Fourth Generation Warfare: "You have to hunt like a network to defeat a network."

arubyan

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Tuesday August 15, 2006 · 11:20 AM PDT

2006/08/15 · 11:20

(Cross posted at E Pluribus Unum)

[Note: This is the first of a series of posts on the topic of fourth-generation warfare (4GW).]

If you read the Seymour Hersh piece in the New Yorker, perhaps you remember him quoting John Arquilla:

"Strategic bombing has been a failed military concept for ninety years, and yet air forces all over the world keep on doing it," John Arquilla, a defense analyst at the Naval Postgraduate School, told me. Arquilla has been campaigning for more than a decade, with growing success, to change the way America fights terrorism.
"The warfare of today is not mass on mass," he said. "You have to hunt like a network to defeat a network. Israel focussed on bombing against Hezbollah, and, when that did not work, it became more aggressive on the ground. The definition of insanity is continuing to do the same thing and expecting a different result."

Well, that got my attention.

I'd been looking for and reading everything I could find on 4GW. I'm a network engineer by training and with my interest in politics and history I found the topic to be fascinating. I started with what many believe is the seminal work on the subject: The Changing Face of War: Into the Fourth Generation. But more on that another time.

Back to John Arquilla, from an interview at the Institute of International Studies...

The social behavior of a network is quite different than a hierarchy, in that decision-making is often consensual in nature; that is, what people choose becomes the path they take. It's not very centrally controlled by any means.
The most successful networks don't have a step-by-step script of their actions, even though they have a sense of a great goal that they want to achieve. It's a little bit like ants, who identify the carcass of a worm that they want to get. The word comes back to others, "the worm is over there," and ants will send out many, many different trails. The ones that turn out to be the easiest, the quickest, turn out to be the ones that more people go to, but there's an absolute multitude of trails that are set up.
Our work there is called swarmed intelligence. The people in the entomology business have figured out a lot about cross-connections and networking. Ants do it, of course, with their pheromones; we do it with our cell phones.

Arquilla goes on to make a lot of very interesting observations in this interview. Here's an outline:

Background ... influence of parents ... education ... mentors ... importance of ideas ... issues of war and peace
Challenges Posed by Networks ...germ of ideas ... collaboration ... empowering of networks ... organizational forms ... swarming ... military implications ... decentralization
The Structure of Networks ... the story ... embedded information ... leaderless swarming ... pulsing ... technology ... control versus ground-level empowerment ... "dirtying" clean money ... social ties
Organizational Response ... moving toward networks ... 9/11 surprise as failure of imagination and organization ... implications for the military ... top sight ... eBay style of command ... empowering soldiers ... morale and ethnical dimension
Societal Networks ... innovation in civil and uncivil organizations ... limiting state power ... consequences for the nation state ... not chess but Go
Conclusion ... 9/11 ... advice to students ... prehistoric social norm of networking

Vietnam, Iraq, Soviet-Afghanistan, Lebanon, and others, are all examples of fourth generation warfare.

How do you fight an adversary like that and win?

Arquilla is one guy who might have the answer.

This content was created by a Daily Kos Community member.

Make YOUR voice heard!

Comments are closed on this story.