Daily Kos

Obama takes planted question? Edwards mute!

Mon Dec 17, 2007 at 09:22:12 AM PDT

I think we are ALL agreed that the practice of taking planted questions on the campaign trail is one which should be discouraged.
Some of you agree that it is a uniquely Bush-league tactic. For the purposes of this post, I'll defer to that latter group.
Given all the negative attention that Hillary got for taking planted questions, one would think that the other campaigns would have made certain to weed out the practice.

Oh well. Obama can always blame this one on his staffers.

   ABC News' Sunlen Miller Reports: Senator Barack Obama, D-Ill., received a very friendly question from a campaign volunteer at an official event -- a practice the campaign admits is not the norm.

   Eighteen-year-old student Jim Mohler was called on by Obama during the question and answer section of a town hall in Estherville, Iowa, and asked, "Right now, as I understand it, the tax limit is $97,000 which means like the most anyone can pay on taxes is what they would pay on $97,000, but yet we have people like Warren Buffett and Bill Gates that are making billions upon billions of dollars and are still paying taxes on $97,000 is anyway we can make them pay taxes on what they're making?"

   Obama thoroughly answered Mohler, then commented, "Good question," before moving on to another.

   The question was very similar to an anecdote which Obama regularly recites on the campaign trail.

   At a town hall in Independence, Iowa, on Sunday, just one day prior to Mohler's question, Obama told the crowd, "Everyone who make $97,000 a year or less, you are paying payroll tax on 100% of your income, now my friend, Warren Buffet, he made $46 million last year, he had an off year," before elaborating on how he intends to lift the cap on Social Security.

from
http://www.theleftcoaster.com/...

Maybe Edwards is just waiting for ironclad proof.
Once that exists, I have no doubt that Edwards will say:
"That's what George does: George Bush goes to events that are staged where people are screened"

I just can't wait!!
Ok, now discuss!

Tags: Obama, Edwards, planted question, Hillary Clinton (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

View Comments | 140 comments