Which Senators' records most resemble John Edwards'?
Given that John Edwards is a relative unknown among the Kossacks, they have, at times, based their opinion of him on relatively superficial characteristics, such as his Southern roots.  As a result, he's often perceived as far more conservative than he is.

For a general election, this perception works for him; it's better to be more liberal than you appear than more conservative, as is the case for Dean.  However, in the primary, it can be a liability.

So I figured I'd compare his record to his fellow Senators, so the Kossoacks could see which better-known Senators' records most closely resemble John Edwards'.

Methodology: Votes considered were those in which both Edwards and the other Senator voted either "Yea" or "Nay"; those votes where they held the same position are counted as agreement.

In the 106th Congress, 1st Sesson:

Senator          Agreement
Bayh     IN            92%
Sarbanes MD            92%
Mikulski MD            91%
Levin    MI            91%
Durbin   IL            91%

In the 106th Congress, 2nd Session:

Senator          Agreement
Akaka    HI            94%
Kennedy  MA            93%
Bryan    NV            92%
Bayh     IN            92%
Kerry    MA            92%

In the 107th Congress, 1st Session:

Senator          Agreement
Mikulski MD            95%
Akaka    HI            93%
Schumer  NY            93%
Leahy    VT            93%
Reed     NV            93%

In the 107th Congress, 2nd Session:

Senator          Agreement
Carnahan  MO           93%
Kerry     MA           92%
Lieberman CT           91%
Johnson   SD           91%
Nelson    FL           90%

In the 108th Congress, 1st Session:

Senator          Agreement
Lieberman CT           98%
Kerry     MA           98%
Daschle   SD           96%
Durbin    IL           96%
Sarbanes  MD           96%

With whom was he most often in disagreement?

In the 106th, 1st: Nickles (R-OK), Kyl (R-AZ), Sessions (R-AL), Thomas (R-WY), Enzi (R-WY).

In the 106th, 2nd: Kyle (R-AZ), Gramm (R-TX), Nickles (R-OK), Santorum (R-PA), Ensign (R-NV).

In the 107th, 1st: Kyl (R-AZ), Gramm (R-TX), Smith (R-NH), Nickles (R-OK), Helms (R-NC).

In the 107th, 2nd: Inhofe (R-OK), Smith (R-NH), Coverdell (R-GA), Helms (R-NC), Gramm (R-TX).

In the 108th, 1st: Nickels (R-OK), Kyl (R-AZ), Smith (R-NH), Gramm (R-TX), Thompson (R-TN).


21 Comments
Comment Settings
  • ( f ) Recommend
  • ( r ) Reply
  • ( p ) Parent
  • ( o ) Open/Close
  • ( j ) Next Unread
  • ( k ) Prev Unread