This site, and others like it on both the left and the right, have expended hundreds of thousands of words over the years trashing traditional media, often rightly so. I think part of this criticism stems from what we citizen activists believe journalism should be - a bedrock of democracy, informing, analyzing, investigating, giving us the facts and the truth laid bare so we can make informed choices as voters and citizens.
When it falls short of this mission, we feel cheated, often with a vehemence as pronounced as that of a misled lover. And there truly is something of a romantic flavor between readers and journalists: the best of both love words, love facts, love information and analysis, love the notion of "comforting the afflicted and afflicting the comfortable," to paraphrase H.L. Mencken. The best readers and reporters also share what I think of as an irreverent yet disarmingly hopeful, no-bullshit, prove-it-to-me attitude that reflects a foundation of either cynical idealism or idealistic cynicism (I can't make up my mind).
At least four of the current and past front pagers here were at one point in their lives working journalists, and I suspect many of the diarists are either current or past reporters themselves. Part of the bitter betrayal expressed on this blog stems from a first-hand knowledge that reporting can be done better, more fully and deeply, and surely more courageously than it has been done under the Bush administration. In these times when so few reporters take career risks at all, worrying about getting a lousy reassignment, offending a source or being shunted out to a hinterland bureau, it's easy to lose sight of those writers and outlets that have shown consistent courage and dignity in the face of ordinary manipulation and not-so-ordinary horror and death.
I'm thinking tonight about Jill Carroll and the Christian Science Monitor.
Carroll, as I'm sure most of you know, was a freelance journalist for the Monitor kidnapped by an Iraqi terrorist group in January on her way to an interview. Her driver was thrown out of the car at gunpoint, her translator was killed and Carroll has been held hostage, seen only on videotape, as demands were made and deadlines were passed.
Last month, the Monitor undertook a creative campaign to free Carroll, scripting and filming public service announcements in Arabic (with the cooperation of CNN), with the message: "Kidnapped American journalist Jill Carroll loves Iraq, and now she needs your help. It is time for Jill Carroll to come home safely." These PSA's are being broadcast now throughout Iraq.
From the Monitor:
The 60- and 90-second spots include quotations from Iraqis speaking of how they consider Carroll to be an innocent sister or daughter, and asking for her captors to see her in the same way and release her. They also include a quotation from an earlier public statement by Jill's mother, Mary Beth Carroll.
The longer spot includes an emotional segment from a press conference of Sunni leader Adnan al-Dulaimi, whom Carroll was supposed to interview on Jan. 7, calling for her release. She was kidnapped near his office.
Touchingly, and in the "finally, good news out of Iraq" category, the Monitor relates;
Iraqi television stations have agreed to run the messages free of charge, in the spirit of a public-service announcement for a captive colleague.
The Monitor is keeping a "Jill Carroll Update" page here, and the PSA can be viewed here.
With the release last week of the three Christian Peacemaker Team hostages, there seems to be more promise for Carroll's survival; indeed, her family expressed "new hope" about the young reporter's fate. Reporters Without Borders last week marked the third anniversary of the Iraq war with the unveiling of portraits of Carroll and two other kidnapped journalists in Paris, the launch of an international awareness campaign about the risks run by journalists in Iraq and the announcement of a support fund for the families of journalists working for newspapers "with very limited resources."
Additionally, Reporters Without Borders released a "survey about the 86 journalists killed in Irak since March 2003 - who they were, how they died, and who fired the shots that killed them." Please, take a few minutes and read it.
These 86 people are not Chris Matthews or Fox News bobbleheads or even one of our favorites, like Keith Olbermann or Jon Stewart. These are people who went to the battleground of a chaotic and war-torn country, and they died trying to bring us the truth.
They were - in the best sense of the word - journalists.