Toronto.  Parents who put their kids in the Alpha school (and some of those parent themselves like Carol Nash attended and benefited from the Canadian free-schools of the 1970s) formed the core of the group in 2006 that successfully set up a public secondary school (grades 7 to 12) on the same democratic-free school model, called Alpha II, which today has 85 students.  

Nash was motivated to be part of the group of nine parents starting the Alpha II school because of her own experience going to public democratic-free schools in Toronto (spawned by Hall-Dennis) between 1969 and 1976.  She contrasted her own positive experience in school with that of her younger siblings who attended more conventional state-standardized schools.  Toward the end of eventually starting her own school, Nash became a teacher herself and continued her education to get a PhD in Philosophy of Education.  Nash credits the fact that she and three others of the nine having PhDs helped convince the Toronto District School Board to even entertain their proposal for a school that would not be required to follow the standardized state curriculum that all other Toronto public schools (except their sister Alpha elementary school) were required to follow.

Interestingly, it was getting the Board’s Director of Alternative Education, who was familiar with and sympathetic to the Hall-Dennis report, to visit some prominent democratic-free schools in the U.S. - Sudbury Valley, Albany Free School and Manhattan Free School - that Nash believes got that key Director to support the new school and successfully convince her Board colleagues to approve it.  Ironically these American schools visited are all private (or rather “independent” as they generally prefer to call themselves) because the school boards in American communities are so under the yoke of state standardization that they cannot possibly allow a public school that does not slavishly follow the state-directed curriculum.  Though Alpha II is a mere nit in a province with over 2,000,000 kids in school, you would be hard pressed to find even one publicly funded democratic-free school in most U.S. states.

Following the Democratic-Free School Model

Alpha II continues to be open today as the rarest of schools, a public democratic-free school because, writes Nash...

Our school has been able to continue with the Board because we have had extremely supportive Superintendents, Principals and teachers who all want to provide the unschool model.  Truly, everything just happened to fall into place at the right time with the right people.  Luck has to be seen as the most important factor.
Though actually a democratic-free school, I note that Nash refers to her school in the quote above as an “unschool”.  The logic I suspect is that since “schooling” implies something done to students by teachers, “unschooling” more accurately describes education that is learner rather than teacher-directed.  Part of that self-direction, that unschooling, is flexibility of attendance to accommodate some students' long commutes.  Writes Nash...
The good thing is a young person is able to enroll in Alpha II as long as they live in Ontario and can get to Alpha II at least once every 15 days.  That means we can serve people who live hundreds of miles away if they can drive into Toronto once a week or take public transit (there are many buses and trains that lead to Toronto).  We are right across from the Dufferin subway station.  Once you get into Toronto, you just have to transfer to the subway and it takes you right across from Alpha II.
Though Nash acknowledges that the Alpha schools have appealed to a mostly white constituency of families, she also calls out the importance of a public alternative school providing options to lower income families...
Like most alternative schools the majority of the 85 kids are white... Since my involvement with the elementary ALPHA began in 1985, there have been plenty of low-income folks. A huge reason for putting up with the rigors of the public system, was that the people most committed to democracy and equity in education do not tend to be able to afford private schools. There isn't much of a wealthy liberal/progressive/radical class in Canada.
The Challenge Replicating the Public Unschool Model

Whereas a public democratic-free or unschool in the U.S. is essentially impossible in today’s frenzy of school standardization, Nash acknowledges that though possible in Ontario, still the bar is set too high for parents to launch other schools on the Alpha/Alpha II model.  Writes Nash...

Other parents could duplicate Alpha II in Ontario.  However, it takes a lot of time, dedicated people, a knowledge of the history of education in Ontario, families who understand the importance of having unschooling as an option, and those great public officials working for the individual boards who know and support this type of education.  I have had families come to me who want to start a similar school somewhere in Ontario but the enormity of all the things they need to do, and the people they have to convince, has slowed them down and made them disheartened.  Remember, even for people like us, who were very well trained in developing this type of school, it was hard for us to.  There were many times when we thought all was lost.  
Contrasting Basic Educational Policy Between the U.S. & Canada

That window of opportunity for starting profoundly alternative public schools like Alpha or Alpha II in Ontario is called out in the “Alternative Schools” page of the Toronto District School Board website (my highlights added)...

