Welcome to bookchat! Where you can talk about anything; books, plays, essays, and audio books. You don’t have to be reading a book to come in, sit down, and chat with us.
I have always been fascinated by the “I Survived” genre of books. I’m not generally fascinated with the books themselves, mind you, but with the fact that they’re so popular. If you go to the Worldometer website, you will see that there are approximately eight billion people on Earth.
Surviving doesn’t seem that difficult or newsworthy.
It reminds me of the last two lines of the chorus from the famous English song, Rule Britannia, which seems to set a rather low bar for the aspirations of an empire. If you recall, those lyrics go like this:
Rule Britannia, Britannia, rule the waves
Britons never, never, shall be slaves
I just think that they should set their sights a little higher is all. It’s the same with surviving.
People survive all the time.
YOU ARE SURVIVING RIGHT NOW!
On the other hand, there’s no doubt that a person dying at sea is less common than a person dying of a heart condition or from poor medical advice provided by a Republican politician. Humans do enjoy life’s rarities and oddities. Still, when you consider the fact that water covers seventy-one percent of the Earth’s surface, it’s really quite amazing that that mode of death is in any way uncommon.
I will admit that I was enthralled with a book titled Unbroken: A World War II Story of Survival, Resilience, and Redemption. That book was No. 1 on the New York Times best-seller list—deservedly so—as it told the life story of Louis Zamperini, an Olympic distance runner and World War II bombardier who crashed down in the Pacific inside his plane, which was having mechanical difficulties.
The poor fellow floundered around in a life raft for forty-seven days before spending the rest of the war in four different Japanese prisoner of war camps.
There are other books in the genre where a significant percentage of the people do not survive. Of course, Alive: The Story of the Andes Survivors is the most avidly read of these adventures. I thought it was a bit gross, and it certainly turned me off of human forever.
And so, because I am, at best, a less than enthusiastic advocate for books of this genre, I’ve recorded a written interview with my Sister, who is. She is a delightful, wonderful person in all respects save her fascination with this kind of book. But, I’ll let her explain it in her own words:
Q: I'm writing a story about the "I Survived" genre of books. I know you are a huge fan of them. You even checked out one of them from the library a week or so ago. So, my first question to you is this: Why do you like those books?
A: Hmm, I don't know that I can pinpoint exactly why. I enjoy novels. Some of them very much, but when I pick up a book or watch a video, 8 times out of 10, it'll be nonfiction: biography, historical narrative, history, or--a survival story. Most of the time I do not gravitate towards a survival novel. Probably because I know by now that there are real experiences out there that can rival the imagination (mine, at least). That doesn't exactly answer your question, dear Pabs, but it touches the surface.
Survival accounts are kinda like a game. As I follow the narrative, I can't help dissecting the choices and actions of the protagonists. "Really? Whadya do that for? You should have done this instead."
Now, I know, Pabs, you are thinking that it's easy for me to second guess a person under tremendous stress and fear. But I think it's human nature. I mean how many people, for instance, wouldn't second guess this horrifying scenario:
Probably, more often though, I wonder if I could ever have pulled through any of the challenges faced by the survivors.
Q: Which do you like best and why?
(a) Stranded at Sea
(b) Stranded in the Mountains
(c) Stranded in the Jungle
(d) Other
A: I first gravitated to mountain adventures, with books chronicling the disastrous 1996 climbing year on Mt Everest especially capturing my imagination. Left for Dead, an account by Beck Weathers, a self deprecating doctor from Texas, who ended up losing hands and nose (if I remember right) may be my favorite climbing account. The guy wasn't an elite climber, but that made his story that much more compelling.
While I still enjoy mountain adventures, I like the sea survival stories best, especially if sharks and storms are involved. I vividly recall an episode of I Shouldn't be Alive that recreated the story of two boys in South Carolina (where I live) who were paddling their fiberglass boat in an inlet. They intended to fish for an hour or two before heading home for dinner. Instead they got pulled out to sea by a strong riptide. In the choppy water their fishing gear was lost. The boys survived several days out to sea without water, food or phone. Quite an episode.
More recently, I've discovered the jungle survival story. The creepiness of the deep jungle is unrivaled (to me, anyway). Think of the predators--Jaguar, Black Caiman, Green Anaconda, wild boar, an unparalleled assortment of insects! Just one little mistake in the jungle can have horrific consequences. A few years ago, I read an account of the disappearance of explorer Percy Fawcett on a 1925 expedition to discover what he called the ancient lost city of Z in the jungles of Brazil. Following on the heels of that book, I discovered the account of Theodore Roosevelt's expedition into the Amazon Basin to survey the River of Doubt. The experience nearly broke him.
There are human survival stories everywhere there are people. The Outback, the African Savanna, plane crashes, Antarctica expeditions. Weather related stories of surviving hurricanes (the one I picked up at the library), blizzards, tsunamis, volcanic eruptions, avalanches. Freak accidents at home.
Q: Can you name some titles that you like best?
A: River of Doubt, by Candice Millard
Through the Brazilian Wilderness, by Theodore Roosevelt
Left for Dead, by Beck Weathers
Black Wave: A Family's Adventure at Sea and the Disaster That Saved Them, by John and Jean Silverwood
Alive, by Piers Paul Read--probably my first real Survival story.
Isaac's Storm: A Man, a Time, and the Deadliest Hurricane in History, By Erik Larson
Q: Why are you such a bad Sister?
A: Probably because you were a terrible influence on me. Still are.
Q: What is the craziest or weirdest survival story you can recall reading?
Possibly the story of five sailors who get hit by a storm in the Atlantic while en route to Florida as they were delivering a yacht to its owner. The yacht sinks and they spend days in a lifeboat on the open sea. The account was riveting. But it was also heartbreaking because three out of the five did not survive the experience. Their story, Shark Survivor, was featured on Episode One of the first season of the TV documentary I Shouldn't be Alive.
Q: Do you also watch survival stories on the television, on YouTube or with a streaming service? If so, which ones?
A: I think I've watched just about every episode of I Shouldn't be Alive on YouTube. Some of them are more compelling than others.
On YouTube I also often watch episodes of I Survived, another old series which documented survival stories that also included accounts of victims of crime as well as accounts of peril in the natural world. I'd love to hear of any newer (or older) programs or books that are out there.
By the way, Pabs, didn't I force you to watch a whole season of I Shouldn't be Alive several years ago? I think you were riveted against your will.
______________________________________
READERS & BOOK LOVERS SERIES SCHEDULE
If you’re not already following Readers and Book Lovers, please go to our homepage (link), find the top button in the left margin, and click it to FOLLOW GROUP. Thank You and Welcome, to the most followed group on Daily Kos. Now you’ll get all our R&BLers diaries in your stream.