The whole kerfuffle comes across as petty and highlights the Times' identity crisis in the age of Trump. Instead of rushing to the frontlines and aggressively confronting America's first pathological liar president, the Times too often embraces timidity, as in its bewildering policy of not calling Trump a liar in the news pages. The paper clings to the idea that sophisticated reporters can't actually tell if he is lying or just confused and misinformed. In essence, the paper is choosing its role as insider White House chronicler over that of aggressive truth teller.
The newsroom knows it should be unabashedly critical and confrontational, and that's how the paper markets itself. But who can forget how, in March, having read not one page of Robert Mueller's report on his Russia investigation, the Times rushed to announce that Trump had been exonerated and that Mueller's conclusions had provided Trump with a "powerful boost" toward reelection?
The official reason behind the unfolding MSNBC ban is that the Times' newsroom guidelines urge reporters to stay away from overly opinionated programming. And I appreciate the significance of that. Years ago I argued that National Public Radio was badly damaging its brand of independent journalism by allowing reporter Mara Liasson to constantly appear on Fox News, which broadcasts racist, hateful programming without pause. NPR allowed the Liasson appearances despite the fact that the radio network's code of ethics stipulated that reporters should not take part "in shows, electronic forums, or blogs that encourage punditry and speculation rather than fact-based analysis."
That was concerning in the case of Fox News, a network that openly broadcasts propaganda. There's obviously nothing in MSNBC's programming day that even remotely mirrors the hallmark dishonesty that Fox News proudly displays. The Times' newsroom policy currently states, "Staff members should avoid strident, theatrical forums that emphasize punditry and reckless opinion-mongering.” Does anyone at the Times actually believe meticulous-minded Maddow engages in "reckless opinion-mongering"?
Note that, in the past, the Times didn't mind sending reporters onto Fox News when it meant attacking Hillary Clinton. Back in 2015, Times reporter Jo Becker happily cooperated with Fox News for its 60-minute special The Tangled Clinton Web. Based on the sloppy, partisan book Clinton Cash, which was published by Rupert Murdoch’s HarperCollins and heavily promoted by Murdoch’s Fox News, Murdoch’s Wall Street Journal, and Murdoch’s New York Post, The Tangled Clinton Web was a mishmash of half-baked Clinton conspiracy theories that had Hillary and Bill Clinton at the center of a supposed vast web of international bribes and payoffs. Why did Becker appear? Because she wrote a controversial Times piece that was inspired by Clinton Cash. Part of the Times' misguided “exclusive” arrangement with the book’s author, Becker’s article tried, and failed, to show that donations to the Clinton Foundation influenced Clinton’s State Department when it signed off on the sale of Uranium One, a Canadian company with uranium mining claims in the U.S., to the Russian atomic energy agency, Rosatom.
Meanwhile, it's hard to shake the idea that institutional jealousy isn't driving some of the Times’ current policy toward MSNBC and Maddow. The host, of course, has certainly dedicated more airtime than anyone in television to the Russia investigation, dissecting all the details and providing a wide context for the still-unfolding scandals. The Times, on the other hand, famously bungled the Russia hacking story during the 2016 elections, to the point where the paper's public editor wrote two stinging columns about the newsroom's Russia failure. (The public editor's position was soon eliminated.)
A tip: The New York Times should spend more time standing up to Trump, and less time standing up to MSNBC.
Eric Boehlert is a veteran progressive writer and media analyst, formerly with Media Matters and Salon. He is the author of Lapdogs: How the Press Rolled Over for Bush and Bloggers on the Bus. You can follow him on Twitter @EricBoehlert.
This post was written and reported through our Daily Kos freelance program.
Comments are closed on this story.