Did he strategically place himself in front of her vehicle with the intention of recording her death, ignoring a ‘subjective belief of imminent harm’.
x
Tina Smith: "I've worked closely with law enforcement in my roles at state and local government, and I have never seen anybody describe as protocol holding a cell phone and taking video while you are simultaneously shooting a gun that ends up killing somebody. It's kind of unbelievable."
[image or embed]
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) Jan 9, 2026 at 7:35 PM
People need to keep pointing out the “evidence” provided was also filmed on his phone, he had it in his hands and may have tried to put it away when he raised his gun to kill Renee Good in cold blood. He wasn’t hit by anything, he may have been fumbling earlier with his phone while harassing them, and as a former firearms instructor and likely not ambidextrous, wasn’t used to firing with one hand and holding a cellphone. Goes to intent.
Shooting right hand evading to his right to hit the windshield means the bullet travels diagonally thru the car… the fatal shots are from the side window
'Not a good look': Trump allies quietly alarmed by ICE shooting response
no ICE agent has EVER been killed in the line of duty OR been convicted of a crime for shooting someone ... meaning their victimhood narrative is a hoax, as is any public accountability for agents.
The incident, which has made headlines across the nation, is far from the first time immigration officers have shot someone in recent months. Good is one of at least nine people across the country who have been shot by immigration agents since September, the New York Times reports. There is something every case has in common: Everyone was in a vehicle at the time of the shooting.
www.motherjones.com/...
x
Amy Klobuchar: "There are now more ICE agents in Minnesota than there are police officers combined in Minneapolis and St. Paul. So they are outnumbering our own local police officers out on the streets."
[image or embed]
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar.com) Jan 9, 2026 at 9:17 PM
GROK:
ICE's use-of-force policy, unchanged since 2018, allows deadly force solely on an agent's subjective belief of imminent harm, lacking vehicle-specific protocols despite at least nine similar vehicle-related shootings since September 2025.
the FOIA exemption ICE relied on is b(7)(E), which allows for the withholding of "law enforcement records" in order to conceal tactics techniques and procedures. in other words, the "OPSEC" excuse.
Redactions weren't bureaucratic oversights—they were tactical camouflage. The admin hid "no-knock" raids behind black bars while quietly building a paramilitary force.
After scrapping police accountability databases on Jan 20, 2025, ICE arrests surged 153% using these secret protocols. The unredacted directive authorized stun grenades in apartments—tactics deployed during Feb 2025 Aurora raids. Now with 12,000 new agents and five custody deaths since December, oversight has vanished completely.
What's their policy on using a cellphone & gun at the same time?