TDSB Alternative schools offer students and parents something different from mainstream schooling. Each alternative school, whether elementary or secondary is unique, with a distinct identity and approach to curriculum delivery. They usually feature a small student population, a commitment to innovative and experimental programs, and volunteer commitment from parents/guardians and other community members. While the schools offer Ministry approved courses, these courses are delivered in a learning environment that is flexible and meets the needs of individual students.
That last sentence offers a glimmer of opportunity, but within a context still focused on provincial/state standardized curriculum.  In comparison my local Los Angeles Unified School District website has no section that I could find for alternative education or schools.  Where I found alternative schools mentioned in a U.S. public school website, it is usually framed as a form of remediation for students who fail in conventional schools.  From the Minneapolis public schools website page on “Alternative Schools” (again my highlights added)...
The Minneapolis Public School district is committed to providing a variety of opportunities to meet the needs of students. These programs provide a caring environment for students who need services beyond the traditional school day and during the summer to meet state and district standards. Students may be referred to alternative schools through one of the traditional Minneapolis public schools or students may choose to attend one of these schools.
Notice the explicit call out that “alternative” schools exist within the standards only, unlike the Ontario public school site indicating their alternative schools merely “offer” standard courses.

The Bottom Line Challenge

I Like Carol Nash’s underlying problem statement...

The fundamental value of both Canada and the US is that people should be free.  Yet, our societies seem to think that freedom is something that only adults should have once they have been through the requisite years of compulsory confinement in schools.  The problem is, once you have spent your childhood and early adulthood in confinement it is difficult to then know what freedom really is and to believe you actually have a right to it.
If our society is going to successfully continue its transition from hierarchies of control to an egalitarian circle of equals, progressive activists who believe in this human developmental transition will have to continue to fight, like these progressive education activists in Canada, to create the opportunity for societal institutions (particularly public schools) to fully embrace democratic principles.
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  Tip Jar (7+ / 0-)

    Cooper Zale Los Angeles

    by leftyparent on Sun Aug 11, 2013 at 05:00:13 AM PDT

  •  Temple Grandin: the world needs all kinds of... (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:

    “You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.” Buckminster Fuller

    by pfiore8 on Sun Aug 11, 2013 at 06:34:43 AM PDT

    •  Thanks for the link! I really like her story... (2+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      pfiore8, FloridaSNMOM

      I saw the movie of her life story and thought it really made the case for the need of people to have the ability to play the key role in their own development and not be trumped by some institutional bureaucratic pigeon hole.

      Cooper Zale Los Angeles

      by leftyparent on Sun Aug 11, 2013 at 07:34:38 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  Thanks for this excellent diary (4+ / 0-)

    I really appreciate you putting this together. I fully support a more progressive egalitarian schooling as represented by the free school movement.

    However, I think you need to address the challenge posed in the United States by the religious Right. If there had a been a school run democratically by parents where I grew up in East Texas, the parents would have created a horrible monster: students probably would have been required to recite the 10 Commandments every morning after the Pledge of Allegiance and would have been bombarded with propaganda about "intelligent design" (creationism), propaganda about the War of Aggression against the South (Civil War), John Birch-inspired racial tracts, and other horrible ignorance. As it was, some of my teachers did "instruct" us this way, but others protected us from this crap and offered a broader perspective and a truly scholarly education.

    Parental consensus does not work when a majority of the parents are fanatical religionists as well as fanatically ignorant and self-righteous.

    A top-down command structure is antithetical to true education and child development, but at least it prevents the worst of right-wing domination and indoctrination (except in Texas where the school board is dominated by right-wing Christianists). The current system at least demands that students are exposed to honest scholarship and introduced to our society's conventional body of knowledge (except in Texas).

    •  I hear your concern about fanatical parents... (2+ / 0-)

      but in the case of these Alpha schools, they had a very high bar pitching a provincial governance body to make the case for having their own school.  If we don't trust parents to be able to convince a board of educrats that they have the idea for a viable school then what's the point of having a democratic society and not a totalitarian state!

      We've got to trust people and accept that there will be some outliers who may do crazy stuff.  IMO you can't design a system to address the fringe.

      Cooper Zale Los Angeles

      by leftyparent on Sun Aug 11, 2013 at 03:05:03 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

  •  And what is the role of the teacher in this model? (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:

    Is the teacher a trained professional who has gone through a rigorous preparatory program lasting years?

    How does the teacher develop and teach the curriculum?  

    IS there a curriculum?

    "Nothing in all the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity." --M. L. King "You can't fix stupid" --Ron White -6.00, -5.18

    by zenbassoon on Sun Aug 11, 2013 at 07:40:42 AM PDT

    •  Generally in democratic-free schools... (0+ / 0-)

      the students set their own curriculum.  The adult staff may or may not be called "teachers" but are there to facilitate where needed and be more like counselors or resource librarians.  

      If a kid wants to learn Mandarin then the adult staff's job is to help the kid research resources for learning the language.  Otherwise the adult staff take care of all the logistical issues that the kids perhaps are not interested in being involved with (tho kids are generally encouraged in all ways to participate in running the school as part of their "curriculum").

      One of the problems the province of Ontario encountered in the late 1960s when they tried to convert all schools to this model was that the teachers had been so thoroughly trained in the directive instructional "sage on the stage" model that they were mostly very uncomfortable with this new "guide on the side" role.

      Cooper Zale Los Angeles

      by leftyparent on Sun Aug 11, 2013 at 02:19:41 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site