By the way, the reasons for Democrats holding private interviews, and conducting them like grand jury hearings, are obvious: They minimize political grandstanding by lawmakers and witnesses. They allow staff attorneys to ask questions for extended blocks of time, and private interviews prevent witnesses from lining up their stories in advance by simply watching what other witnesses say during public hearings.
To its credit, The Washington Post recently published a stinging editorial condemning Republicans for their bogus "process" attacks. "There is an old Washington saying that if you’re arguing about process, you’re losing," the Post editorial board wrote. "A follow-on maxim might be: If you are wrong on process, too, you must really be in trouble."
But this frank discussion should not be restricted to the opinion pages. The fact is, Democrats are following the established rules, as National Memo's Joe Conason helpfully pointed out. "House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-CA), today insists the impeachment inquiry shouldn’t proceed unless the Republicans are permitted to issue subpoenas — but the rule that awards subpoena power exclusively to the majority is precisely what he and his cronies approved four years ago," Conason wrote.
That rather central point was completely omitted by The New York Times in a recent news article headlined, "Republicans Fight Trump’s Impeachment by Attacking the Process." The story presented a partial, Both Sides picture (i.e. Republicans are attacking the process, and Democrats say it's fair). But that leaves out a lot. For instance, during the impeachment inquiries of Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton, the minority power did not enjoy unilateral subpoena power, and fact-finding interviews were often held behind closed doors. (The public hearings came later.)
What the Times article did contain though, were many, many quotes from angry Republicans denouncing the "process." And again, that is what has been shortsighted about the coverage: reporters scrambling to collect outraged Republican quotes without including proper context that the GOP beefs are utterly unwarranted.
Most Republican senators are supporting an unusual, non-binding resolution that publicly condemns the House for how its handling its business—in this case, the impeachment business of Trump. The GOP move has generated lots of press coverage even though it's little more than a stunt, since the Senate, by design, has no say in how the House conducts its hearings. And the coverage has consisted of little more than journalists transcribing (surprise!) angry quotes from Republicans. A Hill dispatch on the resolution last week included seven quotes from Republicans,and zero quotes from Democrats. The article also completely failed to point out House Democrats are following rules established by Republicans.
That Times report also quoted a portion of the Senate resolution denouncing the House, claiming the House inquiry "ignores the procedural rights given to the investigating committee’s minority in previous presidential impeachments." And yes, that would have been a good moment for the Times to point out the House is following rules previously passed by Republicans.
Meanwhile, The Wall Street Journal reported Democrats were being forced to "defend" hosting private impeachment interviews, as the paper embraced GOP talking points. And the Post suggested the House Republican protest last week was "weird" because instead of being locked out of the impeachment hearings, lots of Republicans were attending them and asking questions. (They often use their question time to push debunked conspiracy theories.)
Using the word "weird" suggests Republicans simply can't see the flaw in their logic. But they can. They know their claims are hollow and bogus. They're just hoping the press doesn't say so.
Eric Boehlert is a veteran progressive writer and media analyst, formerly with Media Matters and Salon. He is the author of Lapdogs: How the Press Rolled Over for Bush and Bloggers on the Bus. You can follow him on Twitter @EricBoehlert.
This post was written and reported through our Daily Kos freelance program.
Comments are closed on this story.