George Tenet, Tommy Franks and Paul Bremer received the Presidential Medal of Freedom from George Bush in 2004. At the ceremony, here's what Bush said about each one:
From David Stout's article in the December 14, 2004 edition of the The New York Times:
At the ceremony, Bush said all three "made our country more secure and advanced the cause of human liberty."
"George Tenet was one of the first to recognize and address the growing threat to America from radical terrorist networks," Mr. Bush said. "Immediately after the attacks of Sept. 11, George was ready with a plan to strike back at Al Qaeda and to topple the Taliban."
Mr. Bremer "will be remembered for his superb work in laying the foundations of a new democracy in the Middle East..." Bush said.
From Ann Gerhart's article in the December 15, 2004 editon of The Washington Post:
He praised Franks for his Iraq war plan, which utilized "a force half the size of the force that won the Gulf War" to reach Baghdad in less than a month, "the fastest, longest armored advance in the history of American warfare."
Franks campaigned for Bush in 2004.
After Ron Suskind's book "The One Percent Doctrine" and now Thomas Ricks' "Fiasco" were published, it has become abundantly clear that George Tenet compromised his country and fellow citizens, forsaking his sworn duties because of indebtedness to George Bush.
From Barton Gellman's book review of "The One Percent Doctrine" in the June 20, 2006 edition of The Washington Post:
Suskind's portrait of Tenet, respectful but far from adulatory, depicts a man compromised by "insecurity and gratitude" to a president who chose not to fire him after 9/11. "At that point, George Tenet would do anything his President asked," Suskind writes.
Ricks' portrait of Bremer includes two mistakes Bremer made despite warnings not to do so:
From Thomas Ricks' own article in the July 23, 2006 edition of The Washington Post:
On May 16, 2003, L. Paul Bremer III, the chief of the Coalition Provisional Authority, the U.S.-run occupation agency, had issued his first order, "De-Baathification of Iraq Society." The CIA station chief in Baghdad had argued vehemently against the radical move, contending: "By nightfall, you'll have driven 30,000 to 50,000 Baathists underground. And in six months, you'll really regret this."
He was proved correct, as Bremer's order, along with a second that dissolved the Iraqi military and national police, created a new class of disenfranchised, threatened leaders.
From that same article:
That summer, retired Marine Col. Gary Anderson, an expert in small wars, was sent to Baghdad by the Pentagon to advise on how to better put down the emerging insurgency. He met with Bremer in early July. "Mr. Ambassador, here are some programs that worked in Vietnam," Anderson said.
It was the wrong word to put in front of Bremer. "Vietnam?" Bremer exploded, according to Anderson. "Vietnam! I don't want to talk about Vietnam. This is not Vietnam. This is Iraq!"
Here's Ricks about Franks on the July 23, 2006 edition of Meet The Press:
MR. RICKS: Another surprise to me in writing this was that I think this probably was one of the worst war plans in American history. When you talked to people who had to implement it, they said it didn't speak to the basic problem. All the energy went to how you get to Baghdad, which was the easy part of it. Very little thought went to what do you do after you get there. So they spent 90 percent of their time on 10 percent of the problem. And they had a war plan that was effectively a kind of a banana republic coup d'etats: decapitate the Iraqi regime. When actually the plan that they were supposed to do was supposed to change Iraq and change the Middle East. So the war plan really didn't speak to what top authorities, the president, had asked them to do.
Here's Franks quoted in Colin Fly's May 22, 2006 Associated Press article:
General Tommy Franks, former Central Command Commander, who developed and executed the bloody Iraq fiasco, recently told the National Rifle Association that it wasn't important how many Americans died -- that those who count the increasing number of American soldiers killed in Iraq are missing the bigger picture. "What we're talking about is neither 2,400, 24,000 or 240,000 lives," Franks said. "Terrorism is a thing that threatens our way of life. It doesn't have anything to do with politics."
Some day, some enterprising content provider will create "The Surreal Life #45733" featuring the top failers and greatest brown-nosers of the Bush Administration. How will they be determined? Just check and see who received medals.
