The British philosopher Antony Flew conceptualized the “No True Scotsman” argument in 1975. The presentation of this logical fallacy often takes an appearance similar to this exchange:
Paul: All Scotsmen wear kilts.
Lauren: My uncle, Duncan Machaggis, is a Scotsman and he doesn’t wear a kilt.
Paul: Well, all true Scotsmen wear kilts.
The latter party attempts to refute evidence against a universal claim in a manner that has no foundation in reason: by making the claim a prerequisite, or necessary qualifier, to the subject at hand.
So, from the Left, I’ll offer an apology to Ludmya “Mia” Love.
Read More