Skip to main content

A sign of the times: Popular Science, the 141-year-old publication that's one of my favorites to pick up at airports for in-flight reading, shut off comments on its website today. An important part of the decision was trolls and spambots, just like we struggle to keep in check through community moderation here at Daily Kos.

But there's something else, too, about how people yelling nonsense skews the discussion away from science. Away from fact. Away from their mission, which is to promote science. Away from reality.

It was a difficult and bittersweet decision.

We have many delightful, thought-provoking commenters. But even a fractious minority wields enough power to skew a reader's perception of a story, recent research suggests. In one study led by University of Wisconsin-Madison professor Dominique Brossard, 1,183 Americans read a fake blog post on nanotechnology and revealed in survey questions how they felt about the subject (are they wary of the benefits or supportive?).
From an op-ed the authors of that paper wrote in the NY Times:
  • Uncivil comments not only polarized readers, but they often changed a participant's interpretation of the news story itself.
  • In the civil group, those who initially did or did not support the technology — whom we identified with preliminary survey questions — continued to feel the same way after reading the comments. Those exposed to rude comments, however, ended up with a much more polarized understanding of the risks connected with the technology.
  • Simply including an ad hominem attack in a reader comment was enough to make study participants think the downside of the reported technology was greater than they'd previously thought.
As to shutting off the comments, this might be their most important consideration:
A politically motivated, decades-long war on expertise has eroded the popular consensus on a wide variety of scientifically validated topics. Everything, from evolution to the origins of climate change, is mistakenly up for grabs again. Scientific certainty is just another thing for two people to "debate" on television. And because comments sections tend to be a grotesque reflection of the media culture surrounding them, the cynical work of undermining bedrock scientific doctrine is now being done beneath our own stories, within a website devoted to championing science.
And so, commenting is no longer an option at the Popular Science website. Like I said, a sign of the times. Damned shame. (You can still write a letter to the editor. Or comment on Facebook, Twitter, Daily Kos, &c.)

Personally, it always bugs me - doubly - when there's reports on polls as to whether people "believe" in climate change. Somehow the Fundamentalist Right has made it a point of religious faith to deny climate change - funded by the Koch Brothers, whose wealth arises mainly by the petroleum industry. Yet another way the rich and powerful can put their thumbs on our cultural scales.

But really it's a matter of science, from the left-hand column of the above-the-squiggle table. No amount of propaganda, no matter how effective, will prevent the rising seas from swallowing low-lying islands. Yet the question gets framed in terms of belief, and then it gets reported as a poll result as if public opinion might somehow be able to stem the tide.

Popular Science might well be right that comments are counterproductive to their mission. Sad story, that. Kudos to kos and to all of us. For all our weaknesses and persistent problems, Daily Kos does a reasonably good job of managing the unwieldy chaos also known as comments.

Originally posted to Land of Enchantment on Tue Sep 24, 2013 at 08:31 PM PDT.

