Daily Kos

Open Thread for Night Owls, Early Birds & Ex-Pats

Digg this! Share this on Twitter - Open Thread for Night Owls, Early Birds & Ex-PatsTweet this submit to reddit

Sun Sep 07, 2008 at 10:38:11 PM PDT

Sebastian Mallaby writes at the Washington Post:

McCain's Convenient Untruth

When it comes to fighting wars, John McCain stands up and calls for sacrifice. "We never hide from history; we make history," he declared in his convention speech. But when it comes to taxes, McCain is unwilling to demand even a teensy bit of sacrifice. In a McCain administration, Americans would not have to surrender a dime more of their money to a cause larger than themselves.

Why this bipolar attitude toward sacrifice? Start with the answer that McCain himself provides. "My tax cuts will create jobs. His tax increases will eliminate them," he said at the convention, offering one of the speech's few policy contrasts between Obama's platform and his own. In other words, McCain is not calling for tax sacrifice because he believes it would be counterproductive. On taxes, he is saying, you can selfishly avoid sacrifice -- and serve the public good.

This, unfortunately, is a convenient untruth. Tax hikes taken to an extreme can indeed backfire, harming growth and job creation. But it's a stretch to assert that Barack Obama's tax plan would do that. ...

Obama is not proposing to raise taxes for most Americans. To the contrary, he would triple the earned-income tax credit for low-wage earners, increasing work incentives at the bottom. He would cut taxes on people in the middle -- indeed, he would do so more aggressively than McCain would. It is only the wealthiest Americans who would face higher tax bills under Obama. ...

So McCain's swipe at Obama's tax plan was something other than straight talk. As a share of the economy, Obama's plan would create an overall tax burden similar to the one that existed in Ronald Reagan's time. It would not choke off job creation; rather, it would slow the growth of the deficit and soften inequality. But the really depressing thing is that McCain himself once knew that.

The Overnight News Digest is posted and includes the story, McCain's history of hot temper raises concerns.

Update [2008-9-8 2:3:16 by Meteor Blades]:: A scrolling Diary that should not be missed is ALERT: Palin’s Pipeline is a Climate Crisis Acceleration Machine.

  • ::
Poll

Have you ever been queried in a national poll?

20%2686 votes
76%10050 votes
2%294 votes
0%71 votes

| 13101 votes | Vote | Results

Tags: Open Thread, John McCain (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

View Comments | 259 comments