I recently learned about this breathtaking landscape at the Cleveland Museum of Art, and what struck me most is that this serene, luminous scene is filled with urgent and enduring messages. The painting was created in 1867 and references the 1817 book “Lalla Rookh” by the Irish Catholic poet Thomas Moore.
Moore’s work is an allegory within an allegory—layered moral tales told through story.
The Framework Story: Princess Lalla Rookh
Lalla Rookh is a princess being forced into an arranged marriage with a powerful king. She is miserable—not because the king is necessarily cruel, but because she has no freedom. She cannot marry for love; she must marry for political power.
On her journey to meet this king, a traveling poet-minstrel is sent to accompany her. Along the way, he tells her four stories. Each is a lesson about power, revolution, repentance, and the true path to lasting change.
The Four Stories and Their Lessons
1. The Charismatic Populist Revolutionary Leader
A charismatic populist and religious leader gathers followers, promising to overthrow corruption and rule for the people. Referencing the story of Moses who comes off the Mount and is radiating with such divine light that his followers tell him he should wear a veil, the charismatic leader says he wears a veil because his divine light is so strong. The masses believe they are joining a revolution to bring down a corrupt government and install a government for the people.
Instead, the charismatic leader slowly reveals himself to have been driven by his ego, greed, and personal lust for power. And beneath the veil is not divine light, but a grotesquely disfigured face mirroring the ugliness of his soul. Too late, the populist masses discover that the charismatic leader has led them into authoritarian rule.
This allegory is really about the French Revolution and how the populist revolution ended with Napoleon as an authoritarian ruler. Moore is warning the populist masses about charismatic figures leading them into authoritarianism for their own greed, ego and power.
Lesson: Beware of blindly following charismatic populist leaders into authoritarianism.
2. What God Prizes Most
A fairy seeks entry to heaven. God tells her she must bring what God values most.
She brings:
-
The blood of a fallen hero. And the gates fail to open.
-
The last breath of a romantic martyr. The gates fail to open.
-
Finally, the tear of a repentant sinner.
The gates open. Only the tear of the penitent opens the gates.
Lessons: What God prizes most is humility—recognizing one’s error, changing one’s mind and ways, and repenting.
Power misused is not beyond redemption. But transformation requires acknowledgment, repentance and change.
3. The Noble and Romantic, but Doomed Rebellion
A princess falls madly in love with a man who saves her. The man turns out to belong to a persecuted religious minority oppressed by her father, the king. The oppressed religious minority leads a noble and romantic uprising against their oppressor. The princess disguises herself as a man to join her love in battle. Their uprising is passionate, romantic, and heroic—but was doomed from the start. They both die.
This is an allegory for the Irish Rebellion. The Irish Catholics were being oppressed by the British rule and they led a noble and romantic, but doomed uprising for their cause. Moore himself was Irish and Catholic so he understood this deeply. Moore warns against noble romantic and emotional uprisings that are doomed to end in tragedy.
Lesson: Noble causes and passion alone may end in tragedy.
4. Oppressed Woman in a Harem
A neglected and oppressed woman in a royal harem tries desperately—and destructively—to win the king’s attention who is focused on other matters of the state. Nothing works.
A sorceress advises her to sing him a beautiful song. Through music—through her beautiful art—she gains not only his attention, but respect. Their relationship transforms into one grounded in mutual respect and love. Moore is saying here that to get lasting change, people need to work to change hearts and minds. Art, in this story music, is a powerful vehicle to change hearts and minds without a sword and violence.
Lesson: To get lasting change people need to work on changing hearts and minds. Art can succeed where passion and violence fails. Hearts and minds are changed not by the sword, but through being touched through art.
Princess Lalla Rookh and the Poet-Minstrel
As Lalla Rookh listens to these stories, she falls deeply in love with the poet-minstrel. Ae the poet-minstrel sees Lalla Rookh’s responses to the stories, he learns and falls in love with her beautiful heart and mind. The two fall madly in love with each other.
This painting captures the moment she approaches the palace, believing she is being forced to marry a king because of his power and now abandon the man who has won her heart freely.
But then it is revealed to her that:
The poet-minstrel is the King!
The King chose to secretly accompany her to get to know her, understand her, and win her heart freely through respect, understanding, and story—not coercion. Through the stories, he showed her he understands the correct use of power. He demonstrates that true power does not oppress or dominate. It respects. It listens. And through listening, understanding, and respect - it can win love freely.
The Larger Morals
Princess Lalla Rookh represents the populist masses.
Her lessons:
-
Do not follow charismatic leaders into authoritarianism.
-
Do not be driven by your passions into doomed revolutions.
-
Lasting change requires changing hearts and minds.
-
Art is a powerful tool to change hearts and minds.
Art like:
-
Frederick Douglas's beautiful autobiography,
-
Upton Sinclair's "The Jungle" about worker exploitation,
-
"To Kill a Mockingbird" about racial injustice,
-
"The Grapes of Wrath" which helped shape public sympathy and reforms after the Great Depression,
-
Norman Rockwell's famous painting on race "The Problem we All Live With,"
These beautiful works helped change people's hearts and minds. And in terms of music: ragtime, blues, jazz etc. helped change people's hearts and minds.
Lesson: Working to change hearts and minds is more lasting and successful than using violence and fighting because even if you win, if you haven't changed hearts and minds, you will just have to become everything you opposed.
You have to become the oppressor to keep power.
The King represents those in power.
His lessons:
-
Repentance and humility are virtues showing interior strength and courage.
The immature person:
-
Protects ego.
-
Blames others.
-
Avoids accountability.
The mature person:
-
Reflects.
-
Owns mistakes.
-
Adjusts behavior.
Repentance is not humiliation. It is growth and evolution.
-
The inability to show repentance and humility, ends in authoritarianism and tyranny.
-
Leaders who cannot admit they are wrong, refuse to change course, and protect ego over truth necessarily result in tyranny because they have to deny reality.
-
They have to use their power to distort facts, manipulate narratives, and scare, threaten, and punish truth tellers.
-
History shows this repeatedly. Repentance is what prevents power from hardening into oppression. It keeps leaders accountable to the people, power ethical, and systems working properly.
-
Respect and understanding wins love and loyalty more effectively than oppression and domination.
-
Love freely given is stronger than obedience compelled.
Why Did Duncanson Choose A Scene in 1867?
The painting was created by Robert S. Duncanson, a self-taught Black American artist who rose to international acclaim despite systemic racism.
Because of his race, he was barred from formal training. He taught himself by copying the prints of old master artists and sketching landscapes. He and his family were not allowed to attend exhibitions of his own work. Yet a self-taught black man became one of the most celebrated landscape painters of his era.
Why choose Lalla Rookh?
Duncanson understood power, oppression, and the limits of violent upheaval and revolutionary causes. As a Black artist just after the Civil War in America, he used art —beauty—to change hearts and minds.
You cannot stand before his luminous landscape and credibly argue that he is inferior and does not deserve equal rights. The painting quietly dismantles prejudice.
It does not shout.
It does not moralize.
It persuades through touching hearts and minds.
In this way, his work participates in the same tradition as:
Each changed hearts before laws changed.
Art crosses divides. It creates reflection before reaction.
-
Art forces people to confront and measure their purported values against their actions.
-
Using art to confront people with whether their actions are aligned with their values and bringing about that self-reflection - is one of the most effective ways to bring about change in America.
-
Americans purport to be able liberty, opportunity, freedom, etc. - are they living their values through their actions?
Important Lessons for Today
The painting suggests that violent revolution without changed hearts simply replaces one oppressor with another. If hearts do not change, power must be maintained through domination.
Lasting change requires persuasion, repentance, humility, and respect.
That does not dismiss the power of protest or organizing—but directs how to do them effectively.
And that may be the quiet brilliance of this work.
It asks:
-
How should power be used?
-
How should change be pursued?
-
Can art transform more powerfully than force?
Can protests with beautiful music, art, candles, dance, etc. serve to change hearts and minds more effectively than violence, moralizing, attacking people’s character, and screaming?
Follow Me on Substack