Also republished by SciTech.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Malacandra, a gilas girl, SME in Seattle, Louise, claude, Lupin, Velocity, Alumbrados, paradox, Superskepticalman, tsackton, Ed in Montana, DeminNewJ, vicki, chrississippi, KeithH, RF, Trix, Bill in Portland Maine, Mogolori, filkertom, Phoenix Woman, jotter, Brainwrap, teacherken, Scott Martin, Timaeus, Subterranean, Liberal Thinking, Joan McCarter, Rolfyboy6, Pandora, Powered Grace, NYmom, BigOkie, Bob Love, Emerson, dengre, alicia, Shockwave, LynChi, Wintermute, billlaurelMD, CleverNickName, Jay C, ericy, brendan1963, Vico, Stein, celdd, eeff, devtob, recentdemocrat, gjohnsit, FyodorFish, grover, exNYinTX, hnichols, dpeifer1949, Heart of the Rockies, cinnamon68, Great Cthulhu, Zinman, missLotus, TracieLynn, BlackSheep1, lippythelion69, whenwego, undercovercalico, ehavenot, highacidity, boadicea, mrblifil, farmerhunt, pedrito, retLT, sngmama, bwren, splashy, navajo, artebella, sidnora, fluffy, wader, Texknight, SneakySnu, kharma, dejavu, psnyder, annan, marko, Dallasdoc, mrkvica, Miss Jones, figbash, ranger995, Eyesbright, brainwave, Lawrence, Noodles, duncanidaho, churchylafemme, texasmom, NYFM, DSC on the Plateau, defluxion10, Catte Nappe, chickeee, papercut, kalmoth, lcrp, riverlover, BlogDog, Brian82, LR Frederick, outragedinSF, blonde moment, exlrrp, nswalls, peterj911, zerelda, ybruti, Curt Matlock, KayCeSF, JayDean, ScienceMom, jcrit, xyz, lurker123, Jen Hayden, vivadissent, Josiah Bartlett, xxdr zombiexx, Timroff, murrayewv, oortdust, sawgrass727, Brecht, Dirk McQuigley, maybeeso in michigan, historys mysteries, radarlady, 3goldens, Tinfoil Hat, Ckntfld, ichibon, el dorado gal, UncleCharlie, LakeSuperior, m16eib, caul, SherwoodB, HudsonValleyMark, democracy inaction, Alice Venturi, JohnB47, elkhunter, Simplify, eightlivesleft, basquebob, terrypinder, dewtx, ChemBob, juliesie, Brooke In Seattle, YucatanMan, EJP in Maine, Laurence Lewis, Kevskos, Gary Norton, boofdah, bleeding blue, cfk, Ianb007, majcmb1, freemark, Pam from Calif, Sun Tzu, Sara R, Fury, ladybug53, Ice Blue, blue jersey mom, markdd, Cecile, brentut5, Shotput8, Rusty in PA, sodalis, Lisa Lockwood, sillia, Rogneid, peacestpete, Ekaterin, mightymouse, kathny, bently, begone, mariva, Mother Mags, WuChier, occams hatchet, rserven, kovie, Knucklehead, buddabelly, BachFan, kumaneko, flying shams, myboo, rcbowman, cybersaur, profundo, bastrop, liberalconservative, seefleur, koNko, AoT, KenBee, flygrrl, Naniboujou, arlene, kck, blueoasis, shrike, global citizen, StrayCat, erratic, gpoutney, alwaysquestion, The Hindsight Times, Rosaura, agnostic, jerseyjo, JVolvo, unclebucky, Zwoof, tommyfocus2003, sceptical observer, ER Doc, Unitary Moonbat, middleagedhousewife, blue in NC, Turbonerd, onionjim, BlueMississippi, IL clb, doingbusinessas, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, Dianna, Ian Reifowitz, cohenzee, NancyWH, FrankieB, bstotts, Friend of the court, Temmoku, markthshark, Nulwee, Aaa T Tudeattack, DBunn, Thinking Fella, The Knute, tegrat, clinging to hope, FlamingoGrrl, pgm 01, FoundingFatherDAR, bluicebank, BeninSC, bvljac, dotsright, Cronesense, jessical, Habitat Vic, peagreen, Jarrayy, Loudoun County Dem, JohnMac, tgypsy, camlbacker, Debs2, devis1, ColoTim, paz3, gloriana, EdSF, Stwriley, karmsy, FishOutofWater, Mary Mike, Blue State 68, la urracca, Nespolo, Via Chicago, Cofcos, HeartlandLiberal, daveygodigaditch, Matt Z, terabytes, sfbob, davehouck, bnasley, HCKAD, jayden, martyinsfo, cyncynical, jnhobbs, Fireshadow, millwood, jhop7, gchaucer2, Librarianmom, fbiots, Wreck Smurfy, leonard145b, skod, TexasTwister, keikekaze, Don midwest, kdnla, Ralphdog, on the cusp, TomP, Empower Ink, gizmo59, rmonroe, fb, Mighty Ike, jwinIL14, MKinTN, alkalinesky, mconvente, gzodik, jack 1966, also mom of 5, JeffW, TX Freethinker, SaintDharma32, GAS, wayoutinthestix, MikePhoenix, spacejam, zerone, mamamedusa, Sixty Something, Youffraita, Senor Unoball, Aureas2, Involuntary Exile, bythesea, Ronald England, elwior, Fe Bongolan, skohayes, treesrock, jakebob, mikeconwell, moose67, Dancing Frog, RandomNonviolence, smartdemmg, bluesheep, triplepoint, TokenLiberal, Jeff Y, catly, home solar, codairem, glendaw271, petulans, 3rdOption, costello7, matching mole, BYw, Keninoakland, Quilldriver, rodentrancher, palantir, WearyIdealist, toom, rhutcheson, watercarrier4diogenes, statsone, GustavMahler, maxcat06, JBL55, oldliberal, legendmn, LaFeminista, bluebelle7, maggiejean, prettygirlxoxoxo, Bule Betawi, Rhysling, artmartin, rubyclaire, cybrestrike, J M F, arendt, Dirtandiron, nchristine, LinSea, Magick Maven, ewmorr, bobatkinson, welso, banjolele, Carol in San Antonio, CanyonWren, Don Enrique, Nebraskablue, Ohiodem1, WakeUpNeo, War on Error, Hopeful Monster, fToRrEeEsSt, LibrErica, DefendOurConstitution, petral, geebeebee, Jyrki, mksutherland, Denise Oliver Velez, kevinpdx, Shelley99, Keith Pickering, histOries Marko, Munchkn, stevenwag, sfarkash, Lacy LaPlante, ChartersOfDreams, ArthurPoet, Tortmaster, ayjaymay, jfromga, astral66, Livvy5, karma13612, porchdog1961, nocynicism, Larsstephens, BlueOak, gneissgirl, Railfan, Amber6541, Just Bob, smileycreek, confitesprit, Mokurai, FogCityJohn, p gorden lippy, LaughingPlanet, serendipityisabitch, politik, piers, secret38b, klompendanser, Crabby Abbey, mookins, Polly Syllabic, your neighbor, mjbleo, RJP9999, Eddie L, psychbob, gulfgal98, tb mare, pixxer, Puddytat, Jaimas, nirbama, orlbucfan, DrTerwilliker, MsGrin, kenwards, ericlewis0, USHomeopath, Loose Fur, cocinero, Oh Mary Oh, ZedMont, txcatlin, whatever66, slice, Hooverson, Wisdumb, dpwks, indubitably, theKgirls, Mike08, Barbara Marquardt, kerflooey, Front Toward Enemy, Bluefin, HarpLady, mama jo, Liberal Capitalist, pb3550, Bob Duck, slowbutsure, valkyrry, vahana, AdamR510, BPARTR, La Gitane, Seitanist, Zutroy, Mistral Wind, FarWestGirl, Situational Lefty, mikejay611, OhioNatureMom, Hatrax, kevin k, mujr, wsbuffalo, CoExistNow, trumpeter, Haf2Read, marleycat, sethtriggs, cyberpuggy, thomask, Santa Susanna Kid, Ojibwa, midnight lurker, JWK, gof, SueM1121, merrily1000, Prinny Squad, LSmith, Grandma Susie, IB JOHN, nogo postal, voicemail, Sark Svemes, enhydra lutris, CorinaR, myrmecia gulosa, bluedust, Imhotepsings, VTCC73, Caddis Fly, disconnect the dots, Marihilda, waiting for lefty, blue aardvark, ratcityreprobate, Sunspots, imlpdx, DRo, Regina in a Sears Kit House, jrfrog, Mentatmark, SouthernLiberalinMD, T100R, caryltoo, StPeteDave, No one gets out alive, Laurel in CA, deltadoc, Mathazar, BlueDragon, YaNevaNo, IowaBiologist, Sister Inspired Revolver of Freedom, jellyyork, quill, Only Needs a Beat, Pinto Pony, nominalize, JTinDC, The Book Bear, anodnhajo, angry marmot, Williston Barrett, IndieGuy, ahumbleopinion, DrLori, David54, joanil, Joieau, pimutant, Deep Texan, FloridaSNMOM, Trotskyrepublican, Horace Boothroyd III, This old man, Mr Robert, chicagobleu, Mike RinRI, Th0rn, peachcreek, jan4insight, carolanne, belinda ridgewood, willrob, reginahny, Lilredhead, MartyM, burnt out, pittie70, notdarkyet, wxorknot, bryduck, rat racer, Victim of Circumstance, AverageJoe42, raina, Glen The Plumber, George3, wasatch, mumtaznepal, RonK, AZ Sphinx Moth, Robynhood too, Arilca Mockingbird, Hammerhand, Most Awesome Nana, madcitysailor, BobTheHappyDinosaur, allensl, kestrel sparhawk, Ray Pensador, Lily O Lady, Blue Bell Bookworm, Chaddiwicker, Panacea Paola, Dallas L, simple serf, countwebb, argomd, jbob, Tim DeLaney, SanFernandoValleyMom, Says Who, broths, 84thProblem, DustBunny, goodpractice, minnec, SixSixSix, Alhambra, leeleedee, Aunt Pat, RiveroftheWest, MarEng, JerryNA, JosephK74, LaraJones, bob152, Smoh, IndyinDelaware, ET3117, Hey338Too, Demeter Rising, Mike Kahlow, Expat Okie, marcr22, sjburnman, The Story Teller, Ishmaelbychoice, Jim Domenico, OceanDiver, Retroactive Genius, martianexpatriate, Halfton81, oslyn7, patcii, Metric Only, TheDuckManCometh, Mark Mywurtz, Rich Lyles, dannyboy1, Dr Arcadia, hamjudo, Dodgerdog1, eagleray, Elizaveta, VPofKarma, sillycarrot, Delphinium Unicorn, DoggieBytes, DavidMyers, Here since 02, dcdeland

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site