NYT stands by blame-the-victim coverage of 11-yo girl's rape

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Thursday March 10, 2011 · 2:46 PM PST

2011/03/10 · 14:46

Thanks to Seattle SLOG writer Cienna Madrid for posting this story about the NYT article covering the attack.

The New York Times is basically my favorite media source to criticize. Not because I think they are the worst, by any means, but because I think, unlike FOX news or the NY Post or most other mainstream media sources, they have the potential to rise above the orientalist, racist, sexist, sensationalist tendencies of the American press. So when I'm calling them out, know that it is not out of rage or disdain or even disgust (though I may feel all of those things), nor is it out of a desire to see the newspaper shut down for good; I believe the New York Times is better than the type of reporting I'm about to criticize it for.

An 11-year old girl in Texas was gang-raped. The NYT story on the rape is here. Notice the inclusion of unattributed comments by residents who claim that the girl dressed inappropriately or provocatively. Then remember that she was 11 years old. Ask yourself if there is any outfit an 11-year old could wear, any outfit at all, that would justify or explain a 27-year old man (not to mention high schoolers and middle schoolers) raping her.

Even worse, the NYT is refusing to apologize after being called out for this. I have written a letter to the editor and I encourage all of you to do the same. Letters can be e-mailed to letters@nytimes.com. My own is below the fold...

Poll

0 votes Show Results

0 votes Vote Now!

Six more years (10/21 Murray event at UW)

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Friday October 22, 2010 · 12:18 PM PDT

2010/10/22 · 12:18

This was my half-coherent reaction to the President's speech at the event for Senator Murray in Seattle yesterday. It's cross-posted from my blog dearmrpresident365.

Dear Mr. President,

My throat hurts and I haven't slept for more than fifteen minutes in a row in almost two days. At 4:30 this morning my friend Casi and I boarded a city bus toward the U-district and gleefully informed the driver we were going to see the President. He laughed and told every passenger that he picked up after us that we'd be the first girls in line.

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Thursday September 09, 2010 · 10:12 PM PDT

2010/09/09 · 22:12

Dear Mr. President,

After I posted yesterday's letter I received several disheartening responses. "Is this meant to be serious? " one reader asked, "That President Obama could influence these people to reconsider their actions? You must understand that a direct statement from him on this gives these people the profile they so desperately crave to do what they do in front of the largest possible audience." This morning you gave an interview in which you clearly expressed your disapproval for the planned event, without elvating your opponent. Thank you for this. Such a balance is a difficult one to strike and, given the volatility of the situation, I thought your words were well chosen. I don't know if you changed the man's mind or if his better nature is stronger than I give it credit for. I don't think I was off base yesterday in implying that you had the ability to appeal to this man's humanity, or that, at the very least, it was worth a try.

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Wednesday September 08, 2010 · 12:38 PM PDT

2010/09/08 · 12:38

Dear Mr. President,

I generally do not hold you accountable for the actions and beliefs of those who support you. Martin Peretz, for example, may be a prominent member of the media and a self-described democratic loyalist, but when he expresses his view that Muslims have no claim to first Amendment rights, I don't blame you for that. I do, however, expect you to speak out. I do expect you to show the rest of the world that America cannot accurately be represented by cult leaders in Florida or racists in The New Republic. I expect you to speak out because the world is watching these people and it is watching you.

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Tuesday August 10, 2010 · 1:48 PM PDT

2010/08/10 · 13:48

Dear Mr. President,

For Muslims living in America, Ramadan begins tonight at sunset. I've observed the month-long fast before, but it has been several years. I've decided to do so again this year for a number of reasons, but chief among them is my desire to demonstrate solidarity with Muslims. While I doubt very much that it has ever been an entirely comfortable thing to be an American Muslim, especially since the post-9/11 increase in Islamophobia, the level of antipathy toward Muslims in America seems to be on the rise this year.

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Tuesday July 27, 2010 · 2:05 PM PDT

2010/07/27 · 14:05

Dear Mr. President,

As a part of the Let's Move! campaign, the First Lady has done a commendable job of raising awareness for a number of issues, especially the problems of "food deserts." The distance many have to travel to access fresh, nutritious food has a hugely negative health and environmental impact. Here in Seattle, there are a number of organizations doing really inspiring work to combat this impact.

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Sunday July 25, 2010 · 9:50 PM PDT

2010/07/25 · 21:50

Dear Mr. President,

This morning I woke up to news of a US organization working to send their own aid ship in defiance of the Gaza blockade. This ship will be called The Audacity of Hope, and, because it has also been endorsed by Rashid Khalidi, it is being linked to you by some right-wing media sources. I can see why it might be annoying to suffer the criticisms of political convictions you don't actually have, so I would imagine that you viewed this news as one more headache. I heard it, and, for a moment, all I wanted to do was throw out my plans for the next year and join the crew.

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Friday July 23, 2010 · 2:19 PM PDT

2010/07/23 · 14:19

Dear Mr. President,

What we absolutely need right now, more than anything, is a war between Israel and Iran. This is why I was so pleased to see House Republicans doing their legislative best to egg on the most hawkish elements on either side. Do the ramifications of their votes, the lives and blood and suffering that they are calling for ever occur to them? Or does it stay hidden, disguised in legislative language and washed out in clean black letters on clean white paper?

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Sunday July 11, 2010 · 12:21 AM PDT

2010/07/11 · 00:21

Dear Mr. President,

I've heard many times the sentiment Nicholas Kristof expressed today in his column "Waiting for Gandhi." The idea that the Palestinians have not found their Gandhi, their Dr. King; that one man, could save them all. I don't know if things are that simple. I don't know if a Messiah complex (or a waiting for a Messiah complex) is really what will make things all better. I admire Dr. King, and I admire Gandhi, but they were mortal men that achievement, history and personal sacrifice elevated to something higher, something, quite possibly, unattainable. I think that resting the salvation of an entire people on one man's shoulders is a dangerous proposition. For one thing, it discourages those who would walk the paths of these great men, but could never, alone, hope to fill their shoes. I think you might be able to empathize with this, given those who hailed you as the natural heir to Dr. King (or even Jesus) and then turned their backs when miracles did not appear in your first 100 days. How does a man meet such impossible expectations?

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Wednesday July 07, 2010 · 12:10 AM PDT

2010/07/07 · 00:10

Dear Mr. President,

In high school, they called me man hands. It sounds cruel, but it was sort of an endearment. I do have big hands. The people who love me best still call me this, occasionally, and I love them for it. But it started earlier than that. It started when I was 4 years old and saw The Neverending Story. I promptly convinced my mother to cut off my long golden curls so that I could look like Atreyu. When my older sister told me Atreyu was a boy, I was pretty skeptical; I identified with the character enough to believe that he must be female, like me. After that, it was being the only girl on the soccer field at recess, or picked first for kickball because, as a 5th grader, my 5'+ frame and size 9 shoes made me awkward and strange, but damn good at kicking a ball. These days, I work in a physical, occasionally dangerous and adrenaline-filled job. While my supervisor is female, she acknowledged to me that I'm the first woman to apply in a long time. So, I suppose, she and I work what some would call a man's job. I don't want to be a mother and I don't want to be some one's wife, but I like romantic movies and make-up and Jane Austen novels as much as the next girl. What does this make me?

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Sunday July 04, 2010 · 12:00 AM PDT

2010/07/04 · 00:00

Dear Mr. President,

Two years ago, on July 4th, I was not feeling particularly patriotic. The group of travelers I was with had just arrived in a small Palestinian village after a full day of hiking; several people were sick, we were all hot and exhausted, and, while the village offered us the same legendary Palestinian hospitality that we'd received in other villages, there was an undercurrent of tension and sadness. The night before, in the darkness, IDF soldiers had arrested several young boys known to have been friends with another boy, already arrested for throwing rocks at a tank. Some of the boys had been very young, and no one knew when, or even if, they would be returned to their families. It was hard, that night, to feel anything but sadness at the situation my country had helped create and continued to perpetuate for these people.

Augurgirl

Community (This content is not subject to review by Daily Kos staff prior to publication.)

Tuesday June 29, 2010 · 10:26 PM PDT

2010/06/29 · 22:26

Dear Mr. President,

An exotic meat restaurant in Arizona is coming under fire for serving lion burgers in honor of the world cup. I think this discussion highlights an amusing sort of hypocrisy in our culture, the squeamishness people develop when faced with the ugly consequences of behavior we try to tell ourselves is harmless. I suppose food is harder to swallow when it's got the face of cuddly cartoon creatures acting out their own version of Hamlet. But eating Simba, or Nala, or even Mickey and Minnie, is no worse than eating any of the millions of nameless, long-suffering factory farmed cows or chickens or pigs that are sold and consumed every day. I believe there are ways to respectfully and healthily raise animals for food, and that the healthier the animals, the healthier the resulting food. My moral objections to eating animals is because of their mistreatment in the current system, not because of their cuteness. I think any one who can eat a chicken should have no problem eating a lion. Or, for that matter, a dog.

Newer
Older

RSS

NYT stands by blame-the-victim coverage of 11-yo girl's rape

Six more years (10/21 Murray event at UW)

Day 251-Hype

Day 250- Leadership

Day 221- Why I'm fasting for Ramadan

Day 206- Food deserts, urban farming and earth day

Day 205- The Audacity

Day 203-HR 1553

Day 190- In the footsteps of ancient giants

Day 186- Man hands

Day 183- Privilege

Day 179- Lions and burgers and fries- Oh my!